Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
Porridgeislife · 03/03/2022 14:27

50 years ago is 1972. Yep, no women in the workplace AT ALL Grin

Parker231 · 03/03/2022 14:27

@LouisRenault

50 years ago there were no women in the workplace.

What absolute tosh.

50 years ago my DM was working as an engineer in Ghent and my DMil as a teacher in Quebec. They weren’t unusual.
Whitefire · 03/03/2022 14:26

Yeah I don't want Mumsnet to be a "safe space" as that is code for "always agree with me"

Whitefire · 03/03/2022 14:24

@LouisRenault

50 years ago there were no women in the workplace.

What absolute tosh.

Yeah 50 years ago really isn't that long ago.
Belladonna12 · 03/03/2022 14:23

A safe space means a space either online or offline that has been designed for mothers (I'd hope all parents actually including dad's and guardians) to talk about the challenges in their lives without fear of reprimand or reprecussions.

Lol. Have you been on AIBU before?

GoldenOmber · 03/03/2022 14:22

That's your opinion based on your work environment 🤷🏽‍♀️

What, that some people (parents or not) will take the piss sometimes? I don’t think that’s unique to my work environment.

Also not really clear on what you’re saying here. On the one hand, you say that all parents who head out during work hours to do pickups and dropoffs are making up their hours (even if you don’t know them and their colleagues say they aren’t). But on the other hand, when I gave my workplace as an example of somewhere where they changed my work hours around so I could do exactly that, that’s a ‘toxic’ workplace to you?

LouisRenault · 03/03/2022 14:17

50 years ago there were no women in the workplace.

What absolute tosh.

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 03/03/2022 14:04

@GoldenOmber

As a working mum myself (albeit currently off sick - and I’ve still been getting pings on my work phone Hmm ), I don’t feel it helps me to be lumped in with absolute piss-takers like MabelsApron on some kind of crusade for equality in the workplace, thanks.

My employer is pretty good for working parents. What this has meant for me is that when my DC’s breakfast club didn’t reopen b/c covid, work let me formally change my working pattern so I could do school pick-up. If I get a call from school or nursery saying a child is ill, I know nobody will fuss when I need to go and get them.

What it doesn’t mean is that I can avoid doing the hours and the work I’m contracted for to save myself money/time, and then grump about discrimination if someone pulls me up on it. That’s not helping working mothers; that’s setting us back.

That's your opinion based on your work environment 🤷🏽‍♀️ I've worked in toxic environments like that where parents (because my husband does school pickup a lot right now even though I'm on maternity leave) would be judged for taking out 20 minutes to collect their kids from school and guess what.....I left.

I've worked hard my whole life and I'm going to reap the benefits of that. Me or my partner collecting our kids had never been an issue because the work still gets done but if it ever did become an issue 9 times out of 10 for an office job it's a sign of a toxic workplace.

I'm not performing open heart surgery, having to send an email or join a call 20 minutes later is an absolute nothing and my team appreciate that I trust them and take this standpoint.

Anywhere that would penalise a parent for this is not worth working for in my opinion 🤷🏽‍♀️

GoldenOmber · 03/03/2022 13:57

Argh sorry - “piss-takers like MabelsApron ’s colleagues” that should say! Sorry, blame the lurgy…

GoldenOmber · 03/03/2022 13:55

As a working mum myself (albeit currently off sick - and I’ve still been getting pings on my work phone Hmm ), I don’t feel it helps me to be lumped in with absolute piss-takers like MabelsApron on some kind of crusade for equality in the workplace, thanks.

My employer is pretty good for working parents. What this has meant for me is that when my DC’s breakfast club didn’t reopen b/c covid, work let me formally change my working pattern so I could do school pick-up. If I get a call from school or nursery saying a child is ill, I know nobody will fuss when I need to go and get them.

What it doesn’t mean is that I can avoid doing the hours and the work I’m contracted for to save myself money/time, and then grump about discrimination if someone pulls me up on it. That’s not helping working mothers; that’s setting us back.

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 03/03/2022 13:46

[quote ufucoffee]@Notyourtypicalvirgo
Can you explain what you mean be 'a safe space for Mums' actually means. I genuinely don't know. [/quote]
A safe space means a space either online or offline that has been designed for mothers (I'd hope all parents actually including dad's and guardians) to talk about the challenges in their lives without fear of reprimand or reprecussions.

