Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK in danger from Russia?

614 replies

hereforalongtimenotagoodtime · 24/02/2022 21:58

Keep receiving conflicting information. I am sick to my stomach and quite simply hate the unknown. So a simple question - is it likely that the UK will be in danger from Russia? And if so what does that look like? Cyber attacks, bombs being dropped?

OP posts:
HeadPain · 25/02/2022 09:53

@girlwiththetigertattoo

No the UK isn't in danger. The UK would moan and complain and condemn and secretly offer weapons to Ukraine doing charity works etc. Also the casualties won't be very high like some Middle Eastern country where they deliberately aim at hospitals and civilians with phosphorus bombs to ethnically cleanse and expand housing development. To not allow this to go out of context, I'm no way supporting what Russia is doing right now but what Russia is doing isn't ethnic cleansing and believe me, my native country has lived through ethnic cleansing in Balkans and mass graves are still being dug up today.
"Also the casualties won't be very high like some Middle Eastern country where they deliberately aim at hospitals and civilians with phosphorus bombs"

Wasn't Russia accused of doing these things in Syria?

AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 09:53

@Campervangirl

We're not in any danger, it's a little man flexing his muscles (ok, he's got the might of the Russian military behind him). It's one thing invading Ukraine but it's a completely different ball game taking on America and Britain. No-one is nuking anyone. Putin can make all the threats he wants (must admit the threat was quite scary) but no one is going into a nuclear war or World War 3 over Ukraine. NATO is not going to let Putin get away with causing ww3.
Are you 100% certain over that? Like have you talked to putin about what he is planning and got the full truth? Spoken to Johnson and Biden on their plans, all other country leaders too?

No one here can possibly 100% know what is going to happen. You all thought two weeks ago putin would never invade Ukraine. Proven wrong there.

Hopefully he is only targeting Ukraine but I doubt it. He's old school, its possible he wants more. The one thing we don't know is how far he is actually going to go on that. He could go into that fully if he takes Ukraine.

We will find out over the course of the next few weeks/months/years. But I would not be putting all of my bets on he's definitely not going to target NATO countries. He very easily could.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 25/02/2022 09:46

I think he wants the allies to try and stop him using physical force. It would be an excuse for him to push the button and be remembered for it (assuming anyone survives to tell the tale of course). Regardless of the outcome of this war I believe it will either be climate change or a nuclear war that will end humanity as we know it. 5-7 years ago life was so much simpler. I miss those days when I could actually go to bed without worrying about anything.

Kinsters · 25/02/2022 09:39

But it's not just Putin, is it? He'll have people around him. Even if Putin himself is mad enough to launch a nuke someone close to him will be sane enough to not allow that to happen (you'd hope...).

oakleaffy · 25/02/2022 09:37

@Tealightsandd

If not Russia, there's Long Covid. Despite rumours to the contrary that threat has not gone away.
That’s patently a ridiculous comment. Long or short covid is NOTHING like a potential Third World War kicking off with a bullying psychopath at the helm.
BulletTrain · 25/02/2022 09:34

@RedToothBrush

If not Russia, there's Long Covid. Despite rumours to the contrary that threat has not gone away

If not Russia, there's Long Covid, if not Long Covid, there's extremist Islamic Terrorists, if not extremist Islamic Terrorists there's climate change, if not climate change, there's super bugs and resistance to antibiotics, if not super bugs and resistance to antibiotics, there's poverty and food insecurity, if not poverty and food insecurity, there's the rise of hackers, if there's not hackers, there's the risk of a super volcano, if not a super volcano there's the risk of a coronal mass ejection causing a Carrington Event and taking out all our satellites, power supplies and making planes fall out of the sky.

Or perhaps you could learn about relative risk and how to manage your anxiety better, cos saying shit like this is not a healthy sign.

An excellent post.

Plus, frankly I would rather have long covid than be bombed (nuclear or not) or invaded.

Willyoujustbequiet · 25/02/2022 09:32

Batshit clearly lol

Willyoujustbequiet · 25/02/2022 09:32

I think he's bats hit and would use nuclear weapons.

