Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I tactfully handle this situation?

411 replies

Mogs43 · 27/02/2022 00:05

I am going to visit my home town soon. I had arranged to meet up with a family member and her children- had offered to pay for a meal (she's been very kind since my lovely father died). Another family member got in touch to say she had heard I was coming and having a meal - could she and her children come? It would be nice for them all to catch up etc I agreed. She then said it was her birthday that week but she would rather come to the meal than arrange something else. I said okay and didn't think anything of it.

She has just texted to say she has invited other family and friends (15 so far!!). I have also received text messages from others (not included in the 15) saying they hear I am around and organising a meal etc..So it could be more!

I have in the past couple of years organised meals etc to mark my fathers death/key anniversaries. I have been happy to pay for them as a sort of memorial to him -it has mostly been really nice to see everyone. However, for the last two events I found that the individual whose birthday it is has 'hijacked' the meal, hardly spoke to me and didn't acknowledge that I paid (I wouldn't normally expect any kind of acknowledgment at all but on the last occasion she physically froze me out and left me sitting at the children's table- I felt completely pathetic : fortunately another family member saw what was happening and insisted that the woman's child move to the children's table so I could sit with the adults). Throughout the meal she hardly spoke to me and at the end said all those with children were going somewhere else for ice cream etc. She left without even asking about the bill and nor did she even once acknowledge that the meal was in memory of my father. I haven't heard from her since - just the recent texts. To be honest. she has hardly been there since my father died. She appears to have money- drives a 4x4, regular plastic surgery, hair and nails - so I dont think she is broke :its just how she operates.

I had just wanted to concentrate on those who have been kind to me but its hard to invite some family and not others? Is that unfair?

I could possibly stretch to paying (although money is very tight) and it would be lovely to see (some of) them but I do resent how this has been done. I feel like a mug. The restaurant that I had originally booked can't accommodate such a large group and to be honest I don't fancy spending hours of my time looking for an alternative venue. I did ask her how one of the people she had invited (who had only just phoned asking to lend money) would be able to afford it. She responded that one extra wouldn't make much difference - that the restaurant would probably offer me a deal for such a large group. She clearly expects me to pay.

The individual is a drama queen who falls out with lots of people and I don't want to create a fuss (everything goes on social media and I couldn't bare all the ' let down on my birthday and I'm a single mum etc'). I would also not like to inconvenience the other family members (especially those I had initially invited). I value their friendship and would like to see them . I could do with the company as, to be honest, since my father died I often feel isolated and lonely.

How can I change this situation: should I say I cant go (but then would I have to cancel my whole weekend) or should I just suck it up? What would you do? Thank you- and sorry if I sound a bit pathetic. I am aware of this.

OP posts:
forrestgreen · 27/02/2022 20:08

Well done you should feel proud of yourself. I'd maybe text others that had been invited so this isn't seen as your fault.

Next time you organise something. Just agree that this is just us

WTF475878237NC · 27/02/2022 18:33

Good for you OP. All the best.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 27/02/2022 18:26

To be honest I don't think she'll ever get the message. She doesn't want to - it's how she lives her life. I don't currently have the capacity to get into a big row with her (she ended up physically fighting with another family member ...)

Classy ... not Hmm

Well done on your decision though, Mogs43; it sounds like you've done the right thing, and you can just leave her to leech off the kind of people who'll enable her

Mogs43 · 27/02/2022 18:18

Thank you for your replies. To be honest I don't think she'll ever get the message. She doesn't want to - it's how she lives her life. I don't currently have the capacity to get into a big row with her (she ended up physically fighting with another family member and I am just not like that) - but can soak up anything she puts on social media. I am clear that I am not paying for the meal - it has been cancelled and I have made arrangements to meet with the family member who has been so kind to me.

I know that ideally I would face her head on and there is a risk that by not doing so she will just carry on with more of the same. But to be honest I think she will always be like this - it has served her well in the past so why would she change?

For those who have asked, she has never done anything for me on my birthday - but that's how she is. I will just have to keep trying to engage with those family members who are kind and supportive and try to avoid/have minimal contact with the others- its not always easy but hopefully as I get a bit stronger and less desperate it will improve? Hope so! Thank you again for taking the time to help.

OP posts:
MoFro · 27/02/2022 17:48

Well done OP! Hope you have a wonderful time with your original family member and do something lovely together.

Let CF know she can organise her own birthday do and to you let you and you’ll see if you can make it otherwise wish her a great time and leave her be.

RedRobin100 · 27/02/2022 17:44

@Mogs43 problem is your message to the birthday was still wishy washy. You said you were cancelling it because of restaurant capacity - instead of because you’re not ducking bankrolling her birthday party (CF)

You need to be clearer with her that she was essentially hijacking your event (as she has before) and you won’t stand for it again.

LookItsMeAgain · 27/02/2022 17:32

As @venusandmars has just posted, this birthday person is still not getting the message that you're sending and you've been more than clear with them.

You can do one of two things here.

