Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School providing e-books and no paper books for Reception

213 replies

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 17:00

My DS is in reception year and the school provide his reading books via an app and ask that children read them on an electronic device, iPad, phone or e-reader.

I have been purchasing the books, if the library don't have them (which they usually don't). This is too costly and also causes a delay, as by the time we get the book my DS has been moved on to another.

I guess my AIBU is, AIBU to refuse to allow him to read on a device and just provide books of the same level (from the library) so he can read a real book? I have emailed the school and message his teacher directly but had no response from either. I've even drawn a blank from the PTA.

OP posts:
AdriannaP · 25/02/2022 19:38

It doesn’t matter if he reads the school books or not, just get books of the same level from the library or you get tons of Chip and Biffs from ebay. As long as he reads he will be fine. My DC doesn’t read the school books but reads lots of library books and is an excellent reader.

CuteOrangeElephant · 25/02/2022 19:36

I wouldn't like this either OP, we are a tech heavy household but my 4 year old DD does not have a tablet or anything like that and I refuse to buy one for her.

If school would refuse to send out physical books I would still read with her, but with books from the library. If that doesn't have complete fidelity to the scheme, tough titties.

SkyrocketAway · 25/02/2022 19:32

In YR it’s only recommended to be 10 mins

We always got two books in YR though. 10 mins would be the phonics book, but they also bring home a library book which is just a normal book. We wouldn't read both every time, and it's not expected they read the library book themselves, but it's supposed to be something they've chosen that you look at together, they can attempt words or simpler sentences, or simply be exposed to a wider vocab or different type of text while looking through with you, or just learn things (if they choose non-fiction) e.g. mine chose a lot of science books about dinosaurs and insects. One time DS chose a library book that was about classification in the natural world. So it shouldn't be a chore, because the second book is one that they've chosen due to taking an interest in it during the library trip. The purpose of those books is supposed to be to encourage reading for enjoyment/their own interests, hence them choosing.

So it could be 10 mins, it could be more.

Jadecarrot · 25/02/2022 19:30

Is it little wandle scheme? We have the same If so

LuisaLove · 25/02/2022 19:27

YABVU

TheSnowyOwl · 25/02/2022 19:24

@SkyrocketAway

Reading books sent home from school is what, 10 minutes a day

Far more than that here. Some of the books can't be read in 10 mins. Entirely depends on the school.

In YR it’s only recommended to be 10 mins. Even if they enjoy reading, you don’t want to turn it into a chore.
TheSnowyOwl · 25/02/2022 19:24

We’ve had the best part of two years of having to rely on electronic books due to the pandemic. It’s fine once you get into it. It’s a little like switching from real books to a Kindle.

SkyrocketAway · 25/02/2022 19:22

Reading books sent home from school is what, 10 minutes a day

Far more than that here. Some of the books can't be read in 10 mins. Entirely depends on the school.

drpet49 · 25/02/2022 19:19

I wouldn’t like this either OP

BlingLoving · 25/02/2022 19:17

I honestly can't understand why everyone is so het about this. The important thing is that the children are READING. Reading books sent home from school is what, 10 minutes a day? That much "screen time" is not going to do them any harm and, if you use a kindle or similar it isn't even the same as actual screen time. One of the issues with reading on a screen is that there's less blinking etc, but in my experience, with children's books, they interact with them very similarly to how they do with real books.

I really really can't get worked up about this. Sometimes I like to imagine the outrage of scholars as scrolls replaced books ... "Oooh, it's not the same if you only have to use one hand... where's the dexterity that you need for a scroll.... if it's on a page it's too easy for your head to stay still....."

roundtable · 25/02/2022 19:05

Schools are spending thousands on these schemes and then they will quietly die a death. Lots of them are dreadful. Same authors flogging multiple schemes. Doesn't make you think they really believe in what they are selling does it?

Somebody is making a lot of money from this and it's not schools.

We have refused to buy into a scheme that makes the children read the same books over and over or is reliant on e books. It's dreadful.

I sympathise op, it sounds like you have a school that is not confident in phonics and possibly panic bought a scheme (you don't have to have bought one until the end of spring term). Ebooks aren't evil and definitely serve purpose but they need paper books too imo.

oviraptor21 · 25/02/2022 18:51

@OfstedOffred

The phonics scheme we use specifies that the book should be read 3 times in school and then sent home. The idea is that the child will be reading it fluently by the time it comes home

This is really really poor practice and suggests reliance on memorizing whole words through repetition. Fluency in decoding comes in time with practice decoding new words, not through repetition of the same book!!!

Good grief. The kids must be really bored by the 4th reading. Great way to put them off Hmm
SkyrocketAway · 25/02/2022 18:48

It's just the school reading books, not all books.

Which is a shame because some parents don't value reading and won't be buying many reading books at home at all, won't be going to the library, and the only real reading their kids do is through the school, which could just be e-books.

MrsTophamHat · 25/02/2022 18:47

I'd prefer proper books, but I also want my children's school to be well resourced and if it means money isn't wasted replacing books, or that the books are better quality then I wouldn't mind.

It's substance over style in my opinion. I buy plenty of books for my children and we use the library all the time, so it's not as if they don't know what a real book is.

Goldenbunny · 25/02/2022 18:43

If our school do this I will try get pdfs of the books and print them myself. I do this with DS now so his used to having books printed out to read. I sometimes laminate them if he really enjoys the story. He won't be reading from a device don't want him using devices so young.

yoshiblue · 25/02/2022 18:40

I'm a governor and our school is going to go this way. Every lost or damaged book is £4.00 to replace and the school just can't afford it. I've been shocked at how limited their budgets are full stop.

We aren't in a deprived area, but there are some families that would struggle to pay for lost books so it's easier to roll out e books all round.

As a pp said, they will have already read said book 3 times and should be 90% fluent, so it's really for a final read through with you.

Personally, I would use the ebook offer for the above and supplement with other reading level appropriate material - The usborne reading book sets are brilliant.

FoldedCard · 25/02/2022 18:36

@AngelicaElizaAndPeggy

This is to ensure that children are reading the exactly correct books op. 'fidelity to the scheme' is the new buzzphrase in phonics pedagogy right now. We've had to bin loads of books that can no longer be sent home since they are older and therefore do not represent 'fidelity to the scheme'. I teach reception and, honestly, the new phonics scheme has been the absolute bane of our lives this year and this issue is one of the massive reasons why. I'm sorry that you haven't heard back from your school but you can bet your bottom dollar they will agree with you. Reading an e-book is not right. Could you ask for a supplementary sharing book instead? One that is just for sharing with a grown up for pleasure?
I could have written this message word for word!

We discussed, and dismissed, ebooks, because it was an extra cost on top of the rest of the scheme and there was no way we weren't going to buy 'real' books.

toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2022 18:34

To be fair governors are strategic not operational so the reading scheme may not come up in meetings.

Is this a standalone school or part of an Academy Trust?

Have you joined the PTA to help with the fundraising?

WonderfulYou · 25/02/2022 18:34

YABU

You will find most things are taught on screens. They’ll have maths work set on screens too.
It’s 2022 and that is just the way life is now.

I love a proper book and I would encourage getting him actual books too but you need to either homeschool and teach in a way that you believe is more effective or go along with what the rest of the school does and accept the world has changed since you’ve been in school.

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:32

@DePfeffoff

Out of sheer curiosity, what happens if the family in question simply doesn't have screens at home at all or if, say, the only screens the parents have are phones which they need for work? Would the school provide them?

And what if they are only phones? It seems really undesirable for children to be trying to practise reading from a tiny screen.

The school my DS goes to have repeatedly told parents not to 'worry' if they don't have an e-reader or tablet because everyone has a phone so your child can just read on that! Shock
OP posts:
Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:30

[quote toomuchlaundry]@Mummyoply contacting MP isn’t to complain about the school, but you complain about Government funding for schools.

Did you see my link to the Foyles grant. I know some local schools that have been successful in applications for this grant

Does the school website have copies of the Governor meetings minutes on it. Might show discussion about this decision especially around budget constraints[/quote]

The schools Headteacher attends the PTA meetings and my role is to apply for funding via grants/corporate funding and so I took my idea of funding to purchase real books to the Headteacher via this platform as I wasn't getting a reply any other way. Perfectly acceptable to use the PTA platform in this capacity.

Yes the school does post governors meeting minutes of their website, they have never discussed this topic and instead spend a lot of time tweaking the schools ethos and values.................

OP posts:
Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:26

@okthx

You are not being unreasonable. Please do what’s best for your child. Reading books from electronic screen is NOT best for this age
Thanks
OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2022 18:26

@Mummyoply contacting MP isn’t to complain about the school, but you complain about Government funding for schools.

Did you see my link to the Foyles grant. I know some local schools that have been successful in applications for this grant

Does the school website have copies of the Governor meetings minutes on it. Might show discussion about this decision especially around budget constraints

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 18:26

@GreenNewDealNow

Many jobs involve looking at a screen all day and the government wants to push STEM subjects as they lead to better paid jobs in the future, so in a way they are being trained to tolerate a lot of screen time which may benefit them in the long run. I don't particularly like it either but if that is the form the future economy takes then maybe it has it's pluses.
He's 4years old.......
OP posts:
DePfeffoff · 25/02/2022 18:18

@PAFMO

I know screens are bad, I'm a teacher. But e-readers aren't screens in the computer-screen way. Don't get me wrong, I still prefer books. But e-readers are a great leveller as books are far more affordable for everyone. I'd prefer some of our parents limit screen time by removing the Xbox or Nintendo rather than the Kindle tbh.
I know I may have been lucky, but when my children were learning to read there was no cost to any parent as ordinary books were lent by the school. I remember (as I was a secondary school governor at the time) noticing that the school was actually having to spend more on exam fees than it did on textbooks.