Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

John Lewis’ PR is awful?

168 replies

HelenaHandcart0 · 25/02/2022 14:10

Just received this in an email from JL saying they are ditching the ‘never knowingly undersold’ promise. Sadly I feel this could be the beginning of the end for them (I hope not) but what an awful way to communicate it!

It said:

..’we will be retiring our Never Knowingly Undersold policy this summer. Established back in 1925 and a hallmark of trust for nearly a century, we recognise that this policy is no longer serving you in the way that we would like, as it doesn't allow us to match prices from online-only retailers’

AIBU in thinking their PR is awful in communicating it this way?

OP posts:
merrymouse · 26/02/2022 08:02

as it doesn't allow us to match prices from online-only retailers

I’m confused - this implies that they could price match on-line retailers if they didn’t have the policy.

Having said that I have always thought the slogan was odd because to me it implies they are undersold all the time - just not knowingly.

HelenaHandcart0 · 26/02/2022 08:00

@HaveringWavering should have their job instead.

That would have been much better and retained my trust in them.

OP posts:
HelenaHandcart0 · 26/02/2022 07:57

Belated apologies to their PR team if it is the communications team who decided to share the news this way.

The e-mail felt so disingenuous, as if JL was taking me for a complete fool. Many other corporations may work this way but not HL, or so I’d thought.
It has been JL’s USPs of being owned by the partners, fabulous customer service and good quality products at sensible prices that has kept me going back.
And of course the lovely shops themselves.

I understand that they can’t price match physical shop prices with online retailers but I’m annoyed that they seem to be completely f*caking it up and don’t give a damn about loyal customers. Looking back at my JL account I have spent £12000+ (!) there over the last 3 years so a pretty consistent customer. I hate to think how much a previous poster spent in order to get a thank you card from JL!

Come on JL, we deserve better. Be honest about what you need to do to keep your shops and business alive.

Oh and if anyone is reading this, please don’t expand John Lewis financial products.
It is actual tangible good quality home, electrical, beauty, children’s and baby stuff, clothes, haberdashery, Christmas decorations etc etc I love.

But yes, whoever composed or approved that e-mail is in the wrong job.

OP posts:
HaveringWavering · 26/02/2022 07:56

On that subject: does the OP think that John Lewis should have asked her permission to drop ‘never knowingly undersold’? How else are they supposed to communicate bad news without sugar coating it? What should they have said? We know you won’t like it but tough luck cheapskates, it’s happening?

How about something like this:

“From this summer, we regret that we will no longer be able to stand by our famous promise to be “Never Knowingly Undersold”.

Established back in 1925, Never Knowingly Undersold has been a hallmark of trust for nearly a century. However we can’t match prices from online-only retailers. Rather than make you a promise we can no longer keep, we think that the best way to continue that tradition of trust is to focus instead on offering you the best possible customer service and value for money in our network of bricks-and-mortar stores.”

Libertybear80 · 26/02/2022 01:26

I'm afraid all our prior shopping experiences of the last 20 years are going to change. We were in a golden time for the high street shop. I've always loved a browse in JL but it couldn't last.

MintJulia · 26/02/2022 01:07

Rather than an email telling us they're dumping something familiar and trusted, they should at least have sent an email saying they were introducing something better.

Instead it sounds like 'we're going down-market like everyone else'

Their comms team needs firing.

Iamthewombat · 26/02/2022 00:57

At least some posters are whinging at the price match being withdrawn, irrespective of how communicated.

On that subject: does the OP think that John Lewis should have asked her permission to drop ‘never knowingly undersold’? How else are they supposed to communicate bad news without sugar coating it? What should they have said? We know you won’t like it but tough luck cheapskates, it’s happening?

If they hadn’t communicated the withdrawal of the policy, they would have had to deal with queues of people saying, “cheapass.com are selling this for £5 less, I want you to sell it to me for the same price and if you don’t I’ll kick up a massive stink”.

The message is accurate: if we still want department stores we have to accept that they can’t prove match Amazon, whose physical footprint is giant warehouses in cheap areas. So if we still want JL to exist (I do; it is a great shop), ‘never knowingly undersold’ has to go.

DontBeMean · 26/02/2022 00:45

@EmbarrassedAllOver You've got the wrong end of the stick. Posters aren't complaining that John Lewis are stopping NeverKnowinglyUndersold they are annoyed because John Lewis are trying to tell them it's because it's in the customers best interests when it clearly isn't. John Lewis are being disingenuous and treating their customers like idiots. No one would be pissed off at them if they were honest about it.

Redbirds · 26/02/2022 00:21

@MintMocha

And their 'rewards' are useless now too. They keep sending me surveys about them, and I keep saying the same thing - they are competitions, not rewards! How is a reward for me to enter a competition?! Bring back the coffee and cake vouchers, which meant something tangible, and got me back in the store rather than online.

Then get people properly trained to work in the different departments, and don't ignore the boring bits like haberdashery or whatever - real product knowledge, not just school-leavers trained to use the app and run the tills.

And get rid of the bright orange cheapo branding, and bring back quality products with the JL brand, at a reasonable price.

Drop the NKU if needed, fair enough and I think we'd understand if they can't afford it or whatever. But drop the patronising spin that it's a favour to us.

They should read this thread really, as I think many people here are exactly their core customers!

Agree 100% with this post.
HaveringWavering · 25/02/2022 23:39

@goingback

wow, bricks and mortar retailer struggling in a pandemic fuelled online shopping boom cuts price match policy and some free stuff that people take advantage of, and MNers are "really angry" and "pissed off" Meanwhile in Ukraine...
People are criticising the communication of the change, not the change itself.

It’s possible to be annoyed simultaneously with both Vladimir Putin and John Lewis.

Hairbrush123 · 25/02/2022 23:05

@Noisyprat

The JL 'Never Knowlingly Undersold' was a solid promise when retailers existed on the high street. Once on-line shopping came it was doomed to fail, how can a retailer with massive sqm of floor space and its associated costs compete with a retailer trading out of their garage or direct from manufacturer to consumer.

The fact is that people want the first class service but don't want to pay for. Organisations could either keep their 'exclusivity' or 'trade down'. Most have traded down, lookat BMW, BA and now JL.

The fact is most consumers know the 'price of everything but the value of nothing'. JL have faced a problem, if you want knowledgeable shop floor staff you need to pay them more/offer more. They can't afford to do this because of price competition.

I feel very sad about JL however for me, as someone in their 50's, the enjoyment of high street shopping has gone and is never to return. I like to see, feel, try on goods and have the enjoyment of 'shopping', long long gone and as a result I buy less.

Totally agree. I will continue to shop at John Lewis whenever I can and I am fortunate enough to have a John Lewis store in my local town centre.

People complain about the CEO’s lack of retail experience but I would dread to think how John Lewis would have fared during the pandemic if Sharon wasn’t the CEO. Her predecessor famously said that every city needs a John Lewis when online shopping was growing and shop footfall was starting to fall.

woodhill · 25/02/2022 22:46

@Noisyprat

The JL 'Never Knowlingly Undersold' was a solid promise when retailers existed on the high street. Once on-line shopping came it was doomed to fail, how can a retailer with massive sqm of floor space and its associated costs compete with a retailer trading out of their garage or direct from manufacturer to consumer.

The fact is that people want the first class service but don't want to pay for. Organisations could either keep their 'exclusivity' or 'trade down'. Most have traded down, lookat BMW, BA and now JL.

The fact is most consumers know the 'price of everything but the value of nothing'. JL have faced a problem, if you want knowledgeable shop floor staff you need to pay them more/offer more. They can't afford to do this because of price competition.

I feel very sad about JL however for me, as someone in their 50's, the enjoyment of high street shopping has gone and is never to return. I like to see, feel, try on goods and have the enjoyment of 'shopping', long long gone and as a result I buy less.

