Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK in danger from Russia?

614 replies

hereforalongtimenotagoodtime · 24/02/2022 21:58

Keep receiving conflicting information. I am sick to my stomach and quite simply hate the unknown. So a simple question - is it likely that the UK will be in danger from Russia? And if so what does that look like? Cyber attacks, bombs being dropped?

OP posts:
User1isnotavailable · 26/02/2022 18:01

Did anyone see the BBC news clip with the lady going up to a Russian invading soldier and asking him what he was doing there. Brave lady. He told her not to make things worse. Her response 'how could she make it worse, you have invaded my country"

Brilliant woman and great responses to the invading Russian soldiers. Shame on Russia.

thereisonlyoneofme · 26/02/2022 16:59

I wonder the Russian army is allowing this to happen they must have been brainwashed into believing Ukraine was a threat. Just read a report on BBC that a Russian soldier had no idea they were going to war. They could refuse to fight, what could Putin do against thousands.

Whammyyammy · 26/02/2022 16:52

Once this is all over the people of Russia will suffer for years. The rest of the world will shun them, their economy will be in tatters, their national Airline is banned from most countries and rightly so, they will not be able to visit anywhere. Already putins beloved football team is not going to play in any international games..... putin will be OK, bit his people won't .

HesterAndPearlInBrightSunshine · 26/02/2022 16:35

My heart goes out to those poor people stuck in cellars and waiting in fear....
As for us here, I'm meant to fly long haul to the US at the end of the month. Last time it was a faff because of Covid, now I'm worried about cyber attacks... I think we just need to keep a cool head and get used to international tensions. We all need to steady our nerves. Panic only makes us look weak and fascists, like wild animals, only respect strength.

Kinsters · 26/02/2022 16:32

@getsomehelp

BA have cancelled all flight to Russia, today they had to cancel all short haul flights as their internet was down, not a cyber attack they say. Funny that
BA are very capable of causing IT related chaos without any help from the Russians, they do it all the time.
FatFredsFriedEgg · 26/02/2022 16:13

@getsomehelp

BA have cancelled all flight to Russia, today they had to cancel all short haul flights as their internet was down, not a cyber attack they say. Funny that
It's not a matter of BA cancelling flights to Russia. Russia have banned all British airlines from Russian airspace.
getsomehelp · 26/02/2022 15:46

BA have cancelled all flight to Russia, today they had to cancel all short haul flights as their internet was down, not a cyber attack they say. Funny that

iCouldSleepForAYear · 26/02/2022 12:12

@RestingStitchFace

I am trying not to resort to panic and hysteria but I confess to being worried about the cyber stuff.

I know someone whose company was cyber attacked by the Russians this week. He's not someone prone to panic but he's worried now.

Trying to keep a rational head on my shoulders whilst taking sensible precautions - changing passwords (aim for 18 characters minimum), setting up 2-factor authentication, updating operating systems on IT and backing up computers, keeping paper copies of important documentation, ensuring I have cash in the house, batteries, torches to hand etc.

Trying to find a balance between covering bases and not descending into the bog-roll hoarding crazies.

Same here. Relieved to know I'm not the only one working through that mental list. The way I put it to my father last night was: "I'm trying to keep very calm, but also be wisely prepared."
timeforbedzzz · 26/02/2022 10:53

@FatFredsFriedEgg

I think quite a lot of people have wondered about the point of NATO.

It's to defend its members, not its neighbours.

But it has been criticised for being ineffective for ensuring peace by its members in the past.
FatFredsFriedEgg · 26/02/2022 10:46

I think quite a lot of people have wondered about the point of NATO.

It's to defend its members, not its neighbours.

timeforbedzzz · 26/02/2022 10:44

[quote Alexandra2001]@Justanotherlurker I was really replying to your dubious claim that the west was tapped into Russian secret comms & what a successful plan it all was... - as if you would know & if you did, you wouldn't be on here talking about it.

But you've made my point.... everything you say applies equally if Putin carried on into Poland or Latvia... so whats the point in NATO, he can do as he pleases.

Aside what is it with you rightwingers? any opposition and you throw your toys, pathetic.[/quote]
sorry i tagged the wrong post before I meant this one

I meant what justanother has said makes perfect sense though, I have read in Asian press about Russia being aware of what soldiers were saying back in December. I do think it is fantastic that posters are saying as much as they can here.

I think quite a lot of people have wondered about the point of NATO.

timeforbedzzz · 26/02/2022 10:35

@Alexandra2001

In effect yes, modern day spying, Russia has been building up troops on the boarder for months, everyone knows it would turn into ww3 if NATO/west kicks in but it was more a message to Putin to give him an out, let UK/us take the blame of scaremongering etc and move along

Well, that worked well didn't it? A first world country in the heart of europe being destroyed, whilst the worlds largest and most powerful military alliance stands idly by, with 10s of 1000s of troops and equipment a few miles away.

all we've done is show Putin that all he has to do is walk into Poland etc and say "i ll nuke you if you try n stop me" and we'll stand by as well.

It makes perfect sense though, I have read in Asian press about Russia being aware of what soldiers were saying back in December. I think it is fantastic that posters are saying as much as they can here.
zingally · 26/02/2022 10:05

Honestly... To answer your original question OP... I don't think anyone really knows.

Speaking strictly personally, I'm watching to see how all this plays out for a bit longer before I decide to be worried or not. If things are still escalating significantly in, say, 10 days from now, I'll personally start making preparations to hunker down a bit.

I personally think Putin is full of a lot of hot air and big talk. But... We'll see I guess.

MarshaBradyo · 26/02/2022 09:16

@Justanotherlurker

"Well, that worked well didn't it? A first world country in the heart of europe being destroyed, whilst the worlds largest and most powerful military alliance stands idly by, with 10s of 1000s of troops and equipment a few miles away*

It's called geopolitics, as you are over all these type of threads I thought you would have a basic grasp of it, in a simplistic term it's why Italy didn't want to introduce sanctions to Russia unless they can still supply the oligarchs with designer clothes/furnishings.

Your simplistic interpretation of having 10s of thousands of troops nearby and can do nothing shows you are not aware of possible escalation or geopolitics in general.

It's nothing more than a virtue signal of we should be doing more whilst ignoring the wider ramifications, even the basic grasp of the situation will show that putting troops on the ground will make China, Pakistan,India side with Russia. It is therefore ww3 with a lot nukes on either side.

It's easy to spout online and show how much you care about the situation online, the practicalities of what you want will just mean you can name change and complain that they should have done something different. Empty virtue signaling

Any more reasonable voices are appreciated, so thanks
RestingStitchFace · 26/02/2022 09:10

I am trying not to resort to panic and hysteria but I confess to being worried about the cyber stuff.

I know someone whose company was cyber attacked by the Russians this week. He's not someone prone to panic but he's worried now.

Trying to keep a rational head on my shoulders whilst taking sensible precautions - changing passwords (aim for 18 characters minimum), setting up 2-factor authentication, updating operating systems on IT and backing up computers, keeping paper copies of important documentation, ensuring I have cash in the house, batteries, torches to hand etc.

Trying to find a balance between covering bases and not descending into the bog-roll hoarding crazies.

AllOfUsAreDead · 26/02/2022 08:02

@Justanotherlurker

Didn't say that you couldn't comment either. But you are a tad defensive for someone who knows so much. Next time, just read fully on what I said.

I've read everything you've said across multiple threads, and I'm pointing out there is vast difference of a web based vulnerability and server/crit system one.

I'm defensive when you questioned my knowledge

Oh for god sake I know that, but we are talking to people here who know literally nothing about cyber security and use password123 as a password. Me going into a dictionary definition and pulling out a power point presentation to explain those things will not help them at all.

They need to know that if something big happened, we're basically screwed. Because everything is computer based now. That's all they need to know, they don't need to know how it's done. They need to know how to protect themselves, be extra vigilant on keeping secure.

Kinsters · 26/02/2022 03:31

@Furries I have read the posts and understand the possible scenarios but it's all unfounded speculation as far as I can tell. I can see how it would be catastrophic if they brought down all the banks, all the supermarket POS systems, all the NHS hospitals, all the government departments...but is there really evidence of any actor having the capabilities to pull off the kind of doomsday total shutdown scenarios that have been mentioned? I just don't buy it. There's too much variation in software, systems and security protocols. And that's not even to mention the contingencies that are just naturally built into our lives. Asda tills all down? Go to Tesco instead. Lloyds banking system down? Use cash, a different bank account, mobile payment system.

Furries · 26/02/2022 03:22

@Kinsters

Any evidence that our intel came from cyber means rather than conventional espionage?

And @AllOfUsAreDead surely Wannacry showed that actually there is not uniformity? I'll ask again if there are any real world examples of cyber attacks bringing a country to its knees? I notice none of the cyber attack doom mongers have been able to point to any examples...I realise that in theory it could happen but I just don't buy that it's something anyone could accomplish in practice. Saying that perhaps there are russian spies stationed in all key locations (hospitals, powerplants, water treatment facilities?) is a fine thing to say but is there any evidence this is happening? None at all. It's as realistic as saying there are a load of Russian agents in the UK ready to detonate bio weapons - it's fear mongering and there's no evidence for it. In fact bioweapons would be more likely because at least there there's a proven track record of them causing harm unlike cyber attacks.

TBF, I think a few posters have tried to explain scenarios.

I’m a technophobe. But even I can see the possibilities. The “spies” don’t necessarily need to be placed in the physical locations (hospitals, banks, whatever). It’s not physical sleeper cells in those places.

There are so many possible permutations of how a cyber attack could hit. It’s not going to follow a logical/linear line (ie oh, all banks are out, no worries, I’ve got cash to pay for my food).

Kinsters · 26/02/2022 02:29

Any evidence that our intel came from cyber means rather than conventional espionage?

And @AllOfUsAreDead surely Wannacry showed that actually there is not uniformity? I'll ask again if there are any real world examples of cyber attacks bringing a country to its knees? I notice none of the cyber attack doom mongers have been able to point to any examples...I realise that in theory it could happen but I just don't buy that it's something anyone could accomplish in practice. Saying that perhaps there are russian spies stationed in all key locations (hospitals, powerplants, water treatment facilities?) is a fine thing to say but is there any evidence this is happening? None at all. It's as realistic as saying there are a load of Russian agents in the UK ready to detonate bio weapons - it's fear mongering and there's no evidence for it. In fact bioweapons would be more likely because at least there there's a proven track record of them causing harm unlike cyber attacks.

Furries · 26/02/2022 00:59

@Tealightsandd

You're a hysteric, not someone "Genuine knowledgeable about national (and global) security"

You really have no clue what my area of expertise is.

Lol

Indeed.

Again. I'm stepping away from this (hyberbolic) thread. Don't want me here, stop posting to me. If you could refrain from personal insults, that would be nice but nevermind. The sign of a lost argument.

I'm off out.

Last night, I tried to post in a non-mocking way and to give you the benefit of doubt re a matter that is obviously important to you.

Catching up on this thread today, I’m now neutralising my view. The last thing I’ll say (again) is that you will alienate the majority further if you’re bringing this up on completely unrelated threads. The fact you want to gain recognition for something important to you (and numerous others) is ok. But it’s not ok to do so out of context - and definitely not ok in relation to this situation.

You will likely still get numerous people tagging you as they read your posts. You don’t NEED to respond to them - because your responses add to the alienation.

Justanotherlurker · 25/02/2022 23:48

I was really replying to your dubious claim that the west was tapped into Russian secret comms & what a successful plan it all was... - as if you would know & if you did, you wouldn't be on here talking about it.

I was giving a brief overview of the situation of someone in the know rather than someone like you who has gained Thier knowledge from mass media and think they have authority on these types of threads, if you want to highlight how western intelligence has been wrong feel free to post.

But you've made my point.... everything you say applies equally if Putin carried on into Poland or Latvia... so whats the point in NATO, he can do as he pleases

And yet you haven't refuted it with anything.

Aside what is it with you rightwingers? any opposition and you throw your toys, pathetic

If in doubt, throw the new Godwin's law, you have shown more about your stance in this topic than you realise, and it's not me being the right wing bogeyman you want to paint me as.

Alexandra2001 · 25/02/2022 23:25

@Justanotherlurker I was really replying to your dubious claim that the west was tapped into Russian secret comms & what a successful plan it all was... - as if you would know & if you did, you wouldn't be on here talking about it.

But you've made my point.... everything you say applies equally if Putin carried on into Poland or Latvia... so whats the point in NATO, he can do as he pleases.

Aside what is it with you rightwingers? any opposition and you throw your toys, pathetic.

Justanotherlurker · 25/02/2022 23:15

"Well, that worked well didn't it? A first world country in the heart of europe being destroyed, whilst the worlds largest and most powerful military alliance stands idly by, with 10s of 1000s of troops and equipment a few miles away*

It's called geopolitics, as you are over all these type of threads I thought you would have a basic grasp of it, in a simplistic term it's why Italy didn't want to introduce sanctions to Russia unless they can still supply the oligarchs with designer clothes/furnishings.

Your simplistic interpretation of having 10s of thousands of troops nearby and can do nothing shows you are not aware of possible escalation or geopolitics in general.

It's nothing more than a virtue signal of we should be doing more whilst ignoring the wider ramifications, even the basic grasp of the situation will show that putting troops on the ground will make China, Pakistan,India side with Russia. It is therefore ww3 with a lot nukes on either side.

It's easy to spout online and show how much you care about the situation online, the practicalities of what you want will just mean you can name change and complain that they should have done something different. Empty virtue signaling

Alexandra2001 · 25/02/2022 22:36

In effect yes, modern day spying, Russia has been building up troops on the boarder for months, everyone knows it would turn into ww3 if NATO/west kicks in but it was more a message to Putin to give him an out, let UK/us take the blame of scaremongering etc and move along

Well, that worked well didn't it? A first world country in the heart of europe being destroyed, whilst the worlds largest and most powerful military alliance stands idly by, with 10s of 1000s of troops and equipment a few miles away.

all we've done is show Putin that all he has to do is walk into Poland etc and say "i ll nuke you if you try n stop me" and we'll stand by as well.

Justanotherlurker · 25/02/2022 22:24

I am going to sound dense here but you are saying that the info came from targetting (I had assumed old fashioned spying) - why let Russia know, it seems that Russia either didn't care or it speeded things up?

In effect yes, modern day spying, Russia has been building up troops on the boarder for months, everyone knows it would turn into ww3 if NATO/west kicks in but it was more a message to Putin to give him an out, let UK/us take the blame of scaremongering etc and move along.