Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this what defines a good mother these days?

237 replies

coffeelover13 · 25/02/2022 12:54

Just had a chat with my mummy friends and talking about our weekend plans .. I said that myself & DH are going away on a baby free weekend. (Baby is 8 months)

They were all shocked & said in quite a judging tone that they could NEVER do that !! How awful for the baby !! Wtf 😂

She will be left with my parents who absolutely ADORE her and I know she'll be well looked after. She's breastfed but takes a bottle or formula if needed. I don't see the issue here.

These ladies seem to think that they are better mothers as they have never left their babies for more than a couple of hours.

Looking back they were also shocked when the babies were 2 months old that my DH was "allowed " to do bath time. Again wtf ? He's her dad and after a long day away with work he loved doing bath time once home so I could have a cuppa.

Am I a bad mum ? When I'm with my DD I give her all of me. But I think it's just as important to spend some time with just my DH. Surely if we're happy as a couple that's a good thing for our DD
One of those "I never leave my baby " is an Instagram wannabe influencer & posts every 2 mins. So yes she's with her DD but spends 50% of her day on her phone. So how am I worse for going away for 2 nights ?

OP posts:
Tdcp · 25/02/2022 15:52

I spent every waking moment with DD for 15 months, even then I only for a few hours out alone (not by choice). She barely gets any time away from me still, apart from school really (again not by choice, I try and arrange playdates etc). She's 7 and she still has separation anxiety. I'm not saying leaving your kids at every opportunity is a good thing but being with them 24/7 definitely isn't. Enjoy yourself!

penelopequiche · 25/02/2022 15:49

You are clearly an awful mother. Time to yourself? How dare you?! Seriously though, just be happy that you have lovely parents that will willingly help and enjoy! How can you parent well if you're constantly exhausted and don't have time together as a couple. I left my dd with my mum and dad from time to time when she was little and everyone benefited. Ignore the judgment, better still find friends who don't judge!

Lesperance · 25/02/2022 15:49

I don't think they are jealous, I would not have left my eight month old either. And I wouldn't have been jealous of anybody who did. The bath thing is weird. But you are judging them too. You clearly find it hard to image that anybody could have a different relationship with their baby than you do with yours. Neither of you is right, but you should learn to be a bit more secure in your decisions, because this will not be the last time that you will chose to do things differently to other people.

TheDuchessOfMN · 25/02/2022 15:47

It’s not something I ever did or wanted to do, but I’d never comment if someone else did.
But then I never had helpful grandparents either, so maybe I’d feel differently if they were.

Tbh I’d be more amazed that you could actually leave a breastfed 8 month old for 2 nights. I mean, from a supply/engorgement issue, or the fact that she might be slow to latch once you’re back. I presume you’ll be pumping whilst away? Obviously you don’t have to answer that, just thinking out loud to myself Blush

Enjoy Smile

bluesk75 · 25/02/2022 15:46

@minniep

The bath thing is weird I can't get my head around it at all. I've never left mine while I went away overnight and my eldest is 9 but to be honest for me my issue is that my parents lived for their nights out and didn't particularly care about which sulky teenage sibling of my mum was babysitting so I've horrible memories of being left with people who didn't particularly want to be minding me. My gran sometimes minded me during the day but again I was made to feel like an inconvenience. Nothing horrible or bad ever happened to me but I hated it and I never want my child in that situation. I don't have any younger siblings to babysit for me so in reality it's a non issue but still I've a total thing in my head about leaving the children and them missing me too much but it's my issue. Also my mother has never offered to babysit so there's that. Enjoy your time away OP and appreciate the fact your child has fabulous grandparents.
@minniep what is weird about the bath thing, can you explain because I don't see the problem?
minniep · 25/02/2022 15:43

The bath thing is weird I can't get my head around it at all.
I've never left mine while I went away overnight and my eldest is 9 but to be honest for me my issue is that my parents lived for their nights out and didn't particularly care about which sulky teenage sibling of my mum was babysitting so I've horrible memories of being left with people who didn't particularly want to be minding me. My gran sometimes minded me during the day but again I was made to feel like an inconvenience. Nothing horrible or bad ever happened to me but I hated it and I never want my child in that situation. I don't have any younger siblings to babysit for me so in reality it's a non issue but still I've a total thing in my head about leaving the children and them missing me too much but it's my issue. Also my mother has never offered to babysit so there's that. Enjoy your time away OP and appreciate the fact your child has fabulous grandparents.

inmyslippers · 25/02/2022 15:41

I really don't miss baby mum groups

ImWearingReallyJudgyPants · 25/02/2022 15:39

One of those "I never leave my baby " is an Instagram wannabe influencer & posts every 2 mins. So yes she's with her DD but spends 50% of her day on her phone

I'm afraid your entire post reads as "I'm better than my 'mummy friends'", OP. Of course you are not a bad mum if you're able to leave your baby for a night with extended family who love her, but you already know that.

