Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:04

@QuirkyTurtle

I guess I just have a very different managerial mindset. If people in my team can do their job in 2 hours, I don't care what they do with the rest of their time. In fact, I value those people more than those who need 10 hours to do their job each day.

But I'm in sales and performance is easy to track, you either meet your numbers or you don't.

Some graduates will prefer having an office based job, and some won't. In some industries it's possible and in others it isn't. I personally think 1 day per week is enough. I don't think it's 'entitled' to want to keep the same work/life balance we witnessed during the pandemic (again, WHERE POSSIBLE). For those that have been successfully working from home, I think it's unfair (and entitled) to demand they go back to the office because 'won't anyone think of the children'.

I'm going back 1 day per week from next week after 2 years of wfh and I'm genuinely very excited to go back. I'm encouraging it, and I know my team will be going back 1 day per week on average, but I won't demand more than that.

How many times do posters who work with, or manage, younger people have to explain that none of those younger people, in their experience, want to work from home most of the time? That, in fact, they want to work from an office for at least part of the week and that their work/life balance has been impaired by working from shared housing or a bedroom at their parents’ house? Post after post saying the same thing, but no, you know best.

You are the only person on the thread claiming that younger people want to spend most of their time working from home. Based on your own personal views and what you say your team prefers. They might not: perhaps they have been cowed by your ‘managerial mindset’.

If you manage a sales team that mostly works from home I suppose you are doing cold calling? I don’t think that you can really compare that to more skilled professions for which professional qualifications are needed. People working in those fields, or aspiring to join those fields, absolutely need time in the office to model behaviours and learn how things are done.

Belladonna12 · 28/02/2022 11:55

You're making the same point, just put the other way. Either they need to be in (at least some of the time) and so can't be outsourced, or they don't need to be in ever and so perhaps could be outsourced, depending on the role. People arguing they never need to be in the office are arguing they're in the latter camp.

As I said, they may not need to be in the office much because they have a lot of experience. They may only need to come in for the occasional meeting.

KittenKong · 28/02/2022 11:50

I’m a team of one. I have all my kit set up at home and work way longer than my part time hours precisely because I work from home.

If they were cool with me working my 9-4 rather than my 9.30-6,7,8 then fine. I done walk a dog or sit a watch daytime tv. I’m a grown ass adult who takes their job seriously.

PrimroseTheSmooth · 28/02/2022 11:48

You can't argue that they need to be in the office to perform their job effectively and then say that you could outsource their work

You're making the same point, just put the other way. Either they need to be in (at least some of the time) and so can't be outsourced, or they don't need to be in ever and so perhaps could be outsourced, depending on the role. People arguing they never need to be in the office are arguing they're in the latter camp.

It's happening already- look at how many places now outsource things like IT support.

Belladonna12 · 28/02/2022 11:42

If any of my team members had a stop and decided that they didn’t want to spend any time in the office with the team for any of those reasons, all of which I’ve seen on this thread, that’s what I’d start thinking about. I’m a finance director. We have finance service centres in Eastern Europe. The people working there are excellent: perfect English and a quarter of the price of a U.K. employee. We have a software dev centre of excellence in Eastern Europe too. Why wouldn’t I choose someone there instead of a stroppy U.K. person who values walking their dog or saving money on childcare or watching telly more than performing their role effectively?

Yes, how dare people value saving money or a good quality of life. You can't argue that they need to be in the office to perform their job effectively and then say that you could outsource their work. You also need to take into account that someone may only be able to work at home most of the time because they have experience in the job. A new employee may need to come in more often which could be a bit difficult if they're not in the UK.

QuirkyTurtle · 28/02/2022 11:41

I guess I just have a very different managerial mindset. If people in my team can do their job in 2 hours, I don't care what they do with the rest of their time. In fact, I value those people more than those who need 10 hours to do their job each day.

But I'm in sales and performance is easy to track, you either meet your numbers or you don't.

Some graduates will prefer having an office based job, and some won't. In some industries it's possible and in others it isn't. I personally think 1 day per week is enough. I don't think it's 'entitled' to want to keep the same work/life balance we witnessed during the pandemic (again, WHERE POSSIBLE). For those that have been successfully working from home, I think it's unfair (and entitled) to demand they go back to the office because 'won't anyone think of the children'.

I'm going back 1 day per week from next week after 2 years of wfh and I'm genuinely very excited to go back. I'm encouraging it, and I know my team will be going back 1 day per week on average, but I won't demand more than that.

PrimroseTheSmooth · 28/02/2022 11:35

Do you have to be in every day though?

