Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think if you've booked a seat you get a seat?

180 replies

monroeagogo · 26/02/2022 17:13

Went to the cinema today. Standard Vue. Get there in plenty of time and someone's in our seats.

Politely did the 'oops you're in our seats' chat after furiously checking I was right beforehand. Lots of huffing and puffing from them and rolling eyes and they moved to, admittedly, worse seats further down.

But WTAF.

Surely if you've book a seat in the cinema, on a plane or train, then that's your seat.

Confused
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MsWalterMitty · 04/03/2022 18:51

[quote OnTheBoardwalk]**@Lampyshady* and @MsWalterMitty* I really don’t understand the logic in your posts. Why sit in someone’s reserved seats but then point out there are other unreserved sits they could sit in.

@MsWalterMitty why on earth wouldn’t you sit in a seat you'd reserved?[/quote]
Because I’li reserve so I don’t end up standing. If it’s Full I’ll find my seat, if not I’ll sit anywhere

Ormally · 27/02/2022 23:58

@monroeagogo

Evan you buy a seat for under 5s? I'd hate to travel with a standing child.

Maybe trains need a standing only carriage and everywhere else is seated only, no standing allowed

Nope...I see at least 1 commuter train every few months that has every carriage as full to both seating AND standing room - line of people as if in a queue down the aisle between the seats, when enough services are late or cancelled around it. It looks unsafe whether you are 4 or 34. In cases where I've bee on these, I prefer standing, as sitting down is usually incredibly hot when your face is not catching the air flow higher up.
Urbanisation · 27/02/2022 23:30

Or maybe they could just let people sit in first class if the train is full. Or do away with first class altogether. Christ knows where any meaningful distinction comes in when a so called standard class ticket that doesn't even allow for a frigging seat can cost as much as a hundred and fifty fucking pounds one way.

Really, when it comes to public transport in the UK the problem isn't other passengers, mostly. It's the fact that it's shit, overpriced and staffed by people willing to shaft you even further if they can find some nonsense rule to back themselves up in doing so.

I bet that for most of the people on this thread who have encountered seating problems on trains they were on trains with plenty of empty seats. Just not ones that they could personally sit in.

monroeagogo · 27/02/2022 22:37

Evan you buy a seat for under 5s? I'd hate to travel with a standing child.

Maybe trains need a standing only carriage and everywhere else is seated only, no standing allowed

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 27/02/2022 22:14

@StoneofDestiny

As a guard, I threaten to charge a Child fare for any bags occupying a seat if the train is busy

Thank you - I wish all guards would do that!

It seldom actually comes to that when I intervene. "Can you please remove your bag from the seats so that people can sit down?" said so that everyone can hear shames them.

Trouble is that if the train is busy, the odds on us being able to get through are much reduced. So the threat is most commonly sent down the PA system than face-to-face.

The other thing I have to do is free up the wheelchair spaces for people who actually need them. I'm afraid that a parent with a pushchair gets far more entitled than the hypothetical businessman on his laptop earlier in the thread. "But, but, but..." gets the response of "please fold it down quickly, the train is waiting". I'm stubborn and won't move until I've got the wheelchair in.

For that matter, if you do have an under five then as they go free they aren't entitled to a seat. By all means they can use them if the train is quiet, but if paying passengers are standing then U5s need to either be sat on laps, or be in possession of a ticket.

JudgeJ · 27/02/2022 22:07

@RedRageRestful

We once had a man and young son come up to us , while watching a film in the cinema , and say quite politely, that we were in his seats, he looked at his tickets and our seat numbers, we didn’t actually see his tickets. The film wasn’t full and there was plenty of space.

I checked our tickets and seat numbers, they were correct, and there was four of us, the kids happily munching and sipping on their drinks

I did say to him, that the film had already been on for over an hour at the time, and that he had come in over half way through.

Anyway he went away, and came back again, with a member of staff this time, who looked at our tickets, disrupting us again, and he explained to the man, that he was in the wrong and too early, his film started at least another hour, after the one we were watching now.

You think he would have realised when he entered the dark cinema, and I told him, we had been watching the film for at least an hour already.

Plonker.

