Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:33

You said ‘similar countries’. Would you like to pay similar tax to France, Germany, the Netherlands and Scandinavia, to guarantee the employee (not employer, although I’m guessing that was your mistake) rights you say that you are so keen on?

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:31

@Iamthewombat

I’m not being a drama queen to point out that employer rights in this country are shite

Did you mean ‘employee rights’? And yes, it does sound a bit drama queeny, sorry. Our rights as employees are much better than those of people working in the USA, for example.

You’ve picked a shitty country to compare us to.
Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:31

And employers are being flexible. The OP’s employer is asking for three days per week. I don’t think we’ve heard from anyone who is insisting that their team go back full time, just because

How is it flexible? They are literally dictating it. Are they phasing people back in? Looking at flexible working requests? Or just “telling” people? I suspect that’s why they’re resisting.

In my office, we also have a minimum of 3 days but we are being flexible about days and also getting people to ramp back up to 3 days. Not insisting on it from day 1. It is a shift especially after being home based for so long.

There’s also a cynicism that senior staff don’t trust their staff, and that’s why they really want them back. And that management attitude will come through and staff can feel it.

Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:31

I’m not being a drama queen to point out that employer rights in this country are shite

Did you mean ‘employee rights’? And yes, it does sound a bit drama queeny, sorry. Our rights as employees are much better than those of people working in the USA, for example.

Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:29

@DottyHarmer

Absolutely. I have a ds in his early 20s. Wfh is not popular in the least with him or his friends from home and university.

One of his friends is training with a big accountancy firm. All wfh. All training and audit files done from home. In the past the arid nature of the training was offset by being able to roam round various clients with your fellow trainees and, of course, major bants/hook ups/ romances and friendships etc etc. Well, that’s down the pan if your only contact with your peers is a seeing them in the corner of a zoom call and at best an awkward periodic social meet-up.

As somebody who also trained in a big four firm, I absolutely agree. Client visits are where you learn how things are really done, how businesses work, how to behave around clients, how to assess evidence thoroughly and how audits are conducted. And they are loads of fun when you work with, and sometimes stay away with, your peers and managers.

I’d have hated doing that from home, with only zoom calls for company.

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:28

You call me a drama Queen?

Ok then 🤷🏻‍♀️

I’m not being a drama queen to point out that employer rights in this country are shite. They are. Employees have got plenty to moan about.

You can be as rude as you like, when I didn’t fit your little narrative in your head, but my approach is to treat people with respect and like adults and you’ll get good results. People are resisting returning to the office. I would take the time to listen and understand why - most people are reasonable and can be reasoned with.

Treat them like commodities and they’ll resist. Or, as you call it “strop”.

theemmadilemma · 28/02/2022 12:28

I worked from home originally 2 days a week, moving to full time way before the pandemic hit.

On a global employee call (17,000 worldwide) they annouced 'We will never go back to the old way of working...' So they intend to continue closing offices where appropriate and leaving just main offices in major cities. The majority of the workforce will be home based.

Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:26

@CallyfromBlakes7

I always think it's weird that people think WFH means perching on the end of a bed in your shared house bedroom. There are plenty of other options including co-working, and nothing stops you going into your employer office if you want to.

I don't know why this polarises people so much. Employers who are flexible have the most committed employees and the best results.

Co-working has to be paid for. Are twentysomethings struggling with expensive rents and student loans going to do that?

And employers are being flexible. The OP’s employer is asking for three days per week. I don’t think we’ve heard from anyone who is insisting that their team go back full time, just because.

Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:24

@Iggly

Your reference to ‘those further down the chain’ tends to mark you out as a disgruntled junior employee. Would you prefer your employer to let you do whatever you want, whenever you want, whilst still paying you the same salary, naturally, at the expense of its own commercial success and profitability? Would you be the first to complain if that led to reductions in staffing or pay freezes? I suspect that you would

Ah, well sorry to disappoint you. I’m actually the head of a department with a team of 20. I treat my staff with respect.

We’ve had resistance to people coming back and I’ve worked with them and managed to get them back on a regular basis. Because I’m not a dick, I listen to my team.

You’re a head of department (although I dread to think in what) and you use phrases like ‘those further down the chain’ and drama queen language when discussing working practices? I pity your employers.
Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:21

@Iggly

I absolutely can argue that my team need to be in the office for part of the week to perform their jobs effectively. I manage the team. I notice when we’re working effectively and when we are not, and when we meet in person we solve complex problems much more quickly

Yes but you can’t then argue you’d outsource their job for cheaper (remote) labour as then how would you get them in?

You just need to be more flexible. You don’t own your staff!

When did I say that I owned my staff? You need to avoid over-dramatising, because it weakens your argument. I can decide how my own team works best, though, and that involves some time spent working together in the office.

And, as I point out upthread, if any member of my team came up with a convincing argument for why they should never travel to any kind of office, ever, or interact with their colleagues in person, ever, I’d be considering why I needed to pay a U.K. salary for someone we never saw.

Belladonna12 · 28/02/2022 12:21

Well, that has been happening over the last 2 years and there are people actively working towards most white collar jobs being done remotely.

People on this thread aren't arguing that everyone should work at home whether they want to or not though.

Some employers are selling their offices and moving to hot desking so yes, if a large number of employees choose to work from home, that has an effect on those who do want to come to the office.

If companies have realised that they can shutdown offices to save money because people are able to work at home they will do that anyway. Regardless, your desire to work in an office isn't more important than other people’s desire to work at home, particularly if the latter saves money .

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:19

Your reference to ‘those further down the chain’ tends to mark you out as a disgruntled junior employee. Would you prefer your employer to let you do whatever you want, whenever you want, whilst still paying you the same salary, naturally, at the expense of its own commercial success and profitability? Would you be the first to complain if that led to reductions in staffing or pay freezes? I suspect that you would

Ah, well sorry to disappoint you. I’m actually the head of a department with a team of 20. I treat my staff with respect.

We’ve had resistance to people coming back and I’ve worked with them and managed to get them back on a regular basis. Because I’m not a dick, I listen to my team.

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:17

@CallyfromBlakes7

Well, that’s down the pan if your only contact with your peers is a seeing them in the corner of a zoom call and at best an awkward periodic social meet-up

so you have hobbies and meet people locally instead. People are allowed to make friends away from work!

And it's probably better to avoid "major bants", TBH.

As someone who trained as an accountant, the major bants was a key counter weight to the incredibly intense training! And you didn’t do it during work hours
Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:17

I don’t follow this logic. If you want and need people to be in the office then you have to pay salaries for that location. You can’t make a threat of finding cheaper staff overseas - because that would still mean they’re not in person. Defeating the original argument.

Nope. If somebody launches a campaign to convince me that their role doesn’t require them to ever appear in person, they might just succeed. And, if they did, I might consider whether the business is better served by a different resource offshore, which is entirely logical.

For me, it’s about employees realising that employers have long been taking the piss actually long before covid. There’s a reason we have such poor productivity- it’s because our worker rights are right at the bottom compared to similar countries. People don’t feel valued at all.

Oh, here we go. Up the workers. Have you considered that poor productivity might, just might, be linked to our national tendency towards stroppiness and excuses?

Employers should actually be a bit more flexible and try and a) understand that it’s a shift after two years of remote working b) the experience of senior colleagues isn’t the same as those further down the chain c) you can have more flexible policies and still achieve in person working

Employers have been very flexible from where I am standing. The OP’s employer only wants her back in the office for three days a week, compared to full time pre-pandemic. What is that, if not flexibility? If her employer has noticed a downturn in productivity during the pandemic, they are entirely within their rights to require staff to return to the office for part of the week.

Your reference to ‘those further down the chain’ tends to mark you out as a disgruntled junior employee. Would you prefer your employer to let you do whatever you want, whenever you want, whilst still paying you the same salary, naturally, at the expense of its own commercial success and profitability? Would you be the first to complain if that led to reductions in staffing or pay freezes? I suspect that you would.

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:16

Are you bollocks working two extra hours a day because you aren’t commuting. Pull the other one

Just because you aren’t, doesn’t mean others are the same.

I work longer at home because I don’t lose 3.5 hours crammed onto trains where I can’t work.

CallyfromBlakes7 · 28/02/2022 12:16

Well, that’s down the pan if your only contact with your peers is a seeing them in the corner of a zoom call and at best an awkward periodic social meet-up

so you have hobbies and meet people locally instead. People are allowed to make friends away from work!

And it's probably better to avoid "major bants", TBH.

DottyHarmer · 28/02/2022 12:15

My “absolutely” was to @Iamthewombat !

