Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to overhaul our finances after 20+ years together?

64 replies

mustbefunny · 26/02/2022 09:57

I read lots of threads on Mumsnet and elsewhere about how couples pool/split family money. There are always lots of differing opinions but quite often a clear view that 'surely you talked about this before you married and had children?'. Well yes, we did, and we still do, but things are constantly evolving and sometimes our conversations about finances get pushed to the bottom of the to do list! And so, we end up where we are now...

When we first rented a flat together, we both contributed the same figure in ££. At this time we earned roughly the same. We then bought a house and continued with this set-up throughout job changes, studying etc. First baby comes along and the amount we contribute in ££ changes with DH contributing more each month, but our salaries still get paid into our own accounts and we transfer over a set amount each month to our joint account. Marriage, two more children and 3 house moved later, this arrangement is still in place. In ££ DH contributes 2.5x what I do each month and also pays for lots of things from his own account. However, in % terms, I pay 90% of my salary and he pays about 60%. I do most of my spending from our joint account eg clothes, haircuts, nights out, whereas he pays for this stuff from his own account, but I reckon this only balances things up to about 85%/65% and in actual monetary terms he has >£1000 spare each month whereas I have

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MichaelAndEagle · 26/02/2022 15:25

@InDubiousBattle

We don't really split family money. Everything in one pot, bills etc come out of it and we both spend what we want/need out of it. We've been together a long time and done it this way since we moved in together at 21!
This only works unless one of you is more spendy than the other. Full disclosure I'm the spend one. I need to know how much I'm allowed to spend (and then I spend it all). I'm rubbish Blush
Hunderland · 26/02/2022 15:08

@InDubiousBattle

We don't really split family money. Everything in one pot, bills etc come out of it and we both spend what we want/need out of it. We've been together a long time and done it this way since we moved in together at 21!
^^ this for us too.
Nemorth · 26/02/2022 15:06

We add up all our outgoings. Then share the contribution to those pro rata based on all our income.

Crucially we've agreed a couple of important things. Overpaying they mortgage and paying as much as we can into our pensions. We want to have fun together when we are retired!

We've also made sure that we have the same disposable income each. We spend that in very different ways but it feels more like our own money rather than family money so it's ok.

Iwouldratherbemuckingout · 26/02/2022 14:38

When me and DP were together, we paid an amount proportional to our salaries into the joint account, kept the rest. I was the higher earner, and did try and talk about pooling and pensions (my pension much better) but he wasn’t having any of it. I was quite relieved as I think he would have died on the spot if he knew how much I was spending on the horses!

PigeonLittle · 26/02/2022 14:33

@InDubiousBattle

We don't really split family money. Everything in one pot, bills etc come out of it and we both spend what we want/need out of it. We've been together a long time and done it this way since we moved in together at 21!
This is what we do but it means that we discuss personal spends quite a bit and negotiate. I know some women wouldn't like asking for 'permission' to buy things.
AnneElliott · 26/02/2022 14:29

We have everything in one pot and everything comes out of that. Surely that's easier than working out percentages?

AngelinaFibres · 26/02/2022 14:20

Everything goes into the joint account. We have budgets each for clothes, personal interests( we are retired so husband plays a lot of golf ) ,holidays, household expenses etc. We also have pocket money each month . We have the same amount of money each and can spend it as we wish.

Bofthebang · 26/02/2022 14:04

My husband and I have been together about the same length of time as you, and we’ve always (well, since we moved in together) had a joint account - all money in, bills paid, rest to spend as we want. I’ve seen often on here about having equal spending money but we don’t worry about that - we just buy what we want and to be perfectly honest, if we run short we top up from savings. Probably not a very sensible approach but it’s always worked for us 😄

BrieAndChilli · 26/02/2022 13:53

We have always just shared money ever since we were young and went travelling together.

We used to earn similar amounts but once we started having kids I went part time and into unskilled work that fitted around the kids. DH on the other hand worked up the career ladder and now earns 4 times what I do even though I now work almost full time in a ‘proper’ job.

Our decision to have kids and for me to me at home with them meant my earning potential and career prospects were drastically reduced.
Contributions to family life aren’t just financial, there’s practical (housework, cooking, childcare, errands, admin etc), emotional (making sure kids are happy and healthy), mental (the infamous mental load!!) as well as all the other things that keep family life ticking over - birthday parties, holidays, relationships with extended family etc.
Just having both people contribute lots of money and none of the above means a family won’t flourish. It’s a balancing act and some families need more intangible input, eg if a child has SEN etc.

