Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my sister to fuck off making comments about my son?

193 replies

123gege · 25/02/2022 10:27

My son is almost 2.5, and I’m concerned about his speech. It seems that all other toddlers I know are talking in sentences and my little one just isn’t yet. My sister keeps making comments and I’m so sick of it.

He can say lots of words, his new favourite is spinosaurus which I’m super impressed with. He says at least 50 words, and will occasionally join words together, just not all the time. He said the other day after he got into bed - oh no, where’s my dummy gone? (he only has it for bed time). If I or my partner leave the room for example, he’ll say daddy/mummy come back. If I ask him body parts he can’t name them, he just laughs at me and runs away. He knows his animals though. Should I be concerned he can’t name body parts? Everywhere I’ve read states he should be talking in sentences now and if he’s not he’s really behind. Add on my sisters continuous comments and I’m stressed.

My sisters little one is much further advanced in speech - he’s 4 months younger. And she’s always saying oh shouldn’t he be talking more by now, he doesn’t say much does he, what are you going to do when he’s 3 and he’s still not talking. She knows when his birthday is but said the other day oh is he going to be 3 this year? Knowing full well he is and then followed it up with he’s still not talking much. Like she was trying to say wow he’s 3 this year and isn’t talking. Every time she comes to my house it's like look what my little one can say, say this, say that, oh you're clever, oh you're so smart, you are talking so well. His speech is so good isn't it? I just feel awful every time she's here. I’m just sick of constantly defending him to her attacks. She moans about him being too rough, he's just a busy boy who likes to play, her son is so sensitive and cries at everything - I feel like she's picking him apart every time he does something. Last time she made a comment saying 'you're disabled' because he was being silly, she said it jokingly but it upset me. I've spoken to her about the way it makes me feel and she told me I was being pathetic and to fuck off.

He attends nursery 1 day a week and they haven’t any concerns, I emailed my HV and she said if I have concerns they can come out and do an assessment to see if he needs speech therapy but she said the waiting list is very long. She said because he attends nursery they could also refer? I don’t know whether I should bring it up to the nursery, or ring the HV’s back and get an initial assessment first.

Is he that far behind on speech? What to do about my sister?

OP posts:
Phobiaphobic · 25/02/2022 12:57

I'd simply point out that relative precociousness in certain areas rarely has any impact on later academic or life success. People mature at different rates, and it has nothing to do with final outcomes. That's why parents who gloat about their small children's 'genius' look absurd to those whose kids have grown up.

Dishwashersaurous · 25/02/2022 12:55

Never compare children.

It really it that simple.

Surely as a twin she knows how dangerous and frustrating it is to be compared!

He sounds absolutely fine. Just ask her to stop comparing them

KerryWeaver · 25/02/2022 12:52

In my wider family, the toddlers who were all a little slower to string sentences together have all gone on to have stellar A-levels and glittering careers.

Those who were holding a conversation at a very early stage had really unimpressive A-levels though they did go on to thoroughly enjoy the party scene at their universities but not without incident.

It's a small sample. But if it is anything to go by, you will get your own back on your sister during those later years.

feministqueen · 25/02/2022 12:52

Comparison is the thief of joy. I have 2 children. The first barely spoke til they were 3. The second was yapping away super early and had incredible speech. They're both no more or less advanced now they're a bit older and you wouldn't know the difference.

Human beings aren't robots. We all get there in our own time. If the understanding is there there I'd be less worried about speech at this age.

Sorry your sister is being a dick OP

40thanniversayfastapproacning · 25/02/2022 12:46

My youngest had speech therapy and went to a special nursery as he was behind with speech... He caught up, never shut up as a child (or now) and now has a PhD in philosophy... Your little one may, or may not, be behind but whichever it is, no need to stress at this point.

