Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Automatic or manual?

112 replies

SummerRain41287 · 26/02/2022 12:40

I'm new to mumsnet, it was recommended by a close friend of mine.

Let me get straight to the point. I am 35 years old with 1 child and I should have completed my driving test many, many years ago. Please don't judge! 

I am now in the process of starting my theory practice so that I can hopefully pass and just concentrate on the driving.

Previously, I've had lessons using a manual vehicle and I just can't seem to grasp the (very basic!) concept of clutch control, changing gears smoothly and the rest of it.

DP says that it's 2022 and that most people drive automatic or dual vehicles now.

AIBU to go ahead with practising for an automatic driving licence?

Or

YABU and should just practice for a manual licence.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Chasingaftermidnight · 27/02/2022 18:09

I passed my test on a manual but could never quite get confident on them - it didn’t come naturally to me. I had to concentrate very hard on it, and it always stressed me out, especially when driving in hilly places or busy places.

Switching to an auto changed my life. I actually enjoy driving now. No stalling. No hill starts. No rolling backwards if you misjudge where bite is. No fear of accidentally going into the wrong gear. I feel like 100% of my attention is on the road when I’m driving an auto (which is where it should be). When I drive manuals I always felt I had half my attention on the controls, not on the road. I wouldn’t care if I only had an automatic only licence because I am never getting behind the wheel of a manual again.

But, to give you a bit of balance, my DH hates our automatic. He claims it doesn’t change up and down quickly enough and doesn’t react quickly enough when you need to take advantage of tiny windows of opportunity in busy traffic.

I disagree but that is his view!

JuergenSchwarzwald · 27/02/2022 17:58

it just feels like I'm taking the "easy" option and I don't want to be looked at strangely because I can't drive a manual. But as a pp said, eventually all cars will be automatic or electric and I never thought of it like that

honestly, nobody cares! And you can upgrade your licence if you want to (without any fear of losing the automatic one) but you won't want to, trust me

JuergenSchwarzwald · 27/02/2022 17:57

Once you're comfortable driving and if you feel you really want to drive manuals as well, you can upgrade your license. www.gov.uk/automatic-driving-licence-to-manual

but you really won't need to.

KatharinaRosalie · 27/02/2022 17:40

option 1: pass with automatic, able to drive automatic cars.
option 2: take a lot longer, not able to drive, possibly never pass, not able to drive any cars.

Option 1 seems to be the most logical one? Once you're comfortable driving and if you feel you really want to drive manuals as well, you can upgrade your license. www.gov.uk/automatic-driving-licence-to-manual

EthelTheAardvark · 27/02/2022 16:58

[quote alwayswrighty]@SummerRain41287 honestly I doubt many people now would even think about the fact you might have an automatic licence only. I passed my driving test in 1995, and as far as I'm aware it had to be a manual.[/quote]
No, it didn't. A friend of mine took and passed her test on an automatic back in the 1980s.

Teacupsandtoast · 27/02/2022 14:24

Enjoy learning to drive and the freedom it will bring!!

User405 · 27/02/2022 09:14

The app,is exactly why my dd has only practiced on a touchscreen. It was ok and she still passed it just wasn't what she was expecting.

You can do it on the .gov website as well.

www.gov.uk/theory-test/hazard-perception-test

Cakey46 · 27/02/2022 08:54

I failed many tests in a manual then passed first time in an automatic. Do it, you won't regret it!!!!

alwayswrighty · 27/02/2022 08:44

@SummerRain41287 honestly I doubt many people now would even think about the fact you might have an automatic licence only. I passed my driving test in 1995, and as far as I'm aware it had to be a manual.

SummerRain41287 · 27/02/2022 08:31

@User405

And Summer good luck with your theory test. My dd said that she should have practiced the hazard test using a laptop and mouse because that's what she had to do on the day. She'd only done it on a touchscreen at home.
Interesting. Because I've downloaded an app as things have changed massively since I last practised for my theory. Of course, it was done on laptops or computers back then. I never considered that hazard perception may pose as a problem on a touch screen handheld device as opposed to using the mouse. Thanks for the heads up on this
OP posts:
SummerRain41287 · 27/02/2022 08:28

@gasty

just do auto, I did as in a rush.
Yes I am also in a rush, that's 50% of the reason if I'm honest. It's not fair on my daughter to subject her to yet another cold winter walking to and from school. I also live quite far from the local town, we live in the sticks, so it's always a case of either getting an Uber or a lift if we ever want to go into town. It's a nightmare. I can't do it anymore.
OP posts:
SummerRain41287 · 27/02/2022 08:13

@GeneLovesJezebel

Manual always.
Can I ask what's your reason for choosing manual? I'm interested to hear both sides, not just those saying automatic. Thanks Smile
OP posts:
GeneLovesJezebel · 27/02/2022 07:40

Manual always.

