Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/03/2022 11:41

@QuirkyTurtle

Still have to send emails if I'm sat in the office or not, it literally makes no difference to my job as every minute on my screen is recorded plus audio, plus timed allocated breaks etc etc etc

Wtf where do you work.

Nothing has changed since I worked in a call centre then! I can remember being told off for spending too long in the loo!
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/03/2022 11:40

But that's not the case with a lot of companies @pawpaws2022. Sky are clearly still blaming Covid which is a load of rubbish after two years. I don't have a problem with someone sending an email, the big issue for me is saying it will take 72 hours to action 'because of Covid'!

O2 obviously don't care what their call centre staff are doing but when I ring to discuss a direct debit I don't expect to give my bank details to someone who is clearly outside!

pawpaws2022 · 02/03/2022 11:39

@QuirkyTurtle

Still have to send emails if I'm sat in the office or not, it literally makes no difference to my job as every minute on my screen is recorded plus audio, plus timed allocated breaks etc etc etc

Wtf where do you work.

In a contact centre, standard practice
QuirkyTurtle · 02/03/2022 11:37

Still have to send emails if I'm sat in the office or not, it literally makes no difference to my job as every minute on my screen is recorded plus audio, plus timed allocated breaks etc etc etc

Wtf where do you work.

TheKeatingFive · 02/03/2022 11:34

I won't see my colleagues in the office, like my friend, but may get made to go back in for 2-3 days. What's the logical reason other than 'just because'?

They don't need a reason though. Presumably you agreed a contract which stated your place of work when you took the job.

If you want something different then you need to renegotiate that contract with them or get a new job which meets your requirements.

GoldenOmber · 02/03/2022 11:31

As I said: “Obviously there are some job where this doesn’t matter or doesn’t matter as much, or where you’d be the only person in the office anyway so what’s the point.”

The fact that it doesn’t work for you and your job personally doesn’t mean that many organisations elsewhere who think it does work are all simultaneously going to ditch it if enough people call them dinosaurs.

Lots of people are not going to be able to walk out of their job straight into a fully remote one based on no more than really really wanting to and having read something about the Great Resignation online

AllOfUsAreDead · 02/03/2022 11:26

@GoldenOmber

I question what is the point of hybrid. If you can do all of your job at home, then why does coming into the office matter

Well, from the perspective of a lot of employers, my job isn’t just the individual tasks on my to-do list. It also includes things that work better when people can collaborate and learn from each other in person. So the benefit of hybrid is that you get some in-person time for that side of the job while still getting to work from home some of the time.

Obviously there are some job where this doesn’t matter or doesn’t matter as much, or where you’d be the only person in the office anyway so what’s the point. But for a lot of jobs, there is a benefit to having people actually work together in person, which is why lots of employers are looking to hybrid rather than solely working from home.

Fine if people want to ditch those jobs and look for fully remote jobs instead. But expecting all those employers who see benefits in hybrid to stop caring about it is a bit naive. “On the one hand there are big benefits of wider collaboration and building relationships across teams, of learning on the job by watching others and of helping junior people develop - but on the other hand, Susie over there says she thinks we should all move to fully remote because she wants to walk her pandemic puppy at lunchtimes. What to do, what to do?”

But as I said, what about those of us who still can't SEE other colleagues at work because they are either on different days to come in, or they are in a different location? Many companies are international these days, I used to have colleagues in South America, Europe and Asia. I obviously can't work face to face with them, and many others have similar situations. Their colleagues aren't in their office, so why do they need to be there? What is the point of that?

I won't see my colleagues in the office, like my friend, but may get made to go back in for 2-3 days. What's the logical reason other than 'just because'?

GoldenOmber · 02/03/2022 11:13

I question what is the point of hybrid. If you can do all of your job at home, then why does coming into the office matter

Well, from the perspective of a lot of employers, my job isn’t just the individual tasks on my to-do list. It also includes things that work better when people can collaborate and learn from each other in person. So the benefit of hybrid is that you get some in-person time for that side of the job while still getting to work from home some of the time.

Obviously there are some job where this doesn’t matter or doesn’t matter as much, or where you’d be the only person in the office anyway so what’s the point. But for a lot of jobs, there is a benefit to having people actually work together in person, which is why lots of employers are looking to hybrid rather than solely working from home.

Fine if people want to ditch those jobs and look for fully remote jobs instead. But expecting all those employers who see benefits in hybrid to stop caring about it is a bit naive. “On the one hand there are big benefits of wider collaboration and building relationships across teams, of learning on the job by watching others and of helping junior people develop - but on the other hand, Susie over there says she thinks we should all move to fully remote because she wants to walk her pandemic puppy at lunchtimes. What to do, what to do?”

pawpaws2022 · 02/03/2022 10:59

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

It's much easier to hear at home too as no background noise

That's not always the case though. I've heard what is clearly a radio or TV, noisy kids and, when I phone O2 a couple of weeks ago, sounds that meant he was obviously outdoors!

I'm also sick of 'I'm working from home so will have to send a manager an email' (Sky) and 'a manager will respond in 72 hours because of Covid' (also Sky)

Customer service has definitely not improved!

