Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think LTB is not always financially possible?

143 replies

BigupPemberleyMassive · 26/02/2022 11:43

Especially with so many people struggling on dual incomes, is wanting the kids to be in a dual income, but frosty home unreasonable?

I'm not talking about things like alcoholism or violence, but threads where OP says husband flirted with a co worker by text etc. Obviously not acceptable, but if the choice is separate, move to a smaller more affordable place, an area with bad schools or stay and put up with it but kids have more financial stability?

Median UK salary is £30,000 and often less for women who have taken time out of paid work to have children.

AIBU to think sometimes financial reasons mean one can't LTB?

Or is it better to be struggling financially, and the kids can't do karate anymore or whatever, but you have dignity?

OP posts:
WillTheCircleBeUnbroken · 27/02/2022 16:43

One thing a lot of people underestimate is the impact it’ll have on kids and the relationships they’ll have in the future when one parent chooses to stay for the financial benefits.

Children often model their own relationships on their parents’ and it makes me sad how many of my peers are absolutely miserable living with a man who repeatedly cheats on them and undermines them and it’s seen as something normal they are forced to endure because their mum stayed for financial reasons too. The same can be said for the numerous men I know mirroring their dads who did as they pleased to no consequences just because they were the breadwinners.

Of course it’s more complex than that and the genders can be reversed but it’s not as common as that scenario up there.

figuringoutmylife · 27/02/2022 16:43

I cannot work out what LTB is?!

SheilaWilcox · 27/02/2022 16:39

I agree OP.

I'm a SAHM. Used to have a career, but mental health impact of trying to do it all meant I gave up as 'we' could afford it. Live in South East with DD at private school.
Mental health shot to pieces, partially due to being so miserable with DH. We don't argue and he doesn't see a problem so he won't rock the boat / leave. He's on to a good thing as I'm essestially a maid/gardener/handy man/childcare/cook
Feel dead already, but trapped. No hope of leaving until DD is at uni and I only have myself to support.

Bringsexyback · 27/02/2022 16:37

And I do realise this is shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted but it’s another reason why I wouldn’t entertain having a child with somebody who was self-employed.

Bringsexyback · 27/02/2022 16:35

[quote ldontWanna]@Bringsexyback and if he had quit his job or gone on benefits and all you got was £5 a week if that?

It's a real worry for many, especially this year with the ridiculous price increases for everything. Imagine you left tomorrow, as a SAHM or a NMW job and all you had was that and benefits(when they kick in) , if you even got a home and not "temporary accommodation " aka 2/3 years in a b&b or shared house. No family support or real network.

I'm not saying women shouldn't leave, I'm just saying that it's better to try and understand when they don't instead of judging or dismissing their worries. That rhetoric often doesn't work anyways. It just makes them feel even more isolated,disenfranchised and less likely to ask for help.[/quote]
I’m not referring to women I’m minimum wage or on benefits, although to be honest I struggle to see actually how they would be worse off l have friends who have three or four children with man who were a minimum wage and they too were financially better off away from him then with him because at least he wasn’t taken out of the pot - another large mouth to feed, whilst contributing bugger all to it.

It’s a very rare day when a woman goes from being with a man on £50~60 grand a year and he quit his job and cut his nose off to spite his face and goes to earning nothing and therefore she doesn’t get child-support.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 27/02/2022 16:25

@girlmom21 I had enough money to pay a deposit and then housing benefit paid the rent. It was a private rental. I was lucky to get it to be fair as getting a private rental when you're on benefits is almost impossible now.

girlmom21 · 27/02/2022 16:20

[quote Waxonwaxoff0]@girlmom21 with housing benefit. I claimed benefits.[/quote]
I just thought you were lucky to be able to immediately get a flat, that was all.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 27/02/2022 16:17

@girlmom21 with housing benefit. I claimed benefits.

ldontWanna · 27/02/2022 16:16

@JanglyBeads

The number one predictor of negative outcomes for children is growing up in poverty You mean the number one predictor out of the factors which have been researched properly. There is little large scale research on the effects of growing up witnessing DV, AFAIK.
There's plenty of research and evidence of the impact of ACEs on children. Negative effects are not just limited to emotional and mental afflictions ,but physical too.

