Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK in danger from Russia?

614 replies

hereforalongtimenotagoodtime · 24/02/2022 21:58

Keep receiving conflicting information. I am sick to my stomach and quite simply hate the unknown. So a simple question - is it likely that the UK will be in danger from Russia? And if so what does that look like? Cyber attacks, bombs being dropped?

OP posts:
StormzyinaTCup · 27/02/2022 16:27

I'm still going with willy waving. He is likely playing the psychological/fear game as he did a couple of days ago. He is playing to a western audience as he knows full well his words will be picked up by our media and splashed all over the front pages (a bit like the media headlines during covid which put the wind up people).

He is running out of any 'friends' he may have had prior, China have abstained on UN Security meeting and some Chinese banks are reportedly restricting some of Russia's financial arrangements for purchasing of raw materials, Hungary have agreed to all EU sanctions and Turkey is now calling Russia's attack an 'act of war'.

For every day this goes on Putin looks more and more like a busted flush.

strawberryapricotpie · 27/02/2022 16:08

@Jedsnewstar

The party in control of the uk government is almost entirely funded by the Russians, we are not a threat to them, we are in bed with them.

Come on now b b b b b b b b b b but Corbyn.

This.
sleaf · 27/02/2022 15:56

@Kassle

I was anxious enough already and jumpy at loud noises outside, e.g. aircraft going over thinking it could be a nuclear weapon.

Even if it did happen, it wouldn't be a case of suddenly you hear an aircraft and it's a nuclear weapon.

I know. I heard a distant rumble earlier from the nearby industrial estate and for a moment panicked.
RedToothBrush · 27/02/2022 15:56

@ClaudineClare

True, Red. But I think some posters are deliberately scaring others with the talk of nuclear war. It is not a nice thing to do.
We need to be realistic here.

Its possible. But unlikely.

We need to understand this isn't just about nukes too.

"The only thing we have to fear is fear itself" said Roosevelt. And I think we should be mindful of that.

The population being fearful undermines our governments' ability to deal with this one. We need to be aware of our fear and control it for good reason. Panic and dissent here damages the unity of non military action.

I don't think avoiding the subject helps us with that because we are still fearful though. It doesn't remove the risk of us utterly panicking at a crucial moment further down the line. We need to understand why it is important to hold nerve in the face of the fear. Like the Ukrainian President if you will.

To do this, we have to contextualise it, explaining why we should simultaneously understand why he might be bluffing and why he might not and we do need to take it seriously too. We can't just ignore it. Same goes for other possible threats.

We know that the British and the Russians had intelligence prior to the invasion that he definitely was going to do it. They really didn't think the invasion was a bluff. That suggests our intelligence isn't bad.

And there are lots of Russians who perhaps have more to lose here than some of us. There is an incentive to do away with Putin for many.

Ranting and raving aren't the same as action. Thats what Trump did. We had an unconscious bias from the bluster that he would win a second term. Didn't happen. They are a sign of inherent weakness not strength.

Its what Putin doesn't want us to see. He doesn't want to be the Emperor exposed with no clothes. He's going to be all to aware of how the facade of Russian strength has been harmed. Even if Ukraine lose quickly now.

Fear is driven by the things we don't know.

So focus on the things we do know: good western unity, Putins inherent weakness being found out, military strength not being quite as big as we might have percieved, Ukrainian resistance holding well considering, good Ukrainian propaganda, his need to look tough, good Russian intelligence, poor logistics, Russians citizen concerns over loved ones, fears about money, putins age, a lack of real love for putin domestically, failing to follow basic SunTzu principles, a lack of clear moral cause, a distrust of the Russian state by the Russian public (the level of vaccine uptake in Russia is directly linked to this - so theres clear evidence of not really believing Putin going on), Russian MPs openly dissenting and saying they feel betrayed.

These aren't being stressed enough and we are doing what he wants when he persuades you to look into a pit of anxiety and despair.

We need to understand rationality versus our own fears. This exploitation by politicians has been rampant for the last 6 years in British politics. We need to start learning to identify it better to stop being manipulated too.

We should be able to read anxiety producing shit on the internet, go away talk about it and in doing so rationalise it. If we don't learn this skill we put ourselves at risk of other harms not just nukes.

Kassle · 27/02/2022 15:48

Really hacked off with people using this to score a political point TBH, and I'm about as anti-Tory as they come.

Kassle · 27/02/2022 15:47

B b b b but ohhhhh Je-re-my Coor-byn!

I think our current government are a disgusting group of utter clowns and charlatans (to put it mildly), but thank F we do not have anti-NATO Corbyn in charge right now.

MarshaBradyo · 27/02/2022 15:46

Yeahbut I agree what a ridiculous post from pp

Kassle · 27/02/2022 15:46

I was anxious enough already and jumpy at loud noises outside, e.g. aircraft going over thinking it could be a nuclear weapon.

Even if it did happen, it wouldn't be a case of suddenly you hear an aircraft and it's a nuclear weapon.

sleaf · 27/02/2022 15:46

I wish I hadn't seen this post. I was anxious enough already and jumpy at loud noises outside, e.g. aircraft going over thinking it could be a nuclear weapon.

Yeahthat · 27/02/2022 15:25

@Jedsnewstar

The party in control of the uk government is almost entirely funded by the Russians, we are not a threat to them, we are in bed with them.

Come on now b b b b b b b b b b but Corbyn.

Cut the crap and take your student politics elsewhere.

We acted earlier to supply Ukraine with weapons than just about any other European nation - at a time when Germany wouldn't even let planes carrying them pass through their airspace and did nothing more than offer helmets.

