Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

would your DS join up

258 replies

mariamari2 · 25/02/2022 22:51

Hypothetical but if you have a DS aged 16-25 would they join up in the event of the government requesting volunteers to go and fight in Ukraine. If they did would you try and stop them. I have hear stories about so many young men in Ukraine volunteering and it got me wondering what would young British men do?

OP posts:
SirChenjins · 26/02/2022 17:56

If you mean, would he fight for our country if we were invaded then yes - although he has a heart condition so I don’t think they’d have him fortunately. If you mean would he fight for Ukraine then no. Otoh I am beyond furious with Putin and it’s a good job I have children I don’t want to leave without a mum otherwise I’d be over there.

Highwind · 26/02/2022 17:52

No children but I am 30(ish) and able-bodied. I wouldn’t go and fight in another country (unless conscripted) but if we were invaded I would take up arms.

RobotValkyrie · 26/02/2022 17:48

Nope. I'd instruct them very firmly that they have their whole life ahead of them, and I'd be extremely disappointed if they didn't live it to the fullest. And that their lovely nerdy brains are way to valuable to be spilled on a battlefield. And that if anyone had to die for this country or another, it would be me, not them.

Seriously. Given the way modern wars are fought (high tech equipment requiring more brains than brawls), it makes zero sense to send inexperienced, emotionally vulnerable youngsters to the battle front. Let them live.

worriedmum2022 · 26/02/2022 17:34

My grandpa is of the generation where all young men were called up for national service
Although the current situation is awful - the concept of national service reduces unemployment and gives people a trade/ training and reduces crime in poorer areas and gave young men from deprived areas a chance

Yeahthat · 26/02/2022 17:21

@TyrannosaurusRegina

They didn't struggle to recruit young men to sign up for Iraq and Afghanistan, fighting in far-flung regions with little to do with them.

In the case of an existential threat to this country, they would easily recruit young men to fight.

5128gap · 26/02/2022 17:16

@TyrannosaurusRegina

Men are a different breed in Ukraine. I doubt many young men here would be brave enough to sign up for hand to hand combat.
And what about you? Are you going to be queuing up? Or just sitting their snug and smug, shaming young men for hypothetically not being brave enough to risk their lives? Young men here are our sons and partners. Don't talk about their lives like it's a game of chicken.
Trainbear · 26/02/2022 16:39

What makes you think ylthey would be safe if they did not defend their country and were defeated? The defeated french were enslaved by the Nazis. Young men were sent to wonk in nazi factories.

Bumpsadaisie · 26/02/2022 16:33

If the Russians were rolling up the A6 in tanks towards my little town in south Cumbria, then yes, I would hope my DH and my DS would fight and indeed I would fight too, I can learn to shoot a gun, or if I didn't fight I would help get the elderly and the young to safety.

I think it becomes simple at that point.

More complex is when your loved ones are fighting elsewhere. We have family members who were army officers in the Afghan conflict. My sister in law was a captain in Afghan who led a platoon of soldiers searching for mines and bombs in Helmand, during the fighting. We didn't sleep well until her tour of duty was over and praise God she came home safe.

If my son wanted to go into the army I would be worried but very proud and I wouldn't stop him, if having thought seriously about it, he was still committed.

weegiemum · 26/02/2022 15:39

My ds is 20 and very worked up about the whole thing, but I'm not sure his mental health would allow him in the forces at the moment, he's had a tough couple of years.

If it were our country I'd find it very hard. My kids are 18 (dd2), 20 (ds) and 22 (dd1). Personally I'd be most afraid of dd2, she's little but fierce! I've been a pacifist all my life and would find my children fighting to be awful beyond thinking. My dh is 51 and a doctor, so likely they'd want him too. If we lived in Ukraine id be set to lose them all. I'm so badly disabled I wouldn't make it to a bomb shelter without them to help me.

I don't pray much any more, but I'm praying for Ukraine right now. And for the brave Russians who are out on the street protesting the war.

OhWhyNot · 26/02/2022 15:28

I think we are certainly privileged in this country that we can choose to be pacifists

That isn’t really a choice in many other countries (unless your money allows you to be)

DearlyBeloathed · 26/02/2022 15:14

The only reason people like yourself can fart around with such naive and stupid ideas is because other people are prepared to do the hard work which enables you to live with such a self-indulgent and decadent mindset

Bang on.

OhWhyNot · 26/02/2022 15:02

I think Ukraine has quite a large number of women in their military

But what we have seen on tv is young men declaring that they will fight for their country and returning to fight for their country

It’s not about equality it’s what is being reported

Moody123 · 26/02/2022 14:48

Why just DS what about DDs... I think people forget equality at times like this !

megletthesecond · 26/02/2022 14:48

He wouldn't want to and he carries an epi-pen which appears to disqualify him.

Fizio · 26/02/2022 14:45

@Onlyforcake what a horrible way to put it - ‘commit murder’. DH has been to Kosovo, Afghanistan and Iraq, and who knows where next. DF was in the Falklands. Nobody comes back from these places unaffected by the things they have seen or done, but they are putting their lives on the line for the freedom of others. Don’t tar them with the ‘committing murder’ brush while you enjoy the comforts and freedoms of the life indirectly provided to you by those who have committed said murders.

Yeahthat · 26/02/2022 14:41

@StormBaby

Same goes for you.

Yeahthat · 26/02/2022 14:39

@Onlyforcake

Not to be soilders no. Thankfully my children would volunteer as medics or for aid deliveries but would never commit murder even if it was state sanctioned. Borders are fake human creations it's about time more humans said no to war.
Lol

I wonder if it would all seem like a "fake human creation" if Russian (or Chinese) soldiers were marching in with kill lists, in order to install a puppet government.

Borders are fake - if you're happy to be governed by anyone. You can have your toxic passivity, until someone stronger decides to march in and take over.

The only reason people like yourself can fart around with such naive and stupid ideas is because other people are prepared to do the hard work which enables you to live with such a self-indulgent and decadent mindset.

TyrannosaurusRegina · 26/02/2022 14:21

Men are a different breed in Ukraine. I doubt many young men here would be brave enough to sign up for hand to hand combat.

PferdeMerde · 26/02/2022 14:18

Would your DD join up?

Riverlee · 26/02/2022 14:15

I was somewhat and surprised when on Thursday, ie. Day 1 of the invasion, ds started talking to me about the possibly of conscription. He was adamant he didn’t want to do it.

(Not sure how he would have felt if it were the UK being invaded).

AnneElliott · 26/02/2022 14:11

Signing up to fight in Ukraine - no. If it was happening here and we needed to defend our county then probably yes.

Although I would volunteer before him as I can actually load a gun and am not a bad shot.

TheLoupGarou · 26/02/2022 14:11

My children are far too young (and we are in NI and have Irish passports), but I can't imagine the horror of conscription. If it came to it I suppose we would all have to do what was needed.

StormBaby · 26/02/2022 14:10

I’ve raised mine to all be pacifists so I highly doubt it.

DearlyBeloathed · 26/02/2022 13:55

Thankfully my children would volunteer as medics or for aid deliveries but would never commit murder even if it was state sanctioned

Hmm
Hankunamatata · 26/02/2022 13:54

If your asking if we lived in Ukraine and my adult children - women and men wanted to sign up to defend their country. I would go with what they wanted to do. It's not my place to dictate my grown up childrens decisions.