Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

John Lewis’ PR is awful?

168 replies

HelenaHandcart0 · 25/02/2022 14:10

Just received this in an email from JL saying they are ditching the ‘never knowingly undersold’ promise. Sadly I feel this could be the beginning of the end for them (I hope not) but what an awful way to communicate it!

It said:

..’we will be retiring our Never Knowingly Undersold policy this summer. Established back in 1925 and a hallmark of trust for nearly a century, we recognise that this policy is no longer serving you in the way that we would like, as it doesn't allow us to match prices from online-only retailers’

AIBU in thinking their PR is awful in communicating it this way?

OP posts:
Cuck00soup · 25/02/2022 21:17

There was a thread recently about bringing your whole self to work. JL encourage their staff to "be themselves always" or some such.

What a shame they forgot about their customers.

And yes I do know about rule one in the constitution. The partnership is required to look after its staff not maximise profits. However I don't think Spedan meant forget your customers because profit doesn't matter.

ThunderSnowDrop · 25/02/2022 21:15

That might explain some of it.

MabelMoo23 · 25/02/2022 21:07

@WulyJmpr

I can tell them exactly who their target customers were before they started alienating them. It's almost like their marketing department couldn't accept this and didn't actually like their customers!

I believe the current leadership does not have a fashion background. If they did then they may recall in the late 00s when M&S tried and failed to employ a similar strategy of value ranges. Cheap and nasty clothes no different to Primark thus alienating its core customers.

M&S fashion side of business is only just getting back on track today after correctly identifying their shoppers want quality, style, aspiration and don't mind paying more

Correct. Dame Sharon White who is the current chairman does not have a retail background. She’s an economist who has previously worked for the British Embassy in Washington DC.

This is exactly the problem. JL and Waitrose is now being run by someone who is not a retailer, and simply cares about numbers on a spreadsheet, and it shows

User7497521 · 25/02/2022 21:05

I still buy a lot of electrical and camera stuff from there though as they do give 2 years guarantee and it always seems safer getting it delivered to Waitrose than relying on Amazon not delivering an empty box, and returning back to Waitrose is also easy. DH bought his quite expensive laptop from there and camera

christingle2 · 25/02/2022 20:59

I thought they were going to add that it was being replaced by something that would cater to online stores.

The alternatives proposed aren’t great, but this was a long time coming.

GoodnessTruthBeauty · 25/02/2022 20:52

I live in the US now. We have a high end department store called Nordstrom which is still amazing in terms of customer service. You can almost always return anything, if something is not in stock and its available in another store or in their online store they send it to your home free of charge. If you have their credit card you get lots of perks like free alterations and advanced days for a new season with discounts. Because times have changed they have closed some of the regular stores but have a second store brand called Nordstrom Rack which is more of a discount store and those are apparently doing fantastically well. But they keep the standards in their original brand. I have always loved them for having Lounges which are quiet and peaceful and where it was perfect for breastfeeding a baby and meant I could actually go out shopping knowing I could sit down somewhere private and calm to BF. They still have those Lounges and mothers and older women needing a sit down love them. I recently ordered some trousers from the full price store online and they send them to my local Nordstrom Rack to pick up the next day! This is why I love Nordstrom. JL may want to look at their business model. Despite COVID etc they are still really busy in my local branch.

ThunderSnowDrop · 25/02/2022 20:38

I went into the newly revamped Edinburgh store and found it underwhelming. Haberdashery was always my favourite department so it's clearly over for me.😂

I always went to JL in sales for the bedding and towels. Lately I've been finding stuff smells chemically. Or more recently reading reviews that warn of it and buying elsewhere.

woodhill · 25/02/2022 20:37

@red321

I miss Trewins too and also used to shop there with my mum in the 80s before it moved into the Harlequin.

Ah yes, Trewins down the high street. I worked there (in the Harlequin store) in my gap year. Happy memories. It just about outlived Clements!

For me, the product knowledge has been their downfall. It used to be easy to pop along, ask the experts about the different models and you felt obliged to then order from them. I do NOT want to traipse into store for you to pull up the webpage and read from it.

There was an epic camera sales expert in JL Oxford Street so hopefully he's still there. Although I think they've sold that floor for housing/offices.

Yes lovely Trewins
ThunderSnowDrop · 25/02/2022 20:33

Yes the reward I've been offered is entry to a prize draw 😂

BantersaurusSex · 25/02/2022 19:55

Absolutely agree, OP. I was mightily pissed off with the email today. Talk about trying to spin a pile of shit into thread of gold.

Why not just keep the "never knowingly undersold" policy and apply it to online price-matching too?

That said, I am never shopping at JL again (after an entire lifetime of JL shopping) because they closed down my nearest JL. They can get lost if they think I'm buying from them online instead. I like real shops where I can see and feel things, and (eg) open the doors of a fridge freezer that I'm planning to buy. If I've got to travel 50 miles to the nearest JL to do that, I'll travel 10 miles to the nearest independent instead.

MintMocha · 25/02/2022 19:48

And their 'rewards' are useless now too. They keep sending me surveys about them, and I keep saying the same thing - they are competitions, not rewards! How is a reward for me to enter a competition?! Bring back the coffee and cake vouchers, which meant something tangible, and got me back in the store rather than online.

Then get people properly trained to work in the different departments, and don't ignore the boring bits like haberdashery or whatever - real product knowledge, not just school-leavers trained to use the app and run the tills.

And get rid of the bright orange cheapo branding, and bring back quality products with the JL brand, at a reasonable price.

Drop the NKU if needed, fair enough and I think we'd understand if they can't afford it or whatever. But drop the patronising spin that it's a favour to us.

They should read this thread really, as I think many people here are exactly their core customers!

red321 · 25/02/2022 19:39

I miss Trewins too and also used to shop there with my mum in the 80s before it moved into the Harlequin.

Ah yes, Trewins down the high street. I worked there (in the Harlequin store) in my gap year. Happy memories. It just about outlived Clements!

For me, the product knowledge has been their downfall. It used to be easy to pop along, ask the experts about the different models and you felt obliged to then order from them. I do NOT want to traipse into store for you to pull up the webpage and read from it.

There was an epic camera sales expert in JL Oxford Street so hopefully he's still there. Although I think they've sold that floor for housing/offices.

HaveringWavering · 25/02/2022 19:33

Yes, that is truly terrible writing. Weird doublespeak. A bit gaslighty in fact- “you are telling us you don’t want this aren’t you?”

footballfan1963 · 25/02/2022 19:21

@red321 I miss Trewins too and also used to shop there with my mum in the 80s before it moved into the Harlequin.

Thank goodness for the Brent Cross branch which still seems safe for now. But I shopped there recently for a friend’s baby present and God it was dead. Toy department and nursery department had huge empty spaces instead of being well stocked. It lacked the buzz of years gone by.

linmanuel · 25/02/2022 19:18

@ScrollingLeaves

I should think they had to say something, rather than quietly drop it, because otherwise people might keep contacting them asking for rebates against something they’ve seen on-line.

I don’t think they are favouring their brand with orange lettering saying “Anyday” around the shop for some lines. It makes the overall atmosphere like ‘Kwik Save’. They should change the colour and lettering style in my opinion.

Yes. Seems like a ruse to me, esp on the app where the red prices make it seem like it's on sale

I get that it's everyday good value or whatever but still it irked

I think I am also perhaps too easily irked and need to save my energy for more important things

linmanuel · 25/02/2022 19:16

@pigsDOfly

Don't know about their PR but the level of service from John Lewis, especially in relation to deliveries, has been a disaster for quite a number of years now.
Yy agree
linmanuel · 25/02/2022 19:16

Yes they need to change to never knowingly something else

Their customer service used to be amazeballs
Less so now tbh

Hollyhead · 25/02/2022 19:15

I’m still a fairly loyal customer, I like their personal styling service but I hate the cheapo anyway range. I liked their standard John Lewis and partners range.
I want to be able to buy quality products somewhere on the high street, but buying Anyday makes me feel like I’ve sacrificed quality.

Orcadianrythyms · 25/02/2022 19:08

It's been really hard but I haven't spent a penny with them since November. Two delivery mistakes and the most shockingly bad customer service - enough was enough. I'm sure they don't care but the only power people have is to not give them your hard earned cash.

Candleabra · 25/02/2022 19:07

I strongly suspect the CFO is in charge at JL which is why they’re a) spending no money on the customer experience b) spending no money on the customer experience.

Yep I agree. When the only thing that matters is the bottom line it’s the beginning of the end.

WulyJmpr · 25/02/2022 19:05

I can tell them exactly who their target customers were before they started alienating them. It's almost like their marketing department couldn't accept this and didn't actually like their customers!

I believe the current leadership does not have a fashion background. If they did then they may recall in the late 00s when M&S tried and failed to employ a similar strategy of value ranges. Cheap and nasty clothes no different to Primark thus alienating its core customers.

M&S fashion side of business is only just getting back on track today after correctly identifying their shoppers want quality, style, aspiration and don't mind paying more

NessieMcNessface · 25/02/2022 19:02

Their email was an insult to our intelligence certainly. I am disappointed that they weren’t honest about the situation and tried to pretend that this move was in our best interests. If they had said that in in order to survive the current economic climate they were no longer going to be able to implement their NKU policy I would have respected that but to imply the change is for our benefit is ridiculous. I have pretty much done all my shopping with JL over recent years because of the 28 day NKU policy but I think that will probably change now.

red321 · 25/02/2022 18:59

That made me so sad. My mum and I spent hours in the Peterborough JL, I found it really comforting to have a wander round after she died. I really miss it.

I feel that loss about the Watford store. Many happy memories with my mum. Not such a happy memory of my then toddler projectile-vomiting strawberrry milkshake in their coffee shop.

Even Oxford Street feels a ghost town. It took me and another customer 15 minutes to find someone to answer a query in the jeans department. They're selling £200 jeans, you'd think it's worth their while to have someone to look for sizes or whatever. It's like tumbleweed blowing.

SickAndTiredAgain · 25/02/2022 18:59

I understand why they did it, but I agree with people saying it’s annoying to make out like they’re doing us a favour.

I felt similarly when sainsburys announced they weren’t doing the nectar double up promotion last year because (they said) customers didn’t want it and they wanted to do better things for us instead.. The double up promotion was basically free money to spend in sainsburys - I get why they didn’t want to do it, but don’t act like customers are saying “£40 extra to spend in the shop? No thanks” (£40 was the amount I’d have got if it had continued).

Cuck00soup · 25/02/2022 18:47

@WulyJmpr

I laughed out loud when I read this email. Their leadership needs to have a word

I think it might be the leadership that's the problem.