Mrsbmama · 25/02/2022 12:45

Your sis defo needs to back off, if she's concerned then maybe a chat with you about it but to keep going on and making you feel that way is not fair. All children do these things at different rates. My DS couldn't saying anything other than dada until he turned two, I was worried he even called me dada. I cried when he first called me mama, he doesn't stop talking now days! He was behind slightly but learn so so quickly. He walked at 10 months old!! My DD didn't walk until 14 months and spoke so quickly 🙃 don't stress, make an appointment if you need too and tell your sister she may mean we'll but to stop!

Fink · 25/02/2022 12:45

It's really tough when you have siblings who have kids of a similar age. We've currently got three babies in the family, two from twin sisters and one from another sister, all within 3 months of each other. People do tend to compare their development (and in our case you get comments that relate it to parenting style). That said, there's no need for your sister's comments. She might think that in private, but you've made it clear that it's not helpful or welcome so she shouldn't be bringing it up again. If you think it wasn't clear enough before, then send her a really unambiguous message that you don't want to hear any critical comments about your son's development. Then decide what course of action you will take if she tries it again, because it's easier to make a plan in advance than to be caught in the headlights if she makes a snide comment and you're unprepared.

By the way, your son sounds completely within the normal range, and if you are worried about his development then your healthcare team will be able to advise you.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 25/02/2022 12:44

Your ds sounds fine OP - if he laughs and runs away when you ask him to name a body part he doesn't want to name it, it's not that he can't!

One advantage of working FT when he was small was that I didn't have to put up with competitive mothers.

I noticed a massive difference in my son's speech when he stopped going to nursery and went to a childminder because there were older children there and he learnt from them.

BruceAndNosh · 25/02/2022 12:43

My brother was a late talker.
Then he got to 6, and didn't shut up for the next 7 years

Einstein didn't talk in full sentences until he was 5

SchadenfreudePersonified · 25/02/2022 12:42

@tinyt137

Yes, she definitely needs to mind her own business. Your son is completely normal, don't worry! Literally within days/weeks his speech will suddenly blossom. She sounds like the kind of mum everyone finds annoying, you'd probably avoid her at the school gate... unfortunately she's your sister.
I'm a retired SLT. I worked with adults but obviously did do some children's work when I was training and had my first generalist post.

I agree with what others have said - your son sounds fine. He will suddenly start speaking A LOT! (It is literally known as the "word explosion"). Boys are very often slower to speak, on average , than are girls, but there is always the occasional one, like your sister's who speaks fluently and early. No problem - he's more unusual than yours.

It won't hurt to get a referral, especially if the waiting list is very long, as it will reassure you that things are in hand, and you can always cancel it if you feel you don't need it.

It is more important to check that he is acquiring his speech sounds in the right order, and it sounds from the bit you've shared with us that he is. However, if he gets a speech assessment the therapist will check that. Also he will start to generalise grammar rules which will sound wrong (eg saying "eated", rather than "eaten" ) - don't worry about anything like this, as it is in fact a very good sign that he has noticed a rule and is trying to use it - he'll learn exceptions over time)

My advice is - let him proceed at his own rate, and if your sister comments about him being "disabled" again, break her legs. That is just nasty!

CrotchetyQuaver · 25/02/2022 12:41

I don't have a sister, but I can't even begin to imagine how awful it must be on the receiving end of competitive mothering from one.
I think you should get your DC assessed by professionals to ensure he is within the normal range of development milestones and tell your sister to butt out. She is being absolutely horrible. If you can distance yourself all the better, but I guess that's especially difficult if you're twins.

StillMedusa · 25/02/2022 12:41

Just echoing what everyone else has said...
Your son doesn't have a problem... but your sister does.. hideous competitive parenting!!
Honestly if he's got single words, the sentences will build in time!
I have four.. and there was a huge variation in their skills.. one could talk in sentences at 17m, but his brother had no speech (at ALL) til over 3, was incomprehensible til he was bout 9 and years of speech therapy. And you would NOT know now.
The girls..one was average, one was slow to talk , but when she finally got going at at about 2.5 she rapidly progressed to full sentences.. they just varied , just as they varied in their physical skills!