But I also think we will stand back and let Ukraine fall to avoid this.

I think its advisable to make sure you have some cash to hand.

Burgoo · 25/02/2022 09:30

Its hard to say. If he is either unwell or dying then he may well feel he has nothing to lose. He wants to be seen as a strong man so launching a nuke would certainly put him in the history books and he would go out with a bang.

That said, we have the nuclear deterrent AND they know that if they even attempted it the US would be all over them. The UKs standing is such that France would have to intervene due to proximity and other European nations would follow suit.

You can't predict a lunatic who genuinely believes that Russia has been victimised for decades, that Russia has had countries removed from them and that democracy is going to sweep into Russia and take power from him. Given his likely war crimes, he cannot accept any movement toward Russia because he is likely concerned that he may end up on trial.

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 25/02/2022 09:28

I'm really not sure the UK are in any physical danger as such, as Putin and his buddies so in bed with BoJo & Co. But we really need to look at what he's done since yesterday morning and take some notice. Our govt been fannying around the last 2 years, royally fucking everything up, whilst they continue to cut everything to the bone, including our armed forces. The amount they've been depleted in the last 10 years makes me really nervous. Putin's been planning this for a very long time I feel, been sitting there building his troops/weapons/cash pile, so he can take whatever action he likes, and survive the sanctions we impose on him.

Meanwhile, the UK can't learn from history. We've been building gender neutral toilets.

Ciaram55 · 25/02/2022 09:26

I think a "massive cyber attack" is like an invasion/declaration of war. How could we as a nation ignore something like that. We'd have to retaliate in some form or other.

HufflepuffPride · 25/02/2022 09:21

I think people who spout things like this are just very, very thick and ignorant. If they can’t understand why Russia invading another, independent sovereign state is serious and there is now war in Europe, just three hours away from the U.K. then you’ve got no hope.

RedWingBoots · 25/02/2022 09:20

@HesterShaw1

Someone made the point that part of Russian campaigns, meddling and general shit stirring is via social media. A good example is on this forum and the idiotic "they're talking about subscription in the UK" post yesterday.
That's been going on for years but social media companies including many of those who run forums do SFA about it, as governments haven't forced them to.
HesterShaw1 · 25/02/2022 09:17

@Tealightsandd

Are you really trying to compare post viral symptoms with Russia invading a country and the terror that people in Ukraine are going through? That's in such poor taste it's actually stunned me

Seriously?

You express concern about people suffering terror. What, like the 160,000 people in the UK killed by Covid? And the many disabled Long Covid sufferers.

(Hope, btw that your concern for the people in Ukraine is extended to those suffering in Yemen, Ethiopia, Syria, and other conflict torn regions).

Stunning poor taste indeed to dismiss heart, lung, and brain damage, strokes, clotting, and early dementia, that is Long Covid.

You are obsessed. Absolutely obsessed.
Wbeezer · 25/02/2022 09:17

I agree with @Walkaround, we actually need a form of world government to sort out climate change but culturally and psychologically we don't seem ready for it and it's used as a idea to be very afraid of to really sorry for the likes of Trump and Putin.

Kinsters · 25/02/2022 09:17

[quote Monday55]**@Kinsters* and @Doris86* I know Nato will step-in but we will be too busy being dead by the time Nato retaliate.[/quote]
But that's why it won't happen in the first place. Putin and those around him know that if they nuke the UK then they will be nuked in return and won't win the ensuing war (noone will). Even if Putin is mad enough to want to launch nukes (and I don't think anyone thinks he is) someone around him will have enough sense of self preservation to stop him.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 09:15

If not Russia, there's Long Covid. Despite rumours to the contrary that threat has not gone away

If not Russia, there's Long Covid, if not Long Covid, there's extremist Islamic Terrorists, if not extremist Islamic Terrorists there's climate change, if not climate change, there's super bugs and resistance to antibiotics, if not super bugs and resistance to antibiotics, there's poverty and food insecurity, if not poverty and food insecurity, there's the rise of hackers, if there's not hackers, there's the risk of a super volcano, if not a super volcano there's the risk of a coronal mass ejection causing a Carrington Event and taking out all our satellites, power supplies and making planes fall out of the sky.

Or perhaps you could learn about relative risk and how to manage your anxiety better, cos saying shit like this is not a healthy sign.

Monday55 · 25/02/2022 09:13

@Kinsters and @Doris86 I know Nato will step-in but we will be too busy being dead by the time Nato retaliate.

Scianel · 25/02/2022 09:09

@HesterShaw1 that thread really was something else.

Kinsters · 25/02/2022 09:08

@Walkaround how depressingly true.

Walkaround · 25/02/2022 09:05

In all honesty, I think we’re all fucked, anyway - when climate change is already a massive threat to world stability and life in general, instead of working together as a planet, we are rushing headlong into accelerating the creation of uninhabitable wastelands. It’s not as if we aren’t totally reliant on other countries to feed us, keep us warm, provide us with raw materials, provide us with goods. Our entire economy is corrupt - democracy has not brought honesty or high ideals, just blind eyes turned to the sources of wealth, tax havens, nurturing of oligarchs, hoarding of money by dangerous, powerful, selfish people and institutions, and repulsive billionaires blasting themselves self-importantly into space.

Theunamedcat · 25/02/2022 09:04

@youhadmeatjello

Ah thanks *@doris86* my geography is appalling. I was thinking more of the radioactive material there but realised that made no sense.
It makes a bit of sense but the material from the other reactors was supposed to be removed and the Russians know this they were instrumental in the sarcophagus construction as it currently stands you can stand by the elephants foot for 3000 seconds without taking too much damage which is an improvement on the 30 seconds but the land is still contaminated and I wouldn't personally be wanting my troops there for a significant amount of time so we can expect rapid progress from this point on im afraid
Kinsters · 25/02/2022 09:04

@Monday55

One-on-one war against Russia and we will definitely lose, we literally like a mosquito bite compared to what they can do. The only countries that can win against Russia one-on- one are USA & China and there's absolutely no way China will ever fight on the same side as USA.

A lot of UK citizens sleep easy thinking we can defend ourselves but we are not even in the top 5 strongest armies and we barely make it in the top ten.

But it's not one on one. The UK is standing with all of NATO. Russia is just Russia. I dont think for a second China will fight alongside them. And remember that Russia is really quite a poor country, war will hit their population a lot harder than ours. When the people get fed up enough that's the end of Putin and his regime.
AtomicBlondeRose · 25/02/2022 09:02

The war in Ukraine is undoubtedly really bad but given that there are other wars like this going on all the time that just don’t get any media attention, we need to not catastrophise based on horrible photos and TV soundbites.

We live in an ultra-capitalist world. The people at the very top lead lives of immense wealth and luxury. They might be evil or mad but they’re still people and they don’t want to live in a post-apocalyptic wasteland any more than anyone else does! Where is the profit in nuclear war? There is none! It won’t happen. War in Ukraine on the other hand could be very profitable for Russia.

MorningStarling · 25/02/2022 09:02

Russia is definitely a danger to the UK. They have the nuclear firepower to destroy us if they choose to. We could retaliate with a single nuclear-armed submarine.

It's not likely it would get to that stage though because even Putin knows nuking a NATO country would result in a retaliation from the whole of NATO.

Cyber attacks are more likely, in fact they're a constant danger already. Expect infrastructure like power, communications, travel and banking to be hit suddenly from time to time.

I don't think Putin wants a war with the whole of Europe, he just wants to recover the territory Russia lost when the USSR collapsed. Once he's got Ukraine he'll be moving to reclaim other countries - Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia, Poland, Czechia, Slovakia, Hungary, Romania, Moldova, Bulgaria and the former Yugoslavia. Not necessarily to conquer them but to install pro-Russian governments.

That's where the risk to the UK really ramps up. If he attacks a NATO member, we'll be expected to send troops in. Hopefully it will just be a conventional war on mainland Europe so won't affect us too much. There's a risk it will become a total war of course, