Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School providing e-books and no paper books for Reception

213 replies

Mummyoply · 25/02/2022 17:00

My DS is in reception year and the school provide his reading books via an app and ask that children read them on an electronic device, iPad, phone or e-reader.

I have been purchasing the books, if the library don't have them (which they usually don't). This is too costly and also causes a delay, as by the time we get the book my DS has been moved on to another.

I guess my AIBU is, AIBU to refuse to allow him to read on a device and just provide books of the same level (from the library) so he can read a real book? I have emailed the school and message his teacher directly but had no response from either. I've even drawn a blank from the PTA.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 27/02/2022 14:25

[quote Nix32]@OfstedOffred Not mrsz, but . . . English does conform to the structure of phonics. It's simply a series of codes that you need to be able to crack. The issue comes with the complexity of the code. All words are decodable, but you need to know and understand the code. How else do you approach new or complicated longer words other than by using your knowledge of phonics?[/quote]
If all words are decodable why do DC have to learn 'tricky words'?

Pumperthepumper · 27/02/2022 12:53

If your kid has an eye condition then an e-reader will be hugely beneficial for them. You can change fonts, background colour, you can markup to search for unfamiliar words, add notes, link to further reading, make the text bigger or smaller… if I was you I’d drop the screen time for the Xbox for the e-reader.

Abraxan · 27/02/2022 12:43

@Mummyoply

But it's not one book on an e-reader, it's all school reading books on iPads, phones, laptops - this is what the school are promoting. The school have never actually mentioned e-readers and promote reading on iPads and phones.........
Which equates to 10 minutes a day reading on a screen, 5-7 days a week.
Fairislefandango · 27/02/2022 12:37

Looks as if e-readers (unlike computer screens) are not necessarily any worse for your eyes than paper books link from eye clinic

Fairislefandango · 27/02/2022 12:34

Sod that, their eyesight will be damaged.

My eyesight was great. Until after I studied for my finals. With paper books.

Mummyoply · 27/02/2022 11:50

But it's not one book on an e-reader, it's all school reading books on iPads, phones, laptops - this is what the school are promoting. The school have never actually mentioned e-readers and promote reading on iPads and phones.........

OP posts:
00100001 · 27/02/2022 07:37

@UsernameInTheTown

Sod that, their eyesight will be damaged.
From reading one book on an ereader?
UsernameInTheTown · 27/02/2022 07:31

Sod that, their eyesight will be damaged.

MangyInseam · 27/02/2022 02:21

Do the tech executives educate their children this way?
Last I heard it was no tech or lo tech for the early years modern day mini-aristocrats.

No, they absolutely don't, you are right, many won't allow their kids to use it at all. Much less at school.

And the research supports that. There are no real advantages to having computer tech in learning before, approximately, secondary education.

MangyInseam · 27/02/2022 02:04

[quote toomuchlaundry]@MangyInseam they are not teaching them to memorise words, they are teaching them phonics. But buying books to fit the phonics scheme is expensive, and most schools are struggling to replenish their libraries due to funding[/quote]
It can be expensive however - most libraries also have a fair number of these books. They don't have to be the exact same books as the ones used in class - unless what they are really doing is word memorization.

With good phonics instruction children should actually be able to read simple, real books from fairly early on, buddy reading with a parent if not alone. That's one of the big advantages of phonics, you don't have to have such emphasis on controlling exactly what reading materials they use.

It certainly stinks for parents without the time or resources to access books, even from the library, but it might be an option for the OP.

UndertheCedartree · 27/02/2022 00:52

@BlingLoving

I honestly can't understand why everyone is so het about this. The important thing is that the children are READING. Reading books sent home from school is what, 10 minutes a day? That much "screen time" is not going to do them any harm and, if you use a kindle or similar it isn't even the same as actual screen time. One of the issues with reading on a screen is that there's less blinking etc, but in my experience, with children's books, they interact with them very similarly to how they do with real books.

I really really can't get worked up about this. Sometimes I like to imagine the outrage of scholars as scrolls replaced books ... "Oooh, it's not the same if you only have to use one hand... where's the dexterity that you need for a scroll.... if it's on a page it's too easy for your head to stay still....."

My DC didn't get on with reading on a screen til nearer 9/10. I would have struggled if there was an expectation to read on a screen even 10 minutes a day. And of course as they get older it becomes much more than 10 minutes a day.
Mummyoply · 26/02/2022 19:08

@Gizacluethen

It's an objection to the use of technology

Then you're just going to hold your child back. We live in an age of technology. It's an important thing to learn how to use and most careers will require skills in it. Most of his subjects will require skills in it. He'll be held back in every subject at school and his entire life until he starts learning to use technology.

I find it really quite funny that people object to ereading because their kids get enough screen watching TV and playing video games. It's like saying you can't afford rent because your TV subscription costs too much. Prioritise. And ereading isn't even the same thing as video games.

You're making a rod for your own back, and it's not the schools responsibility to pander to your nonsensical refusal to let your kid use an ereader.

Ha ha ha
OP posts:
Bitofachinwag · 26/02/2022 17:35

@Creamegg84

Our school started to do this during covid. I have kids in y3 and Y6. For the past 12 months they have all been given their own ipad and they do ALL of their work and reading on there. It's good that it saves paper etc but parents were not consulted about this at all. The children are now on screens for most of the school day, plus whatever they go on at home. There has not been a good response by parents, and most (myself included) have refused to read the ebooks. They sent out letters every week trying to force us to do it. I think they have given up now and just accepted that parents aren't happy about it. I know many people expressed their approval at the parent consultations.
Yes of course it saves paper. But making the devices ( that normally become obsolete after a few years) uses a lot of resources and there is a lot of waste when people upgrade to the next version. They also need to be charged constantly.

Paper is, after all, a very recyclable and renewable resource.

Bitofachinwag · 26/02/2022 17:31

@TheDuchessOfBeddington

How do you know that paper books will be out and e-books will be in in 2068?

I don’t, but I do know OP’s DS4 will be living in a very different world than this one.

Yes, it's likely to be different, but I wouldn't assume that that means more "tech".
toomuchlaundry · 26/02/2022 15:05

@Mocara I assume you will also get quite high pupil premium funding

Mocara · 26/02/2022 15:01

If lock down has taught us anything its that familys are tech poor . Our school has all the latest tec and we still hadnt got enogh to share out to our tec poor familys in lock down.
Along side all our tec we have an early years library a ks1 library and a ks2 library . Were in a area of high deprivation but we have a very driven Head and leadership team. We have no buget for our libraries its all achived through grants , donations,sponsership ,fundraising and our familys.

Fairislefandango · 26/02/2022 13:24

It wouldn't even have occurred to me to object to this tbh. My dd is 16 and we bought her a (basic) Kindle when she was 5 or 6, mostly because she'd take umpteen books on holiday and get through them all in a few days. She still reads paper books as well and always did.

I'm a teacher (mostly secondary but some primary). Children are exposed to screens all the time in school from day 1- a lot of teaching is done using interactive whiteboards, plus the children often use individual iPads or laptops. There is no avoiding it.

Everything is technology. Technology is just equipment created through scientific knowledge. A knife is technology, a wheel is technology,printing on paper is technology. Embracing new technology doesn't mean you can't also continue to use older technology.

madmomma · 26/02/2022 13:08

Do both.

jytdtysrht · 26/02/2022 13:06

I'd do a quick read of the school books on the device but supplement this with a subscription to reading chest. I used it for both my dc as the school didn't change books often.

Phineyj · 26/02/2022 13:04

With all the energy shortages and shortages of key rare metals needed for all devices, I wouldn't write the obituary of books on paper just yet.

TheDuchessOfBeddington · 26/02/2022 12:59

How do you know that paper books will be out and e-books will be in in 2068?

I don’t, but I do know OP’s DS4 will be living in a very different world than this one.

Bitofachinwag · 26/02/2022 12:48

@TheDuchessOfBeddington

Your DS is 4. By the time he is at the peak of his career we will be in the year 2068. What will the world look like then? Move with the times seriously 😂
How do you know that paper books will be out and e-books will be in in 2068?
SkyrocketAway · 26/02/2022 12:00

I find it really quite funny that people object to ereading because their kids get enough screen watching TV and playing video games. It's like saying you can't afford rent because your TV subscription costs too much

There's nothing wrong with watching TV or video games in moderation. But those activities are, by their nature, screen-based activities. Reading is not. Children aren't going to struggle with technology just because they don't use e-readers. Plenty kids grow up with a love of reading and videogames etc. I've never used an e-reader because I have real books, and don't see why I should involve a screen in an activity that doesn't require one. So, I'm not sure I should have to cut out videogames in favour of e-readers, when non-screen reading exists. If I want to cut out technology, the obvious choice to me would be e-readers, because there is a viable non-tech alternative which doesn't apply to other tech-based activities.

That said, if it's just going to be 10-15 mins a day reading books on a phone or Kindle or tablet, it's not too bad.

Barbie222 · 26/02/2022 11:35

The concern with screens and eye strain is the time spent doing them, not the screens themselves.

People who spend a lot of time reading close up are equally likely to have issues with short sight /eye strain - as have embroiderers, artists and writers over the years.

So the issue is around how much time is spent on close up vision tasks, rather than how much time is spent on screens. Make sure children are able to look at things far away (outside is best) regularly. If you're doing this, you won't have any more issues with an ebook than you do with a real one.

I think using the ebooks are a smart financial decision for lots of schools who can't afford to keep replacing the books and you'd probably have more joy trying to fund devices for those families who don't have one than trying to reverse a decision which the school will have made in the light of government and Ofsted as has been pointed out.

In ten years time, we're likely to have a device for every child in every classroom to support them in their learning. In the light of this, I think your concern is maybe a little of the old fashioned dislike of the new.

Gizacluethen · 26/02/2022 11:34

It's an objection to the use of technology

Then you're just going to hold your child back. We live in an age of technology. It's an important thing to learn how to use and most careers will require skills in it. Most of his subjects will require skills in it. He'll be held back in every subject at school and his entire life until he starts learning to use technology.

I find it really quite funny that people object to ereading because their kids get enough screen watching TV and playing video games. It's like saying you can't afford rent because your TV subscription costs too much. Prioritise. And ereading isn't even the same thing as video games.

You're making a rod for your own back, and it's not the schools responsibility to pander to your nonsensical refusal to let your kid use an ereader.