Sunnytwobridges · 25/02/2022 15:36

Ahhhh... Sounds like your friends are a bunch of sancti-mummies. Only their way of mothering is the right way.

I had a friend like this. She always made me feel bad for looking forward to my child free summers (once my DD turned 5 she started going to her dad's house every summer for about 6 weeks). I was told what was the point of having kids if I looked forward to time without DD, I should be moping since she was gone instead of enjoying the child free time, etc. For years I felt like a bad mom because I didn't want to spend 24/7 glued to my kid but then one day I realized I was a better mother having that child free time.

There's no right or wrong in this situation. So do what's best for you, as long as your kid is safe and well cared for then you shouldn't feel guilty. I only WISH I could've had some weekends to myself when my DD was 8 months old, that would've been like heaven lol

BoredZelda · 25/02/2022 15:31

I'm not criticising them at all

This isn’t criticism? One of those "I never leave my baby " is an Instagram wannabe influencer & posts every 2 mins. So yes she's with her DD but spends 50% of her day on her phone. So how am I worse for going away for 2 nights

Sounds like you all judge each other. Also sounds like you have your own insecurities to deal with. Go, or don’t go. Whatever works for you.

bluesk75 · 25/02/2022 15:28

I don't get the bath thing though? Is it that they weren't able to trust their partners to bath their baby or what?

bluesk75 · 25/02/2022 15:26

Pay no mind to them.

The first time I ever left DD alone with her dad was when she was 8 weeks and people were so surprised that I'd left her at home. I just went out to get my hair done and a pedicure lol. We first left DD to have two nights away at a hotel when she was 12 weeks. Again, we got loads of comments. I'm not sure if some people want you to be joined to the hip with your baby for every second but I never understood it.

Enjoy your two nights away, I'm sure it's well deserved and it's great to have a break

OfstedOffred · 25/02/2022 15:24

No family willing or able to take them. You start to feel only you can look after them and the thought of leaving them becomes very ailen.

This is really true too. When you don't have family nearby often there isnt anyone who really knows your children well at all whom you could actually leave them with. Then the longer time passes and you haven't done it, that issue gets compounded as your children aren't used to it and find it very unpleasant.

Selma22 · 25/02/2022 15:24

@LuckySantangelo35

For those that wouldn’t leave your baby overnight or for a weekend with loving and capable grandparents-can I ask why? No judgement from me just genuinely curious. Is it that you think they won’t be cared for as well? Is it because you will miss them and would just prefer to be with them rather than anything else? Is it because you worry it would have some adverse impact on baby? Is it because social conditioning means you would feel Guilty of you did? As I say just genuinely curious
For me personally this is the explanation (I don't judge anyone who does this ). My Dd knows when I am away even when talking about my partner .She is breastfed and since birth sort of my mini me.She isn't old enough to understand where I went or care too much about outings or stuff my parents can give her (I'm sure she will love it later on ).At that age majority just want to have their primary care taker near them.My daughter calms down when my shirt is put in her cot not even talking about me actually being next to her.I just know that when I'm away I might be having a blast but she might not be .When she is older and can understand and appreciate the special relationships with others etc then I'm gone .My partner and I are still to take our honeymoon so will definitely utilise grandparents as childcare
WetLookKnitwear · 25/02/2022 15:23

They sound ridiculous, I think you know it too but you’re trying to make yourself feel better by inviting digs against women who do it differently to you rather women who are judgemental of others.

The problem is them being judgemental, not how willing or unwilling any of you are to leave the baby for a weekend. They shouldn’t have made you feel bad.

mam0918 · 25/02/2022 15:22

I struggle with this a bit sometimes.

Me and DH have gone away many times without the kids (usually just a hotel for a night on our anniversary.

We did once go on a 10 day holiday to another continent though (for a milestone birthday) and it wouldn't really have been suitable for small kids (we would need to transport a tonne of stuff + I doubt they would enjoy all the vaccinations, long travel hours and non-fun activities) but I felt guilty even though everyone supported it and said it was great.

