Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this what defines a good mother these days?

237 replies

coffeelover13 · 25/02/2022 12:54

Just had a chat with my mummy friends and talking about our weekend plans .. I said that myself & DH are going away on a baby free weekend. (Baby is 8 months)

They were all shocked & said in quite a judging tone that they could NEVER do that !! How awful for the baby !! Wtf 😂

She will be left with my parents who absolutely ADORE her and I know she'll be well looked after. She's breastfed but takes a bottle or formula if needed. I don't see the issue here.

These ladies seem to think that they are better mothers as they have never left their babies for more than a couple of hours.

Looking back they were also shocked when the babies were 2 months old that my DH was "allowed " to do bath time. Again wtf ? He's her dad and after a long day away with work he loved doing bath time once home so I could have a cuppa.

Am I a bad mum ? When I'm with my DD I give her all of me. But I think it's just as important to spend some time with just my DH. Surely if we're happy as a couple that's a good thing for our DD
One of those "I never leave my baby " is an Instagram wannabe influencer & posts every 2 mins. So yes she's with her DD but spends 50% of her day on her phone. So how am I worse for going away for 2 nights ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JustDanceAddict · 26/02/2022 08:27

Would I have done that at 8 months? No. I was bf DD anyway who wouldn’t take a bottle, ever, and DS had some health issues so it wouldn’t have felt right.
People have different relationships with their respective parents so if she’s really comfortable with them that you feel you can go away and not worry then no major problem.
My DCs started staying at PIL when they were about 18 months-2 but we built it up from leaving them for a couple of hours and then overnight.
We did go out of an evening from when DD was about 5 months and could sleep through until past midnight so wouldn’t need a feed. She was more or less sleeping through by then anyway.

AstonMartini · 25/02/2022 20:58

@felulageller

Oh goodness I hate to think how these kids will turn out.!

(Theirs not yours!)

Would it not be possible to support the OP without judging and condemning mothers who do things differently from her (and, presumably, you)?
Strokethefurrywall · 25/02/2022 20:45

At 8 months old, your baby, today will feel abandoned and not understand that you'll be back after you've had 3 days away.

Given that you absolutely know this, can you site your source please? No?
And given babies don’t have any concept of time, do they feel the same abandonment when you leave a room?
What a crock of shit.

BoredZelda · 25/02/2022 20:18

At 8 months my son wouldn’t accept a bottle woke every few hours and slept in our bed so maybe they’re just envious and feel bad about themselves that they can’t do the same

Or, maybe they just feel differently to the OP. Why must we always project negative emotions on women?

Most of the time people aren’t thinking you are bad, they are reflecting on how they are different and assuming that they must then be bad mothers.

Like the OP is doing, you mean?

BoredZelda · 25/02/2022 20:17

At 8 months old, your baby, today will feel abandoned and not understand that you'll be back after you've had 3 days away.

So mine felt abandoned in NNICU?

cansu · 25/02/2022 20:13

Ignore. Competitive mothering is bonkers and hideous. Why do some women feel the need to outmother others?? V odd. Try and remember that it is mostly bullshit.

BiscuitLover3678 · 25/02/2022 20:09

At 8 months my son wouldn’t accept a bottle woke every few hours and slept in our bed so maybe they’re just envious and feel bad about themselves that they can’t do the same.
Most of the time people aren’t thinking you are bad, they are reflecting on how they are different and assuming that they must then be bad mothers.

BiscuitLover3678 · 25/02/2022 20:07

The bathtime thing is weird.

The going away thing though - are you sure they were saying you’re bad? Maybe they’re more admiring of you? I wouldn’t have been able to leave mine at 8 months at barely can at 2 so I guess I do find it a bit odd, but good for you! I wouldn’t think you’re a bad mum.

felulageller · 25/02/2022 20:03

Oh goodness I hate to think how these kids will turn out.!

(Theirs not yours!)

TheGoogleMum · 25/02/2022 20:01

Enjoy your break :) i actually found it a bit easier to leave DD as a baby compared to now (she's 3) as she's old enough to understand I'm not there now! I would be pickier about who I leave her with now (in laws don't see her as often so I don't think I'd leave her overnight with them now but would as a baby!)

User8721643839 · 25/02/2022 19:58

@coffeelover13

Just had a chat with my mummy friends and talking about our weekend plans .. I said that myself & DH are going away on a baby free weekend. (Baby is 8 months)

They were all shocked & said in quite a judging tone that they could NEVER do that !! How awful for the baby !! Wtf 😂

She will be left with my parents who absolutely ADORE her and I know she'll be well looked after. She's breastfed but takes a bottle or formula if needed. I don't see the issue here.

These ladies seem to think that they are better mothers as they have never left their babies for more than a couple of hours.

Looking back they were also shocked when the babies were 2 months old that my DH was "allowed " to do bath time. Again wtf ? He's her dad and after a long day away with work he loved doing bath time once home so I could have a cuppa.

Am I a bad mum ? When I'm with my DD I give her all of me. But I think it's just as important to spend some time with just my DH. Surely if we're happy as a couple that's a good thing for our DD
One of those "I never leave my baby " is an Instagram wannabe influencer & posts every 2 mins. So yes she's with her DD but spends 50% of her day on her phone. So how am I worse for going away for 2 nights ?

