Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed that the EU won't sanction SWIFT

66 replies

cheddez · 25/02/2022 16:47

Just that really. Why the reluctance?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Duchess379 · 26/02/2022 19:31

It's to do with financial implications to other EU countries. Italy are against it because they sell a lot of luxury goods (Gucci etc) to rich Russians, so they feel they will be hit financially as well.

FourTeaFallOut · 26/02/2022 19:17

Germany was the last country in the EU to object to sanctions on SWIFT payments. Even Biden seems to be rowing back a little.

AdaHopper · 26/02/2022 18:46

A friend works in the gas industry and says 1/3rd of gas used in Europe cones from Russia. If supply stops, it is going to immediatly create a shortage in Europe and prices would shoot up. In the whole of Europe, also the UK.
There is currently no way to compensate those shortages so other payment communications would be used, which may even be an advantage for Russia if their system is used.

Rosebuud · 26/02/2022 18:19

As others have said, Putin has already said he will retaliate for the sanctions, the eu countries who opposes rely heavily on gas from Russia and they are deeply concerned that Russia will cut them off, which would cause their populations a lot of pain.

FourTeaFallOut · 26/02/2022 18:16

Germany has backed targeted restrictions on SWIFT payments. Not sure what kind of heavy lifting the word targeted is doing there and whether it renders the statement a gesture.

FourTeaFallOut · 26/02/2022 13:07

And now Hungary.

FourTeaFallOut · 26/02/2022 12:11

Cypress and Italy have shifted position on Swift today.

Ratonastick · 25/02/2022 19:02

I think the answer is that it may be ineffective against Russia and damaging to the west. It isn’t as simple as just switching off a country. It’s been tried before with Iran and caused more chaos for other countries than for Iran plus drove Iran into exporting its oil to China which made it richer. And, s previous posters have mentioned, it doesn’t cut Russia out of anything as there are alternative systems.

There are more effective transactional sanctions, mainly disallowing Russia from certain currency clearances. The US ban on $ clearance yesterday is far more damaging than a SWIFT ban would be, particularly as oil and gas (ie Russia’s economy) are traded in $.

Having said that, SWIFT is becoming a symbolic issue so I think it will be enacted within a week or so.

MythicalBiologicalFennel · 25/02/2022 18:55

@MaMaLa321

It really isn’t as simple as EU bad/Brexit good or vice Versa. No, but it's showing that the EU isn't the wonderful organisation that so many have claimed on MN.
Thank God Boris, at the helm of a Free Britain, is here to save the day
StormzyinaTCup · 25/02/2022 18:51

@MaMaLa321

It's just the EU. Do you want an organisation that will hold endless meetings and work incredibly slowly? The EU is perfect. Do you want to move quickly? Forget it, its like a sclerotic elephant. Same scenario as the vaccine rollout.
Agree. When speed and decisiveness is required the EU are found lacking (again). They will spend the next few days having meetings, making phone calls and general fannying about trying to get a consensus among 27.

Whilst SWIFT won't save lives it is a show of support for the people of Ukraine and will send a strong message to Putin.

They should be on the same page with this, making a stand not bickering about leather shoes and exemptions and all the while people are being killed FFS.

givethatbabyaname · 25/02/2022 18:50

You’re the one bringing the EU into it, instead of focusing on how to sanction Russia effectively after their invasion of the Ukraine.

It is possible to hold two thoughts at the same time. This is the first real test of the UK on the global stage post-Brexit, in terms of international relations. So far, neither it nor the EU looks to be much of an outlier in terms of the international response to the invasion of the Ukraine. Let's see what happens. Notably absent from the UK's diplomatic efforts, which I would have expected to see, is some cosying up to India (which Biden has done today).

givethatbabyaname · 25/02/2022 18:47

@Armadeus

So if there was no EU, how would countries cooperate to punish Putin. At least they are discussing what to do civilly and logically en masse rather than individual countries taking piecemeal ineffective measures...
The first iteration of the EU was created by the Treaty of Rome in 1957. By your reasoning, no alliance of nations was capable of civil and logical cooperation before then. One wonders how we made it all the way to 2022.
mynameiscalypso · 25/02/2022 18:40

To be fair, this whole discussion is pretty much academic as Germany seem to have capitulated and suggested SWIFT will be part of the next (inevitable) round of sanctions.

TheVanguardSix · 25/02/2022 18:38

This is cowardly and despicable from the EU.

Qualify this view.

SmallThingsEverywhere · 25/02/2022 18:37

@MaMaLa321

It really isn’t as simple as EU bad/Brexit good or vice Versa. No, but it's showing that the EU isn't the wonderful organisation that so many have claimed on MN.
You’re the one bringing the EU into it, instead of focusing on how to sanction Russia effectively after their invasion of the Ukraine.
DirectionToPerfection · 25/02/2022 18:35

@Bugbeds

This is cowardly and despicable from the EU.
Really? What about the 23 EU countries who supported it? Hmm
Armadeus · 25/02/2022 18:34

So if there was no EU, how would countries cooperate to punish Putin. At least they are discussing what to do civilly and logically en masse rather than individual countries taking piecemeal ineffective measures...

mynameiscalypso · 25/02/2022 18:31

@TheVanguardSix

Symbolic? SWIFT is how so many countries actually pay for Russian gas! Maybe not us... but them. And they actually matter. Germany gets 65% of its gas from Russia. Czech Republic, Hungary=100% Russian gas. I don't think cutting Russia off from SWIFT would be symbolic at all.
It would be far more effective to fully block all Russian banks from the Western financial system - only one bank is currently fully blocked. But close all the corespondent banking relationships etc and that would really hurt. There are ways to make payments without SWIFT - Iran proved they could do it when they were kicked out. You can just use other communication methods. Yes, they're slower and more difficult but SWIFT is a long way from being the most powerful sanction by a long long way.
SmallThingsEverywhere · 25/02/2022 18:27

[quote cheddez]@SmallThingsEverywhere so there's more to lose than gain. What a mess. [/quote]
Yes sounds like it. The Economist mentions that the second reason is “ The West, and European countries in particular, would face short-term costs. SWIFT disconnected Iranian banks in 2018, but Russia is far bigger. Russia is the EU’s fifth-largest trading partner. It is the source of 35% of Europe’s gas supply and it is home to €310bn ($350bn) of EU assets. Cutting Russia off from SWIFT could make it harder for international buyers to pay for its energy supplies; it could also prompt Russian retaliation.” So yes it would cause major issues with gas supply.

Notlabeled · 25/02/2022 18:26

@TheVanguardSix

It would break the US and Germany to do this. It could bring about more economic chaos than we could tolerate. It might not hurt the UK much (initially) because we're not nearly as invested in Russian interests as our neighbours are. But if our neighbours' economies collapse on account of SWIFT sanctions, you can bet there will be a harsh knock-on effect. That's a card we shouldn't have to play. I think it would be a real bonehead move to sanction SWIFT. I get the ethical reason for doing so, but actually and ultimately, it would end up being quite unethical. Too much collateral damage/widespread economic collapse. Wouldn't be smart.
That the west has left itself so exposed in this manner just shows how treasonous our "leaders" have been for decades.
TheVanguardSix · 25/02/2022 18:26

Symbolic? SWIFT is how so many countries actually pay for Russian gas! Maybe not us... but them. And they actually matter. Germany gets 65% of its gas from Russia.
Czech Republic, Hungary=100% Russian gas.
I don't think cutting Russia off from SWIFT would be symbolic at all.

cheddez · 25/02/2022 18:25

@TheVanguardSix but surely us backing down only works if Putin is happy to stop at Ukraine?

OP posts:
MaMaLa321 · 25/02/2022 18:25

It really isn’t as simple as EU bad/Brexit good or vice Versa.
No, but it's showing that the EU isn't the wonderful organisation that so many have claimed on MN.

mynameiscalypso · 25/02/2022 18:22

So much of the debate is about SWIFT sanctions when they would ultimately be more symbolic than anything. It's distracting from sanctions which would be far more effective at having the same outcome (and other sanctions which are needed just as much)

TheVanguardSix · 25/02/2022 18:21

To be blunt, cutting Russia off from SWIFT hurls us into a proper world war. It would be catastrophic. It IS the red button.