Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
MabelsApron · 03/03/2022 00:15

@Puzzledandpissedoff

The work is being done - but only because some of us are doing unpaid extra hours to cover others not working their full

Isn't that just enabling management to kick the can further down the road MabelsApron? If someone's not doing the job they're paid for I'm not sure how it helps for you to do it unpaid

It doesn’t help, but I work in provision of services to vulnerable people, so there are real life consequences if everyone just downs tools and leaves on the dot.
RobynMyEmployer · 02/03/2022 23:10

Isn't that just enabling management to kick the can further down the road MabelsApron? If someone's not doing the job they're paid for I'm not sure how it helps for you to do it unpaid.

Well, sometimes it's the difference between submitting a bid on time or missing the deadline and being excluded from the procurement process. I've stepped up and done things other people were supposed to do when I knew it was otherwise going to reflect badly on me as part of the bid team or as the person ultimately managing the process.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/03/2022 21:38

The work is being done - but only because some of us are doing unpaid extra hours to cover others not working their full

Isn't that just enabling management to kick the can further down the road MabelsApron? If someone's not doing the job they're paid for I'm not sure how it helps for you to do it unpaid

RobynMyEmployer · 02/03/2022 21:23

I also don't understand all this "it's a workers market" sentiment that seems to be going around atm. I may have had my head buried in the sand as I've been working flat out all through the pandemic, but previously it was all about ridiculous numbers of people applying for each job and chartered accountants having to work at Tesco to make ends meet.

Justgorgeous · 02/03/2022 21:16

You sound very entitled. Yes they can fire you.

RobynMyEmployer · 02/03/2022 21:12

@KittenKong

‘I’ve finished all my work’. I don’t think I’ve ever said that! I still get calls into the evening…
I was rarely ever twiddling my thumbs either when I was in an office job as projects/bids were a long process. At best, I could get a few days ahead of my current point on the planner. Usually it was a challenge to get everything done on time (due to many stakeholders contributing) and I often felt like the executive summary etc would've been better with an extra day to write it. So I absolutely could've found ways to use any extra time effectively.

But many posters talk of it being pointless sitting in the office and twiddling their thumbs. This is the point where one could say "well, I'm here now. I may as well find something productive to do." This is much less likely to happen at home IMO as there are many other things that can be done instead - like washing, cleaning, dog walking, etc.

KittenKong · 02/03/2022 21:04

‘I’ve finished all my work’. I don’t think I’ve ever said that! I still get calls into the evening…

RobynMyEmployer · 02/03/2022 20:58

Working from the office: "I've finished all my work. May as well ask if there's anything else I can help with."

Working from home: "I've finished all my work. May as well walk the dog."

QuirkyTurtle · 02/03/2022 19:30

We'll have to agree to disagree!

Rosebell75 · 02/03/2022 19:14

Quirky. You say you know your worth and believe you hold the power in your employee/employer relationship but it doesn’t sound to me like particularly good management that you choose to avoid your colleagues/team members asking you ‘constant questions’ by avoiding working with them in the office. It would be far better to ensure they are trained properly to find the answers themselves and to encourage them in doing so by coaching them properly.

That way there’s no need to hide at home in case they disturb your day.

MabelsApron · 02/03/2022 17:54

@C8H10N4O2

I'm not saying that I never take breaks to get a cup of tea or whatever but this is piss-taking on a different scale. We are all paid the same amount to do the same job. Yet there are people on this thread who consider that this is justifiable because it's womens' rights innit. It's setting women in the workplace back, and it will mean that WFH is withdrawn from all of us in the long run I suspect

Where is the management in this? Its their responsibility to ensure flexibility around work doesn't mean work not being done.

What are your disciplinary processes around this and why are they not being used if people are consistently failing to deliver despite accommodations being made?

The work is being done - but only because some of us are doing unpaid extra hours to cover others not working their full.

Management is aware but they're worried that there could be an indirect sex discrimination claim. There have been attempts to sort it out, which have been met with threats to get the union involved. The whole thing is a mess and honestly, whilst management are clearly wet lettuces, the entitlement of the parents where I work is awful and I find it very hard to look past it.

shinynewapple22 · 02/03/2022 15:28

I agree with the poster earlier today who said that this topic is very dependent on the type of company you work for, and the job that you do . It will work for some, but not others.

shinynewapple22 · 02/03/2022 15:25

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

To all those saying how great working from home is, have you got dedicated office space and does your WFH set up meet DSE requirements? I don't have an office and my set up in the dining room would fail a DSE risk assessment and there's no way to change it and I'm know there are people far worse off than me.

I'm very lucky in this respect @PinkSparklyPussyCat . There is only me and DH at home now. I have taken over DS's old bedroom as my office, there is a desk in there and we bought a new office chair at the beginning of the pandemic when first started WFH. I had the opportunity to have a full size monitor but chose to stick with the one on my laptop so I have the extra desk space . I use a full size keyboard and mouse and my laptop is raised on a pile of books so the screen is at the correct level. It is far more comfortable for me than previously where we had to work from different venues and hot desk so not constantly having a comfortable chair etc .

