Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a fair rule re interest badges in GGing?

68 replies

InterestBadgesForGG · 26/02/2022 12:50

DD is 6, and does Rainbows but I know this is the rule throughout girlguiding locally with the interest badges.

Each girl has the opportunity to do 1 interest badge per theme. They are not stopped from doing any of the other badges, but their subs only cover 1 badge. After that parents/the girl is expected to pay 50p per badge.

The only exception is if girls can’t complete any of the interest badges in one theme due to disability or SN, they’re allowed to choose 1 other interest badge instead for that theme.

I think that’s fair enough. We’re a very middle class area where most girls have 2 working parents. Most girls around here seem to do all the interest badges in 1 theme as that’s what the girl wants.

I’m a single parent and it’s never been an issue if I say “DD wants to do this but I can’t afford the 50p until next half term” they’ve still let DD do the badge and given it to her and I’ve just paid it on the next lot of subs. Occasionally we’ll get emails asking if we can donate to interest badges as some girls want to do extras in a theme – and I have sent 50p or £1 if I can afford it so I assume there are things in place for girls/families who want to do more but can’t afford to

I was talking to a friend about it and she’s a guides leader in another district/area. She thinks its not on and that’s what subs are for, for any badge a girl wants to do.

For context our Rainbows and Brownies meet in a school hall (they have a display board and a cupboard for supplies) so I assume they pay the school for allowing them the use of the space so that’s probably what most of the subs cover (it’s £25 for a 12 week term, slightly less for shorter terms and slightly more for longer terms but never goes above £30)

I explained this to friend but she still thinks it’s not on. I didn’t ask her how much the subs in her area are to compare but it does seem fair to me to let them do 1 per theme and then charge for extras.

So WIBU? Me or friend?

YABU – Friend is right
YANBU – You’re right

OP posts:
HollyandJingles · 26/02/2022 14:29

I've been a Brownie Leader for ten years and our subs have always been higher to cover things like badges and include the census. Like other leaders have said, I would be thrilled if my Brownies wanted to do badges at home! The odd one or two girls might do one, but as a rule none of them really want to bother. We don't expect girls to pay for their badges though and having had 3 daughters go through Rainbows, Brownies and Guides I have never been asked to pay for any badges either.

CatRatSplat · 26/02/2022 14:26

£2.50 a week, 1.25 to insurance / cenus fees, 75p to rent, leaves 50p to that week's activities. 50p contribution to a £1 -£2 badges is peanuts but would really help your unit out.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 26/02/2022 14:25

Its 50p. To the majority of people 50p is nothing. But 15x50p is £7.50 which can add up over time. I'm not sure how much the GG badges cost the unit, but in Scouts that doesn't cover the cost of the badge. (About 65p-£1 depending on badge.) I have submitted an £100+ badge order before (the post Covid one!)

Its great she wants to do more

InterestBadgesForGG · 26/02/2022 14:23

@Dixiechickonhols

I’m a guide leader and census and hall fees are our biggest costs. There aren’t an abundance of halls, we use a church hall and they charge even when we are not there. There’s no flexibility eg we cancelled as most girls had covid a few weeks ago (local schools were rife) and still had to pay full. We try to include day to day stuff in subs but extras like trips are paid or part paid eg we went to a pottery place think it was £6 each so we paid half out of subs they paid £3 cash. We are very mc area I’m sure a lot of parents would just pay £x a term and not have to find cash and deal with emails but we have to mindful it might not suit everyone and we find it fairer to do this way. They are doing an activity day tomorrow £15 cash on day. I do hope a parent would say if child would like to go but can’t pay.
@Dixiechickonhols All the subs emails we get say "If you want to keep your childs place but can't pay please get in touch". We've had a couple of paid trips that are the same.
OP posts:
BoredZelda · 26/02/2022 14:22

My daughter did a gazillion badges. We never had to pay extra for any of them.

Beamur · 26/02/2022 14:22

Your subs are very cheap. I guess the arrangement with the badges reflects that. Whilst interest badges are meant to be girl led, Rainbows/Brownies are likely to need parental help. It probably makes sense to communicate to parents the requirements for one badge for the term.
The Guide/Ranger unit I'm familiar with allows girls to do as many badges as they want. We have quite a few girls striving to do them all.
Regarding census payments that's included in subs but the unit is set up to claim quite a lot of gift aid. With the projected rises in this cost, if you don't claim GA i would urge units to look into it. Doesn't cost parents any more aiis not that onerous to claim either once it's set up.

Dixiechickonhols · 26/02/2022 14:21

I’m a guide leader and census and hall fees are our biggest costs. There aren’t an abundance of halls, we use a church hall and they charge even when we are not there. There’s no flexibility eg we cancelled as most girls had covid a few weeks ago (local schools were rife) and still had to pay full. We try to include day to day stuff in subs but extras like trips are paid or part paid eg we went to a pottery place think it was £6 each so we paid half out of subs they paid £3 cash.
We are very mc area I’m sure a lot of parents would just pay £x a term and not have to find cash and deal with emails but we have to mindful it might not suit everyone and we find it fairer to do this way. They are doing an activity day tomorrow £15 cash on day. I do hope a parent would say if child would like to go but can’t pay.

SockQueen · 26/02/2022 14:17

That's fab, it's great when they're really motivated to do them! Unfortunately my current group just don't seem to be - or they're so busy doing 15 other extra-curricular activities that they/their parents don't have time.

Cryingbutstilltrying · 26/02/2022 14:14

@sweeneytoddsrazor ours is covered by subs but only because 20 out of 24 girls I am able to claim gift aid too. It was £37.50 per head this time for us. I had a ‘no spend’ term this time other than badges and hall hire, using what we had already. I’ve found if I put a plea for things on our local village Facebook group I get all sorts of stuff. We will be having a stall at the village fete in the summer to fundraise as next year’s subscription will be brutal. I do know of some places who charge the subscription fee on top of meeting fees though.

Rover83 · 26/02/2022 14:12

Healthy mind is the other purple one she didn't like the sound of the fruit and veg one, she did a sensory safari, bedtime relaxation breathing every night for a week and then a weekend of no Tv or devices

InterestBadgesForGG · 26/02/2022 14:12

@Cryingbutstilltrying

Thinking through the Brownies badges, I think only Dancing would be a complete no for a child with a muscle condition. But there are 3 options in each theme in Brownies so lots to choose from there. She sounds like she got a lot from Rainbows so I wish her well for the future, in my opinion it’s an organisation that works really well for children who sometimes are excluded from other activities.
@Cryingbutstilltrying Thank you, Dancing will be a big no no for her but I've just had a look and for that theme it seems there will be at least 1 other option.

She gets so much out of Rainbows, she absolutely loves it and has gained so much confidence. She's not the most academic (partially due to her muscle condition affecting her fine motor skills) so finds school hard, being somewhere where it doesn't matter how good you are is really great for her.

OP posts:
sweeneytoddsrazor · 26/02/2022 14:09

Those of you who are Brownie/Guide leaders, does the subs include the annual capitation or do the girls pay separately for that.? This year at £42 per girl, that takes up a very large chunk of their subs. We charge £2.50 a week, which just about covers rent with a small amount left over towards their capitation. Most resources are funded by myself and the other leader, unless we manage to get any donations or grants.

InterestBadgesForGG · 26/02/2022 14:08

@Rover83

I must confess I think particularly with rainbows it does involve a lot of parental input for the interest badges. One of DDs friends has just left as the mum didn't want to do the interest badges but her DD was getting upset when the others were getting badges. My DD has worked really hard at her healthy mind badge but I have no idea how to help her 'present' what she's done when it mainly involved being outside and off devices.
@Rover83 Is that for Fruit and Veg? Our leaders let the girls go in and say a poem or sing for the final part, school also said DD could do that bit there and they'd email the leaders and say she'd done it.

I just recorded DD doing hers to my DNs (with my brothers permission) and that was accepted.

OP posts:
Kitkat151 · 26/02/2022 14:05

@coffeecup88

Hi, I'm a rainbow and brownie leader. Our subs is 10/month and all badges are included in that.

I have to say you're getting a real bargain at £25/term and I can understand why they've got this policy in place of trying to keep subs that low.

You are right, rent is probably the biggest cost, our village school charges £15/h for rental so that really add up especially if you are running a small-medium sized unit.

Hth
X

It’s £25 a term here too ( NW ) ....that said my GD who’s 6 and 3 months has never done a single interest badge.....don’t think they do them .....she loves it though...they do lots of fun stuff
Rover83 · 26/02/2022 14:04

I must confess I think particularly with rainbows it does involve a lot of parental input for the interest badges. One of DDs friends has just left as the mum didn't want to do the interest badges but her DD was getting upset when the others were getting badges. My DD has worked really hard at her healthy mind badge but I have no idea how to help her 'present' what she's done when it mainly involved being outside and off devices.

InterestBadgesForGG · 26/02/2022 14:04

@Rover83 Sorry 8 interest badges just counted them, I'd forgotten she'd done some extras

OP posts:
Cryingbutstilltrying · 26/02/2022 14:02

Thinking through the Brownies badges, I think only Dancing would be a complete no for a child with a muscle condition. But there are 3 options in each theme in Brownies so lots to choose from there.
She sounds like she got a lot from Rainbows so I wish her well for the future, in my opinion it’s an organisation that works really well for children who sometimes are excluded from other activities.

AlandAnna · 26/02/2022 13:59

I am giving up my whole Saturday for a guiding event next week so I’m not a total bad mom by the way Cake

Cryingbutstilltrying · 26/02/2022 13:58

I always find it fascinating how many different ways there are of doing things within GG.
I am a Brownie leader. I am so delighted if a girl does an interest badge that I absolutely will buy it from our funds. We charge £25 for a 10 week term and that pays for everything, hall hire, membership, resources, badges. It’s pretty tight most years but we cope with the odd fundraiser locally and gift aid too.
As long as whatever the unit does is made clear from the start, it seems fair enough to charge for ‘extras’. But personally I wouldn’t want to deter a child from doing a badge due to extra cost. Also the effort involved in getting that extra money when I’m always having to chase for the term fees anyway would put me off bothering! Unless the girls are completely badge obsessed I can’t see it being a massive extra cost.

AlandAnna · 26/02/2022 13:57

(Sorry that was so badly typed Blush)

InterestBadgesForGG · 26/02/2022 13:57

@Rover83

We don't pay for badges, I'm not really sure what our subs are but I think it works out to about £2 a night. It seems that my DDs group do one skills builder each term and the girls can do whatever interest badge they want to at home. Our leader tells us what colour they are doing so they can get both colours.

To be honest a large part of rainbows is getting the badges so the aim is to do 6 skill builders and 6 interest badges to get the gold badge, so in theory 12 badges then bronze, silver and gold so 15 badges per girl. I would pay for the badges if we had to but I definitely expect my subs to cover it.

My daughter helped out in the remembrance parade and at the end of that term got a gorgeous poppy badge a skills badge and 2 interest badges and her bronze badge along with the pin badge, I was surprised she got so many badges!

@Rover83 DD has her Bronze, and Silver, 4 theme awards, 4 interest bagdes, 4 skill builders, the Mirabel and Thinking Day badges. She wanted to do the Remembrance Parade but Rainbows don't do it here, only Brownies and Guides.
OP posts:
AlandAnna · 26/02/2022 13:54

It’s not I don’t know want them too. If they do it off their own back, fine! If I have to look through their book, check what they need to get signed off and by whom, it’s not going to happen. I’ve got three children who do various activities outside of school and guiding and a full time job. I’m busy enough without taking on this too. School expects us to help with homework as well…. there are only so many hours in the day.

InterestBadgesForGG · 26/02/2022 13:54

[quote coffeecup88]@InterestBadgesForGG out of interest which of the badges do you think would be affected by medical needs? I've not had anyone raise that issue before and I'd like to be cognisant of issues for any girl that joins with medical needs.

The badges are designed so that each girl can take their own spin on it. All 3 elements completed but the only requirement is that the girl "does their best" as per the promise. And every girl will have different abilities etc. For example I don't expect the 4 yr olds to turn to have written anything for their badges.[/quote]
@coffeecup88 My DD has a muscle condition and doesn't do PE at school or sport outside of school so probably won't be able to do the Agility badge, but she can do Nature as she can do that sat at the table but if she couldn't then she'd be exempt from the interest badge for that theme.

I think she'll likely struggle with Helper and Recycling, going to give Recycling ago but if she can't do it, then I'm not overly bothered (and won't be using the exemption either as she'll be moving to Brownies soon).

I don't know enough about the Brownies badges yet to say if she'll struggle with any.

OP posts:
Rover83 · 26/02/2022 13:52

We don't pay for badges, I'm not really sure what our subs are but I think it works out to about £2 a night. It seems that my DDs group do one skills builder each term and the girls can do whatever interest badge they want to at home. Our leader tells us what colour they are doing so they can get both colours.

To be honest a large part of rainbows is getting the badges so the aim is to do 6 skill builders and 6 interest badges to get the gold badge, so in theory 12 badges then bronze, silver and gold so 15 badges per girl. I would pay for the badges if we had to but I definitely expect my subs to cover it.

My daughter helped out in the remembrance parade and at the end of that term got a gorgeous poppy badge a skills badge and 2 interest badges and her bronze badge along with the pin badge, I was surprised she got so many badges!

coffeecup88 · 26/02/2022 13:52

Yes of course @InterestBadgesForGG but construction and drawing are. And I certainly enjoyed some parental benefits when they DDs were doing their helper.