Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I tactfully handle this situation?

411 replies

Mogs43 · 27/02/2022 00:05

I am going to visit my home town soon. I had arranged to meet up with a family member and her children- had offered to pay for a meal (she's been very kind since my lovely father died). Another family member got in touch to say she had heard I was coming and having a meal - could she and her children come? It would be nice for them all to catch up etc I agreed. She then said it was her birthday that week but she would rather come to the meal than arrange something else. I said okay and didn't think anything of it.

She has just texted to say she has invited other family and friends (15 so far!!). I have also received text messages from others (not included in the 15) saying they hear I am around and organising a meal etc..So it could be more!

I have in the past couple of years organised meals etc to mark my fathers death/key anniversaries. I have been happy to pay for them as a sort of memorial to him -it has mostly been really nice to see everyone. However, for the last two events I found that the individual whose birthday it is has 'hijacked' the meal, hardly spoke to me and didn't acknowledge that I paid (I wouldn't normally expect any kind of acknowledgment at all but on the last occasion she physically froze me out and left me sitting at the children's table- I felt completely pathetic : fortunately another family member saw what was happening and insisted that the woman's child move to the children's table so I could sit with the adults). Throughout the meal she hardly spoke to me and at the end said all those with children were going somewhere else for ice cream etc. She left without even asking about the bill and nor did she even once acknowledge that the meal was in memory of my father. I haven't heard from her since - just the recent texts. To be honest. she has hardly been there since my father died. She appears to have money- drives a 4x4, regular plastic surgery, hair and nails - so I dont think she is broke :its just how she operates.

I had just wanted to concentrate on those who have been kind to me but its hard to invite some family and not others? Is that unfair?

I could possibly stretch to paying (although money is very tight) and it would be lovely to see (some of) them but I do resent how this has been done. I feel like a mug. The restaurant that I had originally booked can't accommodate such a large group and to be honest I don't fancy spending hours of my time looking for an alternative venue. I did ask her how one of the people she had invited (who had only just phoned asking to lend money) would be able to afford it. She responded that one extra wouldn't make much difference - that the restaurant would probably offer me a deal for such a large group. She clearly expects me to pay.

The individual is a drama queen who falls out with lots of people and I don't want to create a fuss (everything goes on social media and I couldn't bare all the ' let down on my birthday and I'm a single mum etc'). I would also not like to inconvenience the other family members (especially those I had initially invited). I value their friendship and would like to see them . I could do with the company as, to be honest, since my father died I often feel isolated and lonely.

How can I change this situation: should I say I cant go (but then would I have to cancel my whole weekend) or should I just suck it up? What would you do? Thank you- and sorry if I sound a bit pathetic. I am aware of this.

OP posts:
WetLookKnitwear · 27/02/2022 10:11

Can you be honest with the first family member? Call them - don’t text, it can be misconstrued. Say look, I want to meet up with close family but I can’t afford to pay for a meal for everyone who wants to come!

You don’t sound pathetic, it’s just an awkward situation which isn’t your fault.

Flickflak · 27/02/2022 10:11

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

WTF475878237NC · 27/02/2022 10:11

You reply "what do you mean the restaurant will do me a deal? I'm not going to be paying for everyone"

^ this.

ThanksItHasPockets · 27/02/2022 10:10

Cancel the trip.

Rearrange for another date.

Don’t tell this person and have as little do with her as you possibly can in the future.

Whatsonmymindgrapes · 27/02/2022 10:09

Don’t pay for them all. That’s not fair

PinchOfVom · 27/02/2022 10:06

Rearrange it on the quiet

Then cancel your attendance

Nordicwannabe · 27/02/2022 10:06

Forcing them to pay is much harder than just cancelling

Given what has happened the last few times, you need to be realistic about your own ability to say no. If you ask everyone to pay for themselves - or try to reduce the numbers - they'll ignore you and you'll end up paying anyway.

It's not fair, but I think you need to reschedule your weekend.

Cancel the restaurant booking (changing it to your relatives name is ambiguous, and she'll probably go ahead and send you the bill, which you'll feel guilted into paying)

And you do need to send a message to everyone saying that you hadn't arranged a family get-together - not sure how that was miscommunicated! You've unfortunately had to cancel your visit that weekend anyway. Hope to see them next time you're there.

If you're feeling evil, you can add that you think DRelative is organising a birthday get-together so maybe they'll all see each other anyway. Let her see what it feels like to be set up! But I suspect you're too nice to do that, so you can just imagine doing it Halo

Then next time you're there, arrange to see people at their homes. Bring a few nice treats, and enjoy each other's company Smile

Continue that until the expectation that you'll pay for big meals out (wtf!?!) has gone.

zingally · 27/02/2022 10:04

Just cancel it, and catch up with the original family privately, or some other time. Sounds like you've got some cf'ers in your family/extended circle.

But... Playing devils advocate here... How many memorial events/dinner do you REALLY need for your deceased father? Your post made me think you weren't in the UK, so perhaps it's culturally different there?
It sounds like he's been deceased a number of years, so actually I'm not surprised extended family are "hi-jacking" the event for other celebrations, such as birthdays.

In the UK, the events after a death consist of a funeral and wake, and MAYBE a celebration of life/small gathering of immediate family, a year after the event. Multiple events, multiple years after the persons death seems... a lot.

RealBecca · 27/02/2022 10:03

I'd tell her there's clearly been a misunderstanding and the one to one meal you had booked with a friend doesnt work with the birthday extravaganza and the restaurant cant accommodate that many so it's better to seperate the two- she can keep the restaurant and tour and friend will rebook elsewhere and hopefully you can meet up with her another time. Tell her you're cancelling the booking tonight but you can pass on her details if she wants to keep it. Oh- and that you never offered to pay for extended family so she will need to pay full costs inc deposit with restaurant.

HeadingForHome · 27/02/2022 10:02

What have I read??! I can't believe cheeky fuckers like this roam the earth. Be direct with the OP, no tactful about it. They won't take any subtle hints so you have to be completely honest.

Angelswithflirtyfaces · 27/02/2022 09:59

Blimey if you organise any meal for these freeloaders I bet you on the day even with advance warning that you are not paying, they will 'forget their purses' or thought it was a misunderstanding etc.
Easier to not organise at all as I bet you end up lending it to most of them who never pay it back causing more ill feeling. Just keep to original family member.

brainhurts · 27/02/2022 09:59

I second a what's app " hi all , so pleased you all want to catch up , it's X amount a head plus your drinks . I think it's easier for everyone to pay the venue direct rather than forward me there share "
They will all drop out .
Also a separate message to your original guest that you will pay there bill but as it's snowballed your not in a able to pay for everyone.

Lifeismeh · 27/02/2022 09:56

You don’t use tact.
You’re brutal and honest… apologise that it’s not the event she thought it was but you were planning a catch up with X friend. Anyone else coming should pay there way.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 27/02/2022 09:55

More mature course of action would probably be to message CF and say 'CF, why are loads of people contacting me about a meal out? I'm not organising a big thing for your birthday?! I'm happy to come to something you organise (if you are, I wouldn't be!) but I'm not organising it, and I'm certainly not paying for everyone. Please let me know what's going on.'

TenRedThings · 27/02/2022 09:53

I think you have to be blunt. ' you seem to have confused your birthday celebrations with a small lunch I was organizing. I am not in a position to pay for or organise your party but it would be lovely to see you, perhaps I could drop by for a cuppa.´

ivykaty44 · 27/02/2022 09:53

I’d set up a whatsapp group for everyone

Call it family meal

Then put this message…

Hi everyone I thought it would be easier to have a group chat to organise family meal

I can book restaurant and put down a deposit for meal. So can all those that want to attend send deposit if £15 per adult and £7.50per child by 7th March. Then I’ll book table with numbers. If I’ve not heard from you by 7th I’ll understand you’re not able to join us on this occasion and hopefully see you another time. Message me separately for bank details for money transfer.
Looking forward to seeing so many of you kiss kiss

This makes it clear you’re not paying
Those that want to see you will contact and pay deposit

Contact your original family that you invited for meal and explain you’re paying their deposit and meal

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 27/02/2022 09:52

Bugger that!!