I work with children who have severe speech delays, and while a few do continue to have severe problems they generally have other significant disabilities.. the vast majority make progress nicely over time!

Your sister however needs to wind her neck in!

Bajezzeuz · 25/02/2022 12:37

My DS was similar to your son by the sounds of it. He got a referal from nursery for his speech but by the time it came through they said he didn't need it!

He's 5 now, has a slight lisp ( which I find so endearing ) his R's and L's and W's sound exactly the same, but school have no issue with his speech

My son couldnt talk properly for a long time compared to his sister and hid peers and it made me constantly worry about him but he's 5 now and a happy little boy who has no issue communicating with people

My HV and the nursery said its more common with boys as their more interested in playing and running around than they are learning to communicate,

Honestly, don't worry. If there's an issue nursery will pick up on it quickly and offer the support needed

needhelp34 · 25/02/2022 12:33

I think your sister is being very insensitive. She’s putting doubts in your mind then making comparisons between the children. That isn’t a kind thing to be doing. Every child develops differently and she’s creating competition between you and the children. She needs to back off.

Your DS is very young and all children develop differently. The biggest explosion in speech development happens between 2.5 and 3. You’ll be shocked at the changes you see in him over the next 6 months. It would probably be premature for you to have an assessment now but I would push for the referral through the HV. My son was referred last July and still hasn’t had an assessment.

If you’re really concerned and you don’t want to wait, a private speech assessment costs around £200. My DS is 3 in May and he has a speech disorder. He’s almost impossible to understand. We decided to go down the private route because it was very obvious to us that something wasn’t right. I hear from a lot of people that their DS didn’t say a lot of words then suddenly explode after the age of 3. With mine it’s different, he tries to talk but his pronunciation has a lot of errors.

From my experience, nursery and HV have too many children to look after and once they reassured it’s not autism they lose interest. What happens with my son is, he’s got no behavioural issues, he’s very social, so the speech thing is overlooked. I also appreciate that boys typically develop slower in this area so it’s not unusual for there to seem like there’s an issue when there isn’t.

I would go with your gut. If you think something is wrong, really push for support (please DM me if you need any help with that). However, If this is your sister creating doubts and you believe your DS is doing ok. Definitely wait and see how he’s doing in 6 months.

Technonan · 25/02/2022 12:32

They all progress differently. FWIW, my youngest granddaughter didn't really start putting sentences together until she was 3.5, but she had clearly been absorbing everything and her language progressed from there in leaps and bounds. She's now a bright, very articulate 7 year old, even more articulate than her early-speaking older sister was a that age. .

Sometimes, people put other's children down to make them feel better about their own. Tell her to lay off, and tell her she doesn't know what she's talking about - because she clearly doesn't.

RewildingAmbridge · 25/02/2022 12:31

Her son might just be advanced with speech, it'll all just balance out. DS talks very well and has from a young age so I avoid comparisons when other people ask how old he was when started talking etc, thing is he can do that but refuses to get on his bike! They're all different. If you have concerns talk to nursery again, but if it's a good nursery they would've raised it if they were worried

BudgeUpAnne · 25/02/2022 12:30

My son is 2yrs 4 months and still doesn't talk, barely a word. I've been told by my HV not to worry. All other aspects of his communication and milestones are spot on, so I'm reassured that he will figure it out eventually.
Your boy sounds like he's doing great, and your sister should keep her opinions to herself

Tomselleckhaskindeyes · 25/02/2022 12:27

my son and my best friends son are 3 months apart. Her son was always advanced with gross motor skills. My son was very articulate. Both caught up but my son is more academic whilst my best friends son can put his mind to any sport and do it well. It's hard to compare the two but they are like brothers and get on so well.

mam0918 · 25/02/2022 12:27

@ancientgran

Kids vary, he sounds perfectly normal. Sometimes kids are advanced in one area but behind in another, I have 4 and honestly the variation in who could do what when was pretty extreme e.g. the one who walked at 9 months and the one who was nearly 18 months, the one who could read at 2 (i.e. recognise words) and could read chapter books at 4 and the one who was basically illiterate at 8. They all look pretty much the same as adults, they all managed to walk, read, talk just at different times.