No one is denying that. Of course,living in poverty makes it more likely for children to be exposed to other traumatic circumstances and environments too. It's a vicious circle.

What is being said is that leaving(especially if there's no abuse) is not always the best option or outcome and many women, even if utterly miserable are painfully aware of that. So maybe some posters could apply a little bit of empathy and sympathy rather than just repeating "where there's a will there's a way" and "there's no such thing as can't " mantra.

ldontWanna · 27/02/2022 16:06

@Bringsexyback and if he had quit his job or gone on benefits and all you got was £5 a week if that?

It's a real worry for many, especially this year with the ridiculous price increases for everything. Imagine you left tomorrow, as a SAHM or a NMW job and all you had was that and benefits(when they kick in) , if you even got a home and not "temporary accommodation " aka 2/3 years in a b&b or shared house. No family support or real network.

I'm not saying women shouldn't leave, I'm just saying that it's better to try and understand when they don't instead of judging or dismissing their worries. That rhetoric often doesn't work anyways. It just makes them feel even more isolated,disenfranchised and less likely to ask for help.

girlmom21 · 27/02/2022 15:57

@sleaf

Many women do not have the money to LTB especially if they don't work or work part time.

But on MN women are often told to LTB even if they have nowhere to go, no money and no support.

I'm not victim blaming here but too many women put themselves in vulnerable financial positions.

I told DP this is the exactly reason I would never give up work. You don't ever want to plan for the worst situation but if he decided to go and cheat on me or gamble our savings away or shove thousands of pounds of coke up his nose I wouldn't have to just stand idly by.

gogohm · 27/02/2022 15:54

It's not without changing your financial position. It is always possible if you need to but life will be tougher. My divorce is costing £550 online plus £99 for the consent order online

sleaf · 27/02/2022 15:52

Many women do not have the money to LTB especially if they don't work or work part time.

But on MN women are often told to LTB even if they have nowhere to go, no money and no support.

JanglyBeads · 27/02/2022 15:50

The number one predictor of negative outcomes for children is growing up in poverty
You mean the number one predictor out of the factors which have been researched properly. There is little large scale research on the effects of growing up witnessing DV, AFAIK.

Bringsexyback · 27/02/2022 15:46

@Neveragain85

I stayed for years thinking I couldn't afford life with 2 kids on my own. Turns out I'm much better off financially without him. Wish I'd done it years before. I don't think putting up with any level of abuse is worth the impact to your MH. I am totally scarred from living with an emotional abuser, I don't know if I will ever get over it or get him out of my head. It wasn't worth staying
That’s exactly the case with me too honestly I do appreciate that things might be different now and I understand that you have to jump through more hoops with universal credits but 100% I was financially better off by about £800 a month once he started paying child support versus when we were together .
TheFirstSpiderMan · 27/02/2022 15:45

@JanglyBeads she has. The answer is not a fat lot. I really thought that LTB was a genuine option for many until I experienced it close up.

No one who can do anything to improve the situation (ie increase benefits, legal aid provision etc) cares.

girlmom21 · 27/02/2022 15:44

@Waxonwaxoff0

I left my ex husband when I had no job. Rented a flat and lived on benefits for a while. I was much happier.
How did you get a flat with no income?
ldontWanna · 27/02/2022 15:42

@Marchmount

Agree entirely Idontwanna. All these sneary posts about dignity. The number one predictor of negative outcomes for children is growing up in poverty. Regaining your dignity is a self-indulgence that many women chose not to take if it means that their kids are growing up in vastly more constrained financial circumstances. When you’re childless, it’s fine if you want to sacrifice your financial security for your principles but when you have kids, you should take them into account.
Posters also forget that help,support ,housing and what's available is often a postcode lottery. Add in lack of a support network, lack of skill,academia etc. and it's a fucking potshot. I have mums at my school that struggle to help their kids with their ks1 homework. How would they be able to navigate the benefit system,applications and all that stuff. Not to mention councils/HMRC actively discouraging people from getting what they are entitled to with hoop jumping and shrugging their shoulders saying "there's nothing we can do."

If there was dignity in single parenthood /poverty there wouldn't be so many women doing sex work and plenty of other dangerous things just to make ends meet.

Often they swap one arsehole for a mysoginistic/abusive boss, job or system because they're broke and desperate.Yay women, you're free and have your dignity.

I think it's important to keep the option on the table, share information on what support and help is there, offer support and advice,look at all avenues, make public and accessible charities, grants,schemes etc. That doesn't mean we can sneer and be all judgy and dismissive when a woman decides that staying is better or at least something she can live with. I'm not including abuse, themselves or their children being in danger etc.

Willyoujustbequiet · 27/02/2022 15:38

@TheBigDilemma

Violence against me. It's all very well saying sofa surf or whatever but you can't with disabled children with aids/adaptations etc...

@JanglyBeads They are much better than they were thank you Smile

Marchmount · 27/02/2022 15:07

Agree entirely Idontwanna. All these sneary posts about dignity. The number one predictor of negative outcomes for children is growing up in poverty. Regaining your dignity is a self-indulgence that many women chose not to take if it means that their kids are growing up in vastly more constrained financial circumstances. When you’re childless, it’s fine if you want to sacrifice your financial security for your principles but when you have kids, you should take them into account.

JanglyBeads · 27/02/2022 12:42

@TheFirstSpiderMan has she checked what e benefits she's entitled to if she had the children with her though?

DragonMovie · 27/02/2022 11:34

@Idontwanna I agree with everything you’ve said especially the last bit.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 27/02/2022 10:55

I left my ex husband when I had no job. Rented a flat and lived on benefits for a while. I was much happier.

TheFirstSpiderMan · 27/02/2022 10:32

I have a friend in this position. Abusive partner. She tried to leave, she did in fact leave for a short while but it's absolutely impossible from what I could see. Entitled to so little due to having just enough assets not to qualify for any legal help. The only option for housing would be a hostel.

Partner made it very clear she would have to fight him for the smallest thing. Not married so only entitled to the house.

She had to leave the children. It just didn't work in anyway. She moved back and I think is biding her time.

Absolutely this is a horrendous situation for the children and her to be in. But the system is designed against her. I was shocked and angry there was so little help.

LakieLady · 27/02/2022 10:10

@DragonMovie

I think there’s an amount of money that you can have where you 1. Can’t afford to raise your children alone (eg rent childcare food) and 2. Also don’t qualify for any financial help/benefits.

So I think it can be very very hard to leave.

I might be wrong? Can someone else advise?

You're right.

The relentless erosion of benefit levels over the last 10 years has disproportionately affected women imo. Single parents are more likely to be on benefits than couples, and the vast majority of those are women.

The earnings threshold at which entitlement ceases is too low to live on imo. You get about £850 a month for an adult and 2 children, and you're likely to have to pay a good chunck towards your rent and council tax out of that, plus all the usual bills.

The benefit cap is crippling and leaves less than £500 a month for everything, including a contribution to rent, if you're renting privately in much of the SE. You have to earn the equivalnt of 16 hours x min wage to be exempt from the cap.

Thankfully, there is an exemption if you or your partner have earned the equivalent of 16 hours x NMW for 9 months out of the previous year, and this holds good even if that "partner" is now your ex. A lot of people, including some of my fellow benefit advisers, don't realise that your ex's earnings count if you've only recently split.

It is very hard, unless you have friends/family who can help, or savings. It means food banks and charity shops, and watching every penny. But this is what people voted for, the bastards.

Swipe left for the next trending thread