Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

would your DS join up

258 replies

mariamari2 · 25/02/2022 22:51

Hypothetical but if you have a DS aged 16-25 would they join up in the event of the government requesting volunteers to go and fight in Ukraine. If they did would you try and stop them. I have hear stories about so many young men in Ukraine volunteering and it got me wondering what would young British men do?

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 26/02/2022 13:51

Totally different issues.

  1. Signing up to.defend the country your living in from attack that is taking place now.
  2. Sign up to defend someone else's country
Confused
SC215 · 26/02/2022 13:50

inews.co.uk/news/world/russia-ukraine-women-volunteers-enlist-ukrainian-army-russia-invasion-threat-escalates-1442651

15% of the Ukrainian army was made up of women before this invasion. There will be more volunteering.

Caranjo · 26/02/2022 13:49

I don't have DC but I would fight for the UK and Finland in whatever way a 52 year old could.

I'm half-Finnish and have many relatives who died fighting Russia, including my grandfather and great-grandfather. I was brought up to be proud of this, that you don't roll over, you fucking go down fighting.

Onlyforcake · 26/02/2022 13:35

Not to be soilders no. Thankfully my children would volunteer as medics or for aid deliveries but would never commit murder even if it was state sanctioned. Borders are fake human creations it's about time more humans said no to war.

SkyrocketAway · 26/02/2022 13:30

I'm a single mum so I wouldn't go out fighting if it means leaving my child. I would want to he with her. If I had to defend her, of course I would.

I've seen this around on twitter, Instagram, Facebook etc. It's a joke but I sort of have the same sentiment. I don't want to be drafted the same as men.

Not that I would be, due to health reasons.

would your DS join up
SkyrocketAway · 26/02/2022 13:26

But yes there are women in the Ukrainian army

SkyrocketAway · 26/02/2022 13:25

Sorry, seen it answered Blush

SkyrocketAway · 26/02/2022 13:25

Why only sons? Lots of women in the army, would anyone's daughter want to fight for, not even Ukraine, but their own country?

SC215 · 26/02/2022 13:22

@User7497521

It's only males in Ukraine so that's probably why OP said males

No, women are allowed to join the army and have been encouraged to learn how to shoot a gun etc over the last few months.

Lubeyboobyalt · 26/02/2022 13:07

I don't have a DS but I'd love to myself if my family didn't depend on me financially. I'm too old for the army (unless through the medical route like doctor, nurse, radiologist etc) but Ukraine are taking volunteer fighters and dishing out weapons.

I think under 21 is too young though, I'd discourage any dc younger than that from trying it

CulturePigeon · 26/02/2022 13:01

I don't think any government would request volunteers. If people do it off their own bat, that's one thing but I can't see a government urging them to do so.

As for general conscription, no-one likes that - least of all the armed forces. They don't want a load of untrained, unfit randoms if they can possibly avoid it, so I don't see any chance of conscription in the near future unless this escalates to an armageddon scenario.

52andblue · 26/02/2022 12:49

@Tomnooktoldmeto

DS was an army cadet, loved it but would be rejected from the forces on at least 3 counts. (ADHD Coeliac and colour blind) He’s a lovely lad but would never survive a war so I’m grateful he wouldn’t be accepted
My DS was an Army Cadet. He loved it buy was bullied by both other Cadets (& some staff!) sadly. He is ideal 'canon fodder' (rule bound, good attention to detail, exceptionally obedient, brave in a crisis) but his Asperger's means he is unlikely to be accepted or called up. My Dd is the same. They'd both go. Thank God they can't. I cried when I read the news article on the lone 21 y/o soldier defending a footbridge in Kyiv today.
OhWhyNot · 26/02/2022 12:19

No I don’t think young British men would do the same

We haven’t lived under threat so dot not feel the same way

If we felt genuine threat for years and years from Russia then yet many would be signing up

ukborn · 26/02/2022 12:06

Yes. He wanted to join the marines at 16. I managed to convince him to finish his education first.

VelvetChairGirl · 26/02/2022 11:47

[quote Porcupineintherough]@VelvetChairGirl actually many rich mens sons died in WW1 and 2. Go up to Eton and look at the In memoriam boards sometime.

