Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK in danger from Russia?

614 replies

hereforalongtimenotagoodtime · 24/02/2022 21:58

Keep receiving conflicting information. I am sick to my stomach and quite simply hate the unknown. So a simple question - is it likely that the UK will be in danger from Russia? And if so what does that look like? Cyber attacks, bombs being dropped?

OP posts:
Justanotherlurker · 25/02/2022 22:17

Yes of course we were but if we were, we wouldn't be telling them! esp difficult to believe because military sensitive stuff isn't connected to the internet, to access you have to physically be there

No of course we would, we couldn't go all out war. Everyone has accepted war has changed and this was a public message to Russia to show they can read their channels

Com satellites were telling everyone what Putin was up too but even then, the West didn't really know when he would move until he did

True, but it was more the invasion is imminent/routes of invasion. This wasn't Iraq WMD scare mongering for the public, it was a message to Putin directly. The military strategists had a part obviously, but in years to come this will be shown to be precise knowledge

Justanotherlurker · 25/02/2022 22:08

Didn't say that you couldn't comment either. But you are a tad defensive for someone who knows so much. Next time, just read fully on what I said.

I've read everything you've said across multiple threads, and I'm pointing out there is vast difference of a web based vulnerability and server/crit system one.

I'm defensive when you questioned my knowledge

Alexandra2001 · 25/02/2022 21:53

One of the reasons that the UK ,US where publicaly briefing the press about the invasion and have shown the exact invasion tactics was to show Russia that they are already in their systems

Yes of course we were but if we were, we wouldn't be telling them! esp difficult to believe because military sensitive stuff isn't connected to the internet, to access you have to physically be there.

Com satellites were telling everyone what Putin was up too but even then, the West didn't really know when he would move until he did.

timeforbedzzz · 25/02/2022 21:45

@Justanotherlurker

Youre right on it being different systems etc that they could gain access to. Not so much on the different technology as most government places especially use the same type of computers and servers, plus the vulnerabilities to target each different kind are all readily available online, including some YouTube demonstrations

How to say you just have surface knowledge of cyber security but try and come across as knowledgeable.

UK infrastructure is under attack constantly, and no one would get very far from following some script kiddy selling dodgy bots on YouTube.

It's military grade cyber war that every country faces daily. We (the EU/us/west) target others daily just as much as they do us.

One of the reasons that the UK ,US where publicaly briefing the press about the invasion and have shown the exact invasion tactics was to show Russia that they are already in their systems.

One of the reasons that the UK ,US where publicaly briefing the press about the invasion and have shown the exact invasion tactics was to show Russia that they are already in their systems I am going to sound dense here but you are saying that the info came from targetting (I had assumed old fashioned spying) - why let Russia know, it seems that Russia either didn't care or it speeded things up?

I wondered about the accusations made against Biden in relation to Ukraine during the election.

AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 21:12

@Justanotherlurker

Also I never mentioned about a script kiddy selling bots. And if you knew what you were talking about, you'd know there's more on YouTube than just that, plus other sites have a lot of info.

Well as your asking I've worked in cyber sec for over 2 decades as a pen tester, I also manage petabytes of sensitive data.

The stuff you find on YouTube would lead you into a honeypot on any gov/critical system

Maybe it's you who should expand your knowledge of watching YouTube videos.

So yes, in short I feel I can comment.

Really? Think you might want to, I've found great info on there before and other places. But we all learn in different ways.

Didn't say that you couldn't comment either. But you are a tad defensive for someone who knows so much. Next time, just read fully on what I said. Smile

Justanotherlurker · 25/02/2022 20:56

Also I never mentioned about a script kiddy selling bots. And if you knew what you were talking about, you'd know there's more on YouTube than just that, plus other sites have a lot of info.

Well as your asking I've worked in cyber sec for over 2 decades as a pen tester, I also manage petabytes of sensitive data.

The stuff you find on YouTube would lead you into a honeypot on any gov/critical system

Maybe it's you who should expand your knowledge of watching YouTube videos.

So yes, in short I feel I can comment.

AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 20:34

@Justanotherlurker

Youre right on it being different systems etc that they could gain access to. Not so much on the different technology as most government places especially use the same type of computers and servers, plus the vulnerabilities to target each different kind are all readily available online, including some YouTube demonstrations

How to say you just have surface knowledge of cyber security but try and come across as knowledgeable.

