Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
shinynewapple22 · 27/02/2022 23:16

@Iamthewombat

No of course not!! I haven't chosen to work from home for these reasons . I work from home because, for the moment, my employer has asked me to do so. I am pointing out some of the benefits of working from home - other than 'slacking off'

You keep quoting me but you are confusing me with someone who said they would refuse to return to the office

No confusion, thanks. You have spent most of the thread agreeing energetically with posters claiming that they shouldn’t be made to work in an office again and that an employer asking them to do so constitutes a diabolical liberty.

Your reasons for preferring WFH are very clear, and rather selfish and disingenuous. You may be WFH for the moment, but I have no doubt that you’d argue against returning to the office, using the same excuses (‘benefits of working from home’) you gave upthread, when your employer tells you to do so.

Your reading comprehension is not very good then !! I may be enthusiastic about WFH but not once have I 'defended' any other poster.

I think your imagination is running away with you .

Belladonna12 · 27/02/2022 23:09

Ok - I agree that it doesn't mean people don't have human contact all day. But it is much of a stretch to think there will be people who live alone or have difficult home lives?

It isn't a stretch but nobody is suggesting people should work at home if they don't want to.

And of course not everyone is the same as me 🙄 but I can't see how everyone just sat at home on laptops is genuinely helpful for most of the population. Their poor eyes for a start!

Why assume that laptops are only used at home? In my workplace everyone uses a laptop whether they are at home or in the office so going back to work won't make any difference.

Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 22:54

No of course not!! I haven't chosen to work from home for these reasons . I work from home because, for the moment, my employer has asked me to do so. I am pointing out some of the benefits of working from home - other than 'slacking off'

You keep quoting me but you are confusing me with someone who said they would refuse to return to the office

No confusion, thanks. You have spent most of the thread agreeing energetically with posters claiming that they shouldn’t be made to work in an office again and that an employer asking them to do so constitutes a diabolical liberty.

Your reasons for preferring WFH are very clear, and rather selfish and disingenuous. You may be WFH for the moment, but I have no doubt that you’d argue against returning to the office, using the same excuses (‘benefits of working from home’) you gave upthread, when your employer tells you to do so.

tootiredtospeak · 27/02/2022 22:37

It's just so selfish to future generations. I dont get it when our kids were at home there was an outcry. It's not just about their education it's the social interaction the isolation and all the other stuff you do not get sat staring at a screen. This applies to adults too and I dont not want the working world to change so much that my now 10 and 5 year olds grow up get a job to what sit in their bedrooms and go to work. Nooooooo they need to see other people leave their house go on a work lunch a work night out make work freinds. Hybrid working is great but people who use that umbrella to permanently WFH are screwing the next generation with a I am alright jack attitude and for what.

shinynewapple22 · 27/02/2022 22:20

@Iamthewombat

I never for one moment suggested that I was using the extra two hours per day to work! Of course I don't do that - if this was the case why on earth would I see a benefit to working from home? I said the extra two hours could be put to better use - be this walking the dog, watching TV - anything is a better use of my time than sitting in a bloody traffic jam!

Better for you, then. Not better for your employer. You don’t get to choose to work from home because you prefer walking the dog or watching telly to commuting.

GrinHmmHmmGrinHmmGrin

No of course not!! I haven't chosen to work from home for these reasons . I work from home because, for the moment, my employer has asked me to do so. I am pointing out some of the benefits of working from home - other than 'slacking off'

You keep quoting me but you are confusing me with someone who said they would refuse to return to the office .

TimeToMakeACupofTea · 27/02/2022 22:17

I love the fantasy that everyone who works from home spends 8 hours a day focusing intently on their work and that people who work in the office spend their time either being interrupted by “chit chat” or having extended water cooler moments and doing fuck all.

Some people are productive, some people aren’t. The location where they do their work has very little bearing on that.

