Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has anyone refused to go back into the office?

841 replies

GreenPepperRed · 27/02/2022 00:12

Just that really. Have a job that can easily be done working from home. Company is now saying compulsory 3 days in the office. Has anyone just not gone in and carried on working from home? How did that turn out?

The majority of my department is insisting they are not going in. Can confirm they are serious because I went in to the office a couple days back and there was probably 10% of the people in.

Intrigued what my company will do. Fire us all?

OP posts:
Notyourtypicalvirgo · 01/03/2022 21:15

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

That's not what I said (but qq.....if you don't have children, why are you on Mumsnet??)

Oh not that one again Confused. There's a lot of boards on MN that don't relate to kids - I first started posting on The Litter Tray.

In the example above, the poster says she has absolutely no spare time in the day and it sounds like time is very tight to the point where scheduling is a problem. In that instance what time you take lunch is pretty low priority and you should be acting in the interest of the team. If you have to squeeze it in at 1-2 because that's the time you don't have calls then so be it, parents shouldn't have to pay hundreds a month in wrap around childcare for your luxury if it isn't necessary.

My lunch break isn't a luxury, it's an entitlement and a necessary one at the moment! It's shit enough WFH without going without a lunch break! Obviously I do take it when it's convenient but I often book things in my lunch hour so try to have a regular time and will decline meetings if I've booked something.

However....in a healthy well organised workplace, this shouldn't be a consideration and you have every right to take lunch whenever you want 😊

Unfortunately ours is manic at the moment but I'm making sure I take a full hour - I need to step away otherwise I'll be resigning!

No one said don't take a lunch break where are you reading that?

I said take it when you can and if your boss won't let you because she's so disorganized and neurotic about a couple people being out for 15 minutes because they're doing the school run and that somehow impacts you.....then leave Jesus Christ because that workplace has much much bigger problems than a few parents.

I take my lunch break when my schedule is clear and that can be anytime when I don't have a call....is that really that hard to understand???

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 01/03/2022 21:12

That's not what I said (but qq.....if you don't have children, why are you on Mumsnet??)

Oh not that one again Confused. There's a lot of boards on MN that don't relate to kids - I first started posting on The Litter Tray.

In the example above, the poster says she has absolutely no spare time in the day and it sounds like time is very tight to the point where scheduling is a problem. In that instance what time you take lunch is pretty low priority and you should be acting in the interest of the team. If you have to squeeze it in at 1-2 because that's the time you don't have calls then so be it, parents shouldn't have to pay hundreds a month in wrap around childcare for your luxury if it isn't necessary.

My lunch break isn't a luxury, it's an entitlement and a necessary one at the moment! It's shit enough WFH without going without a lunch break! Obviously I do take it when it's convenient but I often book things in my lunch hour so try to have a regular time and will decline meetings if I've booked something.

However....in a healthy well organised workplace, this shouldn't be a consideration and you have every right to take lunch whenever you want 😊

Unfortunately ours is manic at the moment but I'm making sure I take a full hour - I need to step away otherwise I'll be resigning!

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 01/03/2022 21:04

We don't tend to have many internal meetings during lunchtime but I tend to decline any customer meetings that fall during lunchtime or are requested before 9am or after 5pm. Obviously if it's essential that's different but most can wait.

NothingIsWrong · 01/03/2022 21:02

I act in the best interests of my team by paying hundreds of pounds a month in wraparound to be focussed on my job during the hours I'm being paid for thank you very much.

QuirkyTurtle · 01/03/2022 21:00

I kind of hate the fact that this thread is making me appreciate my company and industry.

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 01/03/2022 20:59

[quote PinkSparklyPussyCat]@Notyourtypicalvirgo what you're saying is that people who want lunch breaks, which they are entitled to, should be adults and take them when it's convenient for you.

I don't have children but why should I be forced to take my lunch break so someone can pick up their kid? Of course I'll do it to help out occasionally but not because someone expects me to.[/quote]
That's not what I said (but qq.....if you don't have children, why are you on Mumsnet??)

In the example above, the poster says she has absolutely no spare time in the day and it sounds like time is very tight to the point where scheduling is a problem. In that instance what time you take lunch is pretty low priority and you should be acting in the interest of the team. If you have to squeeze it in at 1-2 because that's the time you don't have calls then so be it, parents shouldn't have to pay hundreds a month in wrap around childcare for your luxury if it isn't necessary.

However....in a healthy well organised workplace, this shouldn't be a consideration and you have every right to take lunch whenever you want 😊

GoldenOmber · 01/03/2022 20:58

I want to say that in that case your first problem is forcing your staff into 5 hours of meetings per day.

That’s what some people’s jobs are like. Some require more meetings than others. 🤷‍♀️

Just like some people don’t have the flexibility to arrange all meeting times with their own team based on 5 people’s school run preferences, because their meetings are often with people outside their team and outside their scheduling control.

NothingIsWrong · 01/03/2022 20:56

@QuirkyTurtle

It wouldn't be every day. But yes, there are days during some project phases where we are very meeting intensive. Other phases are not so much. But with lots of projects on, I would foresee at least one day a week where project leads in particular could easily be back to back for 5 hours.

