Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
KimikosNightmare · 27/02/2022 13:26

So you are saying employers can't work out for themselves whether the job could be done at home (or a Filipino at home) even though their employees have been at home for two years and they will only know if employees "insist".

Nope, not saying that. The ethos in my company would have been to employ locally but if employees aren't going to cooperate with us, then we might have a rethink.

marieantoinehairnet · 27/02/2022 13:22

@GreenPepperRed

Also further clarification - yes I've seen threads about an individual refusing to go back into the office. I'm talking about the scenario where 90% of the employees aren't coming in as told and how the company reacted. Have they put their foot down and those 90% faced consequences, or was the company forced to be more flexible with their office working policies?
I completely appreciate site where you are coming from here, it's very hard to see 80% of your colleagues doing what they want and never coming in, when you are part of the mandated group being forced in - very demoralising
KimikosNightmare · 27/02/2022 13:21

@VladmirsPoutine

People who are desperate to have everyone return to the office truly baffle me. Unless you have shares in Starbucks or commercial buildings are your asset then wtf!
I wonder how many pension pots have shares in commercial buildings?
madroid · 27/02/2022 13:20

And I don't think it's the case that businesses have had to have WFH forced on them to recognise it's benefits.

If it was that beneficial for a business, they would have implemented it before the pandemic. It wholly depends on the business, the employment market and the (regional) economy as to whether WFH is good for the business.

If it's not, then employees will be asked to return and deemed to resign if not because they are not delivering their contract.

madroid · 27/02/2022 13:16

@GreenPepperRed We can do our jobs from home. It's beyond me why my company are doing this.

In my experience, that's exactly the problem.

Employees are often quite siloed in their thinking. They don't see the bigger picture.

But if you read through all the responses here, you'll see the reasons that extend beyond individual roles.

They are the reasons that keep a company profitable productive and progressive - everything from assessing WFH arrangements, equipment, productivity, customer service to training, collaboration and teamwork/culture.

If you are running a business, these are vital considerations that individual workers often don't appreciate. Sometimes it's the manager and senior ppl that made WFH work for the business. Because they had to, to keep everyone in work. Now, that's no longer the case and they want workers back.

Gwenhwyfar · 27/02/2022 13:12

"Do you genuinely think that anyone who can see the value of teams working together in an office for part of the week is a ‘forelock tugger’ or, in the words of PPs a ‘boot licker’ or an ‘old boomer’?"

I can see the value of teams working together in the same place for part of the week and I'm nowhere near being the forelock tugger people talk about. I'm really a work to live person, it's got nothing to do with sucking up to management or anything like that.
When I'm in the office I know a lot more about what other teams are doing, what is going on. I interact with more than just my direct team and I can ask or answer questions from various people who would never ring me if I was at home.

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 13:12

Woweee a really sore subject amongst mumsnetters it seems Grin I'm not offended about any of these posts or feel insecure in what I do or my position at work. Amazing what absolute nastiness comes out of a question on a forum, the irony from people telling me how to be professional as well!

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 27/02/2022 13:12

People coming up with all sorts of spurious reasons to have people go back to the office like 'team morale, team-building,' and nonsense about young people working from their bedrooms - where is all that concern for young people when it comes to them being able to afford housing? It's entirely disingenuous. WFH has been immensely life saving for marginalised groups such as those with disabilities or ethnic minorities.

I think WFH upsets a certain segment of middle management who really don't do much but annoy their underlings to make themselves feel important.

We've come close to reimagining a different mode of life and for those who hold all the power and their acolytes it's too terrifying.

Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 13:07

The OP seems offended that several posters have suggested that she is most likely a junior employee.

That’s because she is behaving like a junior employee. Anybody in a senior position will be there because they know how to engage in discussions appropriately. Not skulking at home and trying to organise a revolution against their employer.

Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 13:03

@Bringsexyback

I do sometimes wonder if I live in a parallel universe. I have had absolutely no issues whatsoever with customer service over the last two years. my team have had record-breaking years in terms of revenue, obviously we’re saving an absolute fortune when we don’t renew the massive office lease that we currently have … we are counting the days down until we can get rid of that, everybody’s got rid of desktops and they’ve been replaced with laptops which are far superior. I genuinely don’t understand all the forelock tugging that goes on here, this is the first time in nearly 30 years that the workers hold all the cards and yet so many are trying to scaremonger the masses is into towing the line again. what is wrong with you ?
Do you genuinely think that anyone who can see the value of teams working together in an office for part of the week is a ‘forelock tugger’ or, in the words of PPs a ‘boot licker’ or an ‘old boomer’?