'hi CF, so sorry, plans have changed and I'm not able to meet you for lunch when I come to x, we'll have to meet for a coffee next time I'm in town.'

'hi, original family, meeting you for a meal seems to have morphed into a party for x with me footing the bill. I shan't be going, but would love to meet just you and the kids at alternative restaurant - does that sound OK to you? Really looking forward to seeing you, hope you can make it.'

Depending on how much anarchy you want to cause, you could send the message to the person you actually want to meet first, swear them to secrecy, and cancel on CF last minute so she doesn't have time to cancel and has to pay for HER guests herself!!

Hiphopboppertybop99 · 27/02/2022 09:51

Also how did CF person know you were visiting? Did your family member mention it? - would they be likely to do this again? With the situation escalating again ?

Rockdown2020 · 27/02/2022 09:50

OP, this is terrible. I’m sorry you are in this position at a vulnerable time in your life.

I’d honestly have no time for any of these people including the original family member you agreed to treat to lunch. What exactly was the purpose of them telling other people you were treating them. Having already paid their way multiple times I’d be really embarrassed to accept another meal on you no matter how kind I had been, I mean isn’t that normal whilst someone is bereaved?

Maybe save the time and money on these complete CFs and treat yourself to something nice. It’ll likely still be less than paying for upwards of 20 people (likely more) to eat and drink on your credit cards. I’m genuinely shocked.

You are worth far more than this treatment. If I was feeling really mean I’d cancel due to a stomach bug half an hour before....

SpiderVersed · 27/02/2022 09:49

that the restaurant would probably offer me a deal for such a large group

“Good Lord, CF, I’m not paying for the meal. Whatever gave you that idea?”

Job done.

Tillymintpolo · 27/02/2022 09:47

@Caoimhe17

I have recently split with my partner. Long story short is we moved to Devon to live with his family from Ipswich. We have a 3 year old together and I gave up my whole live in Ipswich to go there. I have been studying at weekends so not been there for the last 8 months at weekends, so I know I've been absent. This is all being held against me. He and his family (who are very controlling and overbearing) don't want me to take my daughter with me. I know she is settled and happy there. I am heartbroken as I want to do what's right for her. I brought up my other daughter on my own but circumstances were different. I know I currently don't have much. Any advice would be appreciated, please no hate as I'm fragile enough as it is
You need to start your own thread
Caoimhe17 · 27/02/2022 09:46

I have recently split with my partner. Long story short is we moved to Devon to live with his family from Ipswich. We have a 3 year old together and I gave up my whole live in Ipswich to go there.
I have been studying at weekends so not been there for the last 8 months at weekends, so I know I've been absent. This is all being held against me. He and his family (who are very controlling and overbearing) don't want me to take my daughter with me. I know she is settled and happy there. I am heartbroken as I want to do what's right for her. I brought up my other daughter on my own but circumstances were different. I know I currently don't have much. Any advice would be appreciated, please no hate as I'm fragile enough as it is

Rainartist · 27/02/2022 09:46

On the other hand I do like the response that said let them all get there expecting a freebie and you just ring to say you have covid and can't make it at the last minute so they have to pay! Grin

MyPretttyRedDress · 27/02/2022 09:43

Oh my word. Birthday girl clearly has the rind of a rhino! It sounds like, not for the first time, you have been bamboozled into doing something you don't want to do.
But here's the good news. You absolutely do not need to do it again.
If you just want to have lunch with your one good friend then that's what you should do. Cancel the other 'friend'. You don't have to explain yourself - just repeat that it no longer works for you. I would not send a message to anyone else as you did not invite them.

Change the venue and enjoy the lunch as you wanted to. I promise you will find it liberating. It might be a bit scary if you are not used to being assertive but the thrill of not being pushed around will be worth it.

Rainartist · 27/02/2022 09:42

You need to be blunt with people like this. State you will not be paying for anyone, so there is no doubt. I'm sure the cheeky fuckers will drop out if they were expecting a freebie! Just send a friendly text saying great to see everyone but you're only paying for yourself.

Arrange a small meal for the friend you want to treat but say explicitly it's just you and them, don't invite xyz.