  1. If you have everyone's number, send one final (and then block everyone) message on WhatsApp saying that CF Birthday Person got the wrong end of the stick, the birthday 'lunch/celebration' is off and if anyone wants to arrange anything, they now have to deal directly with CF Birthday Person and their number is in the group chat. You are bowing out and the reservation is cancelled.
or
  1. You send one message to CF Birthday person saying
"Hi CFker, I'm not sure what you meant by saying that it's up to me, you'll go along with whatever I decide. I decided. I have cancelled the reservation. The lunch/whatever is not happening and you'll have to contact your friends yourself to let them know that whatever this was, is not happening. It's a pity this snowballed but it is what it is. Talk to you soon, Mogs"

Don't worry if they are offended. They clearly didn't mind causing you offence by jumping on the bandwagon of CFer's birthday celebrations, which is really tacky as you just wanted a quiet meal out with your friend and this has happened. They should be offended. At their behaviour and cheeky attitude.

venusandmars · 27/02/2022 17:23

I also texted the family members whose birthday it is - I used a combination of your replies. Explained that the restaurant could not accommodate such a large group so I was going to cancel it. Before I informed everyone I appreciated that it was her birthday and just wanted to check whether she wanted to organise something with them instead? She has just responded saying that it is up to me - she will go along with whatever I decide.

Actually the birthday person is still being a CF. You were clear - that you'd cancelled the restaurant. And you asked if SHE wanted to organise something for her birthday.

Her reply that she would go with whatever YOU decide, doesn't make sense. You have already decided. You've decided to cancel (since it's not possible to accommodate all the guests). That's it, end of story, nothing else for you to decide (or not that you have to tell her about).

It sounds like she is a) assuming you will decide to organise something for her and family and her friends; and b) if nothing is organised by you, then it will be all your fault if she has a disappointing birthday.

I'd get back to hear and say that perhaps she misunderstood. You have decided to cancel, what she wants to do for her birthday event is her decision (and for her to organise), and not yours. Hope she has a nice time.

TableSetting · 27/02/2022 17:21

@Mogs43 what does the CF usually arrange or do when it is your birthday?

WutheringHeights66 · 27/02/2022 17:15

And she’s replied anyway now

ugifletzet · 27/02/2022 17:14

@Howshouldibehave

Nearly 300 replies and not one more post from the OP?

Are you out there, @Mogs43?

OP created the thread just after midnight and around 15:00 people started conplaining that she hadn't replied and asking if this was genuine. The OP is likely to have spent a good chunk of those fifteen hours asleep, then doing whatever she needs to do on a Sunday. I know trolling is a problem on big forums, but I wish people weren't so quick to think troll just because OP isn't living on MN.
venusandmars · 27/02/2022 17:12

Well done @Mogs43 I was a little worried that (in addition to lots of excellent advice) some of the posts were a bit unkind when you were feeling alone and mybe a bit vulnerable. So it's great that you've seen past any negative remarks. That shows you DO have the inner resilience you need and you just have to keep applying that to family situations.

Enjoy your visit.

Decemberly · 27/02/2022 17:12

Well done OP, very glad to see you have been able to resolve this and can now relax and enjoy meeting up with the people who matter. Flowers

Sisisimone · 27/02/2022 17:08

Oh sorry OP, just read your update. Great outcome!

Sisisimone · 27/02/2022 17:07

@singlepringlenotbychoice

I wouldn't even be tactful. I'd reply back say there's been a misunderstanding, you're not paying, it's getting out of hand and that if she wants a birthday celebration she can organise that with all the extra people and that you're sticking to your original plan. She's a massive CF
Exactly this. Can't believe the cheek of the woman
Rustylee681 · 27/02/2022 17:05

👍🏽

Sswhinesthebest · 27/02/2022 17:05

Great. You’ve sorted it.
Perhaps arrange a date with your nice relative on a different weekend, to avoid the birthday weekend? Might make things easier.

Howshouldibehave · 27/02/2022 17:03

I suppose the only risk is that if others find out about this smaller get together they may be offended - but I think that is easily explainable (numbers, cost etc)

It doesn’t need explaining away though. You met up with a household for lunch when you were back. That doesn’t mean you have to see everyone you know. I’d offer to get a takeaway at hers. Don’t tell anyone about it at all.

CoraPirbright · 27/02/2022 17:02

Goodness - does this mean that you have the unenviable task of ringing around everyone she has invited (on your money) and telling them its off? Bloody hell!! CF of the highest order!! She should be doing this!!

newbiename · 27/02/2022 17:01

Great you've got it sorted.
Can you just phone the nice family member and ask her to keep arrangements to herself?
Just say you don't want it getting out of hand again.

notanothertakeaway · 27/02/2022 17:00

When CF said she was happy to go along with whatever you decided, I suspect she meant "you can choose the restaurant as you're paying". I suggest you email everyone to explain you're not going and suggest they liaise with CF with a view to booking elsewhere

Ballcactus · 27/02/2022 16:56

@singlepringlenotbychoice

I wouldn't even be tactful. I'd reply back say there's been a misunderstanding, you're not paying, it's getting out of hand and that if she wants a birthday celebration she can organise that with all the extra people and that you're sticking to your original plan. She's a massive CF
Agree
Gowithme · 27/02/2022 16:55

Well done OP, concentrate on the relatives that really value you. You sound very kind and unfortunately some people will take advantage.

Goatsaregreat · 27/02/2022 16:54

Well done Mogs43 for being assertive. You sound lovely - wishing you an enjoyable visit.

Cakeandcardio · 27/02/2022 16:52

OP, you are not pathetic. You are kind and you are being taken advantage of. Why is her feelings more important than yours? Why should you go to the expense and hassle when she clearly cares so little for you? I've been here before. It's so hard at first but once you take the initial stand, the CFs back down. There's no need to be confrontational but just throw it back to her. Maybe just say something as previous posters have said about the restaurant not being able to accommodate you all. If she then says she will arrange somewhere else then fine. If you do that, when the bill comes, pay for your meal and the family you had originally said you would treat. Just don't mention you will pay. Leave it to her. If she assumes then shame on her. She sounds unkind at best.