We once went to the opening day of a new Harry Potter film, we were sitting at the end of a row, the cinema was pretty full. Just before the programme started a woman breezed in like the Pied Piper, half a dozen or so children trailing behind her and she started to telling people to move seats so she could sit with all these children and some fools complied but they couldn't all got on one row. She then started at us, across the aisle, we should move into the free seats further along the row, surely we realised how important it was that her party sat close to her! She was furious when we refused and pointed out that if it was so important she should have got there earlier!
Changechangychange · 27/02/2022 18:32

@WalkingOnTheCracks we had that happen on a Westjet flight once too. We had paid for seats together, but our actual flight had been cancelled and we’d been rebooked into separate seats on a later flight. I have no issue with being separated from DH, but DS had just turned 2 and was allocated in the seat behind me, which apparently counts as an adjacent seat for the purposes of aerospace regulations, but obviously doesn’t from the perspective of a two year old who can’t see his mum or dad. Somebody did eventually swap, but it was clear the whole plane thought we were CFs.

StoneofDestiny · 27/02/2022 17:43

As a guard, I threaten to charge a Child fare for any bags occupying a seat if the train is busy

Thank you - I wish all guards would do that!

StoneofDestiny · 27/02/2022 17:41

It can make a lot of difference ... the train may not be busy from the start, but people will continue getting on on subsequent stops, thus filling up the train. Someone may well eventually get on and demand you remove yourself from their booked seat.

Just sit in your booked seat!

Exactly - booking seats is an easy process - just sit down in your booked seat and let others have theirs. Don't book, take your chances.
When I get on a train I hope it goes on time and no sod is sitting on my booked seat - if they are I'll politely ask them to move.

StoneofDestiny · 27/02/2022 17:37

Arsewangry
Was I being an arsehole on the train once, six months pregnant - very busy service back from Euston to bham new st. I'd booked a seat and paid a lot for the privilege but due to rail carnage the reservations were cancelled - I asked a guy to move from the seat I had booked because I was cold, wet, tired and in need of a seat. It all kicked off. I just wanted the seat I had paid for

Yes, a giant arse.
Reservations had been cancelled so you had no more right to the seat that anybody else, who probably had their reservations cancelled too. Pregnancy doesn't give you privilege over reservations!
Geezo - what an attitude

affairsofdragons · 27/02/2022 17:28

I find this odd. I book seats on trains just incase they’re busy. But if they’re not busy then I sit anywhere. Yes, he shouldn’t have sat there, but what difference would it have made if you had sat somewhere else?

It can make a lot of difference ... the train may not be busy from the start, but people will continue getting on on subsequent stops, thus filling up the train. Someone may well eventually get on and demand you remove yourself from their booked seat.

Just sit in your booked seat!

Gardeningcreature · 27/02/2022 17:06

I would much prefer the old system with seat allocation on planes. Seats allocated in order, no picking and choosing, on a first come first served basis. So first in the queue gets wear 1A next person 1B and so on.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 27/02/2022 15:44

@DinnoWoman

Tbf it's only an issue on planes because of airline companies' hawkish policies. I am old enough to remember when seats didn't cost extra and there were none of these problems.
My brother and I were separated from my parents on a flight when we were 9&10, 25 years ago. It was sorted on the plane but even in the olden days the last few groups checked in could be separated)
Aroundtheworldin80moves · 27/02/2022 15:42

I have a bit of sympathy on planes... airlines say families don't need to book as they will becsat with their children... its the airlines wanting to get money from adults and then fulfill their safety obligation. They also don't make it clear that together means across an aisle or behind or in front.
(I always used to book seats when travelling one with the children as I didn't want the stress!)

DinnoWoman · 27/02/2022 15:40

Tbf it's only an issue on planes because of airline companies' hawkish policies. I am old enough to remember when seats didn't cost extra and there were none of these problems.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 27/02/2022 15:33

@Bellex

The worst one is on planes!

When you pay extra to sit together and in a certain aisle and then someone with kids gets on last and expects the whole plane to move so they can all sit together.

Last time I went on holiday I’d pay extra to sit with my boyfriend. A couple got on the plane last minute with their baby. She was next to us and he was at the back of the plane and he expected me to move to his seat and kicked up a whole fuss when I politely refused. The person at the back also wouldn’t swap as they were the last people on the plane and created a nightmare situation for the overhead cabins. A guy in the row behind offered to swap so they’d at least be near each other but they refused

I'm totally with the OP on this one. And also as it applies to planes.

There was one time, though, when I did suggest to someone that perhaps they might want to move from a seat that they were completely entitled to.

