Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I tactfully handle this situation?

411 replies

Mogs43 · 27/02/2022 00:05

I am going to visit my home town soon. I had arranged to meet up with a family member and her children- had offered to pay for a meal (she's been very kind since my lovely father died). Another family member got in touch to say she had heard I was coming and having a meal - could she and her children come? It would be nice for them all to catch up etc I agreed. She then said it was her birthday that week but she would rather come to the meal than arrange something else. I said okay and didn't think anything of it.

She has just texted to say she has invited other family and friends (15 so far!!). I have also received text messages from others (not included in the 15) saying they hear I am around and organising a meal etc..So it could be more!

I have in the past couple of years organised meals etc to mark my fathers death/key anniversaries. I have been happy to pay for them as a sort of memorial to him -it has mostly been really nice to see everyone. However, for the last two events I found that the individual whose birthday it is has 'hijacked' the meal, hardly spoke to me and didn't acknowledge that I paid (I wouldn't normally expect any kind of acknowledgment at all but on the last occasion she physically froze me out and left me sitting at the children's table- I felt completely pathetic : fortunately another family member saw what was happening and insisted that the woman's child move to the children's table so I could sit with the adults). Throughout the meal she hardly spoke to me and at the end said all those with children were going somewhere else for ice cream etc. She left without even asking about the bill and nor did she even once acknowledge that the meal was in memory of my father. I haven't heard from her since - just the recent texts. To be honest. she has hardly been there since my father died. She appears to have money- drives a 4x4, regular plastic surgery, hair and nails - so I dont think she is broke :its just how she operates.

I had just wanted to concentrate on those who have been kind to me but its hard to invite some family and not others? Is that unfair?

I could possibly stretch to paying (although money is very tight) and it would be lovely to see (some of) them but I do resent how this has been done. I feel like a mug. The restaurant that I had originally booked can't accommodate such a large group and to be honest I don't fancy spending hours of my time looking for an alternative venue. I did ask her how one of the people she had invited (who had only just phoned asking to lend money) would be able to afford it. She responded that one extra wouldn't make much difference - that the restaurant would probably offer me a deal for such a large group. She clearly expects me to pay.

The individual is a drama queen who falls out with lots of people and I don't want to create a fuss (everything goes on social media and I couldn't bare all the ' let down on my birthday and I'm a single mum etc'). I would also not like to inconvenience the other family members (especially those I had initially invited). I value their friendship and would like to see them . I could do with the company as, to be honest, since my father died I often feel isolated and lonely.

How can I change this situation: should I say I cant go (but then would I have to cancel my whole weekend) or should I just suck it up? What would you do? Thank you- and sorry if I sound a bit pathetic. I am aware of this.

OP posts:
Piffle11 · 27/02/2022 09:12

I get that you don’t want everything plastered all over Facebook, but this is not the time to be tactful. There have been some great suggestions on here: Whatever you end up doing – just meeting your original family member and her children, are meeting everybody – make sure that the CF realises that you are NOT paying for them all. CFs only target people they know they can manipulate, And they rely on people feeling too awkward to question things and not wanting to create a fuss. You really need to call her out on this, and do it sooner rather than later. And if anything does end up on Facebook, just comment underneath that perhaps she shouldn’t expect people to pay for her party. Give us good as you get.

Luckymummytoone · 27/02/2022 09:12

You’ll feel worse in the long run if you go ahead with this. And be very much out of pocket. Please stick up for yourself and stick with the original plan. Be strong!
Sorry about your loss. Hugs xx

WhatAHexIGotInto · 27/02/2022 09:12

I don't think I could go along with this without saying something to this woman. I'm not sure of be particularly tactful either.

Spudlet · 27/02/2022 09:11

Omg, what makes some people like this? How can they think this is an ok way to behave? The mind boggles!

You have to put your foot down op - you must. You are talking about visiting your home town so you don’t live there anymore clearly - so you aren’t going to be stuck bumping into these people at the supermarket. So you can do this then walk away.