NothingIsWrong · 01/03/2022 20:53

If I had to squeeze everything into 10-3, there would be days when meetings would run into each other across the whole 5 hours. Not every day granted, but even a couple of days where there wasn't time for a proper break - seeing as we are all focussing on work life balance - can start to become an issue. Especially if it is seen as prioritising some staffs external commitments in their working hours over others having time for a break and a meal in the middle of the day.

QuirkyTurtle · 01/03/2022 20:53

@GoldenOmber

Anyone who complains about meetings between 10 and 3 being unfair to people who want to take a lunch break. I snorted just typing that out.

At some people’s workplaces, what that would look like is everyone’s calendar being solid back-to-back meetings between 10 and 3, so therefore no chance for a lunch break…

I want to say that in that case your first problem is forcing your staff into 5 hours of meetings per day.
TheFirstSpiderMan · 01/03/2022 20:52

I work for a large organisation and the original plan was for everyone to return 2 days a week I think. There was significant pushback about this and it seems to have dropped to one day a week with some exceptions made with individual managers.

I know they are recruiting some for some fully remote roles too but those that worked for the organisation pre-pandemic won't be able to be fully remote. Interesting to see how that pans out.

The contracts were changed to accommodate for the mix of WFH/ in office.

However the difference with my organisation is that they took the opportunity to give up some of the leased office space (conveniently timed break clause) so physically it will be tricky to have everyone back in office at once.

In short, it's an organisation that has lots of long standing employees and when there was significant pushback on return to the office, they listened. So it depends. It can happen.

GoldenOmber · 01/03/2022 20:52

Anyone who complains about meetings between 10 and 3 being unfair to people who want to take a lunch break. I snorted just typing that out.

At some people’s workplaces, what that would look like is everyone’s calendar being solid back-to-back meetings between 10 and 3, so therefore no chance for a lunch break…

QuirkyTurtle · 01/03/2022 20:50

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

Who's that to *@QuirkyTurtle*?
Anyone who complains about meetings between 10 and 3 being unfair to people who want to take a lunch break. I snorted just typing that out.
Shoemadlady · 01/03/2022 20:49

I work in HR and can confirm that if your contract confirm you work in an office you are required to return. However, you are completely within your right to put in a flexible working application to request to remain working from home or at least working from home a couple of days a week etc. anyone can do this, you don't need to have children etc to do that and the business have to give it serious consideration and have a case as to why not, if they say no.
Good luck!
I've just put one in myself and it was accepted.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 01/03/2022 20:46

Who's that to @QuirkyTurtle?

NothingIsWrong · 01/03/2022 20:42

@Notyourtypicalvirgo

Sorry *@nothingiswrong* but that sounds like a scheduling problem on your part and an unwillingness to be flexible. If you're spending every hour of work in meetings I could potentially see your point (and I mean if that's the case you have bigger issues because there's clearly no time for deliverables).

On my team, we schedule the bulk of our meetings between 10am -3pm and then again between 4-5pm. People who want a lunch break should be adults about it and take their lunch break when they have the time to rather than merely when they want to.

I think we can all agree that child safeguarding is more important than when we all fancy a lunch break and it's a fact of life. I definitely agree with paying for wrap around childcare if you have very young children as not giving them your full attention is a safety issue, but in my case my eldest is 9. Once I pick him up from school he's usually distracted by the PlayStation or doing his homework which means I'm able to log back on at 3.45pm and focus for the rest of my afternoon. It made no sense for either me or my staff pre pandemic to pay for after school childcare for kids this age, it's a waste of money when working from home is always a viable option.

There are 8-9 hours in the work day....if someone doing the school run for less than an hour of one of them causes that much of an issue then again I'll say that's a you problem and the poor parents shouldn't be lambasted for that when everyone is trying to do the best they can both in their jobs and for their families.

As for you not liking people working in the evening....again, I think you need to get over that personally and start thinking more creatively in terms of scheduling. Employees with more autonomy in the way they work have been proven to be happier and less likely to move.

I'm perfectly willing to be flexible, but the fact remains we have multiple projects to resource with multiple external stakeholders. I cannot schedule EVERY meeting between 10-12 and 2-3.

And I'm not about to tell those without children that they can't have a break at lunchtime because I'm planning meetings around school pick up times. That is ludicrous and unfair.

QuirkyTurtle · 01/03/2022 20:37

Do you need to have a meeting every single day at noon? Or are you just finding problems where there aren't any for the sake of the argument? No grown adult will be bothered if once a week they need to take their lunch break at 1 instead of noon.

I'm a manager. I speak to my team and ask for their input. The general consensus was meetings between 10 and 3. Talk to your team instead of coming up with hypothetical scenarios on Mumsnet.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 01/03/2022 20:33

@Notyourtypicalvirgo what you're saying is that people who want lunch breaks, which they are entitled to, should be adults and take them when it's convenient for you.

I don't have children but why should I be forced to take my lunch break so someone can pick up their kid? Of course I'll do it to help out occasionally but not because someone expects me to.

GoldenOmber · 01/03/2022 20:27

@TimeToMakeACupofTea

No compulsion to come back to my office and yet most people are back for 2-3 days a week. The buzzy office vibe is back, except on Friday which seems to be WFH for nearly everyone.
Yes I think that’s fairly common. 2/3 days in the office is what most of my colleagues said they wanted last time they asked us. A few don’t want to/can’t do any days WFH, and a few would prefer to WFH forever but also appreciate that’s not going to happen and aren’t sulking about it. (And probably a few people who like WFH are now quietly looking for a WFH job without making a big fuss out of it, fair enough and good luck to them.)

What I find interesting at my work is that there’s a small but vocal group of people who don’t want to go back at all and don’t think they should have to, who also think they’re speaking for the majority. And who do things like emailing the whole department of several dozen people to rant to us about how unfair it is, in a way that comes off as totally clueless.

It started off when work started making plans to get people back in, and there was this flurry of some people being really shocked because they assumed WFH was permanent, or that ‘hybrid’ meant ‘for everyone but you, Dave in Legal’ or whatever.

It’s like pandemic WFH has mentally isolated some people to a point where they don’t have much insight at all into what their colleagues think, or what’s happening outside their own four walls, or how they’re coming across when they take up other people’s time with “I prefer sitting out in the garden first thing in the morning not sitting on a busy train” (lovely for you, Dave, but why are you emailing us all to tell us that?)

Unpopular37 · 01/03/2022 20:26

@Puzzledandpissedoff

Unpopular37 on MN the "sex discrimination" is a bit of a knee jerk pattern amongst those who haven't got what they want On WFH it tends to start with the dinosaur/luddite insults, work its way through "contact the union/Acas", and then discrimination's tossed around in the hope that something - anything - will stick

Obviously these fallbacks are important and sometimes genuinely needed, but not necessarily because something just doesn't suit

😀
Notyourtypicalvirgo · 01/03/2022 20:23

Sorry @nothingiswrong but that sounds like a scheduling problem on your part and an unwillingness to be flexible. If you're spending every hour of work in meetings I could potentially see your point (and I mean if that's the case you have bigger issues because there's clearly no time for deliverables).

On my team, we schedule the bulk of our meetings between 10am -3pm and then again between 4-5pm. People who want a lunch break should be adults about it and take their lunch break when they have the time to rather than merely when they want to.

I think we can all agree that child safeguarding is more important than when we all fancy a lunch break and it's a fact of life. I definitely agree with paying for wrap around childcare if you have very young children as not giving them your full attention is a safety issue, but in my case my eldest is 9. Once I pick him up from school he's usually distracted by the PlayStation or doing his homework which means I'm able to log back on at 3.45pm and focus for the rest of my afternoon. It made no sense for either me or my staff pre pandemic to pay for after school childcare for kids this age, it's a waste of money when working from home is always a viable option.

There are 8-9 hours in the work day....if someone doing the school run for less than an hour of one of them causes that much of an issue then again I'll say that's a you problem and the poor parents shouldn't be lambasted for that when everyone is trying to do the best they can both in their jobs and for their families.

As for you not liking people working in the evening....again, I think you need to get over that personally and start thinking more creatively in terms of scheduling. Employees with more autonomy in the way they work have been proven to be happier and less likely to move.

bangaverage · 01/03/2022 20:15

It's a huge problem for junior staff. WFH just doesn't allow for the same organic learning and sharing of knowledge.

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 01/03/2022 20:11

Thank you!

TimeToMakeACupofTea · 01/03/2022 20:05

No compulsion to come back to my office and yet most people are back for 2-3 days a week. The buzzy office vibe is back, except on Friday which seems to be WFH for nearly everyone.

Notyourtypicalvirgo · 01/03/2022 20:02

[quote Porridgeislife]@Notyourtypicalvirgo I have post graduate qualifications in applied economics (not just a “business” degree) & work in the same so yeah, if we’re playing university top trumps I’m probably good love Daffodil

Email is shown to decrease productivity for individual workers - reading email is rarely a productive activity, hence the move to Slack etc.

If output = productivity and technology has enabled this so greatly, why has the UK’s productivity declined since 2008?[/quote]
I mentioned my degree because you tried to insult my intelligence babe and I had to reassure you that you aren't talking to someone who hasn't had some form of education in this sector

Productivity dropping since 2008 isn't at all related to the point I made and you know this, just drawing up a straw man to give yourself some kind of weird validation. I made a point about how much more is produced with technological advancement since the 70s and it's literally the whole reasoning why some companies are now moving to a 4 day work week, it improves productivity in the hours worked and we do not need to work 40 hours anymore to produce the same output that we did decades ago.

Either we work less hours or we're paid more.....simple, what we're experiencing now with pay flatlining and hours increasing is nothing short of theft from the average worker. Anyone who disagrees with that quite frankly isn't someone that has the interest of their fellow humans at heart.

We're finally moving to a model which is flexible for people to have a work life balance and it's long overdue. Move with the times or jog on as far as I'm concerned.

Swipe left for the next trending thread