Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Automatic or manual?

112 replies

SummerRain41287 · 26/02/2022 12:40

I'm new to mumsnet, it was recommended by a close friend of mine.

Let me get straight to the point. I am 35 years old with 1 child and I should have completed my driving test many, many years ago. Please don't judge! 

I am now in the process of starting my theory practice so that I can hopefully pass and just concentrate on the driving.

Previously, I've had lessons using a manual vehicle and I just can't seem to grasp the (very basic!) concept of clutch control, changing gears smoothly and the rest of it.

DP says that it's 2022 and that most people drive automatic or dual vehicles now.

AIBU to go ahead with practising for an automatic driving licence?

Or

YABU and should just practice for a manual licence.

OP posts:
bloodywhitecat · 26/02/2022 14:59

@PrimroseTheSmooth

simply cannot grasp the concept of the bay/parallel parking with a manual. I find it so difficult!

I’m not sure that an automatic will make things like parallel parking any easier- reverse is reverse. But if you can’t pass in a manual, it’s definitely worth a try. You can always retake the manual test once you’re more experienced if you want to.

Yes but in an auto reverse is reverse without the clutch control and, for some people (my son included) that makes auto reversing easier.
Sugarplumfairy65 · 26/02/2022 14:58

@Svara

Most people I know drive manual cars, guess if you mix in very middle class circles this may be different though.
I'm not middle class and I've only driven automatics for 35 years. All my family now only drive automatics too including my husband, children and their spouses. We are all working class
ComDummings · 26/02/2022 14:58

Automatic 100%

DeePlume · 26/02/2022 14:58

Sitting in traffic in an auto us just the best! Haha

DrDreReturns · 26/02/2022 14:56

Five years ago I'd said learn in a manual, but I'm not sure now. With the move to electric cars vehicles on the market will be becoming increasingly automatics. So if you think learning a manual will be really difficult go for an automatic.
I used to be very pro manual but we got an electric car last year and I love not having to change gear!

Sugarplumfairy65 · 26/02/2022 14:54

I've been driving automatics for nearly 35 years. They are the future so there's really no point learning in a manual. I've never had a problem buying any car I want or hiring one here or abroad.

PrimroseTheSmooth · 26/02/2022 14:52

simply cannot grasp the concept of the bay/parallel parking with a manual. I find it so difficult!

I’m not sure that an automatic will make things like parallel parking any easier- reverse is reverse. But if you can’t pass in a manual, it’s definitely worth a try. You can always retake the manual test once you’re more experienced if you want to.

DeePlume · 26/02/2022 14:52

Do automatic. I did 6 tests in a Manual and failed. Did one in an auto and passed with 2 minors!

If you're like me my brain just can't process everything that needs to be done in a manual. In the auto it's just stop, go. Like a golf buggy! I've never struggled to find an automatic car.

If you find later on you want to drive a manual you can just take the manual test.

RoastedFerret · 26/02/2022 14:47

@Svara

Why would you think you had to be in middle class circles for your friends to drive automatic cars? It's hardly a class issue. Well people are talking about hybrid and electric cars. I don’t know anyone with one. Most people I know have small second hand manual cars. Most people I know are also working class. It could always be for a different reason though.
The car dh was looking at today was a small second hand hybrid car. Hybrids have been around for quite a while at this point.
SummerRain41287 · 26/02/2022 14:43

Thanks for all your replies, I didn't expect such a huge response. I will go through them all later!

OP posts:
SummerRain41287 · 26/02/2022 14:42

@FourSeasonsTotalLandscaping

Omg are you me? I'm in such a similar position. I've recently started taking lessons in an automatic and it's like night and day - so so much easier. I wish I'd done it years ago but was always swayed by people saying I wouldn't have a "proper" licence.

I no longer give a shit - I'm sick to the back teeth of having no licence at all!

Haha, twin Wink I just simply cannot grasp the concept of the bay/parallel parking with a manual. I find it so difficult!
OP posts:
notthemum · 26/02/2022 14:42

I learned to drive and took my test in a manual (many years ago.) 1st car paid for though was an automatic x dp got it for me. I wasn't pleased at the time.
Because I took my test in a manual I am legal to drive both.
I find the automatic much easier to drive and feel much more comfortable in it.

sheusesmagazines · 26/02/2022 14:25

I got an automatic licence in 2009 and it's never been an issue. Go for auto.

Abhannmor · 26/02/2022 14:20

A workmate used to give me a lift and one day I noticed her car was an automatic. She explained ' I only wanna drive it , not give it a hand job!' My sil changed to an automatic 2 years ago.Wishes she'd done so earlier as her knee gives her gip now.

Associatepeggy · 26/02/2022 14:19

I have an automatic that's not hybrid or electrical. I can drive both. Automatics are not middle class cars. Though I actually have no clue what class I am in, tbh. It all seems very complicated.

@SummerRain41287 we have been discussing this for dd. Both me and dad are of the opinion automatic is fine as she will only be driving my car anyway until she finishes uni in 4 years.

If she needs a car after that, then she will have to get an automatic. I imagine by time she is 30, automatics will be far more common.

It means passing a lot quicker and stresses her out less.

LadyCordeliaFitzgerald · 26/02/2022 14:17

Manual is about muscle memory and it takes a good while to build that. It’s not easy to do the driving and checking and looking at the same time so I completely understand why it’s overwhelming.

But once it clicks that’s it. It’s like riding a bicycle. Do you have access to a car and a safe place to practice stopping, starting, and changing the gears up and down. I spent a fair few hours doing this while I was learning. Instructors will take you straight out on the road after 5 minutes and it can knock your confidence quickly.

The key thing is to understand the “bite” so that you don’t burn out the clutch on a patient friend’s car. It really, really helps to be able to give this your full concentration instead of dealing with the overwhelm of everything else and trying not to kill anyone.

I love manual - I will continue to drive manual as long as I possibly can. But it’s true that might not be for much longer. So if it really isn’t possible to learn don’t worry about it. I just want you to know that lots of us thought we’d never get it and did. And that separating the mechanics of driving out from the road craft can help immensely.

User405 · 26/02/2022 14:12

Well people are talking about hybrid and electric cars. I don’t know anyone with one. Most people I know have small second hand manual cars. Most people I know are also working class. It could always be for a different reason though.

Here is the first hit on auto trader for an automatic under £2000. Automatic card are not for the middle classes. They are just cars with a different gearbox.

www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202202212779350?postcode=ng163ej&include-delivery-option=on&sort=relevance&year-from=2009&year-to=2022&transmission=Automatic&radius=1500&onesearchad=New&onesearchad=Nearly%20New&onesearchad=Used&price-to=2500&advertising-location=at_cars&page=1&percentVehiclePriceDeposit=true

MamaTutu2 · 26/02/2022 14:03

@SummerRain41287 I’ve been driving 10 years in an automatic, I would never have passed in a manual, it just wasn’t workable for me. I bought a cheap automatic afterwards and have never had any real problems. Would recommend 100%

Beees · 26/02/2022 14:02

Well people are talking about hybrid and electric cars. I don’t know anyone with one. Most people I know have small second hand manual cars. Most people I know are also working class. It could always be for a different reason though

Just because some people are discussing accurately that cars will be heading towards being electric or hybrid doesn't mean that automatic cars are not affordable to people who are working class. I'm not sure how much more you think an automatic car costs but the difference in price really is negligible. I suspect many of those you know actually do have automatic cars, it's so commonplace that it wouldn't even be noteworthy in a conversation.

User405 · 26/02/2022 14:02

And Summer good luck with your theory test. My dd said that she should have practiced the hazard test using a laptop and mouse because that's what she had to do on the day. She'd only done it on a touchscreen at home.

Tommika · 26/02/2022 14:02

[quote SummerRain41287]@Tommika honestly, I think it's the manoeuvres that I struggled with when practising in a manual. I found it really difficult to concentrate on the mirrors, any potential hazards, and the bloody gearstick and lowering the gears as I slowed down. It was just a complete mess. I still feel that auto is a cop out and as a pp just explained, what about if we break down in my DP's manual? Or he can't drive it for whatever reason? Then I have a problem Sad[/quote]
It still ultimately comes down to your choice
But as you’re asking the questions my thoughts are that you have a ‘problem’ that could be solved:

  1. Is the simple solution to go automatic
  2. Is to approach the problem in a new way to fix it

In your example of DPs car:
If he has manual and you have automatic then he can drive either car, but with an automatic licence you cannot drive the manual
If he’s incapacited then car recovery can deal with that - he’s the only suitable driver (small print and different levels of cover will apply)
If he suddenly decides to drink when out you can take his keys off him, but the car is staying put
If one car is in the garage then you can’t drive his
If you have a manual Licence then you can take the keys and drive

But there are so many ifs and buts that could or could not happen

You aren’t a failure if you take the ‘easy’ option
But from reading your posts you’re working out the options, so my advise remains to see if there is a solution
There is so much to do all at once while driving, and if you’re not confident then they are compounded even more. An automatic Licence will take away some of that, but so will practice - as long as that practice benefits you as opposed to piling on the pressure

My advice would still be to get in some extra practice, possibly with a different person.
Ideally in a wide open empty area, so that you can focus on gear changes and the clutch
If you can’t do exactly that then try somewhere quiet, put in some practice and see if you begin to benefit
If you can’t ‘improve’ in a time suitable for you then go for the automatic route

www.rac.co.uk/drive/advice/know-how/automatic-vs-manual-cars-which-is-better/

aloysiusflyte · 26/02/2022 14:02

Go for automatic, I was late coming to learning to drive (at nearly 40) tried to master a manual for 6 months and found it stressful and upsetting. Started to hate learning to drive and was considering stopping. Decided to switch to auto and passed first time 3 months later.

Auto takes all the stress out of driving in my opinion and the cars are only slightly more expensive to buy. It's the future after all!

Luckycloverzz · 26/02/2022 14:01

Consider trying with manual for a while longer, I went just automatic and missed out on a great job as company had cars we would need to drive and only manual. I've now gone back and got full manual licence passed. So just consider if any future job may jnclude driving company vehicles it may effect you then. Smile

User405 · 26/02/2022 13:59

We lived in Australia for a while where automatic cars are the norm and when we moved to the uk we both opted for automatic.

My oldest has just learnt to drive and we couldn't find an automatic instructor so she ended up having to learn manual but if we had found one we definitely would have gone for it. I secretly felt a bit sorry for her as there is so much more to think about. Grin

Once you have passed you can always retake your test in a manual in a few years if you really felt the need when you are far more confident.

Svara · 26/02/2022 13:58

Why would you think you had to be in middle class circles for your friends to drive automatic cars? It's hardly a class issue.
Well people are talking about hybrid and electric cars. I don’t know anyone with one. Most people I know have small second hand manual cars. Most people I know are also working class. It could always be for a different reason though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread