Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
Livelovebehappy · 27/02/2022 10:12

It’s a difficult one. Whilst a lot of people are equally productive at home as in the office, there are some that take the piss. We have cases where some colleagues are just popping out willy nilly while at home, and never seem to be contactable. Appear on zoom calls with a toddler on their knee when they’ve been told absolutely no child care during working hours. Each company will determine what’s best for them based on how their employees are doing.

DottyHarmer · 27/02/2022 10:11

@anotherneutralname - I agree. Ds and none of his friends want to sit in their bedrooms wfh.

Scouring for internships I have lost count of the number that are discontinued. One ds showed me last week actually stated that their internship programme was no longer running due to all staff working from home.

So the wfh thing is all very fine if you have a decent set up and are settled in life - just a big FU to those coming behind.

Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 10:11

People who say you have to suck it up or they'll fire you probably have jobs that can't be done from home and don't like it that yours can

Not going down without a fight, are you? Or without a few insults aimed at anybody holding a view different to yours.

Unfortunately for you, you can’t get around the fact that the employer has the power and can require you to work from an office location if that is what your contract says that you must do.

ThreeRingCircus · 27/02/2022 10:10

I'm not sure what you mean regarding tax status changes or occupational health having to make sure you have the correct office setup. If that hasn't had to change in the last two years while people have worked at home why would it need to change now?

I'm not sure on the tax question, other than companies have had to offer the working from home tax rebate at a cost to them but on the occ health point the Health and Safety Executive acknowledged that the pandemic was a temporary situation and suspended the requirement for DSE assessments (short of sending out information to employees, which we did.) They will eventually need to come back in though and employers have a duty in Health and Safety law to meet certain requirements, including assessing the safety and suitably of their employees workstations. If your employer hasn't done that ever before then they're likely in breach of the regulations.

Cakecakeandcake · 27/02/2022 10:10

Last week I tried to speak to my bank, on hold for 50 minutes, that was bad enough but when I eventually got through to the operator. There was kids crying, couldn’t hear the operator. Surely if working from home folk should have childcare in place? Why aren’t folk going back to the office anyway?

Thirkettle · 27/02/2022 10:09

Just quit and get a remote role.

I'm a software dev. Anyone who tries to enforce an office rule gets nothing more than a pile of resignations. In my industry no one's even trying unless they want to lose a whole team.

Ignore the bootlickers. You don't owe your employers anything and don't need to be 'grateful' for a job. They're paying you for your life. You have all the power.

zingally · 27/02/2022 10:08

My partner works in social care. He was office-based pre-covid, and organised carers to go into people's homes.

He was moved (along with the rest of his department) to home-working at the start of the pandemic, and still hasn't gone back.

There was a bit of talk about going back last summer... didn't happen. Then it was supposed to happen this past September... didn't happen.

He's been into the office MAYBE 8 times since this all kicked off, and as far as I can gather, there's now no imminent plans to return to office-based work. And honestly, he prefers working from home anyway!

HavfrueDenizKisi · 27/02/2022 10:05

This will be the start of two pay structures.

One for those who are in the office 3 or more days a week

One for full time WFH.

Why would a company, say in central London, pay a good high wage for someone who lives 300 miles away who has lower costs for housing and no commute?

So they will restructure their pay to reflect this IMO.

This may start with those refusing to come to the office having low/no bonuses and limited or no pay rises.

As they naturally move onto other jobs the new contracts will be exceptionally clear if they are WFH full time or hybrid. And pay will reflect this.

SummerSazz · 27/02/2022 10:05

I run 4 teams and have asked for 2 days in the office. Each team have their days when they are in so they can catch up in their weekly team meeting, collaborate and problem solve more easily. It IS different/more productive ftf in my workplace to do this.

We have taken on a number of people over the last 2 years and they've found it hard to build proper relationships with everything online. This is especially true for the apprentices & grads who haven't had the learning by observation/osmosis which they really crave.

I'm happy to be flexible with the teams but we have to have ftf time. If anyone flatly refused I wouldn't be impressed and would take things further

Meandmini3 · 27/02/2022 10:00

If you expect to be paid then you should expect to do what your employer tells you to do really! It’s not unreasonable to want employees in the workplace.

GoldenOmber · 27/02/2022 09:59

Oh, and some of the holdouts at my work are already managing to piss off their colleagues without realising it. So people may imagine they have more support than they do.

We had a big discussion the other week about how often to have a particular kind of meeting, and agreed it’d be once a month in a particular location, flexibility around the date to suit working patterns.

Immediately: “But we can’t meet there, it doesn’t have decent videoconferencing setup. And people working from home won’t be able to join in the collaborative parts anyway so we should restructure those. And I know you said it would be in person but we need to be inclusive of the people who prefer a 100% work from home pattern.”

Er, no we don’t, and good luck getting the rest of us to join you on the barricades with that approach Dave.

AllOfUsAreDead · 27/02/2022 09:57

@ufucoffee

Refuse if you want but if I was your employer I'd find a way to get rid of you. Get a job with a contract that lets you work from home if you love it so much.
The problem with that attitude is what if your employees take you up on that? Say op is in a team of 10 people, they all want to wfh, employer says no, so they think fine ill find another job. 5 are gone in a month, 3 more a month later. Down to 2 people very quickly, and considering its clearly a job that can be done at home, I wonder how quickly they'll manage to recruit 8 people for an inflexible company?

I imagine the manager by this point may have lost their job too or been demoted. Worked out well didn't it?

See it now already, bad companies looking for staff and can't get any. Can't think why...

TheKeatingFive · 27/02/2022 09:57

I think the employer has the final say on whether it has proven successful and should continue

Quite.

marieantoinehairnet · 27/02/2022 09:55

@CallmeHendricks

I'm curious about the "doing the school run" thing. So, you take 20 mins or so out of your afternoon to collect the kids - then what? Bring them home and..... who is supervising them after that, whilst you're meant to be back at your laptop? You're being paid to work at that point, not do childcare.
I pick one of mine yo, he's at senior school. It take me 15 mins in total, there are no buses, DH does half the week, me the other.

The youngest two go to an Afterschool club.

I take those 15 mins from my lunch break, it hurts no one but gives me peace of mind.

When he gets home he does his homework and gets on himself.

Seriously, some people are so bitter!!

Gowithme · 27/02/2022 09:55

DH's company are 3 days in office, two WFM but he negotiated and now only has to go in if absolutely required - and hasn't been in yet. People who say you have to suck it up or they'll fire you probably have jobs that can't be done from home and don't like it that yours can. Finding and hiring new, good people is a huge hassle.

gannett · 27/02/2022 09:52

@anotherneutralname

To add a bit more anecdote to the mix, about 90% of our 20s/ early 30s employees are keen to be back in the office a few days a week. They've basically "got their tasks done" while WFH and have done their best but we, and they, feel they haven't had the access to informal learning that comes from just being around more experienced specialists. With all the effort we've made at delivering training and mentoring remotely, it still hasn't given them the same pace of career development we would expect.

Plus most of them share houses, sometimes with strangers, so are living and working from a single room - two years of this has been terrible for mental health, understandably.

It will of course take time to rebuild confidence about travelling and being around people, so it makes sense to start gradually. But we do need to start.

Long term, I would expect those who can work a hybrid pattern to see their careers accelerate past those who remain fully remote. And yes, I know once you get to a certain seniority that might not be the case, but as employers we need to give people the best chance to get up to that level first.

A lot of the perceived benefits/negatives of WFH really depend on your industry and role - I'm sure this is true in some companies but it doesn't apply across the board.

I worked from home for a decade before the pandemic, starting when I was - gasp - a 20-something in a flatshare - it was still far better for my mental health than the hell of open-plan offices. I networked online, which I was much better at the networking IRL. It also enabled me to network with people I couldn't necessarily meet in person anyway. Result, I was able to work internationally as well as in my city and now work for an international company - I've never met most of my team (though I've known some online for over a decade) and there's no detriment to the quality of our work.

twominutesmore · 27/02/2022 09:50

"But a measure that has been proven to be successful for many people, companies, organisations."

I think the employer has the final say on whether it has proven successful and should continue. It will have worked for some, as evidenced on here, with many companies electing to continue wfh or allow a hybrid arrangement, but not for others, regardless of what the employee thinks or wants.

Wordlewobble · 27/02/2022 09:49

So in answer to tour question OP if someone on the shielded list whose condition is protected by DDA and whose employers seem to be choosing to bypass OH recommendations can be expected to return to work then I think it depends on your employer how they proceed so you can be strongly encouraged to return to work.

luckylavender · 27/02/2022 09:48

Largely a company CAN tell you what to do or you can look for a different job. Problem solved.

