Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
TurquoiseDragon · 27/02/2022 12:07

This was only meant to be a temporary thing.

However, my organisation decided to do up the offices while we were wfh, and there are not enough desks, etc, for everyone. The idea is for a hybrid working pattern, so I'm going in twice a week.

We now have lockers instead of dedicated desks, and we book a desk in advance online.

I like the convenience of wfh, but it's also good to be in the office sometimes for those impromptu discussions that can get so much done. I also have some nice colleagues, so it's been great catching up. It's not the same wfh. We have Teams, but online calls don't seem to lend themselves to casual calling for a quick discussion.

We have had one or two people hired during the pandemiic who live a long way away. Not sure how that's going to work.

Belladonna12 · 27/02/2022 12:07

@Charlize43

Risky.

How long before companies work out that they can pay $2.44 an hour for a English speaking Filipino working at home to do the same job?

WFH also has a knock on effect for other economies, like transport and also local cafes that rely on lunch time traffic, shops, etc.

There is a bigger responsibility to consider, just because you want to be at home all day in your pyjamas.

If they can pay an english speaking Filipino to work at home then they would surely would do that anyway.
KimikosNightmare · 27/02/2022 12:06

One of the things I cant tolerate is people texting/watsapping asking people who are in the officer to 'just' do this or that

I hate working from home. We always had a skeleton team at all levels in the office . I was one of them and was doing things way below my paygrade/ not part of my job to help out- but stuff that now. If they want things done, get in to the office

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 27/02/2022 12:06

@GreenPepperRed

280 staff not coming into the office when they're supposed to??

I'd imagine the senior staff will start to target your line managers about their inability to manage their staff correctly. I hope none of you like your line managers, since you've all decided to put them in this position.

Most of the line managers aren't going in either! Mine said to me they're not going to force me or my colleagues to come in and if the company starts enforcing it then they themselves be leaving the company going elsewhere. Seems to be a common narrative I'm hearing at the moment. The problem is no one likes working for the company anymore because of their previous actions which I'm not going to go into because it's probably too much of an outing. It's going to be an interesting few months.

I mean, if you're not happy, leave, but behaving like a bunch of toddlers who don't want to go to their rooms is ridiculous.
Charlize43 · 27/02/2022 12:05

Risky.

How long before companies work out that they can pay $2.44 an hour for a English speaking Filipino working at home to do the same job?

WFH also has a knock on effect for other economies, like transport and also local cafes that rely on lunch time traffic, shops, etc.

There is a bigger responsibility to consider, just because you want to be at home all day in your pyjamas.

KimikosNightmare · 27/02/2022 12:03

The only thing that has changed is our senior management are now more open to us doing the occasional day from home, if you're spluttering with a cold but not actually too sick to work, or awaiting a delivery, or have stuff to do that is better with no disturbances. Before the pandemic this would have been frowned upon

I think it's actually gone the other way. Previously in my office not coming in if you had a terrible cold or sickness/ diarrhoea was fine. Now, if you're at home, as you say, "not too sick to work"

KimikosNightmare · 27/02/2022 11:59

@catgirl1976

It’s interesting

We are back in 3 / 4 days a week so I’m looking for another job as there is no justifiable reason. My role can be down (and has been done) perfectly well remotely

A blanket “you must be back in the office x days a week” runs the risk of indirect sex discrimination imo. However that’s not a fight I can be arsed to have so I’ll just get another job and vote with my feet as will my colleagues

No it doesn't. You might like to try and wangle it as such but it really doesn't. If you're playing the childcare card, then childcare is both parents responsibility and if you're working from home you still need to have childcare anyway.
ImInStealthMode · 27/02/2022 11:56

We've been back in the office since the moment we were allowed (we're not in the UK so rules have been slightly different) with a caveat that anyone who felt more comfortable WFH when 'if you can' guidance was in place, could. Only 2 staff members did.

Now that guidance has been lifted our workplace is the office and if we didn't come to the workplace I'm in no doubt we'd be sacked. The nature of our business requires talking to each other and across different teams all the time. We all work better in the office and were glad to get back.

The only thing that has changed is our senior management are now more open to us doing the occasional day from home, if you're spluttering with a cold but not actually too sick to work, or awaiting a delivery, or have stuff to do that is better with no disturbances. Before the pandemic this would have been frowned upon.

bellac11 · 27/02/2022 11:55

One of the things I cant tolerate is people texting/watsapping asking people who are in the officer to 'just' do this or that.

In addition the ones that sit all morning on the phone to IT or their own internet provider saying 'oh I cant get on the system this morning, been on hold for hours with IT/BT whatever'

Come into the office then and get on with your work.

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 11:54

280 staff not coming into the office when they're supposed to??

I'd imagine the senior staff will start to target your line managers about their inability to manage their staff correctly. I hope none of you like your line managers, since you've all decided to put them in this position.

Most of the line managers aren't going in either! Mine said to me they're not going to force me or my colleagues to come in and if the company starts enforcing it then they themselves be leaving the company going elsewhere. Seems to be a common narrative I'm hearing at the moment. The problem is no one likes working for the company anymore because of their previous actions which I'm not going to go into because it's probably too much of an outing. It's going to be an interesting few months.

OP posts:
7eleven · 27/02/2022 11:54

I was chatting to my daughter just last weekend about this. She is the partner responsible for HR in her company. She said that she was supportive of people wanting to do a hybrid system, but there are simply some aspects of the job that haven’t been performed as well at home. She said she was trying to negotiate, but would reluctantly implement procedures if people simply refused. Ultimately employers have the right to demand that their workforce comply with their contracts. She said she intended to everything she could to avoid it getting that far, but would if necessary. Of course employees then have the right to resign and get other jobs. However, her industry is inundated with high quality applicants, so I don’t think it’s really the case the the employees hold all the cards.

somanylies · 27/02/2022 11:51

You may be able to do your job at home but your company needs to look long-term. Its a lot harder for new staff, especially for inexperienced new staff, to get to grips with a role and team if they are not around other people. Most of my learning in new roles was done informally just from being around people and hearing their discussions. That's also how I identified and created new projects.

For established staff with established work networks, working from home may work for you, but not for the long term development of the company.

Personally, as a new member of staff in a new role before lockdown, I now feel completely disconnected from the team, completely un-developed in my role and have lost all commitment and connection to this job and team that I loved for the first few months we were in the office. I'm looking for a new job now directly because of this ( my work are not returning to the office for more than one day a week).

Twitterwhooooo · 27/02/2022 11:50

@FloraPostIt

I started a new job early in the pandemic and have been working from home pretty much constantly ever since. And it has been hard for me and other new people. It feels quite "them and us" between people who worked together pre-pandemic and those who joined after, because of the bonds they'd formed. It has been much harder to learn the role. It has often been very lonely.

People talk a lot about their own productivity without thinking that the productivity, development and well-being of of colleagues is important for the organisation too. Mentoring and working as a team is usually implicitly part of most people's roles, as well as output.

I get that people established in their role and networks prefer working from home. But there is a downside and so some flexibility - from both sides - is needed I think.

I think this is an extremely valid point, and also very relevant for younger people entering the workforce needing to be around more experienced people to learn, not sat in their bedroom on MSTeams all day.
FordSiesta · 27/02/2022 11:49

@tootiredtospeak

I work for a large corporation who hasn't done this yet but sure they will eventually. They paid before the pandemic for an expensive office city centre it fits £2000 in and is being used by less than 10% of that. I appreciate its more convenient for some to work at home but others have just got too used to it. Our economy will falter if everyone does this. Also think of youngsters. If we as older generations make this the new way of working life all our children will pay for that as employers may give up and sell the offices ect. Do you really want young people to have to start their working career stuck at home with minimal real life interaction. I hate how much my pre teens do this now and would hate for this to be their future. Hybrid yes FT WFH no and definitely not for the bullshit reasons some use.
THIS! Imagine having a baby today and in 18 years from now they start their first office job only its not an office, it's them working from a desk in their bedroom with no social interactions or learning to work with others in a real setting!
Nidan2Sandan · 27/02/2022 11:48

280 staff not coming into the office when they're supposed to??

I'd imagine the senior staff will start to target your line managers about their inability to manage their staff correctly. I hope none of you like your line managers, since you've all decided to put them in this position.

FloraPostIt · 27/02/2022 11:47

I started a new job early in the pandemic and have been working from home pretty much constantly ever since. And it has been hard for me and other new people. It feels quite "them and us" between people who worked together pre-pandemic and those who joined after, because of the bonds they'd formed. It has been much harder to learn the role. It has often been very lonely.

