Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Setting the scene or friend zoned? Friend weird approach to dating.

36 replies

Claddinghell · 26/02/2022 00:15

Guy I am good friends with we always flirt and have a laugh. Nothing has happened between us, but always a flirty vibe. Friends for years. Text multiple times a day and see each other weekly or more.

We are active on dating sites with no luck. Think I have feelings, but not sure if it’s cause I connect with him or fancy him. He ticks the boxes and we enjoy the same things, but I think we have been friends for too long. He went through a traumatic break up early last year which I supported and is starting to date.

Last week he told me he had a fling with a distant mutual female friend months ago. He kept it secret from me. She wanted a relationship and he just wanted a fling. He told me he ended it as this friend was jealous of our friendship. She stopped really interacting with me round this point, but I didn’t really think anything of it, as we were not close and in lockdown. Not sure why he told me. I asked to see the texts and she was horrible about me. She has been friends with him for a while and even been out socialising with us, with no issues.

She Accused him of sleeping with me and trying to stop him seeing me. He was delicate after his break up And I think she took advantage of his needy state and pounced - well he was no angel too.

Apparently she had turned into a mini stalker and would drive past my house and stalk me on Facebook and question him on what we were doing, trying to stop him seeing keg. I always wondered why she also phoned when he was with me.

It ended month before Xmas and he blocked her - was only a few months of seeing each other for sex every 2 weeks or so. She contacted him again at Xmas and went mental even though the hadn’t talked for ages as we spent the day together as friends and she saw this on Facebook. Her mutual friends showed her this.

He has told me yesterday when he goes on dates he always tells people about our friendship. Says I am his most loyal friend and if no one can’t understand it then he doesn’t want to date them. Wants to ensure his dates are happy with a female best friend before anything happens. It’s a bit weird to do this, as if I was the date I wouid be suspicious.

He says a few people have had an issue and as I am important to him, they either accept me or leave or he hasn’t taken it further. I did tell him the other day that if our friendship is stopping him finding happiness then we see less of each other as it will naturally happen. He disagreed. He then joked that in a few years time if we are single we will move in together, life pact.

He has essentially blocked himself from dating because of me. I was starting to think he had feelings, but keeps texting me to say he values me as a friend and I will always be in his life. Always uses the friend word.

So what does this mean? I have distanced myself last day or so as the mini stalking news made me feel uncomfortable. I have never been a threat to others - I am nothing special.

Have I been friend zoned as he has texted me loads to say I am his most valued and respected friend. Sort of mini panic or is he setting the scene? He is not the best as being direct, so sometimes I have to read between the lines.

Help me understand!

OP posts:
BloodyForeland · 26/02/2022 10:37

Why would you fancy someone who sounds like a total drama llama, rather sneaky, and very hard work?

Ask yourself why he keeps withholding and then telling you things — like withholding the fact that he was shagging a mutual friend for months, and that he’d fostered a situation where she was insanely jealous of you, and then telling you afterwards that he’d ended it because of you, and showing you her nasty texts? I notice also that you blame all this on her ‘pouncing’ on him when he was ‘delicate’ after a break up, but he sounds to me like an unpleasant stirrer. You clearly fulfil some need in him as an alibi for ending relationships/
creating drama/setting up bizarre imaginary rivalries, but I don’t think this is at all flattering in the way you clearly think it is.

Friendships shouldn’t be this hard. I have longtime male friends who’ve had their share of relationship disasters without it taking up anywhere near this amount of headspace.

If you don’t want to step away from the friendship, tell him you don’t want to feature in his initial pitch to new dates, because he’s just using you to seem desirable. And the reason he will never become your boyfriend is because this way suits him better.

Planesmistakenforstars · 26/02/2022 10:31

@Claddinghell my guess would be to see if you like him. But it's so underhand and manipulative. The stuff about him letting dates know about you, as if it's some star crossed friendship that no one can come between is so dramatic, bordering on yuck. And I would be seriously questioning his motives in telling you about the fling with your friend. You asked to see the texsts, but presumably because you knew about the texts. Because he told you about them. He didn't care to spare your feelings, did he?

FloraPostIt · 26/02/2022 10:18

In your position my head would be in a mess. I would be questioning what hidden meanings there are, driving my friends crazy banging on about it and generally being obsessed. So I totally get what you are feeling and why you are posting.

But from the outside, it's crystal clear that he is an arse trying to keep you dangling.

I've been dangled by arses in exactly this way twice in my life so know of what I speak.

Both arses are now settled with other women and children. And those oh-so-important friendships? Of no importance once they met 'the one'.

Get a cat, is my advice.

Claddinghell · 26/02/2022 10:17

@Planesmistakenforstars what reaction does he want? For me to confess I like him? Which still processing. These feelings have come through more since he told me.

Or to say we are really good friends? He did say I was very secretive about my dating life. But he never asks and I don’t discuss unless someone asks. I certainly don’t tell my dates that they need to accept him. I just assume they do as he is a friend.

OP posts:
Planesmistakenforstars · 26/02/2022 10:05

He probably tells you all about his loads of dates and how important you are to get a reaction. He might have done the same thing about the fling with your friend. Or he's told you so he gets to control the narrative.

If you've known him all this time and the most romantic thing you can say is that you're unsure if you fancy him, then don't date him. He sounds like a dick who is hard work.

Claddinghell · 26/02/2022 09:55

@newnameforthis76 I think he is. He has been a really good friend for me. But suddenly telling me he tells people I am important to him and will always be in my life. Telling me if he dates others they need to accept me or leave. Not too sure why?

That’s the head mess. I said to him A few weeks ago want a best friend I fancy. Then he hits we with all this you are my most loyal friend etc.

OP posts:
newnameforthis76 · 26/02/2022 09:38

He sounds like a manipulative drama queen playing games with the feelings of every woman he meets, including you.

Claddinghell · 26/02/2022 08:46

@DiddyHeck it is a bit dramatic. He didn’t need to tell me. Not too sure if he did to get a reaction. Or prove he was loyal to me. He is the sort of guy that goes all in with a girlfriend and see him less when he is dating. But didn’t with her.

@AbNormalPeeps suppose it’s just weird that he had started to tell me our friendship comes first above a relationship with others. Why!

@Justilou1 I don’t really to speak to her and I know why now. Not to comfortable asking. People assume as on the surface I supppse we look like a couple as we are comfortable around each other. People always assume.

OP posts:
AbNormalPeeps · 26/02/2022 00:34

You've said you aren't sure of your feelings towards him anyway so why are you so concerned with whether you've been friend zoned or not?

For all his speeches to dates, once he finds someone he's interested in you will almost certainly find your friendship cools off. His priority will be the new girlfriend.

If I were you, rather than second guessing how HE feels why don't you focus on working out your own feelings. Because I agree with PP, it does all sound a bit dramatic for a simple friendship.

Justilou1 · 26/02/2022 00:29

I am always wary of men who claim that someone else stalked them. (Like men who have psycho exes, etc….) It sounds like he is gently coercing you into a relationship you may not be sure of. I would try and get the story from her. You haven’t dated him, you haven’t slept with him. Why are people getting the impression that you have?

DiddyHeck · 26/02/2022 00:23

He sounds like a proper drama queen to be honest.

If he wants to ask you out he needs to grow a pair of balls and do it, rather than telling you all the tittle tattle about his last sexual conquest and that weird speech to prospective girlfriends that they must take your friendship with him or leave etc.

Weird but if you're into him then why don't you ask him out?