Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Automatic or manual?

112 replies

SummerRain41287 · 26/02/2022 12:40

I'm new to mumsnet, it was recommended by a close friend of mine.

Let me get straight to the point. I am 35 years old with 1 child and I should have completed my driving test many, many years ago. Please don't judge! 

I am now in the process of starting my theory practice so that I can hopefully pass and just concentrate on the driving.

Previously, I've had lessons using a manual vehicle and I just can't seem to grasp the (very basic!) concept of clutch control, changing gears smoothly and the rest of it.

DP says that it's 2022 and that most people drive automatic or dual vehicles now.

AIBU to go ahead with practising for an automatic driving licence?

Or

YABU and should just practice for a manual licence.

OP posts:
bruce43mydog · 26/02/2022 20:13

I am still manual although my steps dad auto has me hooked 🙂

lalafam · 26/02/2022 20:10

Manual really isn't that difficult when you get the hang of it.

LyndaSnellsSniff · 26/02/2022 20:07

I tried to learn in a manual but it just wasn't happening. People kept telling me to stick with it because you have more choice of cars.

But I just couldn't do it so tried an auto and passed. Give an auto lesson a try and see what you think. Good luck!

bellac11 · 26/02/2022 20:02

I passed in an automatic and have never regretted it we have had a few vehicles and my OH is also an auto driver. I only notice the difference when someone gives me a lift in a manual and I think 'what a load of faff'

JuergenSchwarzwald · 26/02/2022 20:01

@Luckycloverzz

Consider trying with manual for a while longer, I went just automatic and missed out on a great job as company had cars we would need to drive and only manual. I've now gone back and got full manual licence passed. So just consider if any future job may jnclude driving company vehicles it may effect you then. Smile
This sounds highly unlikely unless the job involved driving vans/lorries. Why couldn't you use your own car?
ChocolateCakeYum · 26/02/2022 20:00

I have an automatic license. Hated driving a manual.

All the reasons people list for manuals being better than autos in this day and age are nonsensical. They will say stuff like autos are hard to come by - never had an issue! Or that autos are unreliable - not true! Or that your license will be restricted - big deal. I have no interest in driving anything other than my own vehicle. They’ll also tell you that auto gearboxes are crap - I’ve had 2 cars (one for 3 years, the other about 2 and neither have ever had issues with the gearbox).

Autos are very good for high traffic areas with lots of stop start driving.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 26/02/2022 19:59

Most people I know drive manual cars, guess if you mix in very middle class circles this may be different though

The reasons people give not to drive automatics "too middle class" Grin

Duchess379 · 26/02/2022 19:41

Just go auto. There are lots of cars about now that are auto for you to choose from. I passed in a manual but have been driving an auto for lord knows how long!

FloBot7 · 26/02/2022 18:34

I have a manual licence but haven't driven manual in 13 of the 15 years I've had my licence. Mostly because I moved to New Zealand where most cars were automatic and I just happened to buy one. Driving an automatic is so much easier and with the move to electric cars, automatic could become more common here. When I moved back here everyone said Automatics were expensive and unreliable but I haven't seen any evidence yet. I got a small 5 door automatic Skoda citigo on PCP 4 years ago and its £150 a month. It's passed every MOT without problems. I really like it and don't need a new car so I'm about to get a loan for the balloon payment. It's just under £2,800 (£119 per month for 3 years) but using we buy any car as a benchmark, it's worth £9,500.

gasty · 26/02/2022 18:24

just do auto, I did as in a rush.

alwayswrighty · 26/02/2022 18:17

I don't feel like I'm driving unless it's manual. Having said that I have arthritis in my left hand exacerbated by driving a manual so my next car will have to be auto 😪

@SummerRain41287 do whatever makes you comfortable.

sunshinesupermum · 26/02/2022 18:11

I have driven an automatic since I passed my test when I was 25 many years ago. I cannot understand anyone who still drives a manual. Go for it OP and best of luck with your test.

Itsrainingatlast · 26/02/2022 18:05

Automatic!
I’ve just driven 700 miles (from France) non stop. With cruise control and lane departure as well you’re barely driving now. I’m on my second automatic, would never go back (mines a Yaris…Toyota don’t make manual cars anymore).
My eldest is 16; really not sure there’s any point in him learning to drive a manual when he starts learning next year. I’m fairly sure an automatic licence will become the standard with an ‘enhanced manual’ as an optional extra in the next few years.

Buddywoo · 26/02/2022 15:49

I was just like you and simply couldn't get to grips with gear changing and everything else at the same time.. I had many lessons and gave up in frustration each time.
I was about your age when I bought a cheap runaround automatic car (in those days there weren't so many automatics) and had lessons in it. It was a game changer. I took my test and passed first time.
I drove the car for a couple of years to gain confidence on the road and then had a few lessons and re-took my test in a manual car. Again I passed.
I might not have bothered with the second test but I needed to pass it to get a company car.
Nowadays there are so many automatic cars I would probably stick with that.
Funnily enough, once I had got to grips with the gears I preferred driving a manual car.

flipflopjump · 26/02/2022 15:49

The disadvantages of not having a driving license are far greater than the disadvantages of "only" having an automatic license!

Just take automatic lessons.

(Advice from a 2 car household: 1 electric / 1 automatic ICE).

RosesAndHellebores · 26/02/2022 15:47

The other plus is that when you are older or break an ankle (left only) you can still drive despite the state of the knees. I'd recommend heated seats and steering wheel for anyone arthritic.

Minfilia · 26/02/2022 15:36

Auto.

All cars in the UK will be automatic by 2030, that’s less than 8 years. And the prevalence of electric cars will only continue to increase and make auto driving more common.

I’ve driven auto for 12 years, no chance I’d want a manual now.

Grantanow · 26/02/2022 15:35

My old dad told me never to buy an automatic: he thought they were unreliable. In fact I've had automatics for twenty years and they have proved very reliable and much less effort to drive than a manual and you can override them to some extent to hold the car in a lower gear if needed. They get my vote.

Totalwasteofpaper · 26/02/2022 15:32

[quote SummerRain41287]@bloodywhitecat exactly what DP has been saying. We're living in different times now so maybe driving an automatic won't be classed as a "cop out" as such, as it would have been 15-20 years ago.[/quote]
Exactly this.

As an older learner honestly just do automatic

pigsDOfly · 26/02/2022 15:13

If you're struggling with gears go for an automatic licence. You'll find driving so much pleasanter and less stressful.

I passed my test late 60s early 70s in a manual but I haven't driven one for over 30 years.

I would never go back to manual. Driving an automatic is so much more enjoyable, for me, anyway.

You will find that an automatic will be very slightly more expensive to buy than a manual but on a second hand car it doesn't make that much different and it's well worth the money.

And don't listen to anyone who tells you that automatics aren't as speedy as manuals when it come to acceleration. It might have been true once but those days are long gone.

Go for it, and good luck.

AlexaShutUp · 26/02/2022 15:09

I'd have said manual a few years ago, but the future is all automatic. I think automatic is fine now.

I learned in a manual but got used to driving an automatic when living overseas where automatic was the only real option. I would never go back now.

RosesAndHellebores · 26/02/2022 15:08

Passed in a manual in 1977 Shock. Happily drove a manual until 2010 when the best deal available on what I wanted was automatic. I would never, ever go back to manual despite driving them very happily for decades.

Auto is the way forward. DD only has an auto licence. OK she can't drive her boyfriend's car but he'll have to get an auto anyway.

Only ds drives a manual in our household now and his next car will undoubtedly be auto.

Longdistance · 26/02/2022 15:06

Automatic all the way. I don’t why it took me 20 years to realise this. It’s so wonderful and easy to drive. We live in quite a built up town, traffics everywhere. It’s nice not to keep changing gears.

halfsiesonapotnoodle · 26/02/2022 15:02

Automatic. I am so over bothering with gears. Future cars will be automatic by default. Why learn something you'll struggle with? Don't give it another thought OP.

Teacupsandtoast · 26/02/2022 15:01

Passed at 34 with less than 8 weeks of lessons in an automatic. Hasn't been an issue at all and my life, and my childrens, has improved SO much for being able to drive

Swipe left for the next trending thread