Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School providing e-books and no paper books for Reception

213 replies

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 17:00

My DS is in reception year and the school provide his reading books via an app and ask that children read them on an electronic device, iPad, phone or e-reader.

I have been purchasing the books, if the library don't have them (which they usually don't). This is too costly and also causes a delay, as by the time we get the book my DS has been moved on to another.

I guess my AIBU is, AIBU to refuse to allow him to read on a device and just provide books of the same level (from the library) so he can read a real book? I have emailed the school and message his teacher directly but had no response from either. I've even drawn a blank from the PTA.

OP posts:
Bitofachinwag · 25/02/2022 22:37

@Morethanwordsonapage

Quite surprised at the amount of posters saying it’s more cost effective, what’s the problem. Please can four year olds learn to read by holding a real book? Go to a shelf, pick and choose it, turn the actual pages, have the delight of bringing it home in their book bag? Am I being naive / non-inclusive / a dinosaur for saying this?
No you're not.
Nix32 · 25/02/2022 22:36

@OfstedOffred Not mrsz, but . . . English does conform to the structure of phonics. It's simply a series of codes that you need to be able to crack. The issue comes with the complexity of the code. All words are decodable, but you need to know and understand the code. How else do you approach new or complicated longer words other than by using your knowledge of phonics?

myyellowcar · 25/02/2022 22:33

OP I think this is shocking. If providing children with actual books to read during their first years at school isn’t a priority then god help us all.

It’s creating barriers for the most vulnerable, who on earth could think that reading a book via phone screen is something small children should be doing regularly with a parent at home. It’s so bad for eye health too. There may well be reasons why schools have chosen to do this but it doesn’t mean it’s the right decision or that they should be beyond reproach.

OfstedOffred · 25/02/2022 22:33
  1. The english language is largely phonetic, when you actually understand phonetics properly, eg there are 44 phonemes, not just the 26 single letter graphemes of the alphabet. Many alternative spellings follow clear rules.
  1. Children who have a good grasp of phonics don't need to guess words by looking at pictures for context. Phonics doesn't prevent children pronouncing words correctly by considering textual context.
  1. Fluency is not attained by the memorizing of whole words by visual appearance etc, but by the blending process becoming incredibly rapid and happening in your head at a glance. When you teach a child to read phonetically you literally see this happen around yellow/blue level, you can hear them almost sounding out v fast as they say a word.

(In the absence of MRZ, the phonics guru of mumsnet).

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 22:25

[quote toomuchlaundry]This is one phonics scheme, obviously includes costs of other resources and teacher training but does also detail the cost of a set of books to give you an idea of costs @Mummyoply

admin.ruthmiskin.com/media/uploads/website/rwi_btp_package.pdf[/quote]
Thank you Smile

OP posts:
OfstedOffred · 25/02/2022 22:25

The English language does not conform well to phonics and the children seeing books from old reading schemes might help equip them with some of the reading skills you need in addition to phonics to actually learn to read independently.

Can anyone find @mrz and get her to explain why this is wrong

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 22:24

@worriedmum2022

We had this and all signed a petition as nobody wanted their children increasing screentime

We used the attached to support our argument as the DfE do not encourage screentime but promote actual
Books

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachmentdata/file/1050849/ReadinggframeworkTeachinggthefoundationssofliteracyy-Julyy2021Jann22_update.pdf

Offstead apparently don't really think it's ideal

Amazing! Thank you so much for this Smile
OP posts:
INeedNewShoes · 25/02/2022 22:23

My instant reaction to this would also be very negative.

DD and I love books : it's not just about the content, it's the feeling of sitting down holding a book and turning the pages. It also seems very unhelpful for schools to be encouraging screen use at this age.

But, reflecting on it more, at DD's school they give reading books that are very comfortably within the child's capability. DD is given two books a week and whizzes through them. It takes her literally five minutes to read each book so even if she read them twice it's only 20 minutes a week at most on screen. Not great, but not quite as terrible as I first thought.

Regarding comments that the old books that school libraries still have don't conform to the new phonics scheme, I actually think it's a good thing that schools are still using these. The English language does not conform well to phonics and the children seeing books from old reading schemes might help equip them with some of the reading skills you need in addition to phonics to actually learn to read independently.

OfstedOffred · 25/02/2022 22:19

Some older books arent suitable because they retain strong "look and say" principles - constant repetition of key words rather than anything decodable. Reading champions in particular are terrible for this, their red, yellow and pink books are incredibly boring and basically drill a child in a handful of high frequency words per book.

Most of the modern phonics schemes (big cat phonics, phonics bug, songbirds etc) are fairly consistent and interchangeable.

