Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WWYD- BIL has ‘spoiled’ dh weekend away

285 replies

LoveDaisy · 25/02/2022 12:33

DH’s brother surprised him a few weeks ago with a weekend stay following an outdoor event that will take up most of the day. It was so they could have some quality time away and as gift for dh, he paid for mostly everything. His brother had booked it for a weekend where Dh and I was supposed to celebrate an anniversary so, we changed dates so he could go on the trip. For context, Dh absolutely deserves some time away for himself, so no issue with the trip itself although the timing was off, I was ok changing the dates for him.

Dd was teething this week and ended up with a nasty cold which has meant little sleep for us all. I’ve now caught her cold on top of the infection I have which I’m antibiotics for. So I’m feeling like I’m on my knees trying to push through. But now dh has called to say he is disappointed in his brother… as he has booked tickets for their nephews too (their sister’s children age 3 &4) and had no intention of telling dh! It slipped out and Dh is now saying the vibe of the whole trip has completely changed. It’s not quality time, it’s baby sitting for a weekend. Nephew (3) is not potty trained and they both have never stayed away from their parents. Brother in law has a tendency to do this kind of thing 🙄
With myself and dd sick and the two toddlers attending, Dh is torn as he wants to cancel but his brother has spent a lot of money. The trip is for this weekend and dh has only just found out now, despite his brother booking over a week ago.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TempName01 · 28/02/2022 15:58

Regarding the OPs not updating, I agree it’s frustrating in the same way as if you miss the last episode of a tv show. It’s just nice to know the outcome! Hoping this OP will be back 🤞🏼

Tetchy · 28/02/2022 10:39

I would expect DH to cancel , he has babysitting to do at home !🤔

Tigger1895 · 27/02/2022 18:55

@Teeturtle

Perhaps he thought it would be nice to spend time with the nephews?

I cannot imagine myself cancelling something because I found out my young niece was attending.

Re read
whynotwhatknot · 27/02/2022 15:20

Did he go op? maybe shes too tired too post or too embarrassed because the man actually left her to look after his nephews instead of his own kids

WallaceinAnderland · 27/02/2022 12:57

It's not real life but it is a mildly entertaining pastime to engage with people on 'real life type scenarios'. That is the purpose of the site.

If every thread fizzled out with no engagement from the OP then people would stop using the site because it's boring. Fortunately for MN, there are enough threads to keep people at least mildly interested. But all I am saying is that it's becoming so common that I tend to check OP's contribution before engaging because they often don't post again and generally turn out to be very dull threads.

There are exceptions, as you say, where the thread takes an amusing turn. And, of course, there are people posting in places like Relationships, Bereavement, etc. where support is freely given and really valued and no one would expect anyone to update.

ClariceQuiff · 27/02/2022 12:51

Yes, I think we'll have to agree to differ.

BuyDirt · 27/02/2022 12:43

But it’s not real life and you don’t know the person and that makes all the difference. And in real life, if someone asked for my opinion one day and said they didn’t want to talk about it the next, I wouldn’t say it was rude, no. In fact if they didn’t bring it up, I’d assume they didn’t want to talk about it. I’m not a nosy person, I don’t feel like I need an ending to every situation someone talks to me about. The people I know that do, are gossips and like drama. That’s not for me.

We don’t agree which is fine, I prefer my thinking on this.

ClariceQuiff · 27/02/2022 12:32

But people are not bad for not updating, most likely just busy or just can’t be bothered, the problem went away or........

No, not bad - just discourteous.

Even when they post on a forum, it doesn’t actually make it your business.

I disagree - by asking for advice on a public forum, they are making their problem the 'business' of forum users who respond.

In real life, if you'd had a long conversation about your selfish BIL or whatever, and the next day the person you'd talked to asked whether you'd managed to resolve the problem, most people would consider it rude and odd if you replied 'That's none of your business.'

BuyDirt · 27/02/2022 12:25

It just makes the site more interesting if there aren't lots of abandoned threads. It's not just this one, there are loads. There has to be some level of engagement to make the site worth using. Even if it is all made up bollocks like most of the internet

Some of the best threads are where OP has only posted once or twice and all sorts of crazy posts are made. It’s light entertainment in most cases.

BuyDirt · 27/02/2022 12:23

There's no point in bothering with forums at all unless you assume some kind of good faith.

Confused But people are not bad for not updating, most likely just busy or just can’t be bothered, the problem went away or........
Even when they post on a forum, it doesn’t actually make it your business. I assume many threads are made up, because they are.

WallaceinAnderland · 27/02/2022 12:23

It just makes the site more interesting if there aren't lots of abandoned threads. It's not just this one, there are loads. There has to be some level of engagement to make the site worth using. Even if it is all made up bollocks like most of the internet Grin

ClariceQuiff · 27/02/2022 12:14

Anyone who thinks they are owed a reply or they feel short changed if they don’t get an update, shouldn’t invest any time in forums. There are people who make stuff up for fun. Some forums make their own stuff up for traffic.

There's no point in bothering with forums at all unless you assume some kind of good faith.

BuyDirt · 27/02/2022 12:10

Not invested at all, really - apart from a brief question early on in the thread I haven't posted anything else until now. But there are many others who have. It takes 30 seconds to type 'thanks for replies, will update later' or similar.

Anyone who thinks they are owed a reply or they feel short changed if they don’t get an update, shouldn’t invest any time in forums. There are people who make stuff up for fun. Some forums make their own stuff up for traffic. If they’re real, they may not update for a number of reasons. And in cases like this, not that much time has even gone by so OP may still post.

Crazy.

ClariceQuiff · 27/02/2022 12:06

You are way too invested. OP doesn’t know you regardless of how detailed and thoughtful your responses are.

Not invested at all, really - apart from a brief question early on in the thread I haven't posted anything else until now. But there are many others who have. It takes 30 seconds to type 'thanks for replies, will update later' or similar.

BuyDirt · 27/02/2022 12:04

No one is 'obliged' to reply, either, but forums would soon cease to exist if no one ever bothered!

They wouldn’t at all. As long as the people post an OP, other will happily argue amongst themselves. Half the people clearly don’t even read the OP correctly, never mind any updates anyway, we see evidence of that every day.

BuyDirt · 27/02/2022 12:02

No obligation but I think it's courteous to update when people have taken the time to give detailed and thoughtful responses.

Are you being serious? Courteous?

These are random people on a forum. Also, OP is ill and caring for a young child, of her husband had gone away, she’ll be doing that alone, she may yet come back and update but may be busy or just feeling too ill to bother replying. You are way too invested. OP doesn’t know you regardless of how detailed and thoughtful your responses are.

ClariceQuiff · 27/02/2022 11:54

If they’re real, people are living their lives, they have no obligation to update you.

No obligation but I think it's courteous to update when people have taken the time to give detailed and thoughtful responses.

No one is 'obliged' to reply, either, but forums would soon cease to exist if no one ever bothered!

BuyDirt · 27/02/2022 11:48

There are so many threads like this these days. It's like the OPs can't be bothered. MN used to be so much more interesting with people seeking support and responders feeling helpful by sharing their advice. Now I just keep the last post by OP bookmarked and don't bother with the thread anymore unless they do. Shame though as it makes the site much less interesting.

I thought this was sarcastic, but have a feeling it’s real. 😬

If people feel like this, they’re way too invested. Loads of threads will be made up shit. If they’re real, people are living their lives, they have no obligation to update you. And as for mumsnet giving anyone purpose by making them feel helpful, I don’t know where to start

WallaceinAnderland · 27/02/2022 11:35

@fishonabicycle

It's so bloody irritating when the OP doesn't bother to update their own thread.
There are so many threads like this these days. It's like the OPs can't be bothered. MN used to be so much more interesting with people seeking support and responders feeling helpful by sharing their advice. Now I just keep the last post by OP bookmarked and don't bother with the thread anymore unless they do. Shame though as it makes the site much less interesting.
iRun2eatCake · 27/02/2022 10:57

I suspect the "D"H has gone and the OP is too embarrassed to update.

Mirw · 27/02/2022 09:01

Your DH needs to grow a pair and just say No. Either it is time away with his brother. Or it is time away with his brothers family. One is okay. The other is taking the pis esp when you are unwell. DH should be staying with you no matter how much has been spent. That is an excuse to let your bil off. It needs to stop now no matter how your bil feels. He is not a child.

fishonabicycle · 27/02/2022 08:54

It's so bloody irritating when the OP doesn't bother to update their own thread.

Howshouldibehave · 27/02/2022 08:42

So, I presume it’s this weekend? Did he go? Have you heard much from him, @LoveDaisy?

BestBeforeddmmyy · 27/02/2022 08:40

Your dh could explain that you and the kids are unwell and he needs to stay and look after his family.

Smellycat290 · 27/02/2022 08:33

Yes!! Get him to take your kids too. Awesome solution and BIL seriously can’t object! That’s totally the solution!