If the CF is inviting people many or indeed none of them may know the full circumstances - that she’s shamelessly hijacking you and your visit for her own ends. If you let them know many may be horrified. I would be! I would play dumb if people texted me to ask about arrangements (arrangements? I’m not organising anything, how strange!), organise with nice friend to go somewhere else, tell CF you’ve had a change of plan and you’ll catch up another time, so sorry, something came up… then leave her to deal with any fallout. And never actually organise that catch up with her, because bloody hell.

Newmumatlast · 27/02/2022 09:11

I should've said if it was me I would go with A. This person has no right to invite people without asking you and I would want to make my boundary clear on that without changing what was my original plan. I would even change the venue without telling her to ensure she doesnt just invade anyway especially if i knew i found it hard to stand up to people as you seem to suggest you do.

HomeHomeInTheRange · 27/02/2022 09:10

@Peachtoiletpaper

You don't sound pathetic, you sound kind and taken advantage of. It's hard to assert yourself in the face of extreme brazenness and avarice but it's what you need to do.

I wouldn't try and reframe the big gathering in any way, I.e. by saying you won't pay, or sending prices. I guarantee that CF will be telling people otherwise and sprinkling around the largesse on your behalf. Or people will sneak out, have forgotten their wallets, be a bit short etc etc.

I would just cancel the whole thing and revert to your original plans. At a different restaurant. Let your original friend know exactly what's happened and that's why you're doing so.

You could just tell CF this and let her sort out her mess, offer to meet her separately so she can't truthfully say you've let her down on her birthday or if you know who is meant to be coming, let the group know.

Don't worry about her SM outbursts, just mute.

You could say 'it appears another 15 people have heard they're invited to the lunch I'd originally planned for me and Sue. I'm not looking to host something big this time and was looking forward to a quiet catch up so I'm not sure how this has happened. Obviously I wouldn't be paying for this. I've decided to go back to seeing Sue and kids separately. If you'd like to meet for cake and coffee that weekend, do let me know'.

Be quite cool about this, not placatory. Her behaviour isn't normal.

This is a good approach.
maddening · 27/02/2022 09:10

And also, that the restaurant can not accommodate the increased number of people so could she find an alternate venue as she is local it would be easier for her to do.

Newmumatlast · 27/02/2022 09:09

@Mogs43

I am going to visit my home town soon. I had arranged to meet up with a family member and her children- had offered to pay for a meal (she's been very kind since my lovely father died). Another family member got in touch to say she had heard I was coming and having a meal - could she and her children come? It would be nice for them all to catch up etc I agreed. She then said it was her birthday that week but she would rather come to the meal than arrange something else. I said okay and didn't think anything of it.

She has just texted to say she has invited other family and friends (15 so far!!). I have also received text messages from others (not included in the 15) saying they hear I am around and organising a meal etc..So it could be more!

I have in the past couple of years organised meals etc to mark my fathers death/key anniversaries. I have been happy to pay for them as a sort of memorial to him -it has mostly been really nice to see everyone. However, for the last two events I found that the individual whose birthday it is has 'hijacked' the meal, hardly spoke to me and didn't acknowledge that I paid (I wouldn't normally expect any kind of acknowledgment at all but on the last occasion she physically froze me out and left me sitting at the children's table- I felt completely pathetic : fortunately another family member saw what was happening and insisted that the woman's child move to the children's table so I could sit with the adults). Throughout the meal she hardly spoke to me and at the end said all those with children were going somewhere else for ice cream etc. She left without even asking about the bill and nor did she even once acknowledge that the meal was in memory of my father. I haven't heard from her since - just the recent texts. To be honest. she has hardly been there since my father died. She appears to have money- drives a 4x4, regular plastic surgery, hair and nails - so I dont think she is broke :its just how she operates.

I had just wanted to concentrate on those who have been kind to me but its hard to invite some family and not others? Is that unfair?

I could possibly stretch to paying (although money is very tight) and it would be lovely to see (some of) them but I do resent how this has been done. I feel like a mug. The restaurant that I had originally booked can't accommodate such a large group and to be honest I don't fancy spending hours of my time looking for an alternative venue. I did ask her how one of the people she had invited (who had only just phoned asking to lend money) would be able to afford it. She responded that one extra wouldn't make much difference - that the restaurant would probably offer me a deal for such a large group. She clearly expects me to pay.