Yes I agree

I will continue to shop with JL as I have always had a positive experience but our local one has gone which is a real shame

goingback · 25/02/2022 22:43

wow, bricks and mortar retailer struggling in a pandemic fuelled online shopping boom cuts price match policy and some free stuff that people take advantage of, and MNers are "really angry" and "pissed off"
Meanwhile in Ukraine...

Noisyprat · 25/02/2022 22:25

The JL 'Never Knowlingly Undersold' was a solid promise when retailers existed on the high street. Once on-line shopping came it was doomed to fail, how can a retailer with massive sqm of floor space and its associated costs compete with a retailer trading out of their garage or direct from manufacturer to consumer.

The fact is that people want the first class service but don't want to pay for. Organisations could either keep their 'exclusivity' or 'trade down'. Most have traded down, lookat BMW, BA and now JL.

The fact is most consumers know the 'price of everything but the value of nothing'. JL have faced a problem, if you want knowledgeable shop floor staff you need to pay them more/offer more. They can't afford to do this because of price competition.

I feel very sad about JL however for me, as someone in their 50's, the enjoyment of high street shopping has gone and is never to return. I like to see, feel, try on goods and have the enjoyment of 'shopping', long long gone and as a result I buy less.

ThunderSnowDrop · 25/02/2022 22:16

Wow I never reached those heights.
It was a bit of an institution with my mum though: the senior staff knew her by name.😂

WulyJmpr · 25/02/2022 22:13

[quote EmbarrassedAllOver]@WulyJmpr

It's like a business school case study in how not to do business.

How can you possibly say that without knowing it's balance books, it's contracts, it's costs and profits?

In a world where Amazon is killing off the high street I find it almost laughable to read some of these comments.

"Loyal customers...." I highly doubt it. Buying the odd thing from there doesn't make someone a loyal customer. Not does creating or contributing to this kind of thread in a negative manner.

If you were a loyal customer, you'd accept that they will do what they can. If you want to shop there, shop there. If you don't or can't, then don't. But don't slate them for not price matching when they can't afford to continue it![/quote]
They sent me a Christmas gift as I spent so much money with them a couple of years ago. It included a handwritten note thanking me for my loyal custom.

Livelifeinthebuslane · 25/02/2022 22:09

Has the John Lewis marketing team turned up? Smile

EmbarrassedAllOver · 25/02/2022 22:07

@WulyJmpr

It's like a business school case study in how not to do business.

How can you possibly say that without knowing it's balance books, it's contracts, it's costs and profits?

In a world where Amazon is killing off the high street I find it almost laughable to read some of these comments.

"Loyal customers...." I highly doubt it. Buying the odd thing from there doesn't make someone a loyal customer. Not does creating or contributing to this kind of thread in a negative manner.

If you were a loyal customer, you'd accept that they will do what they can. If you want to shop there, shop there. If you don't or can't, then don't. But don't slate them for not price matching when they can't afford to continue it!

EmbarrassedAllOver · 25/02/2022 22:03

@MintMocha

And their 'rewards' are useless now too. They keep sending me surveys about them, and I keep saying the same thing - they are competitions, not rewards! How is a reward for me to enter a competition?! Bring back the coffee and cake vouchers, which meant something tangible, and got me back in the store rather than online.

Then get people properly trained to work in the different departments, and don't ignore the boring bits like haberdashery or whatever - real product knowledge, not just school-leavers trained to use the app and run the tills.

And get rid of the bright orange cheapo branding, and bring back quality products with the JL brand, at a reasonable price.

Drop the NKU if needed, fair enough and I think we'd understand if they can't afford it or whatever. But drop the patronising spin that it's a favour to us.

They should read this thread really, as I think many people here are exactly their core customers!

Have you ever worked for John Lewis?! Because if you haven't I'm not sure what you're basing that off at all.

I have, and I'll let you know, many of the current staff in haberdashery and fabrics at the Bluewater branch at least have decades in dress making experience. They aren't school leavers in the slightest. They're knowledgeable employees, working for a retail salary, with sector specific, detailed, knowledge.

They can't afford to reward customers. No other company is expected to, bar Boots and the odd supermarket, so why does JL have to? It would be their demise.

And "bring back the quality goods at a reasonable price". Have you even shopped in John Lewis of recent years? Their stuff IS good quality. You don't have to buy the Anyday goods. The other stuff is still reasonable and great quality. My JL towels are by far superior to my other towels and were the same price as everywhere else.

Everyone wants something for nothing. They cannot deliver what Amazon does. End of.

If you want a lovely physical store, with mature, decent customer service, with ethical trading at the heart (where possible) with good customer service policies and a great range of goods, then John Lewis is up there.

If you want a shop that throws money it hasn't got at customers and delivers the impossible, then dream on. Or accept that Amazon is as good as it's going to get price wise.

Cuck00soup · 25/02/2022 22:01

They are trying desperately to survive. Dont kick them while they're down, claiming they aren't 'remembering the customers'

Huh? Retailers need customers to survive.

WulyJmpr · 25/02/2022 21:57

@EmbarrassedAllOver

Sounds like a bitter post tbh.

Does it really bother you that much that they cant price match anymore? I mean, they treat their staff infinitely better than lots of other retailers (I've worked for them previously before you ask), they have massive overheads unlike lots of smaller stores and they ethically trade on lots of products. So of course they can't continue it.

And, I'm sorry, but don't all companies try to positively spin negative changes?

I guess I just think..... So what?! Why make a nasty post about one of the last remaining decent retailers out there

Why? Because most of us are dismayed that while we previously loyal customers can see the writing is on the wall for our much loved JL, the company leadership itself seemingly cannot while it trips and stumbles into obvious gaping retail craters.

It's like a business school case study in how not to do business.

EmbarrassedAllOver · 25/02/2022 21:52

@Cuck00soup

There was a thread recently about bringing your whole self to work. JL encourage their staff to "be themselves always" or some such.

What a shame they forgot about their customers.

And yes I do know about rule one in the constitution. The partnership is required to look after its staff not maximise profits. However I don't think Spedan meant forget your customers because profit doesn't matter.

That's all very well, but if continuing policies means an ultimate demise, then it isn't serving the customer is it?

Wouldn't customers prefer they stay open?

Would you rather they just start giving stuff away? Amazon is killing these stores off. They are trying desperately to survive. Dont kick them while they're down, claiming they aren't 'remembering the customers'

EmbarrassedAllOver · 25/02/2022 21:47

Sounds like a bitter post tbh.

Does it really bother you that much that they cant price match anymore? I mean, they treat their staff infinitely better than lots of other retailers (I've worked for them previously before you ask), they have massive overheads unlike lots of smaller stores and they ethically trade on lots of products. So of course they can't continue it.

And, I'm sorry, but don't all companies try to positively spin negative changes?

I guess I just think..... So what?! Why make a nasty post about one of the last remaining decent retailers out there

Hairbrush123 · 25/02/2022 21:32

I must be the rarity but I love John Lewis and would consider myself a loyalty Blush. I bought most of my furniture from them and have been impressed with the quality. Whenever something has gone wrong, I’ve contacted them and they’ve been very helpful! My local branch in my town centre is always busy but I do agree with the PP that the staff do look slightly scruffy!

Click and Collect is so easy - it’s free to park for 30 minutes right outside John Lewis’ collection point so you maybe have to 10 seconds to the collection point to get your stuff.

GoodnessTruthBeauty · 25/02/2022 21:20

I think this quote from a report on Nordstrom sums up their strategy well. JL don't seem to have a strategy to build a loyal customer base.

"Seamlesscustomer experience
Nordstrom Rack is how the Nordstrom brand invites younger, “aspirational” shoppers in without marginalizing the main department stores’ luxury appeal, and they’re also using their e-commerce legs to get online customers in stores."

Like its very clever and great for customer service that you can order online and they will get it to the closest store to you in 24 hrs. Because of course there is a good chance you will buy something else while you are there.