We backed removing Russia from SWIFT before many European nations and were instrumental in building consensus for it.

We continue to supply Ukraine with weapons and financial support.

B b b b but ohhhhh Je-re-my Coor-byn!

Fuck off.

ClaudineClare · 27/02/2022 15:17

True, Red. But I think some posters are deliberately scaring others with the talk of nuclear war. It is not a nice thing to do.

Jedsnewstar · 27/02/2022 15:16

The party in control of the uk government is almost entirely funded by the Russians, we are not a threat to them, we are in bed with them.

Come on now b b b b b b b b b b but Corbyn.

RedToothBrush · 27/02/2022 15:13

It is so very unlikely to happen that it is not worth wasting energy worrying about it.

I think more to the point, if it happens there's really fuck all you are going to be able to do to protect yourself anyway.

You either die in it or survive and face utter chaos and panic or die in the aftermath.

Not sure I much fancy any of those options tbh.

RedToothBrush · 27/02/2022 15:10

After all, they'll be fully aware that it's the end for everybody won't they?

Probably. You'd hope. But you just don't know and you don't know how Putin is selling it. If he's saying 'we will Nuke Stockholm because the west are too spineless to retaliate' they might believe the hype. Or simply, if you don't go along with this you are dead anyway. You just don't know and thats kind of the point here.

I also think it depends on whether they think they are dead if Putin goes. He could be filling heads with ideas of revolution, imprisonment etc.

What do they fear most?

I do think that rumours about Putin's health are curious though. They match with his ridiculous table afterall. Obviously it could just be propaganda aimed to damage him. But this might well touch a nerve, afterall he sent some punks to intimidate the last leg hosts after they made a bunch of jokes about him being gay.

The fact we can't predict - and we really can't rule anything out - is Putins strength.

Remember he is currently in a position where he's looking weaker than expected militarily and weak on the propaganda war. He has a desire and need to protect his ego and reputation here by acting tough.

Typical bully.

Im sure that the international defence psychologists are processing it all...

croquetas · 27/02/2022 15:00

The threat has always been there. Putin and his generals have nursed this "great ambition" to restore the Russian Empire. Past (western) leaders have lacked the political Will to confront him and have instead sought re- assurance in NATO alliance.
Luckily, whilst the UK, Germany, etc have cut back on defence spending, the US has continued to invest more.

In the event of a nuclear attack, hopefully with advance missile defence capabilities across NATO, we can neutralise / minimise damage and hopefully retaliate with devastating force.

The threat from Russia will always be there, even when Putin is long gone, until it becomes fully democratic, more transparent and progressive.

ClaudineClare · 27/02/2022 14:55

I understand why people are scared, especially younger people. Remember though that there have been times in the past where the world has been far closer to nuclear war than now, from the Cuban Missile Crisis onwards. It is so very unlikely to happen that it is not worth wasting energy worrying about it.

The only people in danger from Putin right now are the Ukrainian people and the young Russian soldiers he is sending to war for no good reason.

RedToothBrush · 27/02/2022 14:54

@Itsnotover

Some people on here really need to get a grip.
How do that help? Actually make an effort to explain calmly then.

There are lots of possibilities and lots of things we realistically should be being cautious and prepared / protect ourselves against.

It is a possibility he would nuke an non nato or a similar nato country believing we wouldn't have the balls or stomach to hit back... As we'd be avoiding mutually assured destruction. That'd be one hell of a gamble though...

Partyatnumber10 · 27/02/2022 14:52

@Itsnotover

I would not be surprised if those closest to Putin have changed to codes on the nukes.
I've been wondering today, in the still highly unlikely event that Putin threw caution to the winds and went to set off nuclear weapons, would a member of his inner circle actually turn and assassinate him? After all, they'll be fully aware that it's the end for everybody won't they?
RedToothBrush · 27/02/2022 14:46

@Youngatheart00

The nuclear word today has terrified me
To which audience is he performing and for what reason?

He is trying to make out that Russia is at risk of western aggression to a Russian audience

He is trying to intimate and scare western audiences to get their public to pressure their governments to backdown to stop the threat of aggression.

None of this means he will use them or that he has any intention of using them. He may be seriously considering it. I doubt thats what Russian want either though. He has to have a country left to be a President of...

Remember he is currently losing the propaganda war badly and needs to change the narrative back in Russias favour.

marieantoinehairnet · 27/02/2022 14:16

Sorry @Itsnotover I didn't realise you owned Mumsnet

Itsnotover · 27/02/2022 14:14

@HelpMeHiveMind

Are the threats of putting nuclear deterrents on high alert aimed at us- would he actually nuke the UK?
No. This thing called mutually assured destruction is why it hasn’t happened for all the years that countries have had nuclear capability.

And no @marieantoinehairnet I will not ‘go away’. There are certain posters on MN alone who enjoy whipping up hysteria.

marieantoinehairnet · 27/02/2022 14:12

[quote Itsnotover]@marieantoinehairnet I think it’s perfectly clear I am not talking about people in Ukraine. So please do stop being so disingenuous.[/quote]
Misuse of a word there, worry is worry and some people need an outlet, you do t need one, you can go away

HelpMeHiveMind · 27/02/2022 14:12

Are the threats of putting nuclear deterrents on high alert aimed at us- would he actually nuke the UK?

Itsnotover · 27/02/2022 14:10

@marieantoinehairnet I think it’s perfectly clear I am not talking about people in Ukraine. So please do stop being so disingenuous.

Itsnotover · 27/02/2022 14:09

It’s normal to worry. Nobody wants any war. Nobody normal anyway. It’s not normal to fan the flames every time there is a crisis and act like ghouls.