People talk a lot about their own productivity without thinking that the productivity, development and well-being of of colleagues is important for the organisation too. Mentoring and working as a team is usually implicitly part of most people's roles, as well as output.

I get that people established in their role and networks prefer working from home. But there is a downside and so some flexibility - from both sides - is needed I think.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 27/02/2022 11:46

@GreenPepperRed

A lot of rudeness slating me as an employee which is completely unnecessary...

I'm honestly envisioning a mass exodus of employees if they put their foot down and the company going down the shitter because of it. Will be interesting to watch. At this point most people I've spoken to there are looking for another job. I supposed we must all be awful employees and the company is perfect Grin

Nothing wrong with looking for a new job if your current one no longer suits you - that's normal, and if the company see a mass-exodus of excellent employees, they may well reconsider things.

But "refusing to go into the office" just seems really petulant and silly.

TheKeatingFive · 27/02/2022 11:46

A lot of rudeness slating me as an employee which is completely unnecessary.

Not really.

Ignoring direct commands and the terms of your contract isn't a mature way of handling things. It won't come across well to anyone.

I'm honestly envisioning a mass exodus of employees if they put their foot down and the company going down the shitter because of it.

This sounds like a fantasy tbh. I get that it's fun to imagine, but you should probably think a bit harder about your game plan if this doesn't come to pass.

Bringsexyback · 27/02/2022 11:44

I do sometimes wonder if I live in a parallel universe. I have had absolutely no issues whatsoever with customer service over the last two years. my team have had record-breaking years in terms of revenue, obviously we’re saving an absolute fortune when we don’t renew the massive office lease that we currently have … we are counting the days down until we can get rid of that, everybody’s got rid of desktops and they’ve been replaced with laptops which are far superior.

I genuinely don’t understand all the forelock tugging that goes on here, this is the first time in nearly 30 years that the workers hold all the cards and yet so many are trying to scaremonger the masses is into towing the line again. what is wrong with you ?

Brainwave89 · 27/02/2022 11:44

WFH was an emergency measure. Most jobs require good collaboration and team work in my experience and this is not best done by working from home completely. Most employers are now working flexibly and it seems that yours are as well. I have had some staff who have refused to return in my team- one as they purchased a dog in lockdown and do not want anyone else looking after it. A number as they are managing childcare alongside working. We have taken disciplinary action and ultimately will dismiss. We pay well, so this will be a big loss to the people concerned, but most employers will rightly take a strong line.

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 11:42

A lot of rudeness slating me as an employee which is completely unnecessary...

I'm honestly envisioning a mass exodus of employees if they put their foot down and the company going down the shitter because of it. Will be interesting to watch. At this point most people I've spoken to there are looking for another job. I supposed we must all be awful employees and the company is perfect Grin

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 27/02/2022 11:37

At the moment it is.

Well I'd expect the crackdown is imminent. I can't imagine a senior management putting up with people ignoring direct requests and the terms of their contract like that. If you are interested in a long term future with your company, you need to engage with them much more smartly than this.

WouldIBeATwat · 27/02/2022 11:37

It also determines how expenses are treated. If you have a WFH contract then trips to the office have to be paid for.

The Covid requirements do not constitute a contractual change.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/02/2022 11:36

If you want to actually change the terms of your contract, I suggest you approach it like an adult and enter into proper negotiations. Rather than refusing to turn up to your contracted workplace - that's very childish

IME it can also suggest that they're not very senior in the first place, since those who are tend to have a better grasp of business needs and often resist behaving like this - though of course it doesn't stop the former insisting that they really are indespensable

In a case like this though, since it turns out the company are already offshoring, I'd be very careful what I wished for

godmum56 · 27/02/2022 11:35

Belladonna12
"Do people's contracts actually state where they will be working?"

@Gwenhwyfar
"Yes, I think mine says something like the office address or on the premises of the employer.
However, that didn't stop my employer sometimes going further than the law on wfh and mandating home working when it wasn't the law so if they can go against the contract, why can't an employee?

Our standard NHS contracts used to say something like "your assigned work base will be xxx but you may be required to work elsewhere according to the needs of the service" Its put in for many reasons, one of which is so that folk can't blanket refuse to go to meetings/seminars etc elsewhere.