Did it ever occur to you that when people fought for their country they were often not fighting for fat politicians but for their family, friends and neighbours? You might be totally chill with watching your neighbours being rounded up and sent east to be gassed, maybe it wouldnt have bothered your grandad, my grandparents actually did do it. Fucked if I'd stand by and let it happen to mine though.[/quote]
What good does it do sending kids to be bullet sponges, the knew full well they were sending kids to die deliberately with shit equipment and fuck all training because why waste money and resources on the walking dead.

I'll trust my grandfather thank you he was there and got a medal in that farce.( also got his stuff nicked by the commanding officers)

BooksAndHooks · 26/02/2022 10:55

Not a chance, but my eldest wouldn’t be eligible anyway.

Didioverstep · 26/02/2022 10:53

Mine aren't old enough. But if it was to defend the country where we live and work and have family I think yes they would. But my dh has done so in the past as his younger self. But he didn't have a choice. His home country has national service. He is 45 and was unlucky when his time came and was up in the mountains. He has many a scar from bullets and was very lucky to not have been killed. Not sure my kids could cope with it but who knows what they are like 15 years from now

Porcupineintherough · 26/02/2022 10:49

@Justkeeppedaling he turned 16 a couple of weeks ago so yeah they'd need to be coming up the street before I handed him a gun. I'd go sooner, or more likely dh would, if there was any chance that civilians in their 50s would be likely to be of any practical help.

Angrymum22 · 26/02/2022 10:49

DS did history GCSE, I wasn’t aware of just how much he learnt and retained about the political history of the 20th century particularly the Cold War, until the Ukrainian situation started.
I am confident that he wouldn’t entertain joining up to fight. He’s a critical thinker and doesn’t believe that war solves problems.

Porcupineintherough · 26/02/2022 10:45

@VelvetChairGirl actually many rich mens sons died in WW1 and 2. Go up to Eton and look at the In memoriam boards sometime.

Did it ever occur to you that when people fought for their country they were often not fighting for fat politicians but for their family, friends and neighbours? You might be totally chill with watching your neighbours being rounded up and sent east to be gassed, maybe it wouldnt have bothered your grandad, my grandparents actually did do it. Fucked if I'd stand by and let it happen to mine though.

Justkeeppedaling · 26/02/2022 10:42

@Porcupineintherough

Only one of mine is old enough. He wouldn't volunteer to fight in Ukraine, I guess he might if the Russians invade the UK (obviously that's not happening but we are being hypothetical). I would probably volunteer too if that were the case. He wouldnt pass the physical for conscription on multiple counts so I dont worry that the army would take him against his will.

Not picking on you as others have said similar, including my own DD, but how close to the U.K. would the Ruskies have to be before people would consider joining up?
If they take Ukraine and move on through to the Baltic counties then down towards the U.K. - at what point do we start mustering an army?

Ukraine left it too late. They are conscripting people now, after the invasion. They should have been signing people up months ago and training them - this invasion hasn't exactly been out of the blue.

Seasidemumma77 · 26/02/2022 10:42

My 17yr old ds is currently doing his phase1 training in the army. He will complete his phase2 training a few weeks before his 18th birthday. I support all my dc's career choices. I am proud of the commitment and determination that this ds has shown to reach even this far in the army.

AnakinthePadawhine · 26/02/2022 10:34

IF, and I mean IF, the UK is under attack from Russia, I cannot imagine that people able to fight (men or women) could stay in good conscience cowering like craven shit muttering how their country does not deserve it. Because let me tell you, if power goes to Russia and its government, those chickenshits would be the first to be considered a waste of resource, or maybe they would become collabo to save their own skin.

User7497521 · 26/02/2022 10:30

It's completely different if the tanks are rolling down your own high street or warplanes are flying above, probably many would defend their country then

Porcupineintherough · 26/02/2022 10:24

Only one of mine is old enough. He wouldn't volunteer to fight in Ukraine, I guess he might if the Russians invade the UK (obviously that's not happening but we are being hypothetical). I would probably volunteer too if that were the case. He wouldnt pass the physical for conscription on multiple counts so I dont worry that the army would take him against his will.