SummerRain41287 · 27/02/2022 07:38

I'm so grateful for everyone's input. I don't feel like such a loser now Grin Thank you Mumsnetters for helping me make my deicison!

OP posts:
SummerRain41287 · 27/02/2022 07:37

@alwayswrighty

I don't feel like I'm driving unless it's manual. Having said that I have arthritis in my left hand exacerbated by driving a manual so my next car will have to be auto 😪

@SummerRain41287 do whatever makes you comfortable.

It sounds silly but that's what it feels like for me, it just feels like I'm taking the "easy" option and I don't want to be looked at strangely because I can't drive a manual. But as a pp said, eventually all cars will be automatic or electric and I never thought of it like that.
OP posts:
Whycatspaint · 26/02/2022 22:12

Didn't pass till I was 32 and fist time in an automatic after 7 failed in a manual. Never looked back and have always driven second hand. You won't regret it!

Gregsprinkles · 26/02/2022 21:54

I'd just go for automatic mow unless you want to hire a car regularly, as automatics cost so much more (currently).

PlanetNormal · 26/02/2022 21:37

Manual gearboxes are on their way out. In future cars will be electric so they won’t have multi-speed gearboxes at all. I would stick to automatic.

alwayswrighty · 26/02/2022 21:33

@EthelTheAardvark I have a highly modified sports car. I just like being able to drop a cog and go. I know modern automatics or sequential gears are much better but last time I drove an automatic it was sluggish.

Luckycloverzz · 26/02/2022 20:47

So jobs that use company cars are quite common and varied. Carers, estate agents, gas/elec workers, and shops that do home deliveries use cars or van, even council workers often use council owned vehicles. It really depends what line of work the OP is in or may go into if job requires you to use company vehicle it will matter.

EthelTheAardvark · 26/02/2022 20:34

@alwayswrighty

I don't feel like I'm driving unless it's manual. Having said that I have arthritis in my left hand exacerbated by driving a manual so my next car will have to be auto 😪

@SummerRain41287 do whatever makes you comfortable.

Sheer curiosity - what do you feel like you're doing when you drive an automatic if you don't feel you're driving?
EthelTheAardvark · 26/02/2022 20:29

@Luckycloverzz

Consider trying with manual for a while longer, I went just automatic and missed out on a great job as company had cars we would need to drive and only manual. I've now gone back and got full manual licence passed. So just consider if any future job may jnclude driving company vehicles it may effect you then. Smile
That's pretty iffy employment practice, as it risks excluding employees with disabilities that prevent them using a manual but not an automatic. I suspect that company was pretty unusual, and in any event it's going to have to change its policies as electric cars become standard.
BurbageBrook · 26/02/2022 20:25

I learned auto and it made it a much quicker process to learn. Auto all the way!

EthelTheAardvark · 26/02/2022 20:22

Automatic, definitely.

I learned on a manual and, I must say, I could never understand why the gear system had to be so difficult to use. Eventually I did learn, passed my test first time, and drove perfectly happily for around 20 years using manuals. Then when my father had to give up driving he passed their automatic on to me and ever since that's what I've stuck with. I now drive a hybrid so have to have automatic anyway, but I wouldn't very willingly go back to manual. I don't feel that I have any more, or less, control of the car but I do a lot of town driving so it's great not having to keep changing gear all the time.

DD is slightly dyspraxic and struggled so much with manual gears that she nearly gave up. Eventually she decided to shift to a lovely fatherly ex-cop instructor in an automatic car and then sailed through her test. Neither she nor I have had any problems in buying cars - OK, it's a bit more expensive but worth it.

Given that the current price of oil and petrol is going to drive more and more people towards electric cars, and therefore bring down prices, I simply don't see the point of putting yourself through all the stress of learning on a system which is going to become ever more obsolete in the foreseeable future.

LaraT211 · 26/02/2022 20:20

Automatic is great. I have probably spent thousands on driving lessons for manuals. I did pass but it was a waste of time as I drove automatic. If I had just had automatic lessons I’m pretty sure I would have passed much quicker. With automatics there’s no worrying about stalling, hill starts etc all the things learners find hardest