All this bollocks about the workers having the power, etc. Yes, some workers do have power if they have top class, scarce skills. That’s a tiny proportion of the workforce. Not Claire who does admin for the environment agency and doesn’t fancy going back to the office because she doesn’t like paying for wrap around childcare.

Perhaps you have failed to notice that as a country we are churning out hundreds of thousands of graduates? All of them motivated to do well in life, to justify their investment in tuition costs. Any perceived labour shortage, which for most professions appears to be at junior levels only, won’t last long.

Don’t let that stop you manning the barricades, though, and complaining that anyone actually, you know, going into an office to work, like we all did pre-pandemic, is a willing slave to the whims of their employer.

This, from the OP:

The company has pissed a lot of people off during the pandemic with some of their actions. To those that have suggested to tread carefully because they can offshore for much cheaper,…There's people who have left already because of some of the stupid things the company have done during the pandemic and they've replaced them with cheaper contractors abroad.

What clearer evidence base does she need that her actions are foolish?

Morale is very low

I have never worked in any organisation where nobody has ever said, morale is very low.

The company now have hundreds of unhappy employees that are just not coming into the office even though they've been told to. Yes hundreds. I'm talking about seeing maybe 20 people in the office when I went in when there should be around 300.

As other posters have noted, the crackdown will be imminent.

Maybe they will get rid of us all and offshore all our work? Will be interesting to see their next move.

Yeah, that is what will happen. It has already begun, as you yourself have told us.

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 12:57

@CatJumperTwat

VladmirsPoutine It baffles me too! The anti-WFHers are always grasping at straws in this thread, desperately hoping everybody will be forced back into the office. So odd.
I don't understand this either tbh. I said in my previous posts I actually went into the office and am being branded a child, lazy, not possibly senior at all sorts asking if anyone else has been in the position where most people are not coming in when they've been told they have to. I don't blame anyone for not coming in at all because the company is completely out of touch in many aspects and their policies make no sense for my industry and the pandemic has allowed people to realise that. My industry is one that has also excelled and exploded massively due to the pandemic.

I honestly think my company is in trouble. Even if some start to come in, they can try offshore 50% of us if they want but I can't imagine it's going to go smoothly.

My company has implied they're going to go back to 5 days in at some point. We're all in professional skilled roles. We can do our jobs from home. It's beyond me why my company are doing this. Maybe long leases they can't get out of? But it's ok because most of us children are dispensable so they're going to be ok it seems...some strange responses here.

Just wondered if anyone was in a company in a similar position where most of the employees are not following the orders but apparently not. I guess that answers my question!

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 27/02/2022 12:49

I can't work out whether the "do what your employer says, no questions" posts

I can't say I see any of those.

What I see are posters pointing out that the OP can't just ignore the terms of her contract like a child having a tantrum.

If she wants to maturely renegotiate that contract, that's a different matter.

gannett · 27/02/2022 12:40

@Bringsexyback

I do sometimes wonder if I live in a parallel universe. I have had absolutely no issues whatsoever with customer service over the last two years. my team have had record-breaking years in terms of revenue, obviously we’re saving an absolute fortune when we don’t renew the massive office lease that we currently have … we are counting the days down until we can get rid of that, everybody’s got rid of desktops and they’ve been replaced with laptops which are far superior. I genuinely don’t understand all the forelock tugging that goes on here, this is the first time in nearly 30 years that the workers hold all the cards and yet so many are trying to scaremonger the masses is into towing the line again. what is wrong with you ?
This.

I can't work out whether the "do what your employer says, no questions" posts here are from (old-fashioned and plain bad) employers trying to crack the whip, or ground-down employees who don't know that a life beyond forelock-tugging is possible.

CatJumperTwat · 27/02/2022 12:39

VladmirsPoutine It baffles me too! The anti-WFHers are always grasping at straws in this thread, desperately hoping everybody will be forced back into the office. So odd.

7eleven · 27/02/2022 12:29

@GreenPepperRed

A lot of rudeness slating me as an employee which is completely unnecessary...

