Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my brother is in an emotionally abusive relationship

60 replies

Mozt · 26/02/2022 17:12

Sorry, this is long but where possible I don’t want to drip feed. Have NC for this.

My brother has been married for over 10 years and has two young DC. His wife, my SIL has always been the more dominant one in their relationship.

Over this past couple of years, I (as well as my parents and siblings) have been getting increasingly concerned over how my brother is being treated by SIL. She is openly critical of him in front of us, calls him a wanker, useless, an arsehole etc for the smallest transgression - eg. forgetting to do some chore she’s asked him to do. She has also in the past called him a c**t in front of their children.

My brother does all the school runs, makes all the family meals, takes his two DC out at the weekend “to give mum some peace”, but this is never reciprocated. He also does all the homeworks, bathtimes, bedtimes and takes the kids to their activities and appointments. He is a great dad to his DC and even SIL begrudgingly admitted this to me once, but in such a way that implied she thought he was shit at everything else.

SIL is by far the main breadwinner in their house, in a very well-paid professional role. My brother’s job pays significantly less. My SIL will insist on multiple family holidays abroad every year and that half the cost of these must be met by my brother, though he can barely afford this as it also “his responsibility” to meet certain household bills such as fuel. I also learned recently that she won’t tell him how much she earns.

Meanwhile, my brother says he feels guilty for buying so much as a cup of coffee and can’t afford new clothes. He dreads his (second hand) car breaking down as he can’t afford to fix it, but SIL recently treated herself to a brand new car.

She also appears to resent him spending time with our parents or our other siblings, and often after he visits my mum and dad she will start a massive row with him when he returns home, then not speak to him for days, so he feels he has to ‘make it up’ to her eg. by cleaning all of the house or taking the kids out of her way.

The worst thing to witness though is the change in my brother’s personality over the past few years. He seems constantly stressed out, on edge, and just generally unhappy; he has developed a nervous tremor in his hands. He is not allowed to go out with the one or two friends he has, or spend any time on hobbies he’s had for years, saying “[SIL] doesn’t like it.” He says he “doesn’t dare ask her” if he can do any of these things in case of a negative reaction such as her not speaking to him for days. He actually seems frightened of her, tbh.

When anyone in our family tells him we’re worried about him, my brother will just blame himself for never doing/saying the right thing. He seems to constantly be walking on eggshells.

My brother is a sensitive, romantic sort who has always wanted to settle down and have a family, but it doesn’t seem like his wife even loves or values him. He is treated like a skivvy and a free babysitter; I find it awful to witness. My family and I fear he will have some sort of breakdown, or worse.

AIBU to think this is an emotionally abusive relationship and if so, how can I /our family help him?

OP posts:
Chocolatehamper · 26/02/2022 19:46

When your SIL has been verbally abusive to your DB in front of you, has anyone ever pulled her up on it? If so, how did she react?

Would pointing out her attitude be enough to show her what she's doing or do you think it would cause your DB more grief? Certainly not making any excuses for abuse, but does she have pressure at work that she can't control and so exerts that control at home instead?

How old are the children? They are the innocent victims in this and need to be protected.

Good on you for looking out for your DB, he needs your help and strength to stand up for himself and his children.

Cosmos123 · 26/02/2022 19:45

Or there and then

Cosmos123 · 26/02/2022 19:45

If someone called my brother these things in front of me I would address it THEN AND THERE.

MissMaple82 · 26/02/2022 19:37

I was in an abusive relationship and I constantly blamed myself, its classic behaviour. It also very nearly cost me my life. But nothing anybody says can make you leave them until you finally reach the point were you cannot take anymore. Just keep talking to him about it and supporting him and talk about the impact to the children.once I did finally leave my children needed therapy

whiteworldgettingwhiter · 26/02/2022 19:36

Oh your poor brother. Sounds like classic abuse. Can you talk to him? What do you do when his wife calls him names in public?? Do you just sit there or do you call her out on it?

Can you help him leave/get help?

MissMaple82 · 26/02/2022 19:34

Yes this is abuse. He probably won't want to admit to it. All you can do is educate him on it. Its also counted as neglect on the children - they should be protected from seeing and hearing harmful or violent things. Very very damaging to all. He needs to get out the relationship

Seemslikeagoodidea · 26/02/2022 19:32

So sad. There are so many tales on here of fathers who don't help with housework or childcare at all, but your brother sounds like he's doing the lion's share of everything, with nothing in return but contempt. You can offer your support and understanding, but he has to make his own choices. Perhaps show him this thread, so he can see what strangers can see so clearly, having the basic facts, with the benefit of emotional distance.

Unless you have left out a massive amount of mitigating circumstances, this seems like abuse to me.

Mozt · 26/02/2022 19:09

@ShaneTwane

Your poor brother. You absolutely have to be there for him no matter what. He might try and start fights or push you all away but right now is when he needs you the most. Is he afraid of losing his children to her if he tries to leave?
I think that's it exactly. Most of the time SIL seems content to have little to do with the children, but I've no doubt she would try to take them away from him completely out of spite - even though she has acknowledged herself in the past that he's a good dad.
OP posts:
Matildalamp · 26/02/2022 19:04

Yes it’s abuse, your poor brother. He’d be much better off without her, as would the children I’m sure.

ShaneTwane · 26/02/2022 18:29

Your poor brother. You absolutely have to be there for him no matter what. He might try and start fights or push you all away but right now is when he needs you the most. Is he afraid of losing his children to her if he tries to leave?

Onlyforcake · 26/02/2022 18:26

He will be better off without her, as would the kids.

Mozt · 26/02/2022 18:21

@nanbread

I'm surprised you have to ask tbh.

This is so obviously, unequivocally abusive.

Your poor brother.

I wonder if there is a freedom programme for men?

Well perhaps I could have worded it more as ‘AIBU to tell my brother I think he’s in an abusive relationship’.

He hasn’t asked me directly for advice but it feels like this can’t go on. I’m so worried about him.

OP posts:
Lalastepmum · 26/02/2022 18:20

Please get him to call a DA charity or the national helpline. They can give him advice. Depending where you are there are solicitors who give free advice too. He can speak to Menkind or men’s advice line
There are male refuges and some have space for children too. But he has to be ready.

I work in this field more than happy to help.

Terfydactyl · 26/02/2022 18:09

Wouldnt you just do the same as if it was a woman going through this?

Let him know you'll be there when he decides to leave, outright state that this is not normal, direct him to phone numbers and organisations that will be useful (without putting him in more danger at home) etc

nanbread · 26/02/2022 18:07

I'm surprised you have to ask tbh.

This is so obviously, unequivocally abusive.

Your poor brother.

I wonder if there is a freedom programme for men?

Mozt · 26/02/2022 18:07

[quote oviraptor21]He should be encouraged to contact one of the organisations listed here. Alternatively, you could contact them so you can give your brother the best help possible.
www.citizensadvice.org.uk/family/gender-violence/domestic-violence-and-abuse-getting-help/#h-organisations-for-men[/quote]
Thank you, that’s a really good idea.

OP posts:
Mozt · 26/02/2022 18:06

@Maggie178

If she's like that in front of you and your family she may be far worse in private
I think so too :(
OP posts:
Mozt · 26/02/2022 18:05

@wanttomarryamillionaire yes, I think this is part of the problem - when asked about it, he’ll deflect and blame himself rather than acknowledge how bad the situation is.

@oakleaffy I absolutely agree he needs to leave and wonder if it would be unreasonable to just tell him so, even if he never asks me what he should do.

@LibrariesGiveUsPower some of it I’ve witnessed, some he’s told other family members about, but he seems to be opening up more and more to family recently and I can’t help but feel things must be getting even worse.

I imagine he is worried that SIL will try to take full custody of the kids (even though she usually doesn’t bother that much with them) just to spite him, and that she might be successful since she is the one with the more financially stable position. But surely that’s not all that is examined in these matters?

@VainAbigail I haven’t posted about this before, no.

If

OP posts:
TellySavalashairbrush · 26/02/2022 18:05

I'd second getting in touch with the organisations the pp has mentioned. He may not be ready to do anything about his dreadful situation yet, but having a loving family member who knows how to support him when he is ready would be very useful.

Pumperthepumper · 26/02/2022 18:03

He could contact citizens’ advice but aside from that, my advice is to let him know you’re there for him when he’s ready to leave and support him practically.

oviraptor21 · 26/02/2022 18:01

He should be encouraged to contact one of the organisations listed here. Alternatively, you could contact them so you can give your brother the best help possible.
www.citizensadvice.org.uk/family/gender-violence/domestic-violence-and-abuse-getting-help/#h-organisations-for-men

bluejelly · 26/02/2022 18:01

So sorry she sounds awful and abusive.

drpet49 · 26/02/2022 17:59

** Imagine if you had switched their genders.
People would be saying “ He’s a controlling narcissistic bully”

That's what your SIL is being to your brother.

He needs to leave.**

^This

Maggie178 · 26/02/2022 17:58

If she's like that in front of you and your family she may be far worse in private

debwong · 26/02/2022 17:56

He sounds like that poor man in Motherland.

Please encourage him to think about leaving.

Swipe left for the next trending thread