I know that this isn't the case for all my colleagues , at least one has said she works from bed as she has no other room to set herself up. We do now have the opportunity to return to the office if we want to, although there is reduced space as some of our centres have been closed permanently, and therefore if you do want to go in you have to book a desk . I don't know whether other colleagues have taken this option up or not .

Ultimately I think we will return on a hybrid model. Much as I love WFH for the convenience and lack of travel, there is one aspect of our work which we are currently doing virtually which in reality would be better for the client if this took place in person and I think that this will resume face to face once appropriate accommodation is sorted . Despite a previous poster misconstruing my earlier comments on this subject , I am quite happy with this when / if it happens .

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/03/2022 13:25

People can argue anything, and do, Belladonna - though it doesn't necessarily mean their argument's credible

I wouldn't automatically expect employers to refuse WFH or hybrid for all, not least because handled well it can work brilliantly. They might approach things differently for proven pisstakers though, because as a PP correctly said managing issues is part of their job despite having many other things to do

Trouble is, pisstakers aren't always amenable to management efforts to stop them being exactly that, which may explain all the threads where what seems rational action attracts "That's illegal!!", "Contact ACAS/your union", "Go off sick", etc., etc.

Belladonna12 · 02/03/2022 13:08

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Wfh is often fine and dandy, but I’m surprised at some on here thinking it eminently reasonable that looking after their dcs at the same time should be accommodated

It was bound to happen though; with older DCs it can work fine, but with little ones it was only a matter of time until this demand was thrown into the mix, and I'm another who worries about what it may do to womens' work prospects - especially at the lower skills end and/or in small companies

I'm worried that it will put companies off letting people work from home altogether. I've worked at home for many years and I always used childcare for my children when they were younger because I didn't want anybody to think I was taking advantage. People can't argue that they can work just as effectively at home as in the office if they are not attending meetings because they are picking children up or looking after them.
AllOfUsAreDead · 02/03/2022 12:58

@TheKeatingFive

I agreed that contract in a different time when they were adamant work could only be done in an office. We've now proven they are wrong.

Well their understanding of the situation and your understanding of the situation may not be entirely the same.

However, they are entitled to maintain/adjust terms as they see fit. You are entitled to agree to them or move on. That's all fine. I'm just not particularly sanguine that there are tonnes of entirely wfh jobs out there waiting to be filled, it all seems to point to hybrid. But I guess we'll see.

The best part is, they've even agreed with us that it works. They've had less sick leave, less stressed employees, happier people. And nothing slowed down, unless it required getting supplies or something that got delayed.

But that's just our departments view, not the whole company. They may not agree which is the problem and then we get forced back.

Thankfully there are remote jobs in what I do. I could get a job for a company in Tokyo if I wanted to, it makes zero difference. But I do like my job, I'd rather keep it, if it still helps my work life balance. My stress levels and health are more important to me than sitting in a chair in a different building.

C8H10N4O2 · 02/03/2022 12:57

@FithrightOpinions

Google The Great Resignation.

People are moving/quitting jobs based on whether companies are retaining Hybrid Working & WFH, and employers are scrambling to retain them.

I've been Hybrid Working for the past 6 years, it's the only way to manage a Pan European team - I certainly can't be in the office for all of them!!!

If I was told I had to be in the office "just because" I'd take my skills, experience, knowledge (and probably half of my team) elsewhere to a company that had evolved and could meet my requirements.

Most problems with WFH are caused by Managers who aren't capable of doing their job properly, and who lack the confidence to manage people they can't see.

They're dinosaurs.

Completely agree with this. I've effectively been hybrid working for well over twenty years and my teams are across all timezones.

The actual problems people attribute to WFH are nearly always organisational process or poor management skills. Most of the real problems are pretty easy to work around if your managers actually do their job.

C8H10N4O2 · 02/03/2022 12:51

I'm not saying that I never take breaks to get a cup of tea or whatever but this is piss-taking on a different scale. We are all paid the same amount to do the same job. Yet there are people on this thread who consider that this is justifiable because it's womens' rights innit. It's setting women in the workplace back, and it will mean that WFH is withdrawn from all of us in the long run I suspect

Where is the management in this? Its their responsibility to ensure flexibility around work doesn't mean work not being done.

What are your disciplinary processes around this and why are they not being used if people are consistently failing to deliver despite accommodations being made?