I was travelling with my younger daughter, who was about eighteen months. We'd been given separate seats - so, she was in A3 and I was in D5 or something. I said to the lady in A2, "I'm really sorry, but would you swap seats with me, so I can be next to the kid?"

She said she wouldn't, as she had specifically booked A2 for the legroom.

I said, "Totally get it. I'm 6'4, and I would have booked it too, if it had been available. So, absolutely fine. Here's her bottle. She'll need that in a couple of hours. Her sleeping patterns are all messed up, so she'll probably be awake halfway across the Atlantic, but she's very keen on The Hungry Caterpillar and Mog, both of which are in the bag. Wake me up if she throws up - she does that sometimes on planes. And thank you so much... I could really do with some kip."

Unfortunately this brilliant scheme didn't work, as the bloke in D4 saw what the issue was and offered to swap with my daughter. Interfering busybody.

DdraigGoch · 27/02/2022 15:04

@SpikeySmooth

Was on Eurostar from Paris to London about 5 years ago. An American family got into a fight with the leader of a school group because the American family said they could sit wherever they damn well pleased. School group leader said he needed the seats so that all his charges were sat near each other and he was less likely to lose any if them. American Woman to,d all her folks to stay where they were. So school group leader fetched the guard/customer service person and the American family were turfed out. The absolute arrogance!
God knows why the American family even did that - Eurostar (like TGV/ICE services) is compulsory reservation, they'd have had seats booked somewhere in the train.
RavenclawsRoar · 27/02/2022 14:45

I'll add a nice story - we booked a flight with our then toddler. It was a budget airline and we couldn't book ds a seat, kids his age had to sit on parents' laps. We booked our seats so we'd have a window and middle seat (standard 3 seats, aisle, 3 seats formation). Board the plane and it turns out every alternate row doesn't have a window, just a grey expanse of wall. This was not clear on the diagram when we'd booked and we were pretty annoyed but what can you do. A couple in front of us turned round and offered to swap so ds could see out the window which was lovely of them (and we bought them a drink and a chocolate each when the tea trolley came down to say thanks). By a stroke of luck, the aisle seat hadn't been booked on their row so we actually ended up with an extra seat for ds anyway. It was lovely of them!

SpikeySmooth · 27/02/2022 14:42

Was on Eurostar from Paris to London about 5 years ago. An American family got into a fight with the leader of a school group because the American family said they could sit wherever they damn well pleased. School group leader said he needed the seats so that all his charges were sat near each other and he was less likely to lose any if them. American Woman to,d all her folks to stay where they were. So school group leader fetched the guard/customer service person and the American family were turfed out. The absolute arrogance!

Juno22 · 27/02/2022 14:35

Sorry, should say that was in first class. Just realised it might be different.

Juno22 · 27/02/2022 14:34

I've chosen seats on Avanti. It automatically allocated a seat but you can go in and change it.

JustLyra · 27/02/2022 13:46

@AutumnDays21

You can choose your own seat number unless it is the last of a particular fee band to be sold. You have an option to change seat as part of the booking process.

This is not available on most train routes - certainly not on Great Western and Transpennine and Cross Country. LNER only afaik.

And LNER once told me that booking a seat doesn't stop someone else sitting in that seat. But they will refund the price of your ticket if they can't find you another seat.

It’s not available on Avanti either

I’ve never been able to pick a seat on the train. At most you can go back and search again so it allocates again in the hope of getting better seats.

AutumnDays21 · 27/02/2022 13:40

You can choose your own seat number unless it is the last of a particular fee band to be sold. You have an option to change seat as part of the booking process.

This is not available on most train routes - certainly not on Great Western and Transpennine and Cross Country. LNER only afaik.

And LNER once told me that booking a seat doesn't stop someone else sitting in that seat. But they will refund the price of your ticket if they can't find you another seat.

beautifullymad · 27/02/2022 13:36

This happened to me and children. They were so embarrassed that I asked people to move.
But as I explained to the children, the cinema was fully booked so everyone needed to be in the right seats.

The people in our seats grumbled that they couldn't see in their booked seats and reluctantly moved.

The people who had sat in their seats also needed to move and three sets of people all standing up moving into their correct seats.

If you've booked them sit in your seat.

Zoom101 · 27/02/2022 13:27

@DdraigGoch it’s people’s sense of entitlement that really gets my goat! Unless you have paid for an extra seat, you don’t get to commandeer it for your personal belongings!