Didn't even read the post.. Your friends are incredibly jealous of your wonderful parents, you lucky thing!!! Yo have a lovely rest away and forget the group of friends
Satingreenshutters · 25/02/2022 19:45

@AgeingDoc

Nobody ever mentioned alone. We were talking with someone else like grandparents Make your mind up. You were castigating me for looking after offspring that you consider too old a few minutes ago, but now it's only "fucking nuts" to take care of your own children but ok to get someone else to do the job? Why? If an adult needs to be with them, what is so odd about it being the actual parent/s if that's what they want? And believe it or not, we don't all have a ready supply of people who are willing and capable of taking responsibility for our children even if we wanted them to. Our extended families are all dead/demented/disabled/hundreds of miles away, none of which make them great babysitter material. It has always been far more effort for us to find someone else to look after our children than to do it ourselves and I don't believe in making life any harder than it has to be.
Emmmmmm ok. You have had 2 nights out in 25 years because you cannot leave your 15 year alone or with friend or someone responsible like an older sibling?

Absolutely nuts! Gonna babysit her yerself on your wedding night. Get a grip.

inheritancetrack · 25/02/2022 19:45

Your friends are nuts

Furrydogmum · 25/02/2022 19:38

My mum used to judge mummies who left their babies with the GPs - never seen such a quick turn around when she got her own grandchildren and wanted free rein!! Grin You are not a bad mum, and neither are they, although being judgy towards you is straying into bad behaviour..

GougeAway · 25/02/2022 19:36

I expect your ‘friends’ are trying to make themselves feel better about the lack of help with bath times, and not having anyone available to provide a weekend of childcare to an 8 month old. Maybe they are trying to convince themselves they have chosen this situation. Still not kind of them. Your criticism of mums who won’t or can’t leave their small babies is also quite unpleasant though. You clearly don’t appreciate being judged so don’t do it back. If you are confident in your parenting decisions, and it really does sound like you are, just be bloody grateful for the break.

SpinsForGin · 25/02/2022 19:35

Of course you aren't a bad mum.
In my circle it's perfectly normal to have grandparents look after children overnight and fit a few days at a time and this starts quite young. And do you know what? The children are absolutely fine!!
Adult time is important! Have fun!

MacauliflowerCulkin · 25/02/2022 19:29

@thanktor

Can you imagine have *@ChoiceMummy* as a mother? Her children will keep so much from her, for fear of the cats bum mouth and nasty judgement. And as for asking *@choicemummy* to look after your child whilst you go away for a couple of nights? Never. Going. To. Happen.

Ultimately mothers like this lose out

Posted to early!!

Totally agree with you!

That 'listen to it' was at @ChoiceMummy

MacauliflowerCulkin · 25/02/2022 19:28

@thanktor

Can you imagine have *@ChoiceMummy* as a mother? Her children will keep so much from her, for fear of the cats bum mouth and nasty judgement. And as for asking *@choicemummy* to look after your child whilst you go away for a couple of nights? Never. Going. To. Happen.

Ultimately mothers like this lose out

Loooool listen to it 😂
Blossomtoes · 25/02/2022 19:03

@BoredZelda

My ex had never even held a baby until he had one.

This is also true for a whole load of women.

And?
minimadgirl · 25/02/2022 19:00

Omg if the father can't bath the baby as it makes you a bad mum, then I must be a terrible mum. I gave perhaps bathed my 22 month old 10 times and have literally never bathed my 4 month old. My Oh always does it and puts my older girl to bed. It's his time with her otherwise he wouldn't get to see her in the week.

SisterConcepta · 25/02/2022 18:54

Weird judgy mummy friends me thinks

Savvysix1984 · 25/02/2022 18:53

Op thank god your friends aren't mine! Within my friend group we have all continued having a social life post baby (obvs slightly adjusted). We are lucky we have grandparents/ aunts who were happy to have baby overnight. Dc are now 7,8,10, and guess what, they haven't been traumatised and are all well adjusted happy kids, who still love having sleepovers at granny's!

Shimy · 25/02/2022 18:52

@Blossom64265

A baby isn’t old enough to have a conversation explaining what is happening and when you will return. They can’t verbalize real questions or tell you about their experience when you get back. Yes, you know your child will be loved and cared for, but the child’s perspective and reflection on the experience matters too.
And the bath thing, why is it strange?
Girlmumdogmumboymum · 25/02/2022 18:50

Of course this isn't what makes a good mum. I can say from experience, if you make your life about your child, your child, your child, its unhealthy for both you and them.
Life becomes a bit of a drudge and you can get swallowed up by motherhood and your child can end up feeling quite strangulated by being the main focus.

Enjoy life for you as well as your child. Enjoy the odd evening out without them, they're safe and with people who love them. It's perfectly fine

use257 · 25/02/2022 18:46

@Blossom64265

A baby isn’t old enough to have a conversation explaining what is happening and when you will return. They can’t verbalize real questions or tell you about their experience when you get back. Yes, you know your child will be loved and cared for, but the child’s perspective and reflection on the experience matters too.
Ah sorry. Didn't see this. This is crazy talk