BobbleHatDay · 25/02/2022 22:16

Later on a mix of ebooks and paperbacks is OK. My youngest battled through lockdowns reading ebooks - very difficult to trace finger under words for example!

toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2022 22:08

Staff costs can make up to 85-90% of school budget, then they have to fund everything else with the balance. With increase in utility costs it is going to be even tougher

Morethanwordsonapage · 25/02/2022 22:07

Quite surprised at the amount of posters saying it’s more cost effective, what’s the problem. Please can four year olds learn to read by holding a real book? Go to a shelf, pick and choose it, turn the actual pages, have the delight of bringing it home in their book bag? Am I being naive / non-inclusive / a dinosaur for saying this?

toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2022 22:04

Many schools have been using books that have been around for many years and which don’t correspond with the current phonics scheme. How many schools use Biff and Chip books but these won’t follow the phonics scheme

Nix32 · 25/02/2022 21:56

@Bitofachinwag They're unsuitable because current thinking is that children should only be reading books that include the sounds they have been taught.

Different schemes teach the sounds in a different order, which means they appear in books in a certain order. They're not necessarily compatible with other schemes.

And yes, schools have a lot less money. Our budgets are in crisis and have been for some time.

Bitofachinwag · 25/02/2022 21:51

@Pinkflipflop85

As reading lead it has just cost shy of £8k to start replacing our unsuitable reading books.
Why are they unsuitable?
Bitofachinwag · 25/02/2022 21:51

@Abraxan

It'll be due to cost. School budgets are limited and can only go so far.

Whilst schools have to pay for the online e-library, it's still cheaper than how much buying multiple copes of the same books, across the entire school, will cost. We need more than one copy of many of the books, esp in the earlier books, for each class. When they go home many are not returned or get damaged, so have to be replaced.

Yes, but have schools got less money now than before reading e-books became available ? Learning to read should be top priority for Reception children!
Pinkflipflop85 · 25/02/2022 21:50

As reading lead it has just cost shy of £8k to start replacing our unsuitable reading books.

SkankingMopoke · 25/02/2022 21:34

Can you find out which scheme and level DC is on (or even better, ask at the end of each half term what level they'll be on after the hols), then buy a bundle of that level's books on ebay or Facebook marketplace? Once DC has moved onto the next level the books can be sold on, usually for what was paid for them, so it is a cost-effective way of doing it. If you were feeling generous and can afford it, rather than selling the books on they could be gifted to school for use with otherswho do not get on with ebooks.

During lockdown this time last year, DD2 was in reception and being sent photos of each page of the week's phonics book plus links to ebooks on Oxford Owl (these were 'for pleasure'). Obviously this was a 'make the best of it' situation, but we did not get on with them at all. Not least because my laptop has a touch screen, and every time 4yo DD wanted to point something out in the picture, the whole page would turn/disappear/zoom. I bought new black and white copies of the 12 scheme books at the level she was on via Amazon, so we could use a hard copy. IIRC, it was about £12 for the set (delivered!), which I sold on for £9. £3 for, essentially, the hire of 12 books seemed a good deal to me.

mumda · 25/02/2022 21:26

Do we hold tablets and phones differently to how we hold books. Has it been assessed for long term damage and RSI problems?

Lottie2017 · 25/02/2022 21:25

Have you tried your local library? Or Biff and Chip sets second hand? My daughter really struggled reading on a screen and I paid a fortune for books before realising our library had a lot of phonics reading books.

NeverForgetYourDreams · 25/02/2022 21:20

Our primary school re used the books every year and replaced when dog eared. Surely they've already got all the books and don't need to get any more so should have enough

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 21:17

@toomuchlaundry

To be fair governors are strategic not operational so the reading scheme may not come up in meetings.

Is this a standalone school or part of an Academy Trust?

Have you joined the PTA to help with the fundraising?

It's a stand alone school and yes I was asked to join the PTA to help with grant applications
OP posts:
toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2022 21:06

This is one phonics scheme, obviously includes costs of other resources and teacher training but does also detail the cost of a set of books to give you an idea of costs @Mummyoply

admin.ruthmiskin.com/media/uploads/website/rwi_btp_package.pdf

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 21:01

@DePfeffoff

Out of sheer curiosity, what happens if the family in question simply doesn't have screens at home at all or if, say, the only screens the parents have are phones which they need for work? Would the school provide them?

And what if they are only phones? It seems really undesirable for children to be trying to practise reading from a tiny screen.

I really don't know TBH, but the school have repeatedly told parents not to 'worry' if they don't have an e-reader or tablet because everyone has a phone so your child can just read on that!
OP posts:
Nix32 · 25/02/2022 21:00

@TrendingNowt Really? All Reception children in all schools get taught phonics using screens? Not in my school they don't. The generalisations are so helpful . . .