Honestly growing up is a marathon not a spring, maybe remind her of the tortoise and the hare.

This can be true to, I read a child tends to preference one skill so some kids are mobile and talk slower and some talk first and gain mobility slower.

The theory is they are communicating a need so prioritising one that suits, walking kids can do things themselves so don't need to ask and talking kids can ask so they don't need to do it themselves so each can take more time learning the secondary skill.

awmum2b · 25/02/2022 12:25

You child is not behind in his speech, every child is different and develops different, there really is no comparison.

Look at all the things he can do, i bet if you really see it there are plenty of things he has more control on and is more developed than his peers.

I felt my child was also behind in comparisons to her friends, who are all within a month of each other. However my child had excellent pincer movements, very good hand eye co-ordination. Could climb , run, skip, throw things with accuracy. Now a year on her speech is improving rapidly, sometimes I sit and wonder why I was even concerned. Some of her pronunciation is still pretty hard and some people don't understand what she's saying (weird as i know exactly what she's saying, and here i thought i was rubbish at languages!)...i tend to repeat the sentence or phrase she's said back to her, but other than we don't do much other work on it. It's not a big deal and I'm not making it one type thing.

As long as he can communicate and his needs are being met it sounds like you're doing a fantastic job!

PerseverancePays · 25/02/2022 12:23

My older sister would make derogatory remarks about my little girl. She didn't grow properly and my sister would tease me that I didn't feed her exciting food and the child would be a midget etc. We fell out as she also said I was being too sensitive when I asked her to stop with the criticising. We are low contact now and have been for a long time. She was a bully when we were little as well.
Child did eventually catch up and is now a normal size adult!

mam0918 · 25/02/2022 12:22

I have a child with expressive DLD.

At your DS age he had about 8-10 understandable (no, yeah, ma, dada etc...) and was using mime (self-made sign language) mostly to communicate.

He still can't talk a year and a half later, he babbles 'sentences' but they aren't made up of identifiable words so it's just things like 'eeeaaah ohhheee da kee ooo ooo, yeah?'.

50 words at 2.5 is perfectly normal and from a parent whose kid has DLD I would say not a worry.

As another example, my other DS didn't say anything until 2 (completely mute - not even coos or babbles and they were investigating if he was deaf) then out of the blue started talking in full sentences one day, he's now a teen and has no issues with speech at all.

All kids are different but 50 words is good.

godmum56 · 25/02/2022 12:20

@esloquehay

Your sister 'jokingly' called your son disabled and you let it slide?! 🤦🤦🤦 You are your son's advocate, his voice at an age when he doesn't have one: stop allowing your domineering sister to slag off your child. If she won't respect your boundaries, then put a healthy distance between you for a while.
this.
ancientgran · 25/02/2022 12:18

Kids vary, he sounds perfectly normal. Sometimes kids are advanced in one area but behind in another, I have 4 and honestly the variation in who could do what when was pretty extreme e.g. the one who walked at 9 months and the one who was nearly 18 months, the one who could read at 2 (i.e. recognise words) and could read chapter books at 4 and the one who was basically illiterate at 8. They all look pretty much the same as adults, they all managed to walk, read, talk just at different times.

Honestly growing up is a marathon not a spring, maybe remind her of the tortoise and the hare.

LagunaBubbles · 25/02/2022 12:18

Sounds like she's the competitive sort and both of you having similar aged kids has given her free reign. It will only get worse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread