Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this what defines a good mother these days?

237 replies

coffeelover13 · 25/02/2022 12:54

Just had a chat with my mummy friends and talking about our weekend plans .. I said that myself & DH are going away on a baby free weekend. (Baby is 8 months)

They were all shocked & said in quite a judging tone that they could NEVER do that !! How awful for the baby !! Wtf 😂

She will be left with my parents who absolutely ADORE her and I know she'll be well looked after. She's breastfed but takes a bottle or formula if needed. I don't see the issue here.

These ladies seem to think that they are better mothers as they have never left their babies for more than a couple of hours.

Looking back they were also shocked when the babies were 2 months old that my DH was "allowed " to do bath time. Again wtf ? He's her dad and after a long day away with work he loved doing bath time once home so I could have a cuppa.

Am I a bad mum ? When I'm with my DD I give her all of me. But I think it's just as important to spend some time with just my DH. Surely if we're happy as a couple that's a good thing for our DD
One of those "I never leave my baby " is an Instagram wannabe influencer & posts every 2 mins. So yes she's with her DD but spends 50% of her day on her phone. So how am I worse for going away for 2 nights ?

OP posts:
usinon · 25/02/2022 13:59

I wouldn't judge you or the other mothers. I always felt a bit agog at the idea of leaving a baby to spend a night away or something because there was no part of me that wanted to! It might be because it was because I was an older mother and so had had a long time of freedom before having dc.

But basically if you want to form an informed objective view it is worth looking at the actual research around attachment for babies. Also look at anxiety, effect of separation as a baby on the child when they get older, cortisol and so on.

If your mother meets the baby's needs and have been a continuous presence then that will be a positive factor here.

The other mothers may not have a trusted parent. I wouldn't have trusted my parents with my dc for 10 mins let alone 2 nights!

reesewithoutaspoon · 25/02/2022 13:56

Nana and grandad had overnights from 5 weeks old. Getting a full nights sleep kept me sane and both now grown adults and they have a wonderful relationship with their grandparent

SamuraiPizzaCats · 25/02/2022 13:56

Is there anything better for a child than having a well adjusted Mum and Dad in a loving relationship? That look after their own wellbeing as well as their child's? I think as they grow up it will set a good example for them. So take the night off 😊😊😊

Lunalicious · 25/02/2022 13:56

I personally wouldn't have left any of my babies for that long that young, we breastfed and did attachment parenting style stuff. I would have hated being apart from then when they were that small. But we all have different priorities in life not everyone wants to be that sort of mum and that is your choice.

caranations · 25/02/2022 13:54

Ignore the martyrs and have a lovely break. Smile

BakeOffRewatch · 25/02/2022 13:52

@KneadingKitty

I didnt and still wouldnt leave my child at that age because I think its too young. Do i think that makes me better? Nah. I have so many flaws as a mother. It simply makes me comfortable with the choices I made for my children. Thats what matters. Youre happy with yours and your child wont come to harm, so whatever. Enjoy! 😊
This is what I mean, @KneadingKitty says it so much better!
TrufflesAndToast · 25/02/2022 13:51

Oh but the bath thing is ridiculous.

I’m envious honestly of people who can worry less than I do. The idea of being a flight away from my kids makes me want to throw up, it blows my mind when people take holidays away from their young kids. But I bet they feel great for it, I wish I could be more relaxed as I know I’m anxious to a quite unhealthy degree at times.

RJnomore1 · 25/02/2022 13:51

Nope op, I’m 45 and my mother was like that, I can only conclude there’s outliers in every parenting generation. Most people wouldn’t bat an eyelid.

BakeOffRewatch · 25/02/2022 13:51

I don’t think you’re a bad mum. I’d reserve that for people who are physically and emotionally negligent.

My DH has been bathing baby since day one, because I had mobility issues.

I wouldn’t have left a breastfed 8 month old personally for two nights. I know mine looks for me and DH though, that’s what pulls at my heart strings. If you know yours is happy with your parents then what’s the big deal.

Mine is in nursery 11 hours a day from 1yo I know some people think that’s awful. But she’s happy there and doesn’t look for us, she’s happily bonded with the nursery carers.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/02/2022 13:50

I wouldn’t have wanted to leave mine (not that the opportunity ever arose then) but I wouldn’t judge anyone for a night or two. In fact when the first Gdc was about 10 months I gave dd a birthday present of a dinner, bed and breakfast, plus a lie in! - at a local hotel for her and Sil - dh and I babysat.

I was Shock though, at a (non Brit) friend, who once told me she’d left her first baby for a whole month with her mother, while she and her dh went on an extended holiday.

Such things were not unusual within her particular (Mediterranean) culture though.

