Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK in danger from Russia?

614 replies

hereforalongtimenotagoodtime · 24/02/2022 21:58

Keep receiving conflicting information. I am sick to my stomach and quite simply hate the unknown. So a simple question - is it likely that the UK will be in danger from Russia? And if so what does that look like? Cyber attacks, bombs being dropped?

OP posts:
StormzyinaTCup · 27/02/2022 09:52

In my opinion putting NATO in right now is not the answer and more than likely playing straight into Putins hands, it's what he wants. He wants an all out War and that would be reason enough for him, this is not just about taking Ukraine.

The risks have only just started for all of us, i think its inevitable we will come into direct military conflict with Russia, the Russians are not going to standby as we send weapons to the Ukrainians are they?

I think you mean Putin is not going to standby, the 'Russians' are not all for this action and they too are going to pay a huge price for this. Putin is acting for and on behalf of himself.

Putin is hiding out in his bunker in the Urals and doing exactly what Hitler did whilst claiming he wants to rid Ukraine of neo-Nazism - he is as mad and bad as Hitler and it really needs someone in his circle to take him down imminently. That isn't something NATO will be able to achieve.

Oblomov22 · 27/02/2022 09:47

I'm not that worried. Should we be?

RedToothBrush · 27/02/2022 09:42

Oh I think Russia will eventually take Ukraine. It has to. Otherwise Putin has failed. But take control? More difficult and a different thing.

Theres evidence this morning that Russian are very aware of the impending banking issue from multiple sources. A run on banks creates chaos and a crisis for Russia internally. So things are starting to impact. I think Putin's gamble was that the West wouldn't unite and were too chicken shit to take significant steps together. Not sure thats working, though how long it can be maintained is another matter. Taking over Ukraine or committing crimes against citizens will probably help to unify though. Precisely to avoid a military front.

What can Putin do with the anger that arises from it? He has to channel it to his advantage and I think thats going to be a real challenge.

I don't rule out scenes like Bosnia by any stretch of the imagination. But I also remain unconvinced that it will connect with Russians either if it happens. Particularly young Russians who don't look back at the USSR with rose tinted nostalgia.

We know that even when you 'shut down' foreign social media, it doesn't mean that people aren't accessing it. There is a risk involved in doing so, but it doesn't stop it.

Ultimately people want a future. One that inspires them and offers opportunities. The current situation contrasts with previous conflicts. There is no real 'moral cause' here even with Putin trying to fake one and there's also no tangible goal for a better future either. You can't say that you are getting more lands for you country for example, because why does Russia need it? You can stir up nationalism and anti western feelings but many will still resent losing what they've recently had and now dont.

Ukrainians speak Russian and are Orthodox Christians. Its harder to have a point of difference. Putin isn't at a point where he is at the height of domestic adulation. He's feared, but feared enough? Yes there is Russian racism and superiority over Ukrainians but being asked to suffer and fight rather than make a deal for peace?

I do note that the Ukrainian president has said they are ready for talks but not in Belarus this morning. And made appeals to Belarus to be Belarusian not Russian.

Thing is Putin has a simple problem with a population without money. They will get angry. He will be able to direct so of that at Ukrainians. But Ukraine is far away and government officials are nearby. Putin isn't universally loved. He will have to dedicate resources to managing growing anger at home.

And like us, Russians priorities are 'how do i pay my bills, how do i keep a roof over my head, how do i keep my children feed?' The oligarchs aren't going to get paid and accessing their cash will be a pain in the arse. Not undoable but difficult. Putin is going to be perhaps expecting the oligarchs to put up and shut up with that. Is that in the oligarchs interests? No nice sunny holidays, their yachts impounded? The oligarchs aren't interested in empty Russian nationalism. Most of them spent a great deal of time outside Russia for a reason. And the Oligarchs really aren't subject to the control of Russian propaganda.

I don't know that there's really an appetite for war within Russia. Putin can argue that its about protecting a way of life and try and make it into a war of independence for Russia. But that is different from his initial false flag agenda about Nazis. It puts him on the backfoot and starting from a weak position. Unlike other dictators, Putin isn't in complete control. He still has a facade of parliament and he still has others he has to rely on and trust for support to maintain his power.

Ambitious men, who may see their own opportunities here.

Putin could try military level cyber attacks but it merely opens another front. And that gives the green light for response. Likewise for military attacks. The public won't see the benefit in a military advance. He could throw a nuke, but that doesn't really benefit his domestic situation and his power if someone throws one back.

If he goes and decides he has nothing to lose, he is also risking taking all his oligarchs and generals etc with him. I remain unconvinced that he can stir up that level of fervor within his own ranks. A few years ago maybe but now? The whole war pretext was because of a growing feeling of Putins personal weakness and was supposed to counter this. I do believe they will see this as a personal miscalculation by Putin rather than a Russian one, and Russia has alternatives.

I do think thats why we will see much talk of these. And actually thats why Oligarchs won't be completely cut off. Handicapped enough but close enough still.

Key point: If you make appeals to the lowest common denominator in patronism, you tend to appeal to those who are least educated and least aware of the world - the masses. But this doesn't work if you also don't have the support of your elites. What does nationalism offer the Russian elite if Russia is isolated?

The framing here is going to be worth watching. The West and Ukraine will make a point of it being Putin's War not Russia's war. For a reason.

The media and individuals here would be wise to take note.

Even if Russia does still take Ukraine quickly, Putin has created a load of crisis for himself. They may well be exploitable, they may not.

Others may have more interest in finding a better exit strategy. Mindful that the US got bogged down in Afghanistan with no exit strategy for years and it still didn't end well, still fresh in minds. And the same went before for the Soviets.

Bottomline: Do Russians really want a war themselves that much? Pride is the thing that will keep them in one. Other alternatives and opportunities will be the thing that gives them an exit strategy.

Alexandra2001 · 27/02/2022 07:12

You don't just take whats being said at face value. You match it up with what you are seeing and what actions have been taken. NOTHING today has said Russia is in control of the situation

They may have had a few set backs but they will soon be in control of Ukraine & what we see and hear on the situation is also controlled to some extent - such as We will send 1000s of X weapons, the reality is its extremely difficult to get them to where they are needed now.
With every likelihood they will fall into Russian hands - Trucks heading to the East are an obvious target.

So I do think the risks here are stabilising for the UK. But ramping up for Ukraine

The risks have only just started for all of us, i think its inevitable we will come into direct military conflict with Russia, the Russians are not going to standby as we send weapons to the Ukrainians are they? equally are we prepared to see a humanitarian crisis the likes of what we have never witnessed in Europe unfold before our very eyes?

Also atm the refugee numbers crossing into Poland Czech etc is relatively small, as war progresses, these will become far more, i hope this is being planned for? but so far we here little about it & thats before we get to the people who cannot escape - where is their food going to come from?

I wish to God we had followed Ellwoods demands months ago to put a NATO Rapid reaction force of 40k into Ukraine, despite Putins threats neither he nor his Generals want to fight the USA/NATO but who really thought Putin would throw us back to the 1930s?

Olden · 27/02/2022 06:54

Thanks @RedToothBrush

TokyoSushi · 27/02/2022 06:26

Hey @RedToothBrush I've been waiting to hear your opinion on what's going on. Fascinating insight, thank you.

Deliberateplanning · 26/02/2022 23:48

RedToothBrush

You are amazing. I always know when I'm reading something written by you. Thank you x

Scianel · 26/02/2022 23:33

I hope sanctions imposed have massive effects for decades

You want innocent Russians, currently children and babies, to suffer the consequences of the actions of one man?

MrsDukeOfHastings · 26/02/2022 22:54

I think this is absolutely heartbreaking to watch happening and I really feel for Ukraine and essentially everyone else is powerless.

The one thing I am concerned about is, if Russia does become completely isolated and condemned by the rest of the world, including China now, will he just think F it and go all out. Will he now just do all it takes to destroy everyone and everything? It's scary times from a very unpredictable and evil man. I think he wants to go down in history and will do whatever it takes to do that.

I don't know much about politics etc but surely if he has broken these laws is he not able to have his presidency stripped?

And if that does happen then I have no doubt that he will just go down in flames and press the button so to speak.

Whammyyammy · 26/02/2022 22:21

@redtoothbrush there's no coming back from his troops invading Ukraine and murders innocent civilians.
The whole world currently stands against Russia. I hope sanctions imposed have massive effects for decades

RedToothBrush · 26/02/2022 22:20

Jane Lytvynenko @janelytv
What many people don’t understand is that we Ukrainians are counting every gunshot, every artillery fire, every tank passing by. On Telegram we exchange videos of neighbourhoods. For those of us lucky enough to be safe, we are getting information out. This is a mass mobilization.

RedToothBrush · 26/02/2022 22:03

@Whammyyammy

Russia has been dragged back behind the iron curtain regardless, and alienated from the rest of the world for decades, with blood on their hands.
Disagree.

It depends on what happens with Putin. If he goes it depends on who comes next.

Many will see a new leader as an opportunity and that will encourage engagement for political and financial reasons.

UKRAINEwearewithyou · 26/02/2022 22:03

@Ganymedemoon

What @RedToothBrush says "Numbers of Russian protesters are still relatively small given the size of the population."

Whammyyammy · 26/02/2022 22:01

Russia has been dragged back behind the iron curtain regardless, and alienated from the rest of the world for decades, with blood on their hands.

RedToothBrush · 26/02/2022 22:01

[quote Ganymedemoon]@User1isnotavailable sorry but your comment is just waaaaay out of touch with what is happening in Russia. Have you not seen the many Russians bravely protesting against Putin. Your comment also is so ignorant and reeks of western privilege. Have you ever lived in a dictatorship? No this is not on the Russian people, it's on Putin. You are wrong. [/quote]
Numbers of Russian protesters are still relatively small given the size of the population. I think they will grow though.

RedToothBrush · 26/02/2022 22:00

@TokyoSushi

Not RTFT but here's my thoughts...

I'm beginning to wonder (maybe wishful thinking) that this might be over fairly quickly. I think Putin has seriously underestimated the incredible fight the Ukrainian people are putting up. Or the strength of feeling from pretty much the whole world against him. I think they will keep turning the screws with the sanctions in every possible area, and hopefully they will begin to bite. Either way he has done irreparable damage to his reputation.

I think that Putin thought that it would be a fairly simple task and now he's being proven that might not be the case, I wonder if he'll soon graciously agree to 'talks' to try to resolve the situation. Either that or he'll ratchet up the invasion to horrific levels so as not to appear beaten. I sincerely hope that it isn't the latter. 🇺🇦

I personally would not go that far. Putin HAS to have a military win, or he will be ousted. So the incentive now is to throw the kitchen sink at Ukraine. Reports this evening were detailing bigger tanks entering Ukraine. These tanks are capable of launching thermobarbaric bombs (sic) so that is ratcheting things up.

Where Putin really is losing (and this does really matter) is with the propaganda war internationally. Ukraine's President has played an absolute blinder and has created a situation where if he is killed he becomes a martyr. And that in turn could ultimately mean he loses the propaganda war back home.

The thinking goes that Putin's strategy was founded on what he observed in Afghanistan last year, with the Taliban storming through and the Ukrainians fleeing in terror and abandoning their defence so he could set up a puppet government very quickly. Instead he's looking like he's just landed himself into a scenario closer to Afghanistan 1979. The trouble with him believing in the former strategy is that favours him deliberately targeting civilians (he has form in Chechnya for this) and he did use chemical weapons in Syria. Its a theory thats gained traction and credibility during the course of the day from a number of credible and experienced sources.

Russia seems to have sustained considerably more casualties than anticipated, soliders have run out of supplies and many are conscripts who thought they were being set for training but were instead sent straight into active service. They don't have much of an incentive to fight. And that contrasts with the defenders who have been stirred up to fight for their own land. If you create heroic martyrs in this way, you inspire others.

So it begs the question of whether Putin can really turn any military victory into a political one (see Afghanistan). He has to win a propaganda war to have any meaningful victory. Is that achievable still?

And thats without considering the domestic situation and a war of attrition. Putin isn't going to fund this from his personal assets...

I think the noise today, suggests that world leaders are likely to go further with sanctions and practical support for Ukraine than anyone would have anticipated just 48 hours ago, precisely because the Ukrainians appear to be holding up better than expected. I doubt this would happen if it were all just good propaganda. These reports have to be viewed as fairly credible by EU countries and NATO countries.

What I find striking is that Russia has blocked Facebook, Twitter and YouTube. They are censoring the word 'war' in all media. Instead its a 'special operation.' This is a real sign of weakness and concern. They have had to respond to the narratives on social media which clearly pose a threat to domestic support. Think US domestic opinion during Vietnam. It also means there's much opportunity for' Russian trolls' to be countering whats playing out on social media. It means that overall their propaganda war is hampered abroad. The question is whether there will be a rally together due to feeling ganged up on, or whether it will start to trigger wider protests. Its difficult to say but effect internationally alone is significant.

In many senses its rapidly becoming a war Putin cannot win as even if he wins militarily he's now got a poison chalice on his hands.

If he does go full on to target civilians, in a 'win at any cost' drive, its going to reinforce the sense of moral responsibility - this might be necessary for EU governments dealing with refugees and soaring costs due to fuel and gas shortages. Again that doesn't help Putin.

By all accounts Putin has fallen for the classic flaw of any dictator and over estimated things and the sheer level of corruption means hes unable to see what his military strength really was. Apparently there were many 'ghost soliders' in the ranks as part of this. So troop numbers, particularly of skilled soliders was actually lower than the Generals thought. Again this makes sense. Especially with the rumours are that civilian doctors are now being conscripted too.

I dont buy into the idea that Ukraine will quickly defeat Russia now either though. Its going to get very very bloody quickly quickly and/or very very bogged down and go on for a long time.

Unless the mood back home changes. That gives me two big IFs. IF the Russian people or Oligarchs turn against him and how far will he go if things start to look bad for him; the rat in the corner. I think these are the really crucial questions for Western leaders.

Ukraine has to turn this into a Russian Vietnam extremely quickly, for its own sake. This is also something of a necessity for the West too, I feel because they have their own domestic audiences to keep happy. Hungry and cold citizens do not make happy citizens. Is this possible?

Crucially, in disabling twitter, Putin is perhaps handicapping his own counter propaganda capacity in the West. Worst still for Russia, official Russian outlets like RT are instead, getting deplatformed.

I think in this sense - which is reflective of hybrid war - the military conflict is definitely only part of the equation here.

Whether this will trigger cyberwarefare or worse - reminds to be seen. Whats happening is actually Russia is struggling to withhold information (via the internet) and western vigilante hackers look to be keeping them somewhat busy with their own cyberattacks. They seem to have managed to perhaps overplayed the threat of cyber attacks and instead pissed off some of the wrong people.

The old adage is true here - you can't hide the truth indefinitely, and if things genuinely are going badly, thats going to become very clear very quickly. Especially in a war, if its going badly. The news does filter back and it does lead to questions being raised. I personally think they will have better days ahead, and the Ukrainians are going to have some big set backs fairly soon, simply from a numbers perspective and if desparation to have some Russian progress sets in.

You don't just take whats being said at face value. You match it up with what you are seeing and what actions have been taken. NOTHING today has said Russia is in control of the situation.

So I do think the risks here are stabilising for the UK. But ramping up for Ukraine.

I think the next 24 - 48 hours will be crucial...

getsomehelp · 26/02/2022 20:41

All their media is censored, the majority believe Ukraine invaded

Ganymedemoon · 26/02/2022 19:11

@User1isnotavailable sorry but your comment is just waaaaay out of touch with what is happening in Russia. Have you not seen the many Russians bravely protesting against Putin. Your comment also is so ignorant and reeks of western privilege. Have you ever lived in a dictatorship? No this is not on the Russian people, it's on Putin. You are wrong.

ParsleySageRosemary · 26/02/2022 19:04

Perhaps the Russian people with backbones who don't believe in invading another country should stand up and protest to Putin. The shame is on all of them. They sit there whilst their army invades a peaceful country. Shame on the Russians.

Also - how successful were British protests in stopping Iraq? Or the particular vision of Brexit that Johnson and Frost foisted off on everyone?
Do the Russian people have more power for change than we do?

Olden · 26/02/2022 18:43

@TokyoSushi exactly my thoughts too. Let's all pray he chooses the first option 🙏

TokyoSushi · 26/02/2022 18:37

Not RTFT but here's my thoughts...

I'm beginning to wonder (maybe wishful thinking) that this might be over fairly quickly. I think Putin has seriously underestimated the incredible fight the Ukrainian people are putting up. Or the strength of feeling from pretty much the whole world against him. I think they will keep turning the screws with the sanctions in every possible area, and hopefully they will begin to bite. Either way he has done irreparable damage to his reputation.

I think that Putin thought that it would be a fairly simple task and now he's being proven that might not be the case, I wonder if he'll soon graciously agree to 'talks' to try to resolve the situation. Either that or he'll ratchet up the invasion to horrific levels so as not to appear beaten. I sincerely hope that it isn't the latter. 🇺🇦

ClaudineClare · 26/02/2022 18:27

Perhaps the Russian people with backbones who don't believe in invading another country should stand up and protest to Putin. The shame is on all of them. They sit there whilst their army invades a peaceful country. Shame on the Russians

This is so woefully ignorant. How keen would you be to get out on the streets and protest if it meant risking imprisonment or death for yourself and your loved ones?

TheHateIsNotGood · 26/02/2022 18:16

Not really - Putin will self-implode soon (like the Wicked Witch crushed in Kansas) but really sadly he's going to try and take as many people as he can with him and cause as much mayhem and chaos as he can.

I do think that he can be crushed by a continual barrage of sanctions, accompanied by sending arms and humanitarian assistance - as expected the poorest country in Europe, Moldova is being inundate by refugees, so we musn't forget them.

Sorry Putin, your time is over, retire gracefully now, as a Black Belt Judoga you should know how to do this.

OneMoreTimeThen · 26/02/2022 18:11

@User1isnotavailable there are brave Russians standing up and being heard. Do you realise what happens to people in Russia who protest? Would you honestly put your family's lives in danger if you faced those same consequences ?

User1isnotavailable · 26/02/2022 18:02

@Whammyyammy

Once this is all over the people of Russia will suffer for years. The rest of the world will shun them, their economy will be in tatters, their national Airline is banned from most countries and rightly so, they will not be able to visit anywhere. Already putins beloved football team is not going to play in any international games..... putin will be OK, bit his people won't .
Perhaps the Russian people with backbones who don't believe in invading another country should stand up and protest to Putin. The shame is on all of them. They sit there whilst their army invades a peaceful country. Shame on the Russians.