Alll our money goes into the joint account and all spending comes out of it.

InconvenientPeg · 26/02/2022 13:49

Mainly it just has to be something you're both happy with and keep talking and evolving it.

We've been completely joint since just before we got married nearly 20years ago. We agreed to pool everything and pay ourselves an equal allowance back. It worked til we couldn't afford the allowance! Then we just pooled everything, and I manage the money, so I'd let him know what we had and if there was spare.

For periods I've not worked or worked part time, or I did and he didn't, so it's worked really well but relies heavily on communication. I've only had to pull him up once when due to his expensive hobby we were outstripping our monthly income.

I just got a full time, decently paid job again for the first time in a few years. I've been part time, then full time but low pay for a while. So wondering whether to go back to an allowance, just to allow for presents and things, but I suspect he won't want to, as he just CBA. And if I want to get him something without him knowing I just buy it on the credit card which is in my name so he doesn't see the bill!

Re someone asking about savings, we have investment accounts that we save into each month, the same amount for each, but we regard the money as joint still, even though it's in individual names, and if we ever withdraw any, we have a look at how the accounts are doing and decide which one to take it out of. I've just taken some out for some household purchases so mine is a bit low, so next time we take some out, it will probably be from his. I guess if one of us wanted to spend on something massive, it might be a problem, but we know what we have and our aspirations are similar, so it hasn't caused an issue so far.

TheLoupGarou · 26/02/2022 13:49

We have separate accounts, but all money is family money. We take it in turns to pay for eg: kids activities, DH pays more bills as he earns more but I usually get food shopping, kids clothes/shoes. We revisit it periodically and redistribute bills if it seems unfair (such as when I increased work hours when youngest DC started school)

MayBMaybenot · 26/02/2022 13:45

We don't split our money. We are a team and accept that one member of the team "contributes" slightly more financially, but everything goes into one pot, everything comes out of that pot and we both have a credit card for personal spends. Large purchases such as holidays, new car or recent building work on the house are agreed between us, budgeted for out of that amount and either saved for, or purchased on a cc and and repaid ..... all out of the one pot.

I really do not get this obsessive MN attitude of "you pay x% and I pay y% , I get the rest of mine, you get the rest of yours ....etc etc " its confusing and unnecessary.

BettyBag · 26/02/2022 13:44

@InDubiousBattle

We don't really split family money. Everything in one pot, bills etc come out of it and we both spend what we want/need out of it. We've been together a long time and done it this way since we moved in together at 21!
Same, been together since I was 18 and he was 20. All money was always pooled even before we lived together. Mainly because we had bearly any. Over the years we have both been in positions were we were the higher earner or a non earner, it was still pooled. We both earn a good wage now, I earn more but it all goes into a joint account and we both just use it.
tickingthebox73 · 26/02/2022 13:40

I think its worth remembering that regardless of what each of you earn, if you went into the relationship with similar money and are married it is essentially all your money equally anyway.

It is far easier to pool it all and spend what you need.

figuringoutmylife · 26/02/2022 13:39

Put everything in the same pot and then give each of you a set amount for saving and personal spends. For example, each of you have 250/month towards savings/retirement and 200/month personal spends. Everything else is joint including a joint savings for holidays, long term etc.

You may need some catching up time too.

Good luck!

wouldthatbeworse · 26/02/2022 13:37

This is interesting. We get left with the same % at the end of the month for spending or saving but i earn 3 times more. I’ve worked really hard to get to a senior well paid role private sector , DH is conscientious but plods along in public sector role. I would feel it was unfair if we got the same spending money when I’d put in so much had graft. BUT if never see DH without enough to see mates, do hobbies etc. I also regularly pay for things myself (kids clothes, activities) that should really come from joint account.

ElephantLover · 26/02/2022 13:34

We have a single pot of money which is our joint income. It might sit in various single/joint accounts but that's irrelevant. Everything goes towards expenses and the remaining either savings or pension - again it may be held in one of our accounts but that's not relevant as it will either move into pension (I plan our pension to ups) or will get spent on holiday. Never have done it any other way. I manage all our finances as DH is too busy with work and can't be bothered. Neither of us spend too much on ourselves other than occasional clothes/shoes/snacks etc. No big hobbies or personal expenses to cater to.

As far as planning goes we've always planned with only DH's income as a source of money. I.e.we should be able to live off his income alone (except holidays). Hence my income (which is around 60% of his due to PT) has always been a surplus and helped us save for deposit/holidays/pension to up,
I hope this helps.

MsJuniper · 26/02/2022 13:27

We budget for the same disposable income each. Salaries into our own accounts but put a different amount each into a joint account for bills and food.

Child Benefit goes into my account and I use that to pay for the children's clothes and school lunches.

I tend to organise it all on a spreadsheet and tell DH if there are any changes and we talk through how it's going every once in a while.

RewildingAmbridge · 26/02/2022 13:24

I still earn more btw but not by a huge amount anymore, I don't see it as me subsidising him he works just as hard as I do, does his fair share around the house and also consolidated his hours after my mat leave so we both cover the same amount of weekday childcare, pick ups, drop offs etc

Abouttimemum · 26/02/2022 13:23

We just pool everything into the same account and budget it all for bills, childcare, house jobs we’re doing currently, savings, holiday savings and whatever is left after that we split / use for leisure spends. Sometimes it gets spent and sometimes it doesn’t and whatever is left goes into the savings as well.

This has worked well for us because I’m a firm believer that money works harder when it’s together, and especially with the house, as we had an offset mortgage that we paid off in under 15 years rather than 25 because all of our money was running through the same account.

Whatever works for you though.

TimeForTeaAndG · 26/02/2022 13:23

DH earns massively more than me (I'm PT and he gets an allowance over his salary due to shift work) but all salary goes in the joint account.

All spending on house and DD comes out of that pot. Small house spends (mostly by me) are joint money and larger house things are discussed (probably anything over about £50 but we don't have a set figure, it just feels like that's a reasonable level.

We each get the same amount into our personal accounts and those purchases are not discussed. I buy clothes, DH buys bike and computer parts.

Anything left over in the joint account when pay day rolls around goes either into savings or overpays the mortgage.

It took us a while to get to this point, especially as DH was the only one earning for a while then when DD was born I didn't like to "ask" for money. Our monthly personal amount has evolved in reflection with our increased salaries over the years but at the end of the day it's all family money so it makes sense that we get equal fun money.

RewildingAmbridge · 26/02/2022 13:22

DH and I pay in different amounts that leave us with the same personal spends money, prior to that all bills etc are covered, including groceries etc, spending for DS and saving amounts for both DS and us jointly are set aside. I tend to save a bit from my personal spends and have invested some of it, DS less so but does save a little for himself, he got some shares from a previous severance package that I said to him to keep because they'd treated him pretty poorly, so that felt fair. We both have good pensions.
When we were first together and not married we did the while 50/50 thing then there was a time when I earned considerably more so paid more, but then it transpired I was actually left with less disposable income than he was so we requested to current set up. I like the personal spends thing because I don't get irritated by his hobby spends, as I know I would if it was all coming out of the same pot, it's up to him what he does with that money he can burn it for all I care.

blibblibs · 26/02/2022 13:19

We live on DH wage and save mine.
DH earns 3x what I do so % and splitting wouldn't really work, however we both have the same attitudes to spending so it works.
And even before when wages were much more equal we pooled everything and had equal amounts of 'own' money each month.

Jmaxx44 · 26/02/2022 13:16

We don’t pool money in our household. DH earns about 2x my salary so he pays all household bills, mortgage etc. I buy all our groceries, stuff for kids, gifts etc. It still works out that DH has a fair bit more personal spending money than me every month but we try to live similar lifestyles, i.e neither of us have particularly expensive hobbies or shopping habits. He also will accumulate his extra money and either put it in our joint saving account (our only joint account) or use it for ‘big’ purchases or costs that occur every so often. For example my car needed about £400 of repairs a while back, we bought some new furniture, holidays etc - DH’s extra money usually covers these. It’s very informal but it works well for us, I understand that this approach might not work for couples whose personal spending isn’t as balanced as ours though.

Rewis · 26/02/2022 13:15

I have a question for "one pot" people. Do you take money for your own savings/investments from the joint pot or from the personal spending money (if you divide it like that)? Do you get the same amount? Or do you only have joint savings accounts? Also is there a limit of using the joint account when you have to talk to your spouse about it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread