Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

would your DS join up

258 replies

mariamari2 · 25/02/2022 22:51

Hypothetical but if you have a DS aged 16-25 would they join up in the event of the government requesting volunteers to go and fight in Ukraine. If they did would you try and stop them. I have hear stories about so many young men in Ukraine volunteering and it got me wondering what would young British men do?

OP posts:
CPL593H · 26/02/2022 20:34

@listsandbudgets. I have to know why you made napalm.

listsandbudgets · 26/02/2022 20:23

@Gasfire

Well, if mumsnet is representative of the whole country, most of the dc would have asd, adhd, dyspraxia or anxiety, so wouldn't be eligible anyway.

Rest easy.

Well as it happens, I'm dyspraxic Grin However this could be put to good use because no one would ever be able to anticipate what I was about to do. It has been said that if I'm playing darts the safest place to stand is right in front of the dart board. I also know how to make napalm and molotov cocktails (the first I've done the second only in theory) and have some small knowledge of deadly poisons so I suppose I may have a purpose. I've never actually USED that knowledge by the way though certainly been sorely tempted at times.

DD is 16 and appears to have a deep interest in biological warfare Hmm - in fact she's talking about joining the forces so she can develop her interest in biochemistry! I'm a bit scared of DD sometimes Grin

DP is a crack shot and calm in a crisis so I fear he'd be in the front line taking people out but he's also a great cryptographer and linguist so perhaps he'd find himself elsewhere?

DS is 9 so guess he's out of the running.

lljkk · 26/02/2022 20:20

Latara -- I can recommend Kate Adey's autobiography if you like her. She had a long journey, strangling rabbits, local radio, Royal Correspondent, then cut her teeth in streets of Northern Ireland, not what you'd imagine as background to foreign war correspondent.

My eldest is in Brit Army. He will think strategically about Ukraine / containing Russia, not act with his heart. I don't think other DC are idealistic, wouldn't rush to defend another country.

Thatsplentyjack · 26/02/2022 20:06

Mine are only 13 and 8 but I know them both well enough to know they would both be determined to go. I would try everything I could to convince them not to.

Latara · 26/02/2022 20:05

@SiobhanSharpe I believe Sweden is quickly introducing conscription as it's neutrality is being threatened by Putin.

Latara · 26/02/2022 20:02

I'm 45 yr old woman with epilepsy & Schizoaffective disorder. But I would be happy to join up if the UK was invaded.
When I was a young girl I thought about joining the army before I realised they don't take people with epilepsy. But they wouldn't exactly be fussy in an national emergency!!

My great gran Lily was one of the first female soldiers aged 21 in the WAAC sent to France in 1917 to support the male troops in Ww1.
My Nan Rita was an ARP messenger aged 15 during the Blitz, delivering messages on her bicycle between ARP posts during bombing raids.
My other Nan Dorothy drove buses during the Ww2 without a proper driving license.

And did you know that during 1940 there was actually a 'Mum's Army' of women who were housewives trained by soldiers in the Uk to fight should the Germans invade?

The job I envy at present though is that of war correspondent... I always secretly wanted to be the next Kate Adie but was too shy to get into journalism. However I wouldn't wish to end up like the late Marie Colvin, a brave lady.

SiobhanSharpe · 26/02/2022 19:58

www.dfa.ie/our-role-policies/international-priorities/peace-and-security/neutrality/
Ireland does indeed have an official policy of neutrality in alliances and conflicts, for those who asked. Much like Switzerland and Sweden.

EthelTheAardvark · 26/02/2022 19:41

Yes, it sounds incredibly arrogant to suggest that “Nerdy” should be spared, not “ Wasted”

Every mother’s son is equally valuable.

But that is exactly the point that @RobotValkyrie was making! Quote:

Given the way modern wars are fought (high tech equipment requiring more brains than brawls), it makes zero sense to send inexperienced, emotionally vulnerable youngsters to the battle front. Let them live

So why accuse her of being arrogant when she is making the same point as you?

DearlyBeloathed · 26/02/2022 19:34

[quote Yeahthat]@oakleaffy

Exactly. Not to mention that if they were Alan Turing level geniuses as she seems to think, they'd be used somewhere appropriate.[/quote]
Yep.

Yeahthat · 26/02/2022 19:17

@oakleaffy

Exactly. Not to mention that if they were Alan Turing level geniuses as she seems to think, they'd be used somewhere appropriate.

Crimesean · 26/02/2022 18:19

My brother is in the army. I'd try and lock him in a cupboard if the UK was invaded.

DS is only little, but same applies

oakleaffy · 26/02/2022 18:13

@AmosBear

lovely nerdy brains too valuable to he spilled on the battlefield

Because they are nerdy? I'm not sure you meant to this way, but this implies there are certain people with brains that aren't supposedly valuable enough to not be spilled on the battlefield. It makes it sound like "you're smart so it would be a waste", and that it's less of a waste for other people who perhaps are not as nerdy or smart...

Yes, it sounds incredibly arrogant to suggest that “Nerdy” should be spared, not “ Wasted”

Every mother’s son is equally valuable.

Never forget that.

EthelTheAardvark · 26/02/2022 18:12

I remember one of those programmes about one of the military colleges where they sat the recruits down and told them to make their wills and write goodbye letters. At that point one of them said it brought home to him how real the risk of death there was and he said he wasn't prepared to lose his entire future. He made it clear that that related to this specific situation, and he wouldn't resist if he were conscripted or the country needed to be defended.

To the credit of his superiors, they sat down and talked it through with him, and then let him leave with their blessing. They more or less said it was a view he was fully entitled to take and they respected him for being brave enough to speak up rather than carry on out of fear of embarrassment.

Alyssasbackrolls · 26/02/2022 18:10

I don't think the Ukrainian army telling those 18-60 young men fleeing at the border yesterday, with or without family were checking on anything like medical status or autism or any other factor. It was "turn around, go back, you're not going any further. You're needed to fight"

That's war. It's horrific. I have teenage sons and one is (yes very Mumsnet) autistic. I actually think he'd be alright and he's a crack shot with air guns and clays. My more sensitive neurotypical son would find it harder. Of course it would be traumatic for us all. Ukrainian young men do not have a choice. Why do you think our sons would?

oakleaffy · 26/02/2022 18:09

@sadpapercourtesan

No, cos I'd break his ankles first Grin

Just kidding. No, mine wouldn't volunteer to fight in Ukraine. Why on earth would they? They're not soldiers.

If in some hypothetical parallel universe the tanks were rolling down our local high street, then I imagine we would all do what we could.

Yes, I’d be trying to defend our area should it be invaded, too ( Hypothetically) A Ukrainian woman gave a Russian soldier “ What for” and he seemed quite calm. I wonder how many Russian men are really keen on invading? They are just pawns in Putin’s power play, while Putin is “ Safe” in his Kremlin palace.
moretrumpetplease · 26/02/2022 18:08

I'd go in a heartbeat, as would my DSis and DBro. DDad too old, or he'd be away this weekend.

EthelTheAardvark · 26/02/2022 18:07

DS did think fairly seriously about joining the navy at one point. It wasn't a time when conflict was specifically likely, but of course we were all well aware that he could find himself in dangerous situations at relatively short notice. We were fairly neutral about it: we could see benefits to him of regular secure employment, getting a lot of training in some very useful skills, and clocking up working experience which was likely to be viewed as valuable throughout his life. On the other hand, he was never very good at dealing with activities that he regarded as pointless (and therefore probably wouldn't have copied with drills etc) and I wasn't sure how he would take the discipline involved.

Ultimately he decided against, and I won't pretend I wasn't relieved. DSIL's son by her first marriage was in the army, and she's been through some awful times when she dreaded opening the door or answering the phone.

Svara · 26/02/2022 18:06

No, my DS will be 16 in a few months and I would take his place if I could. I'm a fit and healthy woman under 40 and I think I would cope better in a crisis than him.

Yeahthat · 26/02/2022 18:05

@RobotValkyrie

Nope. I'd instruct them very firmly that they have their whole life ahead of them, and I'd be extremely disappointed if they didn't live it to the fullest. And that their lovely nerdy brains are way to valuable to be spilled on a battlefield. And that if anyone had to die for this country or another, it would be me, not them.

Seriously. Given the way modern wars are fought (high tech equipment requiring more brains than brawls), it makes zero sense to send inexperienced, emotionally vulnerable youngsters to the battle front. Let them live.

If anyone tried the cowardly, "I'm too much of a special snowflake to fight for the survival of my own country" that you're suggesting here, then I'd hope that they would be handed a rifle and barred from leaving, just as Ukraine has done for all fighting age men.

If there's an existentialist threat to your country and you refuse to do your part, you deserve to be reviled.

How dare anyone expect to live off other people's sacrifices while doing nothing.

AffIt · 26/02/2022 18:02

This is one of the reasons why countries such as Greece, Israel and Korea impose national service on all young people: not to turn them all into front-line killers, but so they have a baseline 'muscle memory' and can take on certain roles at short notice, such as operations, medics, catering etc, which are of use at a population level.

Squirrelblanket · 26/02/2022 18:01

My husband is 53 and says he would volunteer for it.

AmosBear · 26/02/2022 18:01

lovely nerdy brains too valuable to he spilled on the battlefield

Because they are nerdy? I'm not sure you meant to this way, but this implies there are certain people with brains that aren't supposedly valuable enough to not be spilled on the battlefield. It makes it sound like "you're smart so it would be a waste", and that it's less of a waste for other people who perhaps are not as nerdy or smart...

Nanny0gg · 26/02/2022 17:59

@RobotValkyrie

Nope. I'd instruct them very firmly that they have their whole life ahead of them, and I'd be extremely disappointed if they didn't live it to the fullest. And that their lovely nerdy brains are way to valuable to be spilled on a battlefield. And that if anyone had to die for this country or another, it would be me, not them.

Seriously. Given the way modern wars are fought (high tech equipment requiring more brains than brawls), it makes zero sense to send inexperienced, emotionally vulnerable youngsters to the battle front. Let them live.

I think we would be very much in need of 'nerdy brains' rather than brawn

My father was in WWII but he was admin not fighting

Nanny0gg · 26/02/2022 17:58

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

So much for Dunkirk spirit

That was 80 years ago. Maybe we live in a world where people want peace? Wars are generally started by old men. The younger generation seem much more anti war.

What if there isn't much of a choice?

Clearly not all people want peace so sadly sometimes the only way to defend it is to fight.

LondonQueen · 26/02/2022 17:57

What about our DD's? Surely in an "equal world" me and DD should be conscripted too...