Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
maddiemookins16mum · 27/02/2022 15:01

I’m fed up with this, I have three on my team who come up with every excuse under the sun to WFH full time. We’ve gone 3 days WFH, 2 office per week and I have a rota in place. I need people in the office, we deal with documents that need a wet signature from customers (both being sent out and received back into the office). We barely kept on top of this in lockdown, I was actually going into the office 5 days a week (as the Supervisor) to do all post despite it not really being my role.

These 3 staff members have come up with all sorts:
Dogs cannot be left
Petrol too expensive
No childcare (used a Childminder before)
Too noisy in the office
Bus times have changed
Have to get up earlier
Have to get dressed (yep!)
I’m pig sick of them all.
Thursday, one was due in to make sure all post was ready for Friday collection, never came and said ‘I got halfway to work and realised I’d left my pass at home so I wouldn’t have been able to print anything’ so may aswell just WFH.

GoldenOmber · 27/02/2022 14:52

@TrippinEdBalls

But yes my colleagues are hoping for a more flexible work policy than 3 days a week which seems like a controversial opinion here. I agree that 3 days a week in office is not necessary for my industry. I think they would keep a lot of people happy even if they reduced it by one day to 2.

I would bet a lot of money that whatever number of days the company had said, the colleagues who are now refusing to go in would have said it was one more than the reasonable maximum.

This is definitely the case at my work. Policy of coming in for one day every two weeks is still too much for some people.

Can’t speak for the OP’s work which does seem to have wider issues. But for mine, I fear what’s going to happen if enough people really dig their heels in when the orders are still pretty flexible, is that the organisation will respond by saying “okay flexibility didn’t work, we’ll start telling people what days to come in.” Which is not going to go down well with everyone else.

TrippinEdBalls · 27/02/2022 14:43

But yes my colleagues are hoping for a more flexible work policy than 3 days a week which seems like a controversial opinion here. I agree that 3 days a week in office is not necessary for my industry. I think they would keep a lot of people happy even if they reduced it by one day to 2.

I would bet a lot of money that whatever number of days the company had said, the colleagues who are now refusing to go in would have said it was one more than the reasonable maximum.

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 14:29

@Puzzledandpissedoff

I would argue that the bigger picture can still be maintained with a flexible work policy

But you said that's what you've been offered, with just 3 days in the workplace, only now so much of the thread hasn't gone your way it's somehow changed to "heading towards compulsory 5 days back in the office"

While we can't know about your particular workplace, some of us have been very clear that WFH can work brilliantly - though perhaps less so when some regard it as some sort of social crusade instead of a business negotiation based on the needs of all

Ok this is a fair point that I didn't make the culture of the company clear in my initial post.

They're very heavy handed usually and started off their enforcement email with words along the lines of (paraphrased) "in the first steps towards our ways of working post pandemic, we now require everyone to be in the office at least 3 days a week as of X"

The way they worded it sounded like they have plans to increase the number of compulsory days in the office in future.

Colleagues didn't take to that well and most didn't come in 3 days a week even though date X has passed. Some questioned why it has to even be 3 days a week compulsory. Most stayed quiet and just didn't bother coming in.

But yes my colleagues are hoping for a more flexible work policy than 3 days a week which seems like a controversial opinion here. I agree that 3 days a week in office is not necessary for my industry. I think they would keep a lot of people happy even if they reduced it by one day to 2. But it sounds like the company policies are heading in the opposite direction.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/02/2022 14:22

... mums of young kids who are using wfh as a mean not to pay for childcare who are always full of excuses why they are distracted in meetings, having to suddenly disappear or not able to join at all because its pick up time

Indeed

I've mentioned this on here before, but I was less than impressed when unable to hear a professional adviser because of kids screaming in the background
As it happens, in my particular circumstances she's working for a flat %, but considering her usual fee is £280ph I wouldn't expect much admiration from those who've been billed for extra time purely because they couldn't hear a word she was saying

VladmirsPoutine · 27/02/2022 14:22

My company have done something similar. Free breakfast, heavily subsidised lunch and free snacks. You could eat fish and chips with all the trimmings on a Friday for about £1.50.

Tohaveandtohold · 27/02/2022 14:17

My employer has said we’ll be back to the office 40% of the time from September but for now it’s one day a week. This only started last month and there has been lots of people who haven’t turned up to the office. To be fair, for my team, there’s no reason to be in the office, we have 4 people in England and the other 6 in Glasgow and Cardiff so we can’t really be in the same space. we still take our laptops to work and just do the same work just in a different location.

I like the hybrid working model and it works for me so I’m fine with it. They’ve also changed our contract to hybrid working. However, I have lots of colleagues who are not.
My employer is a global cooperation and they value their reputation so they can’t just fire people so they are trying to make the office more appealing like giving us free lunch, etc.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/02/2022 14:12

I would argue that the bigger picture can still be maintained with a flexible work policy

But you said that's what you've been offered, with just 3 days in the workplace, only now so much of the thread hasn't gone your way it's somehow changed to "heading towards compulsory 5 days back in the office"

While we can't know about your particular workplace, some of us have been very clear that WFH can work brilliantly - though perhaps less so when some regard it as some sort of social crusade instead of a business negotiation based on the needs of all

vivainsomnia · 27/02/2022 14:10

I agree with most employees being replaceable. There are many uni graduates full of enthusiasm and willing to learn. They want to work in offices.

I would 100% prefer to enjoy an inexperienced eager starter happy to be there than keep older blaze staff who think that coming 3 days a week is a massive asked.

Same with the mums of young kids who are using wfh as a mean not to pay for childcare who are always full of excuses why they are distracted in meetings, having to suddenly disappear or not able to join at all because its pick up time.

VladmirsPoutine · 27/02/2022 14:08

It was never meant to be a permanent thing, a lot of people seem to be forgetting that.

So what? Things change and evolve every day.

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 14:07

[quote AllOfUsAreDead]@GreenPepperRed

I would just leave now if I were you. If they are going to be daft and send more jobs offshore, let them. Let them figure out how to do that with very few staff left behind to train them.

Going offshore always seems simple, then you get customers complaining of bad service from abroad, they aren't trained right so they can't assist with problems internally or externally etc.

If the company goes under, that's their problem. Get out while you can.[/quote]
I agree with you and so do most of my colleagues seemingly as a lot have admitted they're keeping their eyes open for opportunities elsewhere. Weird thing is the company could prevent the chaos if they adopted more flexible working as opposed to compulsory 5 days a week in the office like where they're heading. I wish I could have been in the big senior meetings where they decided not to be flexible so I could hear what their reasonings were!

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/02/2022 14:03

The OP seems offended that several posters have suggested that she is most likely a junior employee
That’s because she is behaving like a junior employee. Anybody in a senior position will be there because they know how to engage in discussions appropriately. Not skulking at home and trying to organise a revolution against their employer

Quite so

I'd add a small caveat around being exercised about what "everyone else" is planning, mainly because I've seen this so often. Some issues attracts a lot of heat, but once things shake down many of the noise-makers tend to go off the radar, leaving those determined to hold out swinging in the wind and very much in the firing line for whatever follows

Just something to bear in mind when planning anything on the back of "everyone else" ...

AllOfUsAreDead · 27/02/2022 14:00

@GreenPepperRed

I would just leave now if I were you. If they are going to be daft and send more jobs offshore, let them. Let them figure out how to do that with very few staff left behind to train them.

Going offshore always seems simple, then you get customers complaining of bad service from abroad, they aren't trained right so they can't assist with problems internally or externally etc.

If the company goes under, that's their problem. Get out while you can.

Luredbyapomegranate · 27/02/2022 13:55

Dunno about your company.

Overall I’d guess we’ll end up with a hybrid work culture. In my company we don’t find working from home worked all that well FT, but it depends of course.

It depends how bothered they are. They are entitled to have workers back in the office, so if they want to, I guess they will take disciplinary action one department at a time, probably after a consultancy with HR/external advisers on strategy.

I don’t think they will need to fire everyone, as that will get a lot of people back to the office, especially if it’s not required to be full time. Then I’d guess a few people make get fired if they hold out.

CousinQuandary · 27/02/2022 13:53

skulking at home and trying to organise a revolution against their employer.

LOL. To the (virtual) barricades!

TheSmallAssassin · 27/02/2022 13:51

My organisation started off saying we all had to do at least 40% in the office, but we've ditched it now, because it didn't work and we were also missing out on good candidates when recruiting (we are employing a lot of new staff and it really is a job seekers market at the moment)

The team I lead is just as productive as it was when we were all on site together, we are still quite mixed, some in several days a week, some 100% homeworking and I don't see any reason to change that at the moment, but we will see how things go and try to accommodate everyone with a bit of compromise, if necessary. I prefer to work in the office, but I am still struggling to get ready on time in the morning Blush

I must admit I find it hard to understand the "just do what you're told" comments, I think the most successful businesses value their staff and know that listening to them and working together means you get the best out of your people and leads to a more productive workforce. If people aren't working productively at home, then that's a performance issue, rather than a working at home issue.

QuirkyTurtle · 27/02/2022 13:46

It was never meant to be a permanent thing, a lot of people seem to be forgetting that.

No, but in my industry, and certainly in my company, it has shown that it's possible without losing productivity, so why not offer employees the choice?

But I recognise it's not feasible in all industries, so there's no clear cut answer to this.

Not sure why people seem to think it's worth insulting other people over though.

JudgeJ · 27/02/2022 13:36

@kimbyy

It depends on how many stick to their guns & what impact loosing people would have on the business.
And what would be the impact of losing one's job by refusing to return to the office! It was never meant to be a permanent thing, a lot of people seem to be forgetting that.
Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 13:35

Afro??? For!

Wiennetta · 27/02/2022 13:35

Are you in the civil service by any chance @GreenPepperRed? I’ve heard of a few departments with this sort of situation, and I know someone in a arms length body with a similar set up - nobody is going in.

Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 13:35

@Gwenhwyfar

"Do you genuinely think that anyone who can see the value of teams working together in an office for part of the week is a ‘forelock tugger’ or, in the words of PPs a ‘boot licker’ or an ‘old boomer’?"

I can see the value of teams working together in the same place for part of the week and I'm nowhere near being the forelock tugger people talk about. I'm really a work to live person, it's got nothing to do with sucking up to management or anything like that.
When I'm in the office I know a lot more about what other teams are doing, what is going on. I interact with more than just my direct team and I can ask or answer questions from various people who would never ring me if I was at home.

Careful now. By being entirely reasonable you risk being described as a subjugated slave of:

a certain segment of middle management who really don't do much but annoy their underlings to make themselves feel important.

those who hold all the power and their acolytes

Oh yeah, and your reasons Afro seeing the benefit of working from an office are ‘spurious’. Apparently.

Eagle6EyeD · 27/02/2022 13:34

Been back for 6 months+

One person has refused & is ineffectual

It has affected the morale of the rest of the team

Management keep skirting round the issue

So unfair !

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 13:33

Theres an interesting discussion going on here (from those not slamming me personally!).

I obviously cannot control what other people do so am intrigued at my company's next actions.

I'm surprised some of the responses have been so harsh though. I thought more people would be advocating for more flexible working now as it probably would benefit the demographic of this website and most of the repliers to this thread!

Not sure why some people are so angry at the prospect of a long term change in work culture and attitudes towards flexible working compared to pre pandemic. If an industry allows flexible working then why not?

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 13:30

@GreenPepperRed

Woweee a really sore subject amongst mumsnetters it seems Grin I'm not offended about any of these posts or feel insecure in what I do or my position at work. Amazing what absolute nastiness comes out of a question on a forum, the irony from people telling me how to be professional as well!
Yes, you are. Here you are, upthread, being offended:

I said in my previous posts I actually went into the office and am being branded a child, lazy, not possibly senior at all

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 13:26

[quote madroid]@GreenPepperRed We can do our jobs from home. It's beyond me why my company are doing this.

In my experience, that's exactly the problem.

Employees are often quite siloed in their thinking. They don't see the bigger picture.

But if you read through all the responses here, you'll see the reasons that extend beyond individual roles.

They are the reasons that keep a company profitable productive and progressive - everything from assessing WFH arrangements, equipment, productivity, customer service to training, collaboration and teamwork/culture.

If you are running a business, these are vital considerations that individual workers often don't appreciate. Sometimes it's the manager and senior ppl that made WFH work for the business. Because they had to, to keep everyone in work. Now, that's no longer the case and they want workers back.[/quote]
Thank you for a response that isn't nasty!

I see what you're saying. But my colleagues and I are asking the question why we can't stick to more flexible working as the company has heavily implied they're heading towards compulsory 5 days back in the office. No one's saying we're never going into the office ever again. So I would argue that the bigger picture can still be maintained with a flexible work policy, and would result in a happier workforce too.

We're in roles where we have smaller tasks assigned to us which we work on independent and then get in a meeting every week to update our team on what's been done/what else needs to be done to get the bigger aim achieved. I'm also in an industry that is male-dominated so I'm wondering if many posters here cannot relate to what I'm saying and I can't relate to their views because we're not in the same industry/environment?

OP posts: