Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
CallyfromBlakes7 · 28/02/2022 14:22

(so gains 15 hours and probably gives about 6 back)

CallyfromBlakes7 · 28/02/2022 14:22

@Gwenhwyfar

"I think you'll find people are. My DH has a flexible working arrangement of two short days and three long days. Since he worked from home, the short days have become normal length ones."

That's an argument AGAINST wfh if it's being used as a source of free labour.

I agree and I've told him. But on the other hand he saves 3 hours commuting time a day (and the money and stress involved).
housemaus · 28/02/2022 14:15

@tootiredtospeak

It's just so selfish to future generations. I dont get it when our kids were at home there was an outcry. It's not just about their education it's the social interaction the isolation and all the other stuff you do not get sat staring at a screen. This applies to adults too and I dont not want the working world to change so much that my now 10 and 5 year olds grow up get a job to what sit in their bedrooms and go to work. Nooooooo they need to see other people leave their house go on a work lunch a work night out make work freinds. Hybrid working is great but people who use that umbrella to permanently WFH are screwing the next generation with a I am alright jack attitude and for what.
Well, as an employer, I'm not willing to roll back on the significant improvements permanent WFH/very flexible hybrid working has brought for my employees, their happiness, and our company's productivity just because you think it's better not to.

If your children are so bothered when they grow up, they can go and work for one of the many, many companies which will still have offices. Luckily, those that are bothered will have plentiful options to WFH instead.

Coffeepot72 · 28/02/2022 14:08

I don't have the kind of job that's worth commuting more than 45 minutes for so my commutes have always been either a local bus/train ticket (sometimes covered by the employer anyway) or walking.

That's a good point. Lots of people with quite ordinary jobs have a significant commute; high paid professionals do not have the monopoly on this. But the media will have you think otherwise

Chickenkatsu · 28/02/2022 14:04

Everyone else in my team has left the company and my boss is in New York so I'm working from home for the foreseeable future.

Gwenhwyfar · 28/02/2022 14:03

@HardbackWriter

The employee might have to pay for lighting and heat but they don't have to pay travel costs which are a lot higher for many people.

I think it's just worth noting that this is in practice pretty regressive - higher-paid employees are much more likely to have had long commutes, and so have benefited hugely financially, whereas lower-paid staff are much more likely to live near where they work and so won't have benefited from reduction in travel costs but will really feel the increased energy costs, which have a much bigger impact on them than on high earners.

Thanks for saying this. I don't have the kind of job that's worth commuting more than 45 minutes for so my commutes have always been either a local bus/train ticket (sometimes covered by the employer anyway) or walking. To wfh I need unlimited internet as well as heating and light on all day every day. I'm lucky to have been compensated during compulsory wfh, but this will stop if wfh becomes the norm.
Gwenhwyfar · 28/02/2022 14:01

"The employee might have to pay for lighting and heat but they don't have to pay travel costs which are a lot higher for many people."

And not for others.

"You argument that it will effect businesses in town centres assumes that everyone's workplace is in a town centre. Most aren't."

Many, many are though and those businesses won't be moving to the residential areas to make up for it. Our town centres are already suffering with the move to online shopping and out of town complexes.

HardbackWriter · 28/02/2022 13:56

The employee might have to pay for lighting and heat but they don't have to pay travel costs which are a lot higher for many people.

I think it's just worth noting that this is in practice pretty regressive - higher-paid employees are much more likely to have had long commutes, and so have benefited hugely financially, whereas lower-paid staff are much more likely to live near where they work and so won't have benefited from reduction in travel costs but will really feel the increased energy costs, which have a much bigger impact on them than on high earners.

Belladonna12 · 28/02/2022 13:44

@Gwenhwyfar

"Regardless, your desire to work in an office isn't more important than other people’s desire to work at home, particularly if the latter saves money ."

Saves money for the employer, not the employee who has to pay for heat and lighting all day and all the businesses going down the drain because nobody goes into town.
So I'd argue that my desire is no less important than yours.

The employee might have to pay for lighting and heat but they don't have to pay travel costs which are a lot higher for many people. You argument that it will effect businesses in town centres assumes that everyone's workplace is in a town centre. Most aren't.
Cece92 · 28/02/2022 13:42

I was Also wfh during pandemic pre pandemic I was in the office 5 days but my company had now introduced hybrid and we are required to do 2 days. One fixed and the other flexi. I'm in a team of 8 and there's been 3 of us who have stuck to this and the others haven't. My manager went nuts at them last week as they always have excuses as she said to them they worked in the office 5 days before there no excuses anymore. Our offices are still very covid safe and I've never felt unsafe at any point. She also told them if they ain't happy to look for other jobs

Gwenhwyfar · 28/02/2022 13:36

"Regardless, your desire to work in an office isn't more important than other people’s desire to work at home, particularly if the latter saves money ."

Saves money for the employer, not the employee who has to pay for heat and lighting all day and all the businesses going down the drain because nobody goes into town.
So I'd argue that my desire is no less important than yours.

PeeAche · 28/02/2022 13:27

I have!

I told my employer I'm pregnant back in November. They haven't done me a risk assessment to return to the office so I have not returned. I go on mat leave in 3 months so I don't think I'll be going in at all before then. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/02/2022 13:27

All employees have the rights to make one statutory application a year for a permanent change to their contract, I believe, although employers also have the right to refuse them

This is correct, and while employers quite rightly have to give a good reason (as opposed to "I just don't like it") that's not likely to be difficult if WFH has led to a lack of productivity/customer satisfaction despite claims that it all works wonderfully

It's absolutely right for employers to be as flexible as possible within business needs, but for some whatever's offered will quite simply never be enough - hence, perhaps, the "Shan't!!" attitude which tends to appear

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/02/2022 13:16

If you want and need people to be in the office then you have to pay salaries for that location. You can’t make a threat of finding cheaper staff overseas - because that would still mean they’re not in person. Defeating the original argument

Not really, because the original question concerned people refusing to go in, even in OP's case on a flexible basis, and if that happened work wouldn't be done "in person" anyway. Unless it's being suggested that folk are dismissed and replaced, and I wouldn't expect that idea to be popular either

I can't know how many posters were around in the '70s, but it's often forgotten that the mulish "all management are bastards" attitude is partly why so much industry went overseas in the first place - not the only reason of course, but a factor all the same

And many of those who were constantly striking back then insisted "It'll never happen" too

Gwenhwyfar · 28/02/2022 13:09

@CallyfromBlakes7

Well, that’s down the pan if your only contact with your peers is a seeing them in the corner of a zoom call and at best an awkward periodic social meet-up

so you have hobbies and meet people locally instead. People are allowed to make friends away from work!

And it's probably better to avoid "major bants", TBH.

My friends won't come out during the week and I don't think I'm the only person in that situation :(
Gwenhwyfar · 28/02/2022 13:07

"I think you'll find people are. My DH has a flexible working arrangement of two short days and three long days. Since he worked from home, the short days have become normal length ones."

That's an argument AGAINST wfh if it's being used as a source of free labour.

QuirkyTurtle · 28/02/2022 13:02

How many times do posters who work with, or manage, younger people have to explain that none of those younger people, in their experience, want to work from home most of the time? That, in fact, they want to work from an office for at least part of the week and that their work/life balance has been impaired by working from shared housing or a bedroom at their parents’ house? Post after post saying the same thing, but no, you know best.

@Iamthewombat
OK? Their opinions / posts are anecdotal, as are mine. I specified in the post you quoted that some people want it and others don't, some industries allow it and others don't.

I'm not claiming that I know best, I've specified multiple times that it's purely anecdotal based on experience, and that this is an impossible discussion because everyone will be coming in from different walks of life and experiences.

For someone who keeps pointing out other people are 'resorting to insults', you are coming across incredibly condescending and unkind. I'm not really interested in hearing your response because you're clearly not interested in any kind of meaningful debate. None of your posts have been particularly constructive, and you're only attacking and singling out certain posts / people that don't agree with you.

Twitterwhooooo · 28/02/2022 12:56

Iggly flexible working requests are completely different from working from home.

All employees have the rights to make one statutory application a year for a permanent change to their contract, I believe, although employers also have the right to refuse them.

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:49

@Iamthewombat

Yes I would actually although. They’re certainly more civilised.

So you say! I suspect that when higher rate tax increased by 5% (which is what it would take to guarantee benefits at the same levels of some of those countries) you’d be the first to complain.

Also, be careful what you wish for. The group I work for has an Argentinian entity. It is impossible to fire staff there, even if they are incompetent or even fraudulent. Is that what you would like here, with your stated fondness for employee rights? You haven’t even said what specifically you think is worse in the U.K. compared with your personally-chosen set of ‘similar countries’.

I earn enough to be able to afford extra taxes.

I would prefer a more equitable tax system because it benefits us all. A country with a healthy well educated population will have a stronger economy better able to weather any storms that come its way.

Don’t forget, those employee rights impact you too.

Employment rights are about putting in place protections to give employees decent working conditions and provide a framework for employers when things go wrong. I’m not sure why you think the US, with its woeful maternity provision, woeful annual leave provision, is such a beacon to be honest.

Stop trying to denigrate me because I don’t share your values. You’ve tried to suggest I’m some sort of bitter junior worker, you’ve tried to suggest I don’t know how to do my job, you’ve suggested all sorts of nonsense. I disagree with you and there’s no more to be said. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:42

@Iggly

You’re doing it again: whining about ‘management’ and ‘senior staff’. Which tells me very clearly that you aren’t particularly senior yourself and value your popularity with junior people over the needs of the business

Nope not public sector. Although used to be! It’s not about popularity, it’s about treating people as people and with respect.

Nope I am very senior.

I’m just one of those people who see those who treat their teams as commodities and think it’s a bit sad really. What are they trying to prove…? It’s all a bit faux macho.

You are hilarious. All the silly virtue signalling. You have no idea about the priorities of a modern business. You manage a team of 20 and claim to be ‘very senior’, yet you moan about ‘cynicism about management’. It doesn’t add up. As above, I feel sorry for your employers.
Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:40

Yes I would actually although. They’re certainly more civilised.

So you say! I suspect that when higher rate tax increased by 5% (which is what it would take to guarantee benefits at the same levels of some of those countries) you’d be the first to complain.

Also, be careful what you wish for. The group I work for has an Argentinian entity. It is impossible to fire staff there, even if they are incompetent or even fraudulent. Is that what you would like here, with your stated fondness for employee rights? You haven’t even said what specifically you think is worse in the U.K. compared with your personally-chosen set of ‘similar countries’.

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:37

You’re doing it again: whining about ‘management’ and ‘senior staff’. Which tells me very clearly that you aren’t particularly senior yourself and value your popularity with junior people over the needs of the business

Nope not public sector. Although used to be! It’s not about popularity, it’s about treating people as people and with respect.

Nope I am very senior.

I’m just one of those people who see those who treat their teams as commodities and think it’s a bit sad really. What are they trying to prove…? It’s all a bit faux macho.

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:36

And yes, I said employer when I meant to say employee.

Sorry Smile

Iamthewombat · 28/02/2022 12:35

@Iggly

And employers are being flexible. The OP’s employer is asking for three days per week. I don’t think we’ve heard from anyone who is insisting that their team go back full time, just because

How is it flexible? They are literally dictating it. Are they phasing people back in? Looking at flexible working requests? Or just “telling” people? I suspect that’s why they’re resisting.

In my office, we also have a minimum of 3 days but we are being flexible about days and also getting people to ramp back up to 3 days. Not insisting on it from day 1. It is a shift especially after being home based for so long.

There’s also a cynicism that senior staff don’t trust their staff, and that’s why they really want them back. And that management attitude will come through and staff can feel it.

You’re doing it again: whining about ‘management’ and ‘senior staff’. Which tells me very clearly that you aren’t particularly senior yourself and value your popularity with junior people over the needs of the business.

(If it is a business, that is; I’m getting public sector vibes from your posts).

Iggly · 28/02/2022 12:35

@Iamthewombat

You said ‘similar countries’. Would you like to pay similar tax to France, Germany, the Netherlands and Scandinavia, to guarantee the employee (not employer, although I’m guessing that was your mistake) rights you say that you are so keen on?
Yes I would actually although. They’re certainly more civilised.
Swipe left for the next trending thread