Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
pawpaws2022 · 27/02/2022 11:35

Oh and I do between 150-200 calls a day. I physically cannot answer any more so sorry if there's a queue, but it's not because we aren't working

LondonQueen · 27/02/2022 11:33

Depends what your contract says. If it is for a fixed place of work they are well within their rights to dismiss you.

pawpaws2022 · 27/02/2022 11:33

@Guineapigssweak

Those refusing to return to the office need to be fired. They are taking the pi## !!! Using a pandemic to justify an easy working life probably sitting on their backside most of the day. When ever I've had to make important phone calls I have struggled to get an answer or wait in a queue for over an hour and this didn't happen before the pandemic. Totally unacceptable.
It's busy! If you're ringing a call centre they are the most monitored staff you will find My boss knows how many minutes I spend making a brew/in the toilet, when I am sending an email My screen is recorded, audio is recorded, I am at my desk ALL DAY and can't move unless it's for breaks and lunch Breaks and lunch are timed, to the second and we lose all our bonuses if we are late twice

We have people complaining they are waiting and it's because of WFH - it's not because I am the only one WFH! It's because we are short staffed and busier than ever

I mean I don't know how monitored you think we are but trust me, it's HEAVILY

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 11:31

Has that actually happened though? In my experience this kind of thing is much more likely to be big talk that doesn't amount to anything.

At the moment it is. I spoke to one of the few people in the office and they said they'd been in every day and there were never more than around 20 people at any point when as I said there should be around 300.

OP posts:
YellowMonday · 27/02/2022 11:28

It's an interesting question.

At the end of the day, it comes down to your contract, and any WFH agreement your workplace is willing to agree.

My work is taking a hybrid approach, with a ramp up to minimum 3 days a week in the office. There is no room for discussion here. If this doesn't work, this isn't the workplace for you. Everyone is replaceable.

I actually think it's really important to be back in the office. Work is so much more than tasks, and teams/zoom cannot replace the organic conversations/huddles/brain storming that happens in person.

I also have concerns for the junior members in my team over the pandemic WFH not being able to build their networks - being able to go for a walk and talk or coffee with heads of department and c-suite is so important at grad/entry/junior levels.

Fireflygal · 27/02/2022 11:27

I find it extremely important for the sake of young people that this new status quo is maintained. The old boomer mentality of working yourself to death

This is very naive. No one wants to work themselves to death but older people have more experience of trends in the economy and have seen high periods of unemployment due to UK lack of productivity. There are real tangible benefits of working in an office - even the most hi tech companies, developing software prefer people to work closely as it facilities ideas and higher quality. Younger staff lose the experience of being around senior staff, often picking up soft skills that they are not even aware of. Being in sn office creates a culture which just can't be replaced online.

Conversely work ethic has reduced significantly since wfh and to ignore it is foolish (for the economy, which will affect younger people) I've had supplier conversations that just wouldn't happen if they were in an open office. I've had a formal complaint upheld (and financial compensation) against another company because one of their staff acted so poorly which I know was as a direct result of no oversight. I've had projects delayed because the WFH people simply aren't completing tasks. I've called people just after 9am and know they are not long out of bed - a new graduate confirms this. Wakes at 8:30am and in pj bottoms but work top at 9am. They think they are getting away with it but they absolutely are not!

I don't like commuting, I want work life balance but I'm also a realist and know wfh can't continue.

TheKeatingFive · 27/02/2022 11:25

I'm talking about the scenario where 90% of the employees aren't coming in as told and how the company reacted.

Has that actually happened though? In my experience this kind of thing is much more likely to be big talk that doesn't amount to anything.

If you want to actually change the terms of your contract, I suggest you approach it like an adult and enter into proper negotiations. Rather than refusing to turn up to your contracted workplace - that's very childish. If I were an employer I wouldn't be too sanguine about the long term future of employees who carried on like that.

bellac11 · 27/02/2022 11:18

@FrippEnos

I spent 2 hours on hold on the phone the other day to try and sort out an issue caused by the company.

They have reduced the work hours on the phone to 4 hrs per day (10 till 2)

I have spent 6 hours i total waiting in various queues to try and sort the problem only to be informed by the recorded message that all the operatives are busy.

The emails that I have sent are in "Dated" queues and the letters that I have sent are unanswered.

So me being against WFH (in some circumstances) isn't about jealousy or other such bullshit.

Its about jobs not being done in a timely fashion that causes me (the client/customer) the least hassle and cost.

Totally agree, as a customer, service provision from companies has completely gone down the pan with people working from home. Some of that will be absenteeism due to illness obviously but not all.
eca80 · 27/02/2022 11:12

@bellac11 “Whats your evidence for this considering that lots of people were office based before the pandemic, was it sex discrimination then?”

Yes

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 11:12

Also further clarification - yes I've seen threads about an individual refusing to go back into the office. I'm talking about the scenario where 90% of the employees aren't coming in as told and how the company reacted. Have they put their foot down and those 90% faced consequences, or was the company forced to be more flexible with their office working policies?

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 27/02/2022 11:11

Agree with Glowtastic. A lot gets done informally when one sees people in person. It's also much easier to pick up the organisational mood vi's a vi's a strategic decision making.

My team worked from home adequately. No face to face rtw checks, interviews on teams, no learning from "sitting next to nellie" and I think some issues around development because it's hard to judge leadership skills when people work from home. Also a lot more management time is taken up with formal whole team and sub team meetings which have to be very very regular.

I have found wfh often very intense and have had days where teams meetings have started at 8.30/9 and ended at 6/6.30 because nothing can be dealt with on an ad-hoc basis. I have never worked so hard in my life as in the last 2 years.

We are embracing hybrid. Minimum of 40/50% of time in the office. I am going in 4 days a week - I like the divide between home and work. It's interesting to see who wants to come in and who is resisting though.

In London it's a candidates market at present and some element of working from home is proving a good benefit.

bellac11 · 27/02/2022 11:09

@catgirl1976

It’s interesting

We are back in 3 / 4 days a week so I’m looking for another job as there is no justifiable reason. My role can be down (and has been done) perfectly well remotely

A blanket “you must be back in the office x days a week” runs the risk of indirect sex discrimination imo. However that’s not a fight I can be arsed to have so I’ll just get another job and vote with my feet as will my colleagues

Whats your evidence for this considering that lots of people were office based before the pandemic, was it sex discrimination then?
FrippEnos · 27/02/2022 11:07

I spent 2 hours on hold on the phone the other day to try and sort out an issue caused by the company.

They have reduced the work hours on the phone to 4 hrs per day (10 till 2)

I have spent 6 hours i total waiting in various queues to try and sort the problem only to be informed by the recorded message that all the operatives are busy.

The emails that I have sent are in "Dated" queues and the letters that I have sent are unanswered.

So me being against WFH (in some circumstances) isn't about jealousy or other such bullshit.

Its about jobs not being done in a timely fashion that causes me (the client/customer) the least hassle and cost.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 27/02/2022 11:04

If you can do your job WFH then I don’t see the need to go into the office. Given the environmental costs of unnecessary travel it seems sensible for people to WFH if they can do so effectively. Times have changed but some organisations don’t seem to have kept up it seems.

Gwenhwyfar · 27/02/2022 11:04

"You’ve proved your job can be done from home

Have they?"

Yes, but there is a difference between wfh when everyone else is at home and wfh when colleagues are starting to go back in. In peak wfh time, for example, our finance dpt accepted email approval of invoices, now they require a signature and a printout. Soon visitors will be allowed back into the office, etc. etc.

LouisRenault · 27/02/2022 11:03

Yes - I'm losing patience with the "sorry for the delay- covid" hold messages on ALL major companies phone lines these days

Yes, customer service has gone down the pan, both commercial companies and official departments. Either you're waiting in a phone queue for hours, or you have to wait for a call back to deal with your issue, and no they can't tell you when they will call, even though the website says otherwise, or it's all done online, or via text conversation on a mobile, and God forbid your problem is a little out of the ordinary and you need to speak to an actual person to explain it.

All this makes life especially hard for older people, and even more so when the issue is related to a bereavement and things are difficult enough.

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 11:02

Whoah a lot of replies. I've only just checked this thread!

To clarify a few things. Before the pandemic we were in the office 5 days a week. It's a computer based job and we work mostly independently. We went fully remote when the pandemic hit. The company (seniors high up) are now saying compulsory 3 days a week. Our managers are saying do what you want and that they're not going to force us.

There's not a "big outrage" as such because our direct managers are being lax about it, but people just aren't bothering even though we're getting emails from high up saying we HAVE to go in. We have to scan into our office with an id card so they know who's in and who isn't.

I'm in London. And for the couple here that suggested my colleagues and I want to work from home to "slack". No. The london commute is horrendous and we work the same from home than in the office.

I'm just intrigued how this will work out that's all. The company has pissed a lot of people off during the pandemic with some of their actions. To those that have suggested to tread carefully because they can offshore for much cheaper, they're already doing this. There's people who have left already because of some of the stupid things the company have done during the pandemic and they've replaced them with cheaper contractors abroad. Morale is very low and I have a feeling people don't care if they get fired as we're in a competitive industry. So I'm just intrigued how this will pan out. The company now have hundreds of unhappy employees that are just not coming into the office even though they've been told to. Yes hundreds. I'm talking about seeing maybe 20 people in the office when I went in when there should be around 300.

Maybe they will get rid of us all and offshore all our work? Will be interesting to see their next move.

OP posts:
Belladonna12 · 27/02/2022 11:01

@DottyHarmer

Yes, an IT expert is in demand. But not everyone is in this category. Thousands are desperate to work in the civil service (unlike the 80s and early 90 when they were struggling).

Regarding home office set-up, one employee wfh asked Dh for a full ergonomic assessment and special chair/desk etc in her house. Dh replied, “You’ve got a fully-assessed workstation waiting here in the office - you are welcome to use it.”

I think my company would say that too which is why I'm surprised that according to a post above they have to assess workstations if people do any work at home.
DuchessofAnkh1 · 27/02/2022 11:01

"- I am much more productive at home, being able to get on with things without distractions, or worry about having to leave on time"

I have just had a number of discussions with members of staff who are now back in the office full time.

They say they are "overwhelmed" with work, despite being "more productive at home".

The problem is they would work hard and deeply on one project with little office interaction and miss two others which people in the office would have to pick up. The reason they are overwhelmed now is they need to relearn how to work quickly on multiple projects and "get them done" in a shorter space of time.

Gwenhwyfar · 27/02/2022 11:01

@Belladonna12

Do people's contracts actually state where they will be working?
Yes, I think mine says something like the office address or on the premises of the employer. However, that didn't stop my employer sometimes going further than the law on wfh and mandating home working when it wasn't the law so if they can go against the contract, why can't an employee?
anotherneutralname · 27/02/2022 11:01

@gannett I'm really glad that was true for you, and I'm sure it's true for some of our people too. However most of our 20-somethings have been asking to come back into the office, and started to return as soon as they could, citing the strain of their living arrangements / isolation on their mental health as a reason. Neither they nor us are saying it's all or nothing.

So, I think we're actually in agreement that flexibility is key Smile

Glowtastic · 27/02/2022 11:00

@Truthlikeness

I think some people who want to work from home subconsciously or deliberately underestimate the impact on their job. We've been able to do our job adequately for the last 2 years mainly WFH but it would have been far easier and better to be seeing each other and building solid working relationships, having the ad hoc conversations that often lead to surprising solutions.
Agree with this, a lot of creativity, innovation and problem solving goes on in those ad hoc conversations between colleagues and stuff gets resolved more quickly. Having to have constant teams calls is draining and often little gets sorted aside from planning another meeting. Group ms teams calls are a nightmare as it's often hard to know when to speak so you can't get your point across. It's usually the higher paid entitled staff who advocate WFH whilst the lower paid support staff still have to go in and suffer the commute etc.
eca80 · 27/02/2022 10:58

@Iamthewombat

People who say you have to suck it up or they'll fire you probably have jobs that can't be done from home and don't like it that yours can

Not going down without a fight, are you? Or without a few insults aimed at anybody holding a view different to yours.

Unfortunately for you, you can’t get around the fact that the employer has the power and can require you to work from an office location if that is what your contract says that you must do.

They only have the power if you let them. Massive labour shortages in many sectors means the employees have more power to negotiate new terms. Employers take a hard line at their peril.
wishmyhousetidy · 27/02/2022 10:58

I understand why many people like working from home but I do think the service the customer get is definitely poorer from many companies due to this, which isn’t fair as I am not paying a reduced cost for these services.
I get annoyed with people refusing to go back in but I sometimes am not sure whether it is just jealousy on my part as I have to go into work. However, I think being asked to only go in 3 days is a nice compromise and I am not sure why you feel it is unreasonable.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/02/2022 10:58

You’ve proved your job can be done from home

Have they?
It's true many claim this, but when it supports something that's wanted the old phrase "Well they would say that wouldn't they?" comes to mind
It may be so or it may not, but sometimes the view of the employer and that of the employee can differ, and not always because of "presenteeism"

Interesting that even a hybrid model's being deemed presenteeism now though, but then it was bound to happen

Swipe left for the next trending thread