UK infrastructure is under attack constantly, and no one would get very far from following some script kiddy selling dodgy bots on YouTube.

It's military grade cyber war that every country faces daily. We (the EU/us/west) target others daily just as much as they do us.

One of the reasons that the UK ,US where publicaly briefing the press about the invasion and have shown the exact invasion tactics was to show Russia that they are already in their systems.

How to not read everything I said.

Also I never mentioned about a script kiddy selling bots. And if you knew what you were talking about, you'd know there's more on YouTube than just that, plus other sites have a lot of info.

But you'd know this of course, if you knew what you were talking about..

Justanotherlurker · 25/02/2022 20:23

Youre right on it being different systems etc that they could gain access to. Not so much on the different technology as most government places especially use the same type of computers and servers, plus the vulnerabilities to target each different kind are all readily available online, including some YouTube demonstrations

How to say you just have surface knowledge of cyber security but try and come across as knowledgeable.

UK infrastructure is under attack constantly, and no one would get very far from following some script kiddy selling dodgy bots on YouTube.

It's military grade cyber war that every country faces daily. We (the EU/us/west) target others daily just as much as they do us.

One of the reasons that the UK ,US where publicaly briefing the press about the invasion and have shown the exact invasion tactics was to show Russia that they are already in their systems.

AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 19:44

@Kinsters

Youre right on it being different systems etc that they could gain access to. Not so much on the different technology as most government places especially use the same type of computers and servers, plus the vulnerabilities to target each different kind are all readily available online, including some YouTube demonstrations.

However these hackers don't need the help. It's not just one person or even one team. This is likely multiple teams of god knows how many of them working on it. Anonymous just recently took out some Russian sites, that wasn't one person. The Russians and the Chinese had other teams targeting other companies across Europe, not just British ones. They target companies worldwide.

As for the question of are they already in, who knows. Given the threats made, and that I don't believe they are actually as good as anonymous otherwise they'd have gained access to the previous company I worked for, then I'd say they probably already are as it would take them longer to do, not a day. Hopefully that's wrong though.

If you want to look at how badly a ransomware attack for example could cripple a company, and I imagine that's what they might do (effectively hold us hostage until we remove our troops/the usual is give them money but I doubt putin wants money) then look at what happened to SEPA. They spent most of last year redoing their systems, which was of course backlogged thanks to covid so couldn't get supplies quick enough. That's where the problem will lie, getting the technology, because once a computer system has been hit with ransomware, you have to assume anything connected is also compromised. The problem there is its all connected now within one company. And sometimes even across companies if done badly.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 19:12

Don't confuse criminal attacks with military grade attacks.

As for sanctions...there was a report from early feb which made a point of how North Korea was managing to fund its entire nuke programme... Though cyber attacks on cryto currency.

So i do question quite how effective sanctions are really going to be.

Abhannmor · 25/02/2022 19:06

Well yes. Nothing too immediate though. From the elite rather than Russia as a whole. Closing the laundry will hurt a bit. But the alternative is being argued over by dysfunctional parents. Choose which of Washington and Moscow is less insane. In 2003 it would have been a no brainer. Welcome to Brexit.

UkraineThread · 25/02/2022 19:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

youhadmeatjello · 25/02/2022 18:57

@user1481840227 I don’t think he means deaths actually. I did. But now I agree it will cyber attacks. That way he won’t get nuked in return, can cause chaos (and quite probably indirect and direct deaths when systems go down) and cause utter carnage without actually pressing the button that will cause a nuclear World War III.

UkraineThread · 25/02/2022 18:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

MangyInseam · 25/02/2022 18:52

[quote iCouldSleepForAYear]@TheVolturi Haven't seen that one, but have seen plenty of news about Russian war gaming over the years.

The news about one-off infrastructure hacks here and there end up on my radar through work (never directly related to what I actually do, just contained within the trade news sources I read to stay informed and get on with my job).

Pushing boundaries always came across as a way to identify weaknesses. [/quote]
And also, I think, to practice.

If you are going to have a cyber-army making attacks, you have to train them, let them practice, try new things.

MangyInseam · 25/02/2022 18:47

@PastMyBestBeforeDate

It's possibly worth considering that there is a massive global shortage of chips that go into tech equipment. Lead times on IT equipment are long. If cyber attacks result in a need for additional hardware to recover systems or networks then once you've exhausted whatever is in the country, then you could be waiting a long time. It may well not be as simple as recovering a system if you need new or additional hardware.
Especially if all of a sudden the country that produces the majority of those chips is part of China....
MangyInseam · 25/02/2022 18:43

@MistressoftheDarkSide

Well, there's another heavy hitting sanction for you..... Sky have just reported that no Russian acts will be allowed into the Eurovision. Admittedly they did say it might seem trivial.....

Oh Lord, what a time to be alive eh? Hmm

I can't help but think that allowing them on Eurovision might be a kind of psychological warfare against Russia.
user1481840227 · 25/02/2022 18:35

*I don't think the "consequences" Putin is hinting at are nukes, although it's certainly a chess piece being manoeuvred around the board. The i newspaper says the Russians took Chernobyl today.

I think the hinted-at consequence would be coordinated cyber attacks, on critical infrastructure such as hospitals, power plants, banks, and military systems. Something so crippling that it would be almost impossible to effectively organize against.*

I don't think he's talking about cyber attacks. He means deaths.

Sure, the knock on effects of crippling infrastructure will cause deaths...but it's not as dramatic as direct deaths.

Bakewelltart987 · 25/02/2022 18:24

@Valhalla17

If Boris keeps making threats then it's highly likely we will be nuked.
I've missed something, what threats did he make?
iCouldSleepForAYear · 25/02/2022 18:14

@TheVolturi Haven't seen that one, but have seen plenty of news about Russian war gaming over the years.

The news about one-off infrastructure hacks here and there end up on my radar through work (never directly related to what I actually do, just contained within the trade news sources I read to stay informed and get on with my job).

Pushing boundaries always came across as a way to identify weaknesses.

TheVolturi · 25/02/2022 18:04

@iCouldSleepForAYear

I don't think the "consequences" Putin is hinting at are nukes, although it's certainly a chess piece being manoeuvred around the board. The i newspaper says the Russians took Chernobyl today.

I think the hinted-at consequence would be coordinated cyber attacks, on critical infrastructure such as hospitals, power plants, banks, and military systems. Something so crippling that it would be almost impossible to effectively organize against.

It is a risk that IT security researchers have been well aware of for decades. And if you Google IT security breaches at the types of infrastructure I've listed, you will find plenty of small-scale examples of it in recent memory. One-off hacks of a power plant here, an oil company there. I believe a hospital in upstate New York may have even been hacked not that long ago, to the point of endangering patients.

Undersea cable attacks (IT and electrical) have also crossed my mind, because those stretch for thousands of miles. And while the Navies are aware of the possibility of those cables being cut in an attack (and thus, monitor for hostile parties) I understand these cables are very difficult to defend. If a an undersea interconnector cable is cut or destroyed, it can take months to repair. You have to find the damage in the first place, and then the digging it up and repairing at sea is tricky work.

Have you ever watched the series on Channel 5 Warship? They're constantly out there seeing off the Russians in every series, it's seems like the Russians are always pushing boundaries even in normal times.
Mollysocks · 25/02/2022 18:00

Wondering whether the F1 will go ahead. F1 reportedly said they’d see how things went Confused (translation: let’s see about the moneyz) to be honest I don’t hold out much hope of it being cancelled, F1 love hosting in corrupt countries 😬

DdraigGoch · 25/02/2022 17:59

@Xiomara22

Should we be worried that Russia has control of Chernobyl . Is there not a reason behind that? What if the bombing destroys the shelter protecting people?
One would hope that they had the sense to keep clear of the sarcophagus. There is a danger though that shell fire will disturb contaminated ground.
BulletTrain · 25/02/2022 17:49

@the80sweregreat

They have cancelled a football match and their entry to the Eurovision Song Contest. 😕
It's not just "a football match". It's an enormously profitable football match for their economy. Tourism, money to use the stadium, massive audience for sponsoring companies. The Champions League tournament has been partly sponsored by Gazprom, the Russian state gas company, for 10 years.
JustALittleHelpPlease · 25/02/2022 17:43

This thread is hilarious!

Poster "something other people don't like"

Posters "fuck off"

Poster "responds"

Posters "wot you doing back here, we told you to fuck off"

[Face/Palm]