TrufflesAndToast · 25/02/2022 13:50

Being honest I do raise an internal eyebrow at the idea of leaving an 8 month old breastfed baby for two nights out of choice but I would NEVER say anything negative out loud as it’s totally none of my business. I’m not honestly surprised you noticed some hesitancy from a group of mums of babies when you said that, because it’s unlikely that all of those people would make the same choices as you. But if you’re happy it doesn’t matter, so enjoy your weekend and stop worrying about anyone else’s opinions.

Geranium1984 · 25/02/2022 13:49

OMG your baby sounds so chilled out and flexible being happy with grandparents and takes a bottle. BOOM, what a dream, I'd go for it!

My boy is now 18mo and has always been a stage 5 clinger and never took a bottle so I had never really left him with anyone apart from his dad. We got him a babysitter at 10mo on occasions as we wanted to prep him for going into nursery when I went back to work at 12mo. Was very difficult and he took a long time to settle into nursery.

If baby is happy and your confident about the care I'd say you're doing very well and wish I could do the same! Enjoy!!

Also re. Bath I definitely have my dh bath my son, and I think most of my friends husbands do too. Totally normal. Ask these women how they cope without any help.

KneadingKitty · 25/02/2022 13:46

I didnt and still wouldnt leave my child at that age because I think its too young. Do i think that makes me better? Nah. I have so many flaws as a mother. It simply makes me comfortable with the choices I made for my children. Thats what matters. Youre happy with yours and your child wont come to harm, so whatever. Enjoy! 😊

SoftSheen · 25/02/2022 13:45

You're not a bad mother, of course.

But it isn't surprising that many mothers wouldn't leave their 8 month old for a weekend (I wouldn't have done). If the baby is breast fed, then a 48 hour absence is quite difficult for both mother and baby.

And not leaving a baby overnight until they are a year or two old doesn't necessarily mean their parents can't be 'happy as a couple'.

KirstenBlest · 25/02/2022 13:45

Looking back they were also shocked when the babies were 2 months old that my DH was "allowed " to do bath time.

These are the 'mummy friends' who will be complaining on here that their DH has a hobby and 'never helps'

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 25/02/2022 13:44

When Will Storr was interviewed about the most recent book—The Status Game: On Social Position and How We Use It—he specifically mentioned status jostling as a good or bad parent on MN.

It looks like it's all about choices and behaviour but it's about people competing for status and attempting to draw up rules in line with their own definitions. Competing in games with other people's rules can be very poor for people's mental health.

www.amazon.co.uk/dp/0008354634?tag=mumsnetforu03-21

thanktor · 25/02/2022 13:42

Me - when I’m on form
Not me - when I’m rushing and harassed

sweeneytoddsrazor · 25/02/2022 13:42

My parents had all my children and my sisters children for overnight stays from a very young age. They also took them away for up to a week at a time. It gave all the parents time to themselves to catch up on sleep or just enjoy some time with partners. All of them have an incredibly close bond still and all of them choose to visit GPS either for family occasions or on their own for a cuppa and a catch up.

DropYourSword · 25/02/2022 13:38

[quote coffeelover13]@DropYourSword

Sorry I meant before this thread. 😊
Feeing a lot better after hearing people's opinions and that I'm not the only one [/quote]
I totally misinterpreted your post Blush

I thought the "thanks all" was a snarky "thanks for making me feel shit" and now I see it was literally meant completely genuinely! Apologies

coffeelover13 · 25/02/2022 13:36

@DropYourSword

Sorry I meant before this thread. 😊
Feeing a lot better after hearing people's opinions and that I'm not the only one

OP posts:
RandomQuest · 25/02/2022 13:35

Get some new friends and ditch the pathetic mummy martyrs. They’re not your people.

Kylereese · 25/02/2022 13:33

Lol. They’d hate me then. My pfb went to grandmas on her 14th night so I could have a full nights sleep

Somethingsnappy · 25/02/2022 13:31

I didn't ever leave mine at that age for practical reasons (BF), but to be honest whether I could have left them on an emotional level or not would have depended on the child. I have 4. My first was very independent and sociable. I think I'd have felt reasonably OK for a night away from her. The others would have struggled more with it and consequently, so would I. My current baby would be very unhappy without me, and so I couldn't bear to leave him as I'd be worrying constantly. For me, it's definitely related to how the babies would have managed.

Blossom64265 · 25/02/2022 13:30

A baby isn’t old enough to have a conversation explaining what is happening and when you will return. They can’t verbalize real questions or tell you about their experience when you get back. Yes, you know your child will be loved and cared for, but the child’s perspective and reflection on the experience matters too.

ThackeryBinks · 25/02/2022 13:29

I first left my baby at 8 months. It was hugely traumatic. Left once more for an operation. Absolutely inseparable from each other. My DD hated school the separation from me being part of it. We are just getting the hang of it now. DD is 19! Does this make a good mother? Not so much! I would do it very differently with hind sight. One of the best things you can do is show your kids a healthy loving relationship. Enjoy your weekend lovely!