I'm honestly envisioning a mass exodus of employees if they put their foot down and the company going down the shitter because of it. Will be interesting to watch. At this point most people I've spoken to there are looking for another job. I supposed we must all be awful employees and the company is perfect Grin

Oh dear. Sounds like you need to grow up a bit maybe?
VladmirsPoutine · 27/02/2022 12:29

People who are desperate to have everyone return to the office truly baffle me. Unless you have shares in Starbucks or commercial buildings are your asset then wtf!

RosesAndHellebores · 27/02/2022 12:26

Lots of those complaining about going back right now will be braying to by the autumn when they realise they can take advantage of heating and lighting at work rather than suffer increased energy bills at home.

Also, work is a social.consteuxt and for those of us who need that working from home has been sound destroying.

Belladonna12 · 27/02/2022 12:26

@KimikosNightmare

If they can pay an english speaking Filipino to work at home then they would surely would do that anyway

Nope- not until workers started insisting that they can do it just as well at home. I can think now of several roles in my office where that wouldn't have been considered before, but now? Possibly

So you are saying employers can't work out for themselves whether the job could be done at home (or a Filipino at home) even though their employees have been at home for two years and they will only know if employees "insist".
Didyousaynutella · 27/02/2022 12:23

I think people that are refusing point blank are idiots and if their jobs get outsourced to a cheaper country it will be fully deserved. If a company is offering hybrid working from home then they are very lucky to have that option. As someone who hasn't had that option and had to go to work throughout this whole thing it annoys me. They should be grateful they have been able to work from home when they could and grateful companies are now offering a compromise.

moretrumpetplease · 27/02/2022 12:21

I was wfh the duration of the pandemic; we're now 2 days a week in the office. Don't like it, quit, my work are being very decent in giving us the 3 days wfh option (we can go in full time if we want) - my job can easily be done from home but we knew home working wasn't forever

ImInStealthMode · 27/02/2022 12:17

@KimikosNightmare If we are in fact too sick to work then it's still fine to take a genuine sick day (I did last week - when I called in I said I'd check emails later in the day and my MD categorically told me not to even think about it) but these days our company is far more open to people staying away with the type of mild cold symptoms they'd always have come in with before.

LouisRenault · 27/02/2022 12:14

People talk a lot about their own productivity without thinking that the productivity, development and well-being of of colleagues is important for the organisation too.

There's also the impact on other members of the household to consider. How many threads have there been -

DP wfh has taken over the living room and we all have to tiptoe round:

DP is always here and I never get any time to myself:

DP is on calls all day. He's really loud and it's so annoying:

(Plus the issues of confidentiality because as the person on the other end of the phone you don't know who might be overhearing.)

KimikosNightmare · 27/02/2022 12:12

If they can pay an english speaking Filipino to work at home then they would surely would do that anyway

Nope- not until workers started insisting that they can do it just as well at home. I can think now of several roles in my office where that wouldn't have been considered before, but now? Possibly

Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 12:10

@DottyHarmer

Yes, an IT expert is in demand. But not everyone is in this category. Thousands are desperate to work in the civil service (unlike the 80s and early 90 when they were struggling).

Regarding home office set-up, one employee wfh asked Dh for a full ergonomic assessment and special chair/desk etc in her house. Dh replied, “You’ve got a fully-assessed workstation waiting here in the office - you are welcome to use it.”

I like your husband’s style.

And yes, you are correct, loads of people want to work in the civil service or in government departments. For the pension, the benefits and the generous maternity pay, usually. You see loads of posts on MN from people asking advice on applications for civil service roles.

I’ve worked in the civil service. I got out as soon as I could! 60% of the people working there could be replaced in a heartbeat, probably with better candidates. So I don’t think that most of the civil service office refuseniks have a leg to stand on.

KimikosNightmare · 27/02/2022 12:09

@Charlize43

Risky.

How long before companies work out that they can pay $2.44 an hour for a English speaking Filipino working at home to do the same job?

WFH also has a knock on effect for other economies, like transport and also local cafes that rely on lunch time traffic, shops, etc.

There is a bigger responsibility to consider, just because you want to be at home all day in your pyjamas.

100% spot on. I can't be replaced by a $2.44 English speaking Filipino but several people in my office who don't want to come back could easily be.