The individual is a drama queen who falls out with lots of people and I don't want to create a fuss (everything goes on social media and I couldn't bare all the ' let down on my birthday and I'm a single mum etc'). I would also not like to inconvenience the other family members (especially those I had initially invited). I value their friendship and would like to see them . I could do with the company as, to be honest, since my father died I often feel isolated and lonely.

How can I change this situation: should I say I cant go (but then would I have to cancel my whole weekend) or should I just suck it up? What would you do? Thank you- and sorry if I sound a bit pathetic. I am aware of this.

I would either

A. Say you shouldn't have invited people without asking me. This was originally just going to be a meal with X person and a small affair. I agreed to just you as extra but you have without my consent changed it so apologies but I am just going for a meal with X person and you can do your own thing.

B. Say you shouldn't have invited people without my consent but now that you have that's fine. However, to be clear, this is not an invitation from me where I am paying for everyone. Everyone will need to pay for themselves. Please can you make them aware. I will repeat that at the start of the meal/text everyone too. I have only agreed to pay for X person as a gift which is why the meal was originally just with her.

MissMaple82 · 27/02/2022 09:09

You need to grow a back bone and say no put her in her place!

Peachtoiletpaper · 27/02/2022 09:08

You don't sound pathetic, you sound kind and taken advantage of. It's hard to assert yourself in the face of extreme brazenness and avarice but it's what you need to do.

I wouldn't try and reframe the big gathering in any way, I.e. by saying you won't pay, or sending prices. I guarantee that CF will be telling people otherwise and sprinkling around the largesse on your behalf. Or people will sneak out, have forgotten their wallets, be a bit short etc etc.

I would just cancel the whole thing and revert to your original plans. At a different restaurant. Let your original friend know exactly what's happened and that's why you're doing so.

You could just tell CF this and let her sort out her mess, offer to meet her separately so she can't truthfully say you've let her down on her birthday or if you know who is meant to be coming, let the group know.

Don't worry about her SM outbursts, just mute.

You could say 'it appears another 15 people have heard they're invited to the lunch I'd originally planned for me and Sue. I'm not looking to host something big this time and was looking forward to a quiet catch up so I'm not sure how this has happened. Obviously I wouldn't be paying for this. I've decided to go back to seeing Sue and kids separately. If you'd like to meet for cake and coffee that weekend, do let me know'.

Be quite cool about this, not placatory. Her behaviour isn't normal.

Dottychickens · 27/02/2022 09:07

Unfortunately there is no tactful way to handle these sorts of people.

You could cancel all plans then just phone the original family and organise a ‘secret’ meet-up.

But personally, after tears if also being the one who got used by family members, I’ve learned the only way I’d to say no.

Don’t worry about social media, when she posts her critic messages about you, other will just roll their eyes and think here she goes again!

Please don’t pay, this will happen again and again and again if you don’t put your foot down.

Drama queens tend to just be bullys.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 27/02/2022 09:07

This is not the time for tact, OP! May be hard, I know, when you’re not that kind of person, but it’s time to be blunt.

I am honestly in awe (not in a nice way!) of the utterly brazen cheeky-fuckery some people are capable of.

3luckystars · 27/02/2022 09:06

Actually I have just had a better idea.
Cancel it all. Say something came up. Visit the nice friend at their home instead.

Buy the nice friend a voucher for the restaurant. Tell them when they book a meal to let you know and you will try to come along too (as their guest), but never as long as you live book a restaurant again in that town because it is full of grabbers.

maddening · 27/02/2022 09:06

I would email and say just to confirm that everyone will need to pay for their own food and drinks.

washingmachines4 · 27/02/2022 09:06

Hey OP,
This is a horrible situation, I can totally see myself getting stuck with this kind of thing because I hate conflict and try not to rock the boat.
Here is what I would do:
Cancel your trip, tell your lovely friend that you are really sorry but would she mind terribly if you moved the date and took her out for dinner on x date instead?
Tell the all self important birthday girl that you are really sorry but you have had to cancel your trip, you are really sorry not to see her over her birthday, you wish her a really happy time and lovely meal with her friends.
She can't be expecting you to pay if you are not there.

Gizacluethen · 27/02/2022 09:05

We actually have a lovely generous person like you in the family and a CF of the highest order. He's actually fallen out with us because I call him out on his bullshit too much so doesn't come to anything we're at unless someone is paying, he just can't resist a free meal. He actually invited his FRIENDS to her birthday meal. I've coached her well though and she told him no!
He left her last party with two plates of food (on top of what he'd eaten) and EIGHT slices of cake!

flashpaper · 27/02/2022 09:02

@DifficultBloodyWoman

WTF???
  1. Contact EVERYONE with a group email/text/WhatsApp.

Dear all,
First, I want to say that I’m so looking forward to seeing everyone soon and catching up with you.

However, I understand that lots of people have been told I am hosting a dinner at /restaurant name/ on /date/for /x number of people/. That is not the case!

I’m not sure quite how that happened but, unfortunately, I already have plans then and /the restaurant name,/ wouldn’t be able to accommodate so many people at that time anyway.

That said, I really do want to see everyone so please can we make other arrangements? I’m not planning a big party because I really want to spend quality time with you to catch up and I’ve found that just doesn’t happen with a million people around.

Lots of love - Mogs

  1. Then contact your original invitees and tell them it is still on.
  1. Then (optional) contact Cheeky Fucker Birthday Girl and say you’ve no idea how a meal out with her snowballed to you paying for x number of people at a restaurant so you’ve had to email everyone to put a stop to it. Good grief - can she imagine the bill?!? But you’d love to celebrate her birthday with her so she should let you know when and where her party is so you can give her a birthday card.
  1. Have a laugh with everyone about it and point out how ridiculous it is to expect you to foot the enormous bill for a catch up with so many people when you only get to spend. 3 minutes talking with each person. You’d much rather have a cup of tea (at someone’s home ) and a ‘proper chat’.

I suspect that there is more than one cheeky fucker in the group and they will be suitably ashamed of taking advantage of your hospitality in the past. If they grumble about it, they clearly prefer your credit cards to your company.

Completely agree with this. It wouldn't surprise me if a bunch of people you didn't know turned up to celebrate CFs birthday, after being told the meal was "on her".
Howshouldibehave · 27/02/2022 09:01

@HAF1119

I would be the opposite of tactful

Great that it is now your birthday celebration! Can you let me know if I need to pay for my portion just so I can be prepared, not a problem but just some pay for their birthdays others we all split the bill!

Let her act on that

Grin
HAF1119 · 27/02/2022 08:59

I would be the opposite of tactful

Great that it is now your birthday celebration! Can you let me know if I need to pay for my portion just so I can be prepared, not a problem but just some pay for their birthdays others we all split the bill!

Let her act on that

BorsetshireBanality · 27/02/2022 08:58

Also family member 1 told CF that you were funding a meal and CF thought “I’ll have some of that”

If you want to go ahead with first family only, you need to tell them not to tell CF about new meal plans.

You know you will be made out to be the bad person depriving CF et al of a free birthday shindig.
M good luck!

RedRobin100 · 27/02/2022 08:57

You NEED to stand up for yourself here OP.

Cancel the whole thing and go back to the original plan with your chosen friend - and don’t let anyone else know.

Don’t be bullied into being a mug.

PurpleHollyhocks · 27/02/2022 08:57

Cancel the whole thing, you will end up paying by the end of the night

Tillymintpolo · 27/02/2022 08:56

Say ‘sorry can’t come now, hope you have a nice meal’ then go somewhere else with the original person

Howshouldibehave · 27/02/2022 08:55

Insanity: doing the same thing over agitated and expecting different results.

What’s your plan, @Mogs43?

Yeahbutnotreally · 27/02/2022 08:55

I’d just Cancel & go and see the original family then order a takeaway/take picnic food.