Mrsmch123 · 27/02/2022 09:48

If your contract says you are working from the office you either go back or change to a job were wfh is the case🤷🏻‍♀️
Out of curiosity why are you so against it?

eca80 · 27/02/2022 09:47

@gannett

Workers should 100% agitate for better working conditions, not sit around waiting for them to be granted. The best way to do this is as a group. OP's colleagues shouldn't just refuse on an ad hoc basis though, they should actually team up and make a formal request to keep WFH. Cite whatever numbers and examples that show your performance hasn't been affected, cite improvements to your work-life balance and mental health.

Staff have strength in numbers. Presumably most if not all of them are good at their jobs and it's in the company's interests to retain them. Hold the line - you have more power than you think if you work together and it's a completely reasonable request.

Posters talking the big talk about "I'd just FIRE YOU ALL" seem pretty ignorant about how good companies operate. Good companies hire employees who are good at their jobs, not identikit drones who can be replaced at the drop of a hat.

In many companies I know about, returning to the office hasn't been a blanket order from on high, it's been negotiated with staff, particularly talented staff, and what they want has been fully taken into account.

Well said
gannett · 27/02/2022 09:45

Workers should 100% agitate for better working conditions, not sit around waiting for them to be granted. The best way to do this is as a group. OP's colleagues shouldn't just refuse on an ad hoc basis though, they should actually team up and make a formal request to keep WFH. Cite whatever numbers and examples that show your performance hasn't been affected, cite improvements to your work-life balance and mental health.

Staff have strength in numbers. Presumably most if not all of them are good at their jobs and it's in the company's interests to retain them. Hold the line - you have more power than you think if you work together and it's a completely reasonable request.

Posters talking the big talk about "I'd just FIRE YOU ALL" seem pretty ignorant about how good companies operate. Good companies hire employees who are good at their jobs, not identikit drones who can be replaced at the drop of a hat.

In many companies I know about, returning to the office hasn't been a blanket order from on high, it's been negotiated with staff, particularly talented staff, and what they want has been fully taken into account.

anotherneutralname · 27/02/2022 09:45

To add a bit more anecdote to the mix, about 90% of our 20s/ early 30s employees are keen to be back in the office a few days a week. They've basically "got their tasks done" while WFH and have done their best but we, and they, feel they haven't had the access to informal learning that comes from just being around more experienced specialists. With all the effort we've made at delivering training and mentoring remotely, it still hasn't given them the same pace of career development we would expect.

Plus most of them share houses, sometimes with strangers, so are living and working from a single room - two years of this has been terrible for mental health, understandably.

It will of course take time to rebuild confidence about travelling and being around people, so it makes sense to start gradually. But we do need to start.

Long term, I would expect those who can work a hybrid pattern to see their careers accelerate past those who remain fully remote. And yes, I know once you get to a certain seniority that might not be the case, but as employers we need to give people the best chance to get up to that level first.

QuirkyTurtle · 27/02/2022 09:44

[quote macshoto]@QuirkyTurtle My experience in professional services is that our graduates in their first 3 years are largely saying how much better it is being back in the office than wfh.

Appreciate it may be different in other roles, but in an organisation where a lot of learning on the job happens, relying on coaching from more senior team members, gathering in the office (or at client sites) has real value.

I completely agree we are very unlikely to return to 5 days a week in an office, but I think 2/3 days / week on average through the year is likely to be the minimum for people who want to progress.[/quote]
I see! Yes I know my views are anecdotal and probably tied to my industry. I work in sales which is already notorious for its flexibility, especially since it's very easy to measure performance against numbers and we've seen in increase in performance rather than decrease. Reading all these comments though I can see that for some industries and workplaces this may not apply.

I've trained most of my team during the pandemic and definitely agree some things are easier in person. During training stages I probably would be stricter on office work.

I am not saying office work should be illegal, I'm just an advocate for offering the choice, if performance isn't affected.

BoredZelda · 27/02/2022 09:44

I’m a teacher so obviously don't have the option to wfh but am surprised that so many people are digging their heels in about staying at home when it was only ever a temporary measure.

But a measure that has been proven to be successful for many people, companies, organisations. The more forward thinking less dinosaur companies were already moving to a hybrid, this simply pushed many of those who were reluctant by demonstrating to them, actually there are some benefits to it.

I have worked for companies who had a hybrid WFH for about ten years.