Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this what defines a good mother these days?

237 replies

coffeelover13 · 25/02/2022 12:54

Just had a chat with my mummy friends and talking about our weekend plans .. I said that myself & DH are going away on a baby free weekend. (Baby is 8 months)

They were all shocked & said in quite a judging tone that they could NEVER do that !! How awful for the baby !! Wtf 😂

She will be left with my parents who absolutely ADORE her and I know she'll be well looked after. She's breastfed but takes a bottle or formula if needed. I don't see the issue here.

These ladies seem to think that they are better mothers as they have never left their babies for more than a couple of hours.

Looking back they were also shocked when the babies were 2 months old that my DH was "allowed " to do bath time. Again wtf ? He's her dad and after a long day away with work he loved doing bath time once home so I could have a cuppa.

Am I a bad mum ? When I'm with my DD I give her all of me. But I think it's just as important to spend some time with just my DH. Surely if we're happy as a couple that's a good thing for our DD
One of those "I never leave my baby " is an Instagram wannabe influencer & posts every 2 mins. So yes she's with her DD but spends 50% of her day on her phone. So how am I worse for going away for 2 nights ?

OP posts:
ChoiceMummy · 25/02/2022 17:40

@coffeelover13

Thanks all

Started to feel like I'm not that great of a mum for being ok with leaving her for 2 nights with people that love her

So in effect you're leaving your 8 months old for 3 days if going for 2 nights.

Yes, I'd judge you too!

Matters not that the grandparents love her, they're not their primary caregiver. She will feel abandoned.

Lesperance · 25/02/2022 17:38

@bluesk75

I really want to know what's weird about the dad bathing his kid at 2 months old😂 I seriously don't get it
Because you think that the poster was saying it's weird for a dad to do the bath at 2 months. The poster was probably saying that it is weird that Looking back they were also shocked when the babies were 2 months old that my DH was "allowed " to do bath time. Some people think they might have a point about leaving the baby, but that the attitude to dads doing bath is weird. Actually I do think this is very, very odd, on the OP's side. What kind of a martyrish mother does all the baths for eight weeks? Talk about a rod for your own back!
Lesperance · 25/02/2022 17:34

@Chonfox

I can only imagine that people who says they could "never leave" an 8 month old child have no trusted family members who will take said child. Otherwise it's an attitude I quite literally can't fathom. How can people not be DYING for a break after 8 months of baby drudge?! I wouldn't have left my children with anyone but my mum at that age. My mum was heavily involved in their care since birth and so leaving them with her was akin to leaving them with their father, in fact it was better for them as mum was way better with them than DH when they were babies/toddlers.

We went on a 10 day trip to America when they were about 10months and 2yo and left them with my mum. It was brilliant. I'm sure some may have raised eyebrows but no one dared raise it with me! I never really question my mothering and wouldn't allow anyone else to either - I refuse to engage in that sexism. The majority of mothers give their mind, body and soul to their DC when they're little. We serve more holidays if anything! So when you ask "am I a bad mum?" I feel irritated - you're feeding into that nonsense. You KNOW you're not a bad mum. Don't let people influence you like that. Particularly people who are most likely jealous, martyrs, or riddled with internalised misogyny.

Enjoy your well deserved break Wink

I didn't have people I could leave my children with. But I'm sure I wouldn't have wanted to leave them. But I can't fathom getting into a situation whereby your mum is more reliable carer than your child's father, when you are married and living together. That's why it felt like drudgery to you. Not everybody has the same experience.
Satingreenshutters · 25/02/2022 17:27

@AgeingDoc

*I just think that is bizarre, your kids are all over 15 and some in their 20's and you and your hubby have "looked after" them every night except 2. In 25 years? Utterly utterly bizarre. They are adults. My eldest lives with her partner and runs her own business. Of course I don't look after her. But because there is a big age gap, when she left home, the youngest was still in primary school and obviously couldn't be left alone. The arithmetic isn't terribly difficult. If you have children with a fairly wide age range, you are obviously going to have at least one who is dependent for far longer than if you only have one or a couple with a small age gap. And no, I don't consider a 15 year old an adult. Whilst it isn't actually illegal to leave a child of that age alone overnight, it certainly isn't recommended. Both the NSPCC and the government suggest 16 as the minimum age it's reasonable to leave a child alone overnight.
Nobody ever mentioned alone. We were talking with someone else like grandparents.
WimpoleHat · 25/02/2022 17:27

Comparing your own choices with other people's is an enormous waste of time and energy and rarely ends well.

This is the best piece of advice I’ve ever seen on MN….

Maray1967 · 25/02/2022 17:21

OP, so tell them straight and then walk away. No one needs ‘friends’ like these.
You said one is an influencer and posts all the time - tell her straight. ‘Well, I don’t think it’s great parenting to spend half the day on your phone but you seem to .’
Don’t sit there in silence while they make you feel you bad.
Can you tell I was the bottle feeding mum who responded firmly to a couple of mum-martyred breast feeding mums when they commented ?

I regard it as a service to unknown others who might not be able to cope with the unhelpful or unpleasant comments as robustly as I can. If I make just one of them think twice about comments like that in future I have done a good deed. Making someone feel bad about leaving an 8 month baby with loving grandparents needs a firm response.
Have a great weekend!

OfstedOffred · 25/02/2022 17:12

How can people not be DYING for a break after 8 months of baby drudge?!

I just never felt like this.

My life and identity didnt end when I had kids. But it changed. It grew. I'm ok with that. My identity will continue to change and grow as they do, don't worry I'll be just fine when they move on and leave home!

bluesk75 · 25/02/2022 17:12

In 25 years of parenting, I've been away from my children overnight for a grand total of two days. I didn't enjoy it although they were fine. It's not bad parenting to want to be with your kids.

That is crazy

bluesk75 · 25/02/2022 17:12

I really want to know what's weird about the dad bathing his kid at 2 months old😂 I seriously don't get it

bluesk75 · 25/02/2022 17:11

@RedRobyn2021

The bath thing is really weird btw
@RedRobyn2021 what's wrong with a dad bathing the baby at 8 weeks?? I honestly don't get it
Jvg33 · 25/02/2022 17:10

Have a nice weekend away. I wish I were you this evening.

Ohyesiam · 25/02/2022 17:09

Sounds like you’ve got the balance right in lots of ways.

peboh · 25/02/2022 17:08

I think it's just a difference in people and personalities.
A mum at my dds nursery was asking about holidays, and I mentioned that I was going away in the summer for a friends wedding, but leaving dd and dh at home ... and she was baffled. Couldn't understand how I could have a holiday without my husband and child. I didn't feel judged, I just laughed it off and understood that her ideals were different than mine.
I never thought she meant to be tell me I was a bad mum either, and if she did then that reflects her and not me.

BoredZelda · 25/02/2022 17:07

You are allowed your own interests and life away from your children.

Equally, you are allowed not to be bothered about that without being accused of martyrdom.

RedRobyn2021 · 25/02/2022 17:06

@Echobelly

Yeah, some people are martyrs. I totally get and have sympathy for people who don't have money or family for extended childcare and never get out because of that, but I'll admit I rolleyes at people who say things like 'We've been invited to a childfree wedding with the bride paying for luxury accommodation. My parents live round the corner and are very happy to have the kids (6 & 8), but we've never had a single night out since they were born because I feel so baaaaad about leaving them. Should we go?'

Not having any kids-free time when you have options to do so is not actually good parenting.

Can't do right for doing wrong can we?

I'm not a good parent because I don't leave my baby now.

Honestly, you're being just as ridiculous as these women the OP has been talking to.

AgeingDoc · 25/02/2022 17:05

*I just think that is bizarre, your kids are all over 15 and some in their 20's and you and your hubby have "looked after" them every night except 2. In 25 years? Utterly utterly bizarre. They are adults.
My eldest lives with her partner and runs her own business. Of course I don't look after her. But because there is a big age gap, when she left home, the youngest was still in primary school and obviously couldn't be left alone. The arithmetic isn't terribly difficult. If you have children with a fairly wide age range, you are obviously going to have at least one who is dependent for far longer than if you only have one or a couple with a small age gap.
And no, I don't consider a 15 year old an adult. Whilst it isn't actually illegal to leave a child of that age alone overnight, it certainly isn't recommended. Both the NSPCC and the government suggest 16 as the minimum age it's reasonable to leave a child alone overnight.

Selma22 · 25/02/2022 17:04

@Chonfox

I can only imagine that people who says they could "never leave" an 8 month old child have no trusted family members who will take said child. Otherwise it's an attitude I quite literally can't fathom. How can people not be DYING for a break after 8 months of baby drudge?! I wouldn't have left my children with anyone but my mum at that age. My mum was heavily involved in their care since birth and so leaving them with her was akin to leaving them with their father, in fact it was better for them as mum was way better with them than DH when they were babies/toddlers.

We went on a 10 day trip to America when they were about 10months and 2yo and left them with my mum. It was brilliant. I'm sure some may have raised eyebrows but no one dared raise it with me! I never really question my mothering and wouldn't allow anyone else to either - I refuse to engage in that sexism. The majority of mothers give their mind, body and soul to their DC when they're little. We serve more holidays if anything! So when you ask "am I a bad mum?" I feel irritated - you're feeding into that nonsense. You KNOW you're not a bad mum. Don't let people influence you like that. Particularly people who are most likely jealous, martyrs, or riddled with internalised misogyny.

Enjoy your well deserved break Wink

I trust my mil and my own mother very much but my daughter spends her time mostly with me (maternity ).She sometimes doesn't settle with my partner even (he has a job and only looks after her after work ) .Mother and child has a different relationship and some are ok being apart some have separation anxiety. I Would love to get time away but I start to get anxious and I know she does too if its too long.
Girliefriendlikespuppies · 25/02/2022 17:01

I left my dd at 6 months to go to a friends wedding, she was with her nan and apart from my boobs feeling like they were going to go pop it was fine!!

I also went on holiday abroad without her for a week when she was 3yo and again when she was 4 😬 again she was with her nan and we both had a lovely time.

RedRobyn2021 · 25/02/2022 16:59

The bath thing is really weird btw

RedRobyn2021 · 25/02/2022 16:58

Of course you aren't a bad mother!!!

If you're comfortable leaving your daughter for the weekend with her grandparents there's absolutely nothing wrong with that.

I say that as a mother who wasn't comfortable being apart from my daughter until very recently (she is 12mo). If you are happy and baby is happy, ffs there isn't a problem!

Sometimes you need to have some time to yourself and with your partner, just do whatever works for you guys and ignore their frankly stupid comments

Chonfox · 25/02/2022 16:56

I can only imagine that people who says they could "never leave" an 8 month old child have no trusted family members who will take said child. Otherwise it's an attitude I quite literally can't fathom. How can people not be DYING for a break after 8 months of baby drudge?! I wouldn't have left my children with anyone but my mum at that age. My mum was heavily involved in their care since birth and so leaving them with her was akin to leaving them with their father, in fact it was better for them as mum was way better with them than DH when they were babies/toddlers.

We went on a 10 day trip to America when they were about 10months and 2yo and left them with my mum. It was brilliant. I'm sure some may have raised eyebrows but no one dared raise it with me! I never really question my mothering and wouldn't allow anyone else to either - I refuse to engage in that sexism. The majority of mothers give their mind, body and soul to their DC when they're little. We serve more holidays if anything! So when you ask "am I a bad mum?" I feel irritated - you're feeding into that nonsense. You KNOW you're not a bad mum. Don't let people influence you like that. Particularly people who are most likely jealous, martyrs, or riddled with internalised misogyny.

Enjoy your well deserved break Wink

bluesk75 · 25/02/2022 16:51

@Lesperance

I don't think they are jealous, I would not have left my eight month old either. And I wouldn't have been jealous of anybody who did. The bath thing is weird. But you are judging them too. You clearly find it hard to image that anybody could have a different relationship with their baby than you do with yours. Neither of you is right, but you should learn to be a bit more secure in your decisions, because this will not be the last time that you will chose to do things differently to other people.
@Lesperance can someone please tell me why the bath thing is weird!!!
Satingreenshutters · 25/02/2022 16:50

@AgeingDoc

Sorry but that is NUTS!!!! in 25 years you have spent 2 nights away from your kids??? 25 fucking YEARS??????? Are you for real If the poster has several children spread over a wide-ish age range that wouldn't be particularly odd in my opinion. I doubt she means she has never been apart from the 25 year old. My children range from mid 20s to mid teens and there have been very few nights when there hasn't been at least one of them with us. Not both parents all the time it's true, due to work commitments, but I can only recall 2 or 3 nights when someone other than DH or I looked after them. My in laws stayed over once and my sister has had them once or twice. Doesn't seem to have harmed any of us as far as I can tell.
I just think that is bizarre, your kids are all over 15 and some in their 20's and you and your hubby have "looked after" them every night except 2. In 25 years? Utterly utterly bizarre. They are adults!
mistermagpie · 25/02/2022 16:47

@Owieeee

The thing is ppl on here are saying over and over again how they can't imagine never getting a break as a couple etc etc while mentioning their relatives who help . Some ppl don't have that option , my family just don't help at all, even when I have been ill alone with all 3 tiny kids id get loads of virtual support and get better soon and I was on my knees at times, nothing will induce them to help, it's almost a principle with them. And *@Ghostofchristmaspasty* said it becomes so alien as you just aren't at all used to any help or your DC's ever being taken care of by someone else. Of course my DH and I go away and take time out separately but we CAN'T as a couple. Of course it's lovely to get away together but many ppl just don't have the option. In real life my friends are the same , the amount of events that only one of us can attend and then we get asked but why isn't DH there " we don't have babysitters, we can't get away together".
I feel you. I am NC with my whole family, none of them have ever even met my three children, so not even virtual support there. DHs parents are very good but they live abroad most of the year and when they are here they prefer catching up with friends and things to babysitting, although they love our children. They will take them out and even overnight sometimes but individually, so obviously will still have the other two children to look after. I can't blame them though, my kids are 2, 4 and 6 so pretty full on!

I'm the only one out of my friends who doesn't get some sort of weekly childcare and weekend type babysitting from family. Most people I know get a lot of help.

AgeingDoc · 25/02/2022 16:47

Sorry but that is NUTS!!!! in 25 years you have spent 2 nights away from your kids??? 25 fucking YEARS??????? Are you for real
If the poster has several children spread over a wide-ish age range that wouldn't be particularly odd in my opinion. I doubt she means she has never been apart from the 25 year old.
My children range from mid 20s to mid teens and there have been very few nights when there hasn't been at least one of them with us. Not both parents all the time it's true, due to work commitments, but I can only recall 2 or 3 nights when someone other than DH or I looked after them. My in laws stayed over once and my sister has had them once or twice. Doesn't seem to have harmed any of us as far as I can tell.