Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
Porridgeislife · 01/03/2022 13:09

We have advanced so much in terms of technology that our outputs have dramatically increased since Henry ford introduced the 40 hour workweek, and unfortunately we haven't been compensated for this increase in productivity over the years.

Output doesn’t equal productivity.

One of the UK’s biggest economic issues is that we rank behind France, Germany, the US and other similar countries for productivity per hour worked which hasn’t budged in some 30 odd years. In 1960 we were the most productive in Europe.

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 01/03/2022 13:06

@MabelsApron

And so what if they are?

@notyourtypicalvirgo Erm, maybe re-read my second paragraph again?

What is there to re-read? You're being overdramatic. I'm sure you're childless colleagues have coffee breaks longer than the school run that they don't declare or make up time for but that doesn't fit the agenda does it?!

Time to get with the times unfortunately and focus on output and deliverables rather than bum on seat time 🤷🏽‍♀️

It also sounds like you aren't being particularly accommodating to parents either. If you know people are likely to be doing the school runs you don't HAVE to schedule meetings at 3pm, the same discussion can be had at 2pm....just sounds like a load of spite for no reason

MabelsApron · 01/03/2022 13:00

And so what if they are?

@notyourtypicalvirgo Erm, maybe re-read my second paragraph again?

Wordlewobble · 01/03/2022 12:52

I am still working from home part time (I have teens who are self sufficient during the working day) and am I CEV. I am much more productive than the other full timer and part timer in my team (who both have slightly younger kids as although they are back in the office part of the time now). They are forever having to leave early or start late to take X or Y to X or Y appointment or pick X or Y up early from school early as she or he are not well for 6th or 7th time this month or are working from home as its half term, they have a workman in to do this that or the other or they are waiting for a delivery etc.

I am working extra hard at home and have done since the start of the pandemic (as confirmed on the spreadsheets showing how much work we each all do) and as I am terrified to go back to the office and grateful to still be WFH, I am CEV and have an OH report supporting my WFH. Yet because of Pee takers who are continuing to work at home because they can skive off more. So I am also having to return to the office before the suggested return date of the OH report.

Belladonna12 · 01/03/2022 12:48

I agree that people shouldn't be looking after children while working at home. I used nursery/after school clubs etc when my children were younger to make sure that I wasn't interrupted on a working day. It's not good enough to say the time will be made up in the evening. However, I think that could be made clear by managers rather than preventing work from home altogether.

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 01/03/2022 12:45

@MabelsApron

I really enjoy WFH and at the moment we still are doing it full time. The problem I have with it is that my colleagues are all using it as an excuse to do twice-daily school runs and not attend meetings as they're sorting out kids snacks/helping them with tasks/watching them do stuff etc.

They all say they're making up the time in the evening but I've seen no evidence of it (I'm often still logged on myself in the evening) and even if they were, we need support during the working day, not at night. It's causing a lot of resentment as those without kids are picking up all of the slack, attending all of the meetings and working extra hours to ensure the necessary work gets done.

Management are aware but are buying into the cries of sex discrimination that inevitably happen whenever they try to enforce these people doing their jobs. In future I suspect there'll be a lot of people trying to use WFH as a way of getting paid to look after their kids, because childcare is so expensive.

It drives me mad because it's piss-taking that'll see the benefit removed from everyone else as well.

And so what if they are?

We have advanced so much in terms of technology that our outputs have dramatically increased since Henry ford introduced the 40 hour workweek, and unfortunately we haven't been compensated for this increase in productivity over the years.

Don't be a jobsworth, there's absolutely time in the day to do school pickups and it's better for everyone. Happier kids, happier parents and ultimately happier employers as it means parents are likely to stay in their jobs longer because of this increased flexibility.

I'm a manager myself and I couldn't care less if my team pop out to do school pickups, the work still gets done and I'm personally not paying them out of my own pocket.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 01/03/2022 12:28

Unpopular37 on MN the "sex discrimination" is a bit of a knee jerk pattern amongst those who haven't got what they want
On WFH it tends to start with the dinosaur/luddite insults, work its way through "contact the union/Acas", and then discrimination's tossed around in the hope that something - anything - will stick

Obviously these fallbacks are important and sometimes genuinely needed, but not necessarily because something just doesn't suit

MabelsApron · 01/03/2022 12:25

I really enjoy WFH and at the moment we still are doing it full time. The problem I have with it is that my colleagues are all using it as an excuse to do twice-daily school runs and not attend meetings as they're sorting out kids snacks/helping them with tasks/watching them do stuff etc.

They all say they're making up the time in the evening but I've seen no evidence of it (I'm often still logged on myself in the evening) and even if they were, we need support during the working day, not at night. It's causing a lot of resentment as those without kids are picking up all of the slack, attending all of the meetings and working extra hours to ensure the necessary work gets done.

Management are aware but are buying into the cries of sex discrimination that inevitably happen whenever they try to enforce these people doing their jobs. In future I suspect there'll be a lot of people trying to use WFH as a way of getting paid to look after their kids, because childcare is so expensive.

It drives me mad because it's piss-taking that'll see the benefit removed from everyone else as well.

Kumbaya12 · 01/03/2022 11:35

@Notyourtypicalvirgo

Now that electricity and gas are shooting through the roof I think you might find your company will start letting you all work from home more to reduce overheads 😉
Quite the opposite. Keeping an empty building open/heated/lighted takes up the bulk of the bill. Having people plugged in and working are smaller additions
Notyourtypicalvirgo · 01/03/2022 11:31

Best comment here

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 01/03/2022 11:15

Now that electricity and gas are shooting through the roof I think you might find your company will start letting you all work from home more to reduce overheads 😉

Belladonna12 · 01/03/2022 10:33

I agree that even when wfh there were still team meets but that isn't usually 3 days a week. I think I went to the office about a couple of times a month prior to the pandemic.

AWOL66 · 01/03/2022 09:48

@Angliski

I’ve wfh for over 20 years for myself snd for various firms. Even when my contract was wfh, there was a reasonable expectation that I would come in for team meets, sometimes client stuff or just to be with others and share info. The problem with wfh experiences people had in the pandemic is that they don’t understand that that wasn’t a normal wfh experience. There is so much more to be gained from a wider pallet of options eg meeting half way, team days, meeting on client site or in a cafe. If your org have asked you to return to the office, it’s because they believe there are benefits to mixing, mingling…

If you don’t return… how will you train new colleagues? How will you help junior colleagues have a sense of team? How will you experience any org wide knowledge sharing? I think many people need to move from ‘I’ to ‘we’ again. If you don’t want to be part of something, work for yourself or find yourself an entirely remote role, but don’t take advantage of your social contract with your employer.

This is so well put and very insightful. I 100 per cent agree!
Unpopular37 · 01/03/2022 09:04

@catgirl1976

It’s interesting

We are back in 3 / 4 days a week so I’m looking for another job as there is no justifiable reason. My role can be down (and has been done) perfectly well remotely

A blanket “you must be back in the office x days a week” runs the risk of indirect sex discrimination imo. However that’s not a fight I can be arsed to have so I’ll just get another job and vote with my feet as will my colleagues

How on earth did you come to the conclusion that this is indirect sex discrimination ffs? Talk about looking for shit that isn't there. If you were originally employed to work in 'x' place, then that's where you work, despite being able to do the job atop mount Everest/whilst caving/on a beach. WFH was temporary, and while I agree that it is a good thing for some, if it isn't for your employer, well tough; as you say, you can always vote with your feet
GoldenOmber · 01/03/2022 07:54

Yes, still a thing some places.

KittenKong · 01/03/2022 07:53

I haven’t had a London Allowance since… way last century. Is it still a thing?

GoldenOmber · 01/03/2022 07:50

The London allowance is there due to the higher cost of rent and mortgages and general living here and with costs rising why should people travel into the office if their job can be done at home?

Employers aren’t supposed to change your terms and conditions of employment just on a whim, so I agree that unilaterally reducing people’s pay by taking away the London weighting wouldn’t be fair (or legal!)

But at the same time, they’re obviously not going to want to keep paying that for people who don’t need or want to be in London. Why would they? So I would expect more employers saying things like, “yes we’re happy to renegotiate your contract so you can work from home all the time, but in return you’ll lose your London weighting.”

Mandyjack · 01/03/2022 07:44

@Belladonna12

I need to have the room at 20 or 21 degrees because I'm sitting down all the time so I need the heating on all day. I need the light because I live in an old place and the windows don't allow enough light in for me to work otherwise.

A light in one room doesn't cost that much. I'm not sure what the temperature of my room is at the moment but I sit down to work too and I certainly don't need the heating on all day. Perhaps you live in Scotland or in a house with no insulation but I don't think you can assume that everyone who works from home has the heating on all day, every day.

We have our heating on 20 all day so obviously it goes on and off with the thermostat. The room I work in isn't the warmest so I have a blanket in there and if it's really cold use a hot wheat bag too
Mandyjack · 01/03/2022 07:38

Most people have ultd broadband now as they stream TV shows and movies. I have ultd and it's just over 20 quid a month so far cheaper than what most pay for Sky TV which I gave up when I got a Freesat Box. We can't go into the office when we want as we have to book a desk and there are only 4 to book from for our dept. 1 desk is used all the time by someone with no WiFi so that only leaves 3 in the whole building for us. 95% of us don't want to be there and prefer to WFH.

Spaciet · 01/03/2022 06:06

@Whitefire

I don’t think we’ve heard from anyone who is insisting that their team go back full time, just because.

I am back in the office full time 'just because' It is what it is, I guess. Work are currently recruiting - there has not been a shortage of applicants even with working full time in the office.

Some of the whinging on this thread is ridiculous.

Away from mumsnet lots of people don't mind or even prefer going into the office so not surprised people are still applying.
Ewan83 · 01/03/2022 00:06

I do love how people assume those of who have established lives and homes in London and the south with agreed salaries and other commitments taken on pre-pandemic should now just take a pay cut if we wfh or do more time at home and get the job done as effectively as colleagues doing the same work in an office because times have moved on and technology now allows it. The London allowance is there due to the higher cost of rent and mortgages and general living here and with costs rising why should people travel into the office if their job can be done at home? I’m all for hybrid but just want employers to be sensible in why some people are looking at when to stay at home when feasible. Not everyone is in a position to move to the coast or up north or whatever just because they want to and can easily wfh more or full time and rents and mortgages have only increased - like everything else travel, petrol, Nat insurance etc etc. People just want a better quality of life, an extra hour or two at home with the children instead of the commute (and more money to put towards soaring bills while wages are stagnant) which they didn’t have before because many firms were anti wfh. We’re such a stressed out society - why not help people where possible to have a good life balance? Also if people are talking about people saving money commuting then surely anyone walking into the office should have their pay reduced too?

Userxxxxx · 28/02/2022 22:56

But do companies really know how to train people these days.
No.

I mean when I was senior on hotel reception you would sit side by side, training plans would be signed that you understand just what task xxx involved - nowadays none of that happens.

Most companies I've been at pre pandemic think 2 weeks is enough mate, if that. To think I used to work for a legendary travel holiday booking shop in early 00's that said you were not a sales consultant until your 2nd year - no workplace is like this today.

I mean 2 weeks spent when you've physically gone into an office for half that time spent lobbed in front of a pc with some 'buddy' on zoom shotting of that they were the only only left out of the training group last year and quite willing to tell you wrong things 'because it is a dog eat, dog world isn't something to be proud of.

There is no camaraderie in today's world.

I love working from home, I hate the one day in the office where you can expect to sit in silence. I didn't have the nice work from home experience in March 2020 - I was covering for a pregnant person who unknown to me would take frequent breaks during the day to lay down often and expect me to work late under their guilt, lunch breaks where unknown and you know on arrival back to the office in July 2020 it was said I appeared more confident because I had no choice but get on with it, alone.

Maze76 · 28/02/2022 22:55

Prior to Covid I worked 3 days in the office 2 days from home. We’ve been told we have to work at least 2 days in the office - can choose more if we wish.
Now energy prices have rocketed , the cost of parking/fuel , I’m going to have to weigh up which options are more cost effective.

Mandyjack · 28/02/2022 22:55

@DungballInADress

Raise a flexible working request.

That said, I work in HR and people are leaving companies who are mandating return to office to move to where I work because we are promoting more flexible ways of working - agile working and/or hybrid available to all office based, most desks now hot desks and we offer 9 day fortnight. Companies need to move with the times or employees will go elsewhere.

A lot of companies are also trying 4 day weeks
NothingIsWrong · 28/02/2022 22:54

@CallyfromBlakes7

I always think it's weird that people think WFH means perching on the end of a bed in your shared house bedroom. There are plenty of other options including co-working, and nothing stops you going into your employer office if you want to.

I don't know why this polarises people so much. Employers who are flexible have the most committed employees and the best results.

I always think it's weird that people have no sense of confidentiality requirements when happily suggesting co working spaces. I can't be the only one who is not permitted to work where I might be overheard due to security concerns.

And yes, employers do stop people coming into the office. I moved from my last job because they would not let me return, despite the adverse effects WFH was having on my mental health. My current job said 3 days in 2 at home, which was perfect and are now making noises about wanting to cut costs by making me foot the bill for an office i.e. WFH. I told them the day they presented me with a WFH contract would be the day I quit and I meant it. So far, it has not materialised but I am still looking for a new job again as I do not trust them to try and kick us out to save money.