I feel bad because our parents never went away without us BUT at the same time, I'm a SAHM so it's not like my kids only see me on holidays and we do go on family holidays too where they are all aimed at the kids enjoyment (child museums, soft plays, kids shows etc...).

I don't think its healthy to never have time away, even on 'date nights' (pretty rare lol) kids stay with grandparents overnight because by the time we have had a meal and been to the cinema/show its past their bedtime so would be cruel to drag them up and home just so we could pretend we're better for having them sleep in our house.

They are with beloved grandparents not left alone in the garden to fend of Jackyls in the fridged weather hardly cruel.

OfstedOffred · 25/02/2022 15:22

Either option is fine. Some people just have no desire to leave the kids with grandma for a long weekend. I work full time and my kids sleep well, so I get every evening alone time with DH and we can very easily get out to dinner or cinema etc while asleep, so to me I dont have that need to leave the kids to just get a bit of time with DH.

Its horses for courses. There's no one good way to be a mum. You don't need to justify your choices to them, but it's also fine for them to not feel any particular desire to leave their own kids.

mynamesnotMa · 25/02/2022 15:21

They are jealous.

Satingreenshutters · 25/02/2022 15:20

@TrufflesAndToast

Also having just read your reason for not wanting to leave your baby. That is totally understandable. You have a certain anxiety around it and even though you know those things most probably will not happen, you also know you could not relax or enjoy yourself if you were out. That is perfectly normal. My issue is with those who try and make others feel like a shit mother if they DO decide to go out and waffle on and on about how they could NEVER do it under any circumstance etc purely to bring the other Mum down.

I have huge anxiety around my teenagers going out at night, I imagine all sorts, the MAJORITY of it unfounded but I still do it every week and can't sleep until they are in so I get where you are coming from.

Ghostofchristmaspasty · 25/02/2022 15:17

I would have been jealous tbh. Breastfed both my babies until they were toddlers. They were both hard work and poor sleepers.

DH lacking confidence and got very stressed with crying being unable to soothe them.

No family willing or able to take them. You start to feel only you can look after them and the thought of leaving them becomes very ailen. It's no wonder people struggle, the village just isn't there for some. It is now they are older ( parents of their friends) and it's amazing to be able to ask people for help.

I'm not sure what I would have done differently - ensured I had a robust DH and set of grandparents who were willing to help.

Enjoy your time away.

I would have felt so much better supported had I have able to go away and leave them with someone I trusted.

OddSocksSparklyDocsandDungaree · 25/02/2022 15:09

People will always find something if they can. I was told my daughter was too young to go to nursery at 5.5 months old. Now, shes 1 and has zero issues with separation.

Satingreenshutters · 25/02/2022 15:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Solmum1964 · 25/02/2022 15:06

I've always felt very fortunate. My PILs stayed at our house when my twins were about 5 months old so DH and I could go away for our anniversary. They had seen DC multiple times up to then and DC were no longer breastfed due to me having an allergic reaction when they were a few weeks and needing antihistamines. We only went a short distance - just in case - but DC were fine.
PILs regularly had the children for a week at a time in school holidays (lived about 3 hours drive away on a good run) and they were thoroughly spoilt. Unfortunately FIL has sadly died but now adult DC have a fantastic relationship with MIL and will visit when they can, even though one has moved even further away.
I was very happy to encourage a good relationship, knowing that if we ever needed, as opposed to wanted, the PILs to have the children all would be happy. I don't think it's good for young children never to have been left with anyone else. They are much more likely to be upset if this were to be necessary in an emergency!

Holskey · 25/02/2022 15:02

I'd have loved a night away! (Though I wouldn't enjoy 2 nights.) The reason I've never done it is because my ds would have separation anxiety. It depends on the child you get.

Then there's childcare, sleeping arrangements, feeding etc.

Practicalities aside, these mothers probably thought of their babies upset and missing them and were horrified by that idea.

Sailor2009 · 25/02/2022 14:58

My 11 month old goes to my ILs one night a month so me and her dad can have date night. I work from home but each month I leave her with her dad so I can go down to our head office for 3-4 days. Those nights laying in a hotel reading in peace and sleeping all night are bliss.
Once I go back to work properly I will leave her with her dad for 6 weeks at a time, that's going to be tough admittedly. Your friends would hate me.