Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School providing e-books and no paper books for Reception

213 replies

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 17:00

My DS is in reception year and the school provide his reading books via an app and ask that children read them on an electronic device, iPad, phone or e-reader.

I have been purchasing the books, if the library don't have them (which they usually don't). This is too costly and also causes a delay, as by the time we get the book my DS has been moved on to another.

I guess my AIBU is, AIBU to refuse to allow him to read on a device and just provide books of the same level (from the library) so he can read a real book? I have emailed the school and message his teacher directly but had no response from either. I've even drawn a blank from the PTA.

OP posts:
Creamegg84 · 26/02/2022 11:34

Our school started to do this during covid. I have kids in y3 and Y6. For the past 12 months they have all been given their own ipad and they do ALL of their work and reading on there.
It's good that it saves paper etc but parents were not consulted about this at all. The children are now on screens for most of the school day, plus whatever they go on at home.
There has not been a good response by parents, and most (myself included) have refused to read the ebooks. They sent out letters every week trying to force us to do it. I think they have given up now and just accepted that parents aren't happy about it. I know many people expressed their approval at the parent consultations.

BigupPemberleyMassive · 26/02/2022 11:27

*are digital natives

BigupPemberleyMassive · 26/02/2022 11:27

These children and digital natives.

AIBU to not want my child to buy shop bought clothes and want her to sew her own?
AIBU to not want pre sliced bread?
AIBU to not want a spinning Jenny in the house and to weave things by hand?

Times move on. The future is digital.

You can still go to the library with him once a week for paper books to read at home.

SkyrocketAway · 26/02/2022 11:22

I said "not truly phonetic", that isn't what I meant. I meant what I said at the end. Should read "isn't truly phonemic".

SkyrocketAway · 26/02/2022 11:21

I have never understood people who claim that English reading isn't phonetic.

It is phonetic, in that it isn't ideographic, but it's not truly phonetic in the sense that every word is decodable, so if you know "ea" makes and "ee" sound, you should be able to decode words with it in, and yet you get "I read it once, I will read it again".

"The bandage was wound round the wound."

"After seeing the tear in the clothes, I shed a tear"

The same combination of letters don't always make the same sound and it doesn't really make sense. Why is tomb pronounced completely differently to bomb? It doesn't make sense, simply looking at the letters.

"Poem" should be pronounced like "pohm" if you know that "oe" makes an "oh" sound, as in "toe".

That's what I think is meant when people say it's not phonetic, because that is the way many non-linguists understand and use the term.

Of course, what they mean, is the orthography of the language is not phonemic.

School providing e-books and no paper books for Reception
ThunderSnowDrop · 26/02/2022 10:56

Do the tech executives educate their children this way?
Last I heard it was no tech or lo tech for the early years modern day mini-aristocrats.

toomuchlaundry · 26/02/2022 08:28

@MangyInseam they are not teaching them to memorise words, they are teaching them phonics. But buying books to fit the phonics scheme is expensive, and most schools are struggling to replenish their libraries due to funding

TheDuchessOfBeddington · 26/02/2022 03:07

Your DS is 4. By the time he is at the peak of his career we will be in the year 2068. What will the world look like then? Move with the times seriously 😂

MangyInseam · 26/02/2022 02:39

[quote Nix32]@OfstedOffred Not mrsz, but . . . English does conform to the structure of phonics. It's simply a series of codes that you need to be able to crack. The issue comes with the complexity of the code. All words are decodable, but you need to know and understand the code. How else do you approach new or complicated longer words other than by using your knowledge of phonics?[/quote]
I have never understood people who claim that English reading isn't phonetic.

What the heck do they think we have an alphabet for? Learning to read English is nothing like learning to read an ideographic language.

MangyInseam · 26/02/2022 02:35

This is a very bad teaching practice. Reading on a screen is not the same for kids and it's a bad way to teach them to read.

Mind you the whole teach them by having them memorize words approach which is what a lot of these reading approaches do is not very good either.

My own approach would be to ignore what the school is doing, get a good phonics book to work from, and use your own or library books. There are lots of options that a parent can use that are inexpensive, or your library may even have a few you can at least look through.

UndertheCedartree · 25/02/2022 23:28

Unfortunately, this is what happens when school budgets are cut to the bone. This is why you should really speak to your MP.

I agree with you, I wouldn't want my DC mainly learning to read from a screen. Besides other issues, you don't want your DC having all that blue light before bed, which may be the only time some have to read. It really doesn't sound ideal for 4 year olds.

At my DD's school prior to Covid they always had real books. But they didn't mind what the DC read at home, or even were just read to as long as books were being shared 3x per week. You can get some phonics books like Songbirds where there is something like 4 stories in 1 book so cheaper. Or get books from the library - I wouldn't worry about it being exactly what is sent home from school.

Since Covid no books have been sent home which has been since Y3 for my DD. I'm not sure what was happening in Infants classes. They are just expected to read their own books from home or the library. They used to use Bug Club in the younger years where a book was read to them and they answered comprehension questions on it. We did it on a laptop maybe once a week. I wouldn't have liked it to be instead of real books.

I hope you get some answers from school and I hope your fundraising is successful.

Ozanj · 25/02/2022 23:12

develops other skills

Ozanj · 25/02/2022 23:12

@HiJenny35

Don't talk rubbish Ozanj, what do you think we do with a children who have a vi and need all texts enlarged, we use screen readers for everything, it makes no difference to their ability to study for exams, concentration or motor skills.
You’re comparing apples and oranges. A child with a VI wouldn’t be able to learn at all without screens (or it would be more difficult). For a child without disabilities learning on paper is easier than screens and develops other screens too.

This explains it

www.scientificamerican.com/article/reading-paper-screens/

Paper based learning to read can help develop IQs. So by getting rid teachers are ruining the futures of kids whose parents can’t afford to buy the paper books to supplement their education. It’s so unfair.

CarbonelCat · 25/02/2022 23:07

"Some schools round us do this, and shout loudly about what amazingly tech-rich experiences they give the DC

That's really quite bizarre. Effectively they're claiming credit for the fact that parents have got screens (or been made to buy them) when that is nothing to do with the school's efforts at all."

To be fair to them, the academy chain provides all pupils with devices if they need them, but that's what puts me off. The pupils spend large parts of the day on screens/using tech at school and are expected to then continue their homework etc on screens at home too. I'm far happier with a low-tech school with paper resources as it means that their screen hours per day are pretty low even if they veg In front of the TV at home. And, they don't ever do reading books either in school or to send home. No written log either as all progress is captured via the apps. Great for data, not so good for kids imo.

Bitofachinwag · 25/02/2022 23:05

tracking of how many times its been read
Do you mean that the teacher / the company that makes the e-books would be able check how many times a named child has read a specific book? That's really invasive and controlling.

HiJenny35 · 25/02/2022 23:04

Don't talk rubbish Ozanj, what do you think we do with a children who have a vi and need all texts enlarged, we use screen readers for everything, it makes no difference to their ability to study for exams, concentration or motor skills.

HiJenny35 · 25/02/2022 23:01

I would love our school to bring this in. First readers even the best aren't joyous to read they are learning texts, stick them on a kindle, do it after school, get nice books from the library with lively pictures and a great story to share at bedtime. Books in the lower years are constantly ripped, pages lost, drawn on, spilt over, you get a new set and by the end of term they are wrecked and not through people being naughty just repeatedly using thin sets of books. Plus you need so many books to keep all the children moving on effectively. It schemes allows such a wider choice, access to more levels, tracking of how many times its been read and by who etc. Just much more effective all round. You can still have all the lovely books you want outside of this.

Ozanj · 25/02/2022 22:57

A child learning how to read from a screen isn’t going to develop the concentration and motor skills they need to revise for and pass exams. It just won’t happen. Make a complaint but you should probably start searching for a new school.

Russell19 · 25/02/2022 22:55

@Bitofachinwag yes they could do that....but then they/big name publishers wouldn't make literally thousands of pounds selling programme access/resources. It's big money. My school alone have spent around 5k and that was a cheap budget.

DePfeffoff · 25/02/2022 22:53

Some schools round us do this, and shout loudly about what amazingly tech-rich experiences they give the DC

That's really quite bizarre. Effectively they're claiming credit for the fact that parents have got screens (or been made to buy them) when that is nothing to do with the school's efforts at all.

hellithurt · 25/02/2022 22:50

It's 2022 OP!
It's all about it's all about technology!

Nix32 · 25/02/2022 22:47

@Morethanwordsonapage They will be doing that as well. Ebooks are a tiny part of learning to read.

Bitofachinwag · 25/02/2022 22:43

[quote Nix32]@Bitofachinwag They're unsuitable because current thinking is that children should only be reading books that include the sounds they have been taught.

Different schemes teach the sounds in a different order, which means they appear in books in a certain order. They're not necessarily compatible with other schemes.

And yes, schools have a lot less money. Our budgets are in crisis and have been for some time.[/quote]
That makes sense. And I know it's not the fault of individual schools.
But I think the funding system is wrong. There are millions of children learning to read the English language. DfE (or whoever makes these decisions) could easily make their own reading scheme and distribute it to all state schools. This would be so much cheaper.

Nix32 · 25/02/2022 22:42

@myyellowcar It's really not shocking. Using ebooks in this way will be a tiny part of how children access reading material. They will have a reading corner - with real books, topic books - again, real books, and print in the environment - real life things such as calendars, greetings cards, diaries. There will be plenty of opportunities for them to access books, ebooks are simply another tool.

toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2022 22:38

But if you have a choice of no books or e-books what would you rather?