CallyfromBlakes7 · 28/02/2022 12:15

Are you bollocks working two extra hours a day because you aren’t commuting. Pull the other one

I think you'll find people are. My DH has a flexible working arrangement of two short days and three long days. Since he worked from home, the short days have become normal length ones.

biggreenhouse · 28/02/2022 12:14

we have a few people refusing to come in for the required number of days, and they are now in the process of being fired.

DottyHarmer · 28/02/2022 12:14

Absolutely. I have a ds in his early 20s. Wfh is not popular in the least with him or his friends from home and university.

One of his friends is training with a big accountancy firm. All wfh. All training and audit files done from home. In the past the arid nature of the training was offset by being able to roam round various clients with your fellow trainees and, of course, major bants/hook ups/ romances and friendships etc etc. Well, that’s down the pan if your only contact with your peers is a seeing them in the corner of a zoom call and at best an awkward periodic social meet-up.

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:13

I absolutely can argue that my team need to be in the office for part of the week to perform their jobs effectively. I manage the team. I notice when we’re working effectively and when we are not, and when we meet in person we solve complex problems much more quickly

Yes but you can’t then argue you’d outsource their job for cheaper (remote) labour as then how would you get them in?

You just need to be more flexible. You don’t own your staff!

CallyfromBlakes7 · 28/02/2022 12:13

I always think it's weird that people think WFH means perching on the end of a bed in your shared house bedroom. There are plenty of other options including co-working, and nothing stops you going into your employer office if you want to.

I don't know why this polarises people so much. Employers who are flexible have the most committed employees and the best results.

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:12

@PrimroseTheSmooth

Do you have to be in every day though?

@Iggly, no, and I'm not arguing that people generally should be in every day- I'm in favour of some flexibility. My point is addressed to people who think they should never have to go in.

That’s fair enough. I don’t think people do need to be in everyday but should be in some of the time
Gwenhwyfar · 28/02/2022 12:08

@Belladonna12

Ok - I agree that it doesn't mean people don't have human contact all day. But it is much of a stretch to think there will be people who live alone or have difficult home lives?

It isn't a stretch but nobody is suggesting people should work at home if they don't want to.

And of course not everyone is the same as me 🙄 but I can't see how everyone just sat at home on laptops is genuinely helpful for most of the population. Their poor eyes for a start!

Why assume that laptops are only used at home? In my workplace everyone uses a laptop whether they are at home or in the office so going back to work won't make any difference.

Yes, I use a laptop at the office now, but that's because of the pandemic. When they had to buy everyone a laptop they got rid of the desktops. Luckily I do have a proper screen at the office.

"nobody is suggesting people should work at home if they don't want to."
Well, that has been happening over the last 2 years and there are people actively working towards most white collar jobs being done remotely.
Some employers are selling their offices and moving to hot desking so yes, if a large number of employees choose to work from home, that has an effect on those who do want to come to the office.
I know of people who want to go back, but not if they won't have a fixed office and will have to carry their laptop every day anyway.

For me, wfh does mean I don't have human contact between 9 and 5 and many days not at all, except for online team meetings with no time for chit-chat.

Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:08

@Belladonna12

If any of my team members had a stop and decided that they didn’t want to spend any time in the office with the team for any of those reasons, all of which I’ve seen on this thread, that’s what I’d start thinking about. I’m a finance director. We have finance service centres in Eastern Europe. The people working there are excellent: perfect English and a quarter of the price of a U.K. employee. We have a software dev centre of excellence in Eastern Europe too. Why wouldn’t I choose someone there instead of a stroppy U.K. person who values walking their dog or saving money on childcare or watching telly more than performing their role effectively?

Yes, how dare people value saving money or a good quality of life. You can't argue that they need to be in the office to perform their job effectively and then say that you could outsource their work. You also need to take into account that someone may only be able to work at home most of the time because they have experience in the job. A new employee may need to come in more often which could be a bit difficult if they're not in the UK.

I absolutely can argue that my team need to be in the office for part of the week to perform their jobs effectively. I manage the team. I notice when we’re working effectively and when we are not, and when we meet in person we solve complex problems much more quickly.

As for the ‘experience in the job means that you don’t need to be in the office’ argument: don’t be silly. I need my experienced people to be there with the rest of the team. So that the team can work effectively, exchange information, come up with ideas for problem solving, share experience and ideas.