That's not to say childless people shouldn't be on Mumsnet, but childless people coming to Mumsnet to judge and pile on to mothers with their own agenda is intrusion into a safe space.

It's like me going onto an LGBTQ website and crying "what about straight people???", I just wouldn't do it, it's a dick move

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 03/03/2022 13:42

@RobynMyEmployer I mean I'm sorry that happens to you but that sounds like a boundary issue. I only do work outside of my contracted hours if it's truly urgent (and I have been known to get taxis to central London at 4am in a genuine time of crisis). Just because someone emails you at 5.35pm doesn't mean you need to respond if you are working from home.

ufucoffee · 03/03/2022 13:37

@Notyourtypicalvirgo
Can you explain what you mean be 'a safe space for Mums' actually means. I genuinely don't know.

CallyfromBlakes7 · 03/03/2022 13:34

@RobynMyEmployer

Working from the office: "I've finished all my work. May as well ask if there's anything else I can help with."

Working from home: "I've finished all my work. May as well walk the dog."

Nah. Working from the office - I've finished all my work. Sit here twiddling my thumbs posting on Mumsnet until 5.30 when I can go home.

Working from home - I've finished all my work. May as well put the washing machine on (don't have a dog). 5.35 comes and an email comes in. Oh I may as well deal with that as I am here and have time (if I had been in the office I'd have been on the train home and would not have seen it until tomorrow).

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 03/03/2022 13:32

[quote CallyfromBlakes7]@Notyourtypicalvirgo - excellent post[/quote]
Thank you 😊

CallyfromBlakes7 · 03/03/2022 13:32

@Notyourtypicalvirgo - excellent post

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 03/03/2022 13:17

I'm dipping in and out of this thread and choosing not to respond to the hystericals here who choose to create hypothetical situations that don't exist or misrepresent what people are saying but I've noticed some pretty concerning observations here:

  1. I'm sure people picking up their kids ARE making up hours, maybe they work through their lunch and low and behold you probably aren't seeing that if we work from home. I myself regularly will do work at 5.30-6am because that's the time I wake up, have some breakfast and then head to the gym. So I'll quickly do a daily update email as I wait for my cereal to digest. Family friendly working doesn't mean not doing your hours.

  2. there are a few childless women on this thread who are being pretty negative about parents working from home and I just want to say how sinister this is. MUMSnet should be a safe space for mums, somewhere they can connect with other parents and not be judged as "setting women's rights back" (LOL!!!) for picking up their children from school.

  3. Work evolves through the decades. 50 years ago there were no women in the workplace. The past few decades women have entered but have expected to emulate men, acting as though they don't have children and being penalised if they do. We're now moving to a new model where our technological capability means we can all work from home, so there is more flex in what can and can't be done.

  4. look it up but the average worker is only productive for 4 hours a day and your brain can only concentrate about 90 minutes at a time. Very few people work flat out for 8 hours a day and I have worked in banking, in agencies, across football clubs..... pretty much every industry I work in I see MEN (not necessarily women) pretending to work when they're really playing fantasy football on a second tab or sneakily watching the world cup. If you decide the the extra time you have in the day where you'd normally be getting a coffee in the office or twiddling your thumbs is better spent putting on a load of washing or walking the dog....GOOD FOR YOU

  5. a lot of posters here have some pretty serious internalised misogyny. Up to you if that's how you want to live your life but stop enforcing your bullshit on other women.

CHEERS 😊

MabelsApron · 03/03/2022 12:36

@Puzzledandpissedoff

I work in provision of services to vulnerable people, so there are real life consequences if everyone just downs tools and leaves on the dot

I get that completely, and I'm honestly not suggesting anyone should grudge a short spell to finish what they're doing, but hours of unpaid work?

As I said upthread an awful lot of emotional blackmail goes on in the caring professions around vulnerable clients, and it's obviously right that folk care about them within the limits of their jobs
However I stand by my view that, while it might avert an immediate problem, it's not really helping the bigger picture if employees just pick up the slack themselves

Well, yeah, of course it isn't helping the bigger picture. But if 8 out of a team of 10 are working 6 hours per day rather than their contracted 8, and the team's workload is calculated on the basis of 10 people working full time, then the 2 people who aren't taking the piss are going to be working additional hours to ensure that the services get provided. The 2 of us can stop doing that, but it would mean that services do not get provided. I find that difficult to live with, and it's really easy for those who aren't in the sector to say that we should just stop doing it as it's not helpful.

As I said, management is aware, they're scared shitless of the threatened discrimination claims, and so they're humming and harring. I do blame them for being so wet about it. But my anger is chiefly at the 8 people who are taking the piss, because if they'd just do their bloody jobs then none of us would be in this mess and we could all just enjoy the benefits of WFH. Ultimately they'll probably be lost to all of us.

Belladonna12 · 03/03/2022 11:19

This is an interesting point - I work somewhere where we're very much not yet back at the office (and I don't think the company intends us ever to be completely back) and this is being overlooked - loads of my colleagues have terrible set ups that are going to fail a DSE assessment (mine doesn't because I have a back problem, so we spent our own money on a desk etc, but not everyone can do that, or has space to.) When the DSE assessments start being done properly again, aren't these colleagues going to have to go back into the office full time as the company can't allow them to work in unsafe conditions?

I suppose it will be up to the employee. I don't think the employers have to visit people to conduct the assessments. Where I work we do online training and assess ourselves. Noone checks I have done it properly. I doubt that they have to legally so most employers probably won't.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 03/03/2022 09:07

I work in provision of services to vulnerable people, so there are real life consequences if everyone just downs tools and leaves on the dot

I get that completely, and I'm honestly not suggesting anyone should grudge a short spell to finish what they're doing, but hours of unpaid work?

As I said upthread an awful lot of emotional blackmail goes on in the caring professions around vulnerable clients, and it's obviously right that folk care about them within the limits of their jobs
However I stand by my view that, while it might avert an immediate problem, it's not really helping the bigger picture if employees just pick up the slack themselves

LittleWins · 03/03/2022 08:26

@RobynMyEmployer

Working from the office: "I've finished all my work. May as well ask if there's anything else I can help with."

Working from home: "I've finished all my work. May as well walk the dog."

Again, not a WFH issue. This is a poor management issue.
110APiccadilly · 03/03/2022 07:06

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

To all those saying how great working from home is, have you got dedicated office space and does your WFH set up meet DSE requirements? I don't have an office and my set up in the dining room would fail a DSE risk assessment and there's no way to change it and I'm know there are people far worse off than me.
This is an interesting point - I work somewhere where we're very much not yet back at the office (and I don't think the company intends us ever to be completely back) and this is being overlooked - loads of my colleagues have terrible set ups that are going to fail a DSE assessment (mine doesn't because I have a back problem, so we spent our own money on a desk etc, but not everyone can do that, or has space to.) When the DSE assessments start being done properly again, aren't these colleagues going to have to go back into the office full time as the company can't allow them to work in unsafe conditions?
KatherineJaneway · 03/03/2022 06:55

I’m interested to understand why people feel they’d be so unproductive in an environment with colleagues around them?

I am less productive in the office. At home I choose when to reply to an IM or whether to let a phone call go to voicemail if I have an urgent deadline. In the office you can be easily interrupted. There are benefits of being in the office and I use my office days for those reasons as well as work I cannot do from home.

Lanareyrey · 03/03/2022 05:35

I have hated wfh and am glad to go back into the office. Our company has many problems with people being lazy wfh, so I welcome going back in and some normality.

Ciaobaby92 · 03/03/2022 04:41

I think the pandemic has opened our eyes to the fact that there is a better way to live. There is no need to force people to spend 8, 10, 12+ hours a day out of the home, when we could greatly improve the quality of our lives by having 2-3 days a week to WFH, if feasible. I do think it’s fair for employers to expect us to come in a couple times a week, if one was initially hired to work at the office. But there’s no reason to go back to the old 5+ days a week, commuting into work everyday if it’s not necessary.

I don’t even have children but I can see how the WFH model has taken a tremendous amount of stress off of my co-workers who do have children, and I support them completely. I appreciate having an extra couple days a week to be home with my old dog, and it means the world to her to have me home more, and not too tired and stressed out from a 12 hour day to walk her. There’s so much more to life than just working.