LimeSupper · 02/03/2022 12:49

How can the company possibly do everything from home though? Perhaps there are employees who can do work tasks from home but the office base is much more than just a place to complete those tasks. What happens to all the training of new staff? The informal learning they do from shadowing or just working around other colleagues. The raising of standards of colleagues through collaboration, sitting next to others with different ideas and bouncing ideas around. How about parity (particularly for younger/ poorer colleagues) in house shares or unsuitable noisy accommodation who benefit greatly from being part of the office base work force. What about team building and building of soft skills?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/03/2022 12:48

Wfh is often fine and dandy, but I’m surprised at some on here thinking it eminently reasonable that looking after their dcs at the same time should be accommodated

It was bound to happen though; with older DCs it can work fine, but with little ones it was only a matter of time until this demand was thrown into the mix, and I'm another who worries about what it may do to womens' work prospects - especially at the lower skills end and/or in small companies

QuirkyTurtle · 02/03/2022 12:37

@Whitefire

Lots of people seem to have a very inflated sense of self, this may be justified, but the vast majority of us are easily replaceable. I'm sure most companies would just tell people to suit themselves if they threaten to leave over the working arrangements. There are plenty of others who will be happy to step into the role.
Maybe. In my case I like to think I just know my worth. This company needs me so much more than I need them. They could sack me, but my combination of skills and knowledge specific to this industry will be near impossible to replace. They know this, I know this, so I'm in a very privileged position to make demands.

This won't be applicable to most people though I'm sure.

TheKeatingFive · 02/03/2022 12:31

I agreed that contract in a different time when they were adamant work could only be done in an office. We've now proven they are wrong.

Well their understanding of the situation and your understanding of the situation may not be entirely the same.

However, they are entitled to maintain/adjust terms as they see fit. You are entitled to agree to them or move on. That's all fine. I'm just not particularly sanguine that there are tonnes of entirely wfh jobs out there waiting to be filled, it all seems to point to hybrid. But I guess we'll see.

AllOfUsAreDead · 02/03/2022 12:21

@TheKeatingFive

I won't see my colleagues in the office, like my friend, but may get made to go back in for 2-3 days. What's the logical reason other than 'just because'?

They don't need a reason though. Presumably you agreed a contract which stated your place of work when you took the job.

If you want something different then you need to renegotiate that contract with them or get a new job which meets your requirements.

I know and I will be if they do that. I agreed that contract in a different time when they were adamant work could only be done in an office. We've now proven they are wrong. They have no argument anymore for this, and they'll lose employees due to that. But as I say, that's their problem not mine. I don't particularly care who I work for as long as I get paid.
MabelsApron · 02/03/2022 12:05

@DottyHarmer

Things have changed rather too quickly. It must be a nightmare for HR departments, and worse for those with no dedicated HR who have to try to manage the “new normal” and some people’s demands.

Wfh is often fine and dandy, but I’m surprised at some on here thinking it eminently reasonable that looking after their dcs at the same time should be accommodated. They are in fact pushing back the cause of women, by positioning themselves as the caregiver and homemaker as their primary role . If someone can never join meetings at certain times (and depending on industry you may have clients who if they say 3pm you are bloody well there at 3pm and waiting till 4 if they so demand) or there are small children interrupting constantly then no employer is going to be impressed.

Obviously wfh is handy in lots of ways: saves money, you are in for pets, deliveries, kids, workmen etc etc. But ultimately you are being paid to do a job and I think a fair few people (particularly on here) seem to have forgotten that in their glee at being more comfortable.

Agree. An example from yesterday.

I log on at 8am as normal. It's just me and the other childless person in the team. We crack on with the urgent stuff and when we're asked to attend an emergency 9am meeting, we agree between us who goes. From 9.30am or so, the parent colleagues start to show up. They hear about the work arising out of the 9am meeting and say we seem to have it covered. The work is covered by the person attending the 9am meeting in addition to their other daily duties/work.

Another emergency meeting is scheduled for 2.30pm. The parents are all once again absent, and this time I go to the meeting. The parents return around 3.30pm or so and again say we seem to have it covered. They remain logged on but are basically impossible to reach because their children are now home. They all vanish at 5pm saying they'll log back on later. By this point, I've sorted out the work arising out of the emergency 2.30pm meeting, and am now finishing the work that I had to put aside to attend it. I log off at 6pm.

Childless colleague and I log back on at 8am today and nothing has been done overnight, and there's no evidence of anyone logging on after we logged off.

I work in public sector and if the work isn't done then people suffer.

I'm not saying that I never take breaks to get a cup of tea or whatever but this is piss-taking on a different scale. We are all paid the same amount to do the same job. Yet there are people on this thread who consider that this is justifiable because it's womens' rights innit. It's setting women in the workplace back, and it will mean that WFH is withdrawn from all of us in the long run I suspect.

Whitefire · 02/03/2022 11:53

Lots of people seem to have a very inflated sense of self, this may be justified, but the vast majority of us are easily replaceable. I'm sure most companies would just tell people to suit themselves if they threaten to leave over the working arrangements. There are plenty of others who will be happy to step into the role.