SpikeySmooth · 27/02/2022 22:15

I work for the Tube in London (so have never WFH, not even to do training, all online or F2F) and my bosses have acknowledged the WFH revolution has had a catastrophic effect on the organisations finances (that, and the Mayor of London) and so we are being "restructured" (read: job cuts). I would absolutely love all the commuters we had pre-Covid to come back, but it hasn't happened. Annual and monthly Travelcard sales are down. Instead people are using their contactless cards to come into the city once or twice a week.

If you have made it work, good for you. But there is a much wider impact for the economy, and job market. Job availability for roles that serve the commuter industry has shrunk. So some people have gained, but others have lost out

Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 21:52

I never for one moment suggested that I was using the extra two hours per day to work! Of course I don't do that - if this was the case why on earth would I see a benefit to working from home? I said the extra two hours could be put to better use - be this walking the dog, watching TV - anything is a better use of my time than sitting in a bloody traffic jam!

Better for you, then. Not better for your employer. You don’t get to choose to work from home because you prefer walking the dog or watching telly to commuting.

shinynewapple22 · 27/02/2022 21:41

[quote PrimroseTheSmooth]@shinynewapple22 This was definitely our experience in lockdown- in fact, during the time when you were allowed into the office if you couldn't work from home we ended up opening an office (attendance completely optional) as so many younger people were really struggling with the isolation of wfh and we had real concerns over mental health.[/quote]
@PrimroseTheSmooth I can well believe it. As I said, I would have hated working from home in my 20s. I think there are possibly specific reasons in the case of our workers - mainly based around the length of their journey - either because this involves a difficult journey by public transport or because they were employed during the WFH period and don't reside within the local area .

shinynewapple22 · 27/02/2022 21:34

@Iamthewombat

Are you bollocks working two extra hours a day because you aren’t commuting. Pull the other one.

I worked with people, years ago, who used this excuse to WFH. Their commuting time was going to be used for extra work, they said. You could never get hold of them. They used to claim that they had been at their screens since 6 am. That was easy to check: they hadn’t. *

I never for one moment suggested that I was using the extra two hours per day to work! Of course I don't do that - if this was the case why on earth would I see a benefit to working from home? I said the extra two hours could be put to better use - be this walking the dog, watching TV - anything is a better use of my time than sitting in a bloody traffic jam!

I'm not an 'office refusenik' by the way! No-one has asked me to return . I was simply responding to another poster that there are other reasons for wanting to work from home than the fact that you can 'slack off'. In my case this would come to light within a few days - I agree that wouldn't be the case for everyone .

pawpaws2022 · 27/02/2022 21:23

@DuvetD you get used to it. I've always worked on screens, between 8-12hrs a day
If I was in the office I would be on a desktop but I'm on a laptop at hone

DuvetD · 27/02/2022 21:04

@Belladonna12

I'm not jealous grin I couldn't think of anything worse than WFH all the time. I can see the benefits of hybrid working sure, but is everyone so antisocial on MN they don't want human contact during the day?

Just because people work from home doesn't mean they don't have human contact during the day.

I worry about a vision of the future where 80% of young adults are sat in their bedrooms on laptops all day. I mean, that's scary and can't be good for anyone's mental / physical health.

I have worked at home for many years and my mental health is fine. Not everyone is the same as you.

Ok - I agree that it doesn't mean people don't have human contact all day. But it is much of a stretch to think there will be people who live alone or have difficult home lives? And of course not everyone is the same as me 🙄 but I can't see how everyone just sat at home on laptops is genuinely helpful for most of the population. Their poor eyes for a start!
ButtockUp · 27/02/2022 20:17

@ufucoffee has it.

I've said , on similar threads, about an insurance employee that I needed to speak to regarding a policy but I kept being asked to " hang on " as she had to deal with her toddler.

It's almost impossible, now, to speak to anyone at any company, as you have to wait in an interminable queue and then you get cut off after soooo long.
Interesting to note how many more people are out jogging/walking the lockdown puppy/in the park compared to before the pandemic.

When I retired, not many people would be in the supermarket/high street.
Post pandemic, the supermarket/high street seem like an ordinary Saturday afternoon... even on a mid week morning.

There's a little, out of the way cafe, near me that was always barely half full by lunchtime.
You now have to book a table , days in advance , as it's stuffed full by mid morning, by... working age women , who never used to be there pre pandemic.

I feel that some of these wfh folk are pulling a fast one.

Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 20:05

[quote AllOfUsAreDead]@GreenPepperRed

I would just leave now if I were you. If they are going to be daft and send more jobs offshore, let them. Let them figure out how to do that with very few staff left behind to train them.

Going offshore always seems simple, then you get customers complaining of bad service from abroad, they aren't trained right so they can't assist with problems internally or externally etc.

If the company goes under, that's their problem. Get out while you can.[/quote]
Sounds like great advice…great for the OP’s employer, that is. Who wants to employ a load of grumbling, militant whiners who aren’t interested in the well-being of the business and who refuse reasonable requests?

ufucoffee · 27/02/2022 20:01

@Iamthewombat

A lot of people in this thread are acting like pursed-lipped dinosaurs, though.

(To describe people who can see the benefit of teams working together for at least part of the week, and don’t subscribe to the view that we should all refuse reasonable working requests from our employers because we’ve got THE POWER etc)

Hurrah! A new insult to go with ‘boot lickers’, ‘forelock tuggers’ and ‘old boomers’.

Keep them coming. Bear in mind that if you have to resort to name-calling, it’s because your argument doesn’t stand up.

WFH people can work more efficiently as they don't get interrupted by others chit-chat

Come off it! As if you are gazing intently at your screen for eight hours. And is ‘chit chat’ so awful? It’s howinformation is exchanged and how relationships are built.

they save two hours per day commuting time which could be our to better use

Are you bollocks working two extra hours a day because you aren’t commuting. Pull the other one.

I worked with people, years ago, who used this excuse to WFH. Their commuting time was going to be used for extra work, they said. You could never get hold of them. They used to claim that they had been at their screens since 6 am. That was easy to check: they hadn’t.

they save a fortune on petrol and can see that less cars on the road is better for the environment

I believe that the first thing matters to the office refuseniks, but not the second. It’s just a convenient excuse.

I agree wholeheartedly
Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 19:53

If people WFH slacked off they'd lose their jobs, same as if they were in the office.

Oh, you sweet child.

Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 19:51

A lot of people in this thread are acting like pursed-lipped dinosaurs, though.

(To describe people who can see the benefit of teams working together for at least part of the week, and don’t subscribe to the view that we should all refuse reasonable working requests from our employers because we’ve got THE POWER etc)

Hurrah! A new insult to go with ‘boot lickers’, ‘forelock tuggers’ and ‘old boomers’.

Keep them coming. Bear in mind that if you have to resort to name-calling, it’s because your argument doesn’t stand up.

WFH people can work more efficiently as they don't get interrupted by others chit-chat

Come off it! As if you are gazing intently at your screen for eight hours. And is ‘chit chat’ so awful? It’s howinformation is exchanged and how relationships are built.

they save two hours per day commuting time which could be our to better use

Are you bollocks working two extra hours a day because you aren’t commuting. Pull the other one.

I worked with people, years ago, who used this excuse to WFH. Their commuting time was going to be used for extra work, they said. You could never get hold of them. They used to claim that they had been at their screens since 6 am. That was easy to check: they hadn’t.

they save a fortune on petrol and can see that less cars on the road is better for the environment

I believe that the first thing matters to the office refuseniks, but not the second. It’s just a convenient excuse.

Rosebell75 · 27/02/2022 19:12

Just because you’ve been able to WFH for the last two years doesn’t mean it’s the most effective way to do your job 100% of the time. During the pandemic we were all forced to adopt a different way of working but that doesn’t mean it automatically means it should continue that way.

Absolutely, for some tasks WFH is a good thing. However, there are some parts of most jobs that are better done together, in person. It’s also a really important part of any job to connect with colleagues, to be flexible and collaborate with others so simply refusing to go back to the office for any reason whatsoever seems ridiculous.

Individuals may think they’re more productive WFH 100% of the time but most organisations seem to disagree so I think that’s often a false narrative to justify not going back.

Having said that, I also think organisations need to be flexible and adopt truly hybrid working arrangements so everyone benefits from being able to choose the best place to undertake the task, be that at home or the office.

I8toys · 27/02/2022 19:01

I was 2 days WFH and 3 in the office before Covid. I'm still working at home because its more productive for me tbh and no one in my office has gone back full time yet and hybrid working has been discussed. I also have been diagnosed with a frozen shoulder so I can't drive for long periods of time anyway.

shinynewapple22 · 27/02/2022 18:53

@grapewines

A blanket “you must be back in the office x days a week” runs the risk of indirect sex discrimination

How? WFH should have childcare in place in any case.

But you can see that child care for someone's working hours 9-5.30 is a lot easier to get than child care from 7.30 am - 7.00 pm to include commuting time ?

Parker231 · 27/02/2022 18:48

I work in London for a global corporate finance company. We were lucky enough to have a hybrid working policy in places years before Covid. I have staff in three countries. They can work from home, the office, at a clients or in a coffee shop. They plan their own diaries in conjunction with the needs of the clients.
There are no plans to make any changes to the policy - it worked before and during Covid so no reason to think it won’t work in the future.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 27/02/2022 18:40

Agreed. When it gets warmer, I know I will once again be treated to my wfh neighbour’s booming work calls. Confidentiality? What confidentiality?

We were sent an email reminding us of confidentiality on calls. I just laughed. I live in a one bedroom flat, I work in the living room and DH is semi retired so is often around. Why should he have to go out just because I have to work from home? It’s my home, not my office!

bedheadedzombie · 27/02/2022 18:32

My husband. He's a contractor (contract is till the summer) and simply told the client that if they don't agree, that's fine and he'll terminate the contract effective whenever they want but that if they want to continue with him they really need to stop asking (pestering) him to come in. They said fine and stopped asking him to come in...

But they need him more than we need the money so it's an easy position to be in to refuse. Not everyone will have that option.

SarahProblem · 27/02/2022 18:28

It’s probably too early to have many or any cases where colleagues have done collective action about WFH. Are you in a union OP? Has your employer suggested or in fact done any employee consultation?

The sense I’m getting from friends who are director-level in workplaces is that their employers are mostly being accommodating/not enforcing much whilst they get their ducks in a row, establishing the company stance and going through the relevant HR/legal considerations. But the other shoe is about to drop.

The wider questions PPs have raised about WFH generally is interesting but is going to really depend on the sector you work as to whether WFH really works (for the business)– I think some people think because businesses ‘coped’ with staff working from home, it should be rolled out widely.

My employer has used the WFH to launch a longer-term review of whether hybrid working is the right thing for the business (the CEO wants everyone in the office, but a highly unionised workforce means they are being careful).

My experience is that WFH 100% doesn’t work. Virtual meetings aren’t as productive people more easily opt out (which is a management issue in part) Hybrid working only works if the team are all in together at the same time and hybrid meetings are truly awful. The other angle is not everyone has the luxury of having a spare room to work in particularly if they live in cities in shared house which is common for younger people.

Belladonna12 · 27/02/2022 18:26

I'm not jealous grin I couldn't think of anything worse than WFH all the time. I can see the benefits of hybrid working sure, but is everyone so antisocial on MN they don't want human contact during the day?

Just because people work from home doesn't mean they don't have human contact during the day.

I worry about a vision of the future where 80% of young adults are sat in their bedrooms on laptops all day. I mean, that's scary and can't be good for anyone's mental / physical health.

I have worked at home for many years and my mental health is fine. Not everyone is the same as you.