I've posted this before Customers say to us about service. There is only me WFH. The reason they are queuing is because we are busy, and people have left. Nothing at all to do with WFH or covid Still have to send emails if I'm sat in the office or not, it literally makes no difference to my job as every minute on my screen is recorded plus audio, plus timed allocated breaks etc etc etc Customers are also a lot more demanding post lockdown

(I'm not working this morning!)

TheKeatingFive · 02/03/2022 10:55

There's jobs out there for remote working

I'm not seeing too many of these tbh. The vast, vast majority of companies seem to be hedging their bets on hybrid for the minute and seeing how it pans out. Which makes sense.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/03/2022 10:50

To all those saying how great working from home is, have you got dedicated office space and does your WFH set up meet DSE requirements? I don't have an office and my set up in the dining room would fail a DSE risk assessment and there's no way to change it and I'm know there are people far worse off than me.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 02/03/2022 10:48

It's much easier to hear at home too as no background noise

That's not always the case though. I've heard what is clearly a radio or TV, noisy kids and, when I phone O2 a couple of weeks ago, sounds that meant he was obviously outdoors!

I'm also sick of 'I'm working from home so will have to send a manager an email' (Sky) and 'a manager will respond in 72 hours because of Covid' (also Sky)

Customer service has definitely not improved!

AllOfUsAreDead · 02/03/2022 10:41

@GoldenOmber

But you'll find this opinion is verging on evil on here. How dare you. Grin

I don’t think it’s ‘verging on evil’ at all, but it is perhaps exaggerating what ‘hybrid’ means in many workplaces and how much choice employees have actually got at the moment.

Many places are offering hybrid and will continue to. But the OP’s workplace is already one of those! Three days a week in the office and two at home is hybrid. When employers say they offer hybrid, a lot of them mean working patterns like that with minimum days in the office.

The pool of employers offering “come in as and when you like and nobody’s fussed if you want to be out of action between 3 and 4 for the school run” does exist but it’s a lot smaller. So if you want one, perhaps don’t burn all your bridges with your current employer while you’re looking, no matter what you’ve read online about the Great Resignation…

But the rest of the team doesn't want to go into the office and hasn't. Op was one of the few that bothered.

Really I question what is the point of hybrid. If you can do all of your job at home, then why does coming into the office matter, especially if they are staggering when people are in? Like my friend is having to go back in two days a week by her boss, but her boss isn't even in the office the two days she is there. None of her colleagues are there either, so she sits alone and still has to talk to them via an online platform. That will be my situation too if I have to go back in. What is the point of that? No face to face meetings still, no customer contact, no need to use facilities in the office.

What's the point? It's just a different location where your employees could be miserable. Some will like it, others won't. Give them the choice.

Otherwise they will walk. That's the companies problem though, not the employees. There's jobs out there for remote working, I could get one of those easily if my workplace want me in, and sadly will. Many others will too.

pawpaws2022 · 02/03/2022 10:19

@Whitefire

Contact centre. I don't have time to drink a brew let alone speak to a colleague It's much easier to hear at home too as no background noise

My contact centre colleagues all prefer to be in the office, but I guess it depends on the purpose / role of the contact centre.

Tbh it is everyone else who hates working in their vicinity, they are so noisy. Grin

Yeah I much prefer working at home. Control of temperature, no background noise We don't have meetings or anything so I'm not really missing out. Usually get chance to say half a sentence between calls Grin
Whitefire · 02/03/2022 10:06

Contact centre. I don't have time to drink a brew let alone speak to a colleague
It's much easier to hear at home too as no background noise

My contact centre colleagues all prefer to be in the office, but I guess it depends on the purpose / role of the contact centre.

Tbh it is everyone else who hates working in their vicinity, they are so noisy. Grin

DottyHarmer · 02/03/2022 10:01

@FithrightOpinions - how did you acquire your “skills, experience, knowledge” may I ask? Some people are being very short-sighted with an “I’m all right, Jack” attitude and a big foot kicking the ladder away.

I posted on this thread or another that ds, in looking for work, has seen so many internships axed. One was honest enough to say on their website, “Our internship programme is no longer running due to staff now working from home.”

GoldenOmber · 02/03/2022 09:53

But you'll find this opinion is verging on evil on here. How dare you. Grin

I don’t think it’s ‘verging on evil’ at all, but it is perhaps exaggerating what ‘hybrid’ means in many workplaces and how much choice employees have actually got at the moment.

Many places are offering hybrid and will continue to. But the OP’s workplace is already one of those! Three days a week in the office and two at home is hybrid. When employers say they offer hybrid, a lot of them mean working patterns like that with minimum days in the office.

The pool of employers offering “come in as and when you like and nobody’s fussed if you want to be out of action between 3 and 4 for the school run” does exist but it’s a lot smaller. So if you want one, perhaps don’t burn all your bridges with your current employer while you’re looking, no matter what you’ve read online about the Great Resignation…

AllOfUsAreDead · 02/03/2022 09:19

@FithrightOpinions

Google The Great Resignation.

People are moving/quitting jobs based on whether companies are retaining Hybrid Working & WFH, and employers are scrambling to retain them.

I've been Hybrid Working for the past 6 years, it's the only way to manage a Pan European team - I certainly can't be in the office for all of them!!!

If I was told I had to be in the office "just because" I'd take my skills, experience, knowledge (and probably half of my team) elsewhere to a company that had evolved and could meet my requirements.

Most problems with WFH are caused by Managers who aren't capable of doing their job properly, and who lack the confidence to manage people they can't see.

They're dinosaurs.

This.

But you'll find this opinion is verging on evil on here. How dare you. Grin

FithrightOpinions · 02/03/2022 09:10

@naffusername

I'm going to ruffle feathers but I'm so tired of this.

I've been trotting into a hospital and working every, single, day of this Pandemic.

Unlike many of our clerical and administrative staff who are now pulling this exact same thing.

I've been paying for parking even on my vacation and the sick days. They've had their parking suspended because they are working from home.

The job they were hired for is in a hospital, show up and do your job or find another one it's that simples.

I don't take patients home to tend. I don't take the paperwork home.

I'm probably going to ruffle some back then....

Rather than expect them to find another job, why don't you??

You could also lose the commute, not pay parking, not have to go in every day....

FithrightOpinions · 02/03/2022 08:58

Google The Great Resignation.

People are moving/quitting jobs based on whether companies are retaining Hybrid Working & WFH, and employers are scrambling to retain them.

I've been Hybrid Working for the past 6 years, it's the only way to manage a Pan European team - I certainly can't be in the office for all of them!!!

If I was told I had to be in the office "just because" I'd take my skills, experience, knowledge (and probably half of my team) elsewhere to a company that had evolved and could meet my requirements.

Most problems with WFH are caused by Managers who aren't capable of doing their job properly, and who lack the confidence to manage people they can't see.

They're dinosaurs.

C8H10N4O2 · 02/03/2022 08:48

@vivainsomnia

family friendly working is better for society and our mental health Family friendly doesn't mean mothers of younger kids get to dictate working hours for anyone else so that they can save money on childcare.

Everyone has needs, not just mothers. They don't get to rule life for everyone else. This attitude that mother needs are more important than anyone else's is pure self-centeredness.

Then you need to address the societal situation which makes women overwhelmingly responsible for childcare whilst also not providing adequate and affordable childcare (leave it to the market!) and berating women both for being WOHMs or SAHMs.

The commonest problem I'm seeing around childcare is not women wanting to save money on childcare but simply the affordability since covid and the reduction in capacity.

We invest a lot in our juniors and frankly if we took the attitude that the women were disposable when they had children we would lose them to our competitors. A bit of flexibility and support during a limited time results in retention of star performers and future leaders. Its a no brainer.

QuirkyTurtle · 02/03/2022 08:37

I’m interested to understand why people feel they’d be so unproductive in an environment with colleagues around them?

@Rosebell75 - this may be specific to my job but at the office, when their manager is sitting in front of them, the threshold for asking questions is much lower than WFH. Every five minutes I'd have someone say 'hey QuirkyTurtle, remind me what I need to do if X'. WFH they'd have to message or call me, while the answer is easily found doing a quick Google search or just thinking for one second before asking. In the office, I hardly got ANY real work done until everyone else had left for the day.

Cablefable · 02/03/2022 08:35

@naffusername

I'm going to ruffle feathers but I'm so tired of this.

I've been trotting into a hospital and working every, single, day of this Pandemic.

Unlike many of our clerical and administrative staff who are now pulling this exact same thing.

I've been paying for parking even on my vacation and the sick days. They've had their parking suspended because they are working from home.

The job they were hired for is in a hospital, show up and do your job or find another one it's that simples.

I don't take patients home to tend. I don't take the paperwork home.

Are they doing the job effectively? My DB works in a corporate role and the team has been told throughout they can't go back into a healthcare environment whilst they can work from home as there isn't enough room to socially distance- as the rules haven't been relaxed in those settings yet they are still at home. They've been told they will probably just be back for vital meetings etc in the future, as long as the work is getting done though is it an issue? Just as your job doesn't afford the same opportunity does that mean no one should get it?
QuirkyTurtle · 02/03/2022 08:30

@naffusername

I'm going to ruffle feathers but I'm so tired of this.

I've been trotting into a hospital and working every, single, day of this Pandemic.

Unlike many of our clerical and administrative staff who are now pulling this exact same thing.

I've been paying for parking even on my vacation and the sick days. They've had their parking suspended because they are working from home.

The job they were hired for is in a hospital, show up and do your job or find another one it's that simples.

I don't take patients home to tend. I don't take the paperwork home.

Sorry but I'm not willing to give up my increased quality of life just because other people can't WFH.

"If I'm suffering everyone else should too."

vivainsomnia · 02/03/2022 08:23

family friendly working is better for society and our mental health
Family friendly doesn't mean mothers of younger kids get to dictate working hours for anyone else so that they can save money on childcare.

Everyone has needs, not just mothers. They don't get to rule life for everyone else. This attitude that mother needs are more important than anyone else's is pure self-centeredness.