@Iggly, no, and I'm not arguing that people generally should be in every day- I'm in favour of some flexibility. My point is addressed to people who think they should never have to go in.

Iggly · 28/02/2022 11:28

If any of my team members had a stop and decided that they didn’t want to spend any time in the office with the team for any of those reasons, all of which I’ve seen on this thread, that’s what I’d start thinking about. I’m a finance director. We have finance service centres in Eastern Europe. The people working there are excellent: perfect English and a quarter of the price of a U.K. employee. We have a software dev centre of excellence in Eastern Europe too. Why wouldn’t I choose someone there instead of a stroppy U.K. person who values walking their dog or saving money on childcare or watching telly more than performing their role effectively?

I don’t follow this logic. If you want and need people to be in the office then you have to pay salaries for that location. You can’t make a threat of finding cheaper staff overseas - because that would still mean they’re not in person. Defeating the original argument.

For me, it’s about employees realising that employers have long been taking the piss actually long before covid. There’s a reason we have such poor productivity- it’s because our worker rights are right at the bottom compared to similar countries. People don’t feel valued at all.

Employers should actually be a bit more flexible and try and a) understand that it’s a shift after two years of remote working b) the experience of senior colleagues isn’t the same as those further down the chain c) you can have more flexible policies and still achieve in person working etc.

For example, I like having a mix of in person vs wfh and would rather we worked it so that we all came together in the office on certain days. Then you make the most of collaborative working etc. then people can chose when to be at home to get stuff down.

It’s about balance. But employers are acting like they own their staff. This is what happens when you don’t have trade unions - the balance has gone too far the other way.

Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 11:28

As for people going on about not wanting WFH for their kids…there are still lots of jobs which remain people facing. Your children will have a choice to decide what they go into. It’s not my job to pave the way for your children’s careers and ways of working.

Wow. Just wow.

So anybody who would like to go into accounting, or commercial law, or the actuarial industry, or insurance, or any other well-paid professions other than medicine or being a barrister can jolly well suck up the isolation of working in their bedrooms because you’d prefer there to be no offices - so that you can’t be compelled to travel to one - or get a job in a shop where they can interact with people.

Iggly · 28/02/2022 11:23

@PrimroseTheSmooth

Any argument that your job is merely the tasks you can do from home and that your employer gains nothing from having you there in person is an argument to outsource your role to somewhere cheaper. Indeed, this was the way things were going even before Covid: when I started work I had a secretary in the office next to mine. Now I send any secretarial work to someone in South Africa.
Do you have to be in every day though?
PrimroseTheSmooth · 28/02/2022 11:23

@Iamthewombat Exactly.

Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 11:21

STROP not stop!

PrimroseTheSmooth · 28/02/2022 11:21

Maybe in certain jobs / industries this applies, but not everyone's.

Sure, but for some roles it will be enough to tip the balance.

Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 11:20

@QuirkyTurtle

Any argument that your job is merely the tasks you can do from home and that your employer gains nothing from having you there in person is an argument to outsource your role to somewhere cheaper.

If my job could be done from somewhere cheaper, they'd have moved it already. We have teams in India and Brazil. Maybe in certain jobs / industries this applies, but not everyone's.

The PP didn’t say that every job in the U.K. involving partial working from home would be outsourced.

She said that where people whose employer has requested their presence in the office for part of the week argue that they don’t need to be there because:

-in-person interaction isn’t important
-coaching younger team members isn’t important
-informal contact isn’t important
-they can easily solve problems without spending any time face to face with their colleagues thank you very much
-they work just as well at home despite their employer’s views to the contrary
-their job is just a set of flowcharted tasks that don’t require any in-person human finesse or intuition

They might as well wear a badge saying “have you realised that you could get someone to do this cheaper somewhere else? If not, I am here to suggest it to you”.

If any of my team members had a stop and decided that they didn’t want to spend any time in the office with the team for any of those reasons, all of which I’ve seen on this thread, that’s what I’d start thinking about. I’m a finance director. We have finance service centres in Eastern Europe. The people working there are excellent: perfect English and a quarter of the price of a U.K. employee. We have a software dev centre of excellence in Eastern Europe too. Why wouldn’t I choose someone there instead of a stroppy U.K. person who values walking their dog or saving money on childcare or watching telly more than performing their role effectively?

QuirkyTurtle · 28/02/2022 10:33

Any argument that your job is merely the tasks you can do from home and that your employer gains nothing from having you there in person is an argument to outsource your role to somewhere cheaper.

If my job could be done from somewhere cheaper, they'd have moved it already. We have teams in India and Brazil. Maybe in certain jobs / industries this applies, but not everyone's.

Belladonna12 · 28/02/2022 10:33

@PrimroseTheSmooth

Any argument that your job is merely the tasks you can do from home and that your employer gains nothing from having you there in person is an argument to outsource your role to somewhere cheaper. Indeed, this was the way things were going even before Covid: when I started work I had a secretary in the office next to mine. Now I send any secretarial work to someone in South Africa.
People will still generally go into the office for meetings though.
PrimroseTheSmooth · 28/02/2022 10:13

Any argument that your job is merely the tasks you can do from home and that your employer gains nothing from having you there in person is an argument to outsource your role to somewhere cheaper. Indeed, this was the way things were going even before Covid: when I started work I had a secretary in the office next to mine. Now I send any secretarial work to someone in South Africa.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/02/2022 09:59

I believe that (saving money) matters to the office refuseniks, but not (the environment). It’s just a convenient excuse

Another one who very much agrees with this
It's amazing how quickly folk leap upon "the environment" when it supports something that suits, just as some prate about the impact of having children only after completing their own family. You'd have thought that could have been worked out before, but apparently not

SudaneseHipHopFan · 28/02/2022 09:25

In my new role, I have been WFH from the start agreeing to go into the office every now and then. All informal, not in my contract. Other colleagues however, after WFH since start of covid are now also expected to go back in 3 days a week. We have different roles, so not comparing apples to apples. Not popular at all.

I think it is largely an age thing. Younger colleagues are happy to be back in and I can totally understand why - working at home may not be as comfortable and they miss the social aspect. I would be the same at their age.

If they said to me there was an expectation to go back in 3 days a week, I would honestly say 'that doesn't work for me - your move' (a bit politer than that but that would be the message).

But that would be with the expectation that they could decide to let me go. If they did then no hard feelings. I live too far away to commute and have zero interest in that lifestyle anymore. I work long unsociable hours, which I can tolerate from home but not otherwise.

Like most things in life it depends who has the most leverage - do you want the job more than they want you in the job. Who will blink first.

DottyHarmer · 28/02/2022 09:09

@LuckySantangelo35 - then it’s not Boomers’ fault that they have all the housing wealth. Current 40-somethings are shafting the upcoming generation work wise. And mentally, too.

The worst wfh offenders are councils, or at least my local council. They are in full-on 2020 lockdown mode. Their offices are closed, and you can only email a central address which is checked and then the emails forwarded to the appropriate department whose staff are all wfh (this is a big council, too). Wonderful! those who wfh might claim. I think they’ve managed to reduce their workload by 90% .

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/02/2022 08:20

Lots of us have to do lots of screen time where we are in the office or working from home, makes no odds.
As for people going on about not wanting WFH for their kids…there are still lots of jobs which remain people facing. Your children will have a choice to decide what they go into. It’s not my job to pave the way for your children’s careers and ways of working.

AWeekinJanuary · 28/02/2022 08:18

Customer service has been shit over the past two years. WFH may not be the only factor, but it definitely is a factor, and doesn't fit in with the 'so much more productive' line you hear on MN.

No idea about customer service, but my job involves reviewing documents and talking people through what I’ve done with them. If I wasn’t getting through what’s on the pile, my ‘customers’ would be shouting about it. I don’t get to simply choose not to turn work around if it’s there. Deadlines and volume of work dictate whether I’m having a relatively quiet week or not, not where I am.

I take the ‘all my wfh friends watch Netflix all day’ posts (there is at least one on this thread) with a massive pinch of salt.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 28/02/2022 07:40

And of course not everyone is the same as me 🙄 but I can't see how everyone just sat at home on laptops is genuinely helpful for most of the population. Their poor eyes for a start!

If I hadn't been allowed to take home one of my screens I would have refused to WFH until they provided me with proper equipment. There is no way I could have looked at a pathetic little laptop screen all day.

Iamthewombat · 27/02/2022 23:18

You’re definitely on the ropes if you’re pulling out the “your reading comprehension isn’t very good” gambit.

IcedPurple · 27/02/2022 23:17

@Pandai

Hopefully lots of customer service jobs are back in the office, nothing quite like phoning to sort something important out and hearing a shrieking toddler in the background or oh sorry will have to get back to you as we don't have that software at home.
Customer service has been shit over the past two years. WFH may not be the only factor, but it definitely is a factor, and doesn't fit in with the 'so much more productive' line you hear on MN.