Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School providing e-books and no paper books for Reception

213 replies

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 17:00

My DS is in reception year and the school provide his reading books via an app and ask that children read them on an electronic device, iPad, phone or e-reader.

I have been purchasing the books, if the library don't have them (which they usually don't). This is too costly and also causes a delay, as by the time we get the book my DS has been moved on to another.

I guess my AIBU is, AIBU to refuse to allow him to read on a device and just provide books of the same level (from the library) so he can read a real book? I have emailed the school and message his teacher directly but had no response from either. I've even drawn a blank from the PTA.

OP posts:
Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:15

@toomuchlaundry

Why did you contact the PTA?

I assume it is to do with budgets.

Some of our local schools have had their book budgets cut to zero as they were in deficit budget. Complain to your MP

The schools Headteacher attends the PTA meetings and my role is to apply for funding via grants/corporate funding and so I took my idea of funding to purchase real books to the Headteacher via this platform as I wasn't getting a reply any other way.

Contacting local MP is a good idea, I'll see if I can get a response from the school first. I'd rather keep a good relationship with them if possible.

OP posts:
Nix32 · 25/02/2022 18:14

@OfstedOffred It's a DFE approved provider which is having a very positive impact on the children. The 3 reading sessions have three different purposes, it's not about learning the book by rote. Please don't discredit something without knowing the details. The vast majority of my time in school is spent teaching phonics and reading; to have it dismissed is really demoralising.

DePfeffoff · 25/02/2022 18:13

Out of sheer curiosity, what happens if the family in question simply doesn't have screens at home at all or if, say, the only screens the parents have are phones which they need for work? Would the school provide them?

And what if they are only phones? It seems really undesirable for children to be trying to practise reading from a tiny screen.

toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2022 18:13

School reading books were always a very small part of the books we read at home with DC

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:13

@PAFMO

I know screens are bad, I'm a teacher. But e-readers aren't screens in the computer-screen way. Don't get me wrong, I still prefer books. But e-readers are a great leveller as books are far more affordable for everyone. I'd prefer some of our parents limit screen time by removing the Xbox or Nintendo rather than the Kindle tbh.
We don't have screens at home, a very old iPad that we occasionally use to find a clip of something but no consoles etc. I have a phone (that I use for mumsnet! Smile) and that's it. I know screens will come but I will avoid them for as long as I can due to the many valid reasons already mentioned
OP posts:
chiiipsandsalad · 25/02/2022 18:13

And yes I think you would be unreasonable to refuse to engage with e-reading for this purpose.

chiiipsandsalad · 25/02/2022 18:11

I think you are making a bigger issue of it than it needs to be. If this is the way the school has decided to do reading books, and you can't get the hard copy easily I don't know what else you can do?

It's just the school reading books, not all books.

You can still enjoy proper books at home and from the library.

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:09

@ThunderSnowDrop

Tbh I would complain using reasons mentioned in previous posts. However I'd do what was asked but at the minimum level. Longer term I'd just focus on reading being something done primarily outside of school with real books as tbh the school books and methods in our experience were not that engaging.
Thank you, I was trying to avoid complaining officially but I may have to if I keep getting ignored by the school
OP posts:
Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:08

@HenceThus this exactly

OP posts:
Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:07

[quote Nix32]@MintJulia It's not that easy. I have approximately 30 books that the children might read in one term - which one I give them depends on their progress, I wouldn't be able to tell you in advance.[/quote]
Yes I do completely understand that, in the same way that I hope my DS's teacher understands that I can't magic a book up in 24hrs, even if I buy it, delivery will still take a few days at least. I did buy his first few books and he'd moved on within days and by the time we got the book he'd jumped 2 ahead.........

OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2022 18:06

Some schools share teachers, especially if in a Trust, so may have a teacher beaming into a number of schools at a time. Again it is mainly to do with funding, but also sharing expertise.

How big a school is it @Mummyoply?

okthx · 25/02/2022 18:06

You are not being unreasonable. Please do what’s best for your child. Reading books from electronic screen is NOT best for this age

GreenNewDealNow · 25/02/2022 18:06

Many jobs involve looking at a screen all day and the government wants to push STEM subjects as they lead to better paid jobs in the future, so in a way they are being trained to tolerate a lot of screen time which may benefit them in the long run. I don't particularly like it either but if that is the form the future economy takes then maybe it has it's pluses.

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:04

@MintJulia

It's really bad for their eyes.

I'd ask the Head for a list of the books they will need each term and order paper versions in advance.

My DS does have an eye condition, I was planning on asking his consultant about the reading situation at his next appointment which is only a few weeks away.
OP posts:
Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:03

@BogRollBOGOF

Reading books, actual books is important. There is an order of reading direction to understand (which may be harder in ND children) and there is fine motor control in turning pages. The more children use fine motor control, the better stamina they have for developing writing. So many children have spent too much of the past couple of years living a 2D experience on screens. Reading off backlit screens is more visual stress.

E-readers have their uses, but it's a bloody stupid policy to deprive new readers from access to books.

Annoyingly, you'll probably have to give in because of the volume of books children get through in the early stages of reading. Worth making you concerns known though.

Thank you @BogRollBOGOF I really resonate with your reply
OP posts:
Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:02

@ChildrenGrowingUpTooFast

I had a subscription to reading chest and it was brilliant. But I'll use that to supplement the school's reading. YABU to not use a tablet if you have one. They are getting a lot of maths homework via tablet apps too. And the amazon fire tablets don't work because they aren't on the apple or google app store.
A 4 year old reading on a tablet doesn't sit well with me, there is a lot of research that recommends children are not taught in this way. The school already have their in-school maths lesson on the 'big screen' as well as their music lessons. It feels like in-person activities are being water down.
OP posts:
SnowFlo · 25/02/2022 18:00

School books will not provide that connection.

That depends. Maybe if they just do their phonics book. Mine have 3 books and one is chosen from the library by the kid. Last week mine chose a book about Gray bats and issues with declining populations and subsequent conservation methods, she really enjoyed learning about it and learning new words etc. This week she's chosen one about lions, which she love (because they love the Lion King films and the Lion Guard TV show). School books don't just have to be their reading scheme books, but I guess some schools don't have the resources to give each child more than that each week. I mean, some can't even provide the reading scheme books anymore Sad. Schools desperately need more funding! They should be able to provide paper books and more than just one imo.

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 17:59

@SnowFlo

I don't know what I'd do in your situation. Give in, I suppose, even though I would be really unhappy about it!

I couldn't afford/find all the books they need in hard-copy. My DD is in Year 1 and they bring 3 reading books home and change them every week. One boom is at their level and it's working with the scheme the school uses, the second book is a book that will challenge them and is a level above their reading level, and the third book is one the child has chosen themselves from the school library.

Does your school send home hard copies of books? I won't 'give in' but I do absolutely want to find a solution. I really thought the library would be it, but they just don't stock the books.....

I asked the school for a list of a terms worth of books so I could pre-order, try and get them but they said they couldn't give this to me as the list will Change depending on pace of development. Which I do find odd as they won't push my DS to a higher level of reading or any other subject, even though they acknowledge his capabilities, it's all a bit odd.....but I'm happy if he's happy and I'd rather he wasn't overwhelmed so I'm happy to go with the school on that one.

OP posts:
OfstedOffred · 25/02/2022 17:59

The phonics scheme we use specifies that the book should be read 3 times in school and then sent home. The idea is that the child will be reading it fluently by the time it comes home

This is really really poor practice and suggests reliance on memorizing whole words through repetition. Fluency in decoding comes in time with practice decoding new words, not through repetition of the same book!!!

tothemoonandbackbuses · 25/02/2022 17:57

You could print the books out at home. Or if you know the scheme you may be able to buy the books in advance. Or just pick a different phonic scheme where you can buy the books and use that

toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2022 17:57

If you are an expert at getting grants maybe signpost your school to this

www.foylefoundation.org.uk/how-to-apply/state-schools.php

OfstedOffred · 25/02/2022 17:56

'fidelity to the scheme' is the new buzzphrase in phonics pedagogy right now. We've had to bin loads of books that can no longer be sent home since they are older and therefore do not represent 'fidelity to the scheme'

Tbf I think a lot of schools are seriously misinterpreting the reading framework on this though, theres this idea you must only have books from ons publisher. In reality the government would like you to bin all your old books that are non decodable, heavily relying on mindless repetition of key words etc (reading champions I'm looking at you!!). But a school with a selection of decent phonics scheme books should find they are all consistent with letters and sounds and basically proceed through phase 2/3/4/5 in the same way - big cat phonics, Pearson phonics bug, songbirds etc, shouldn't have a problem dipping in and out of different publishers.

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 17:54

@Nix32

The phonics scheme we use specifies that the book should be read 3 times in school and then sent home. The idea is that the child will be reading it fluently by the time it comes home. If you give him an alternative, he won't be benefiting from the reading he's already done at school. It's worth asking why they've chosen to do it this way. I know I'm gutted by the number of books that have come back to school damaged, or not returned at all.
Thank you, yes I have asked several times but no response from the school yet. We are lucky that my DS can read to a higher level than school are teaching him. He can read the books they give him independently and apply the correct phonics. He reads at a higher level at home, however, he is young and I think as all the children 'level out' he won't always have this to fall back on and will need to read the schools set books at home to progress, it's just a question of, how? How can I do this without using a device?
OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2022 17:51

Do you know how much a set of class reading books would cost?

Do the school have a phonics scheme?

00100001 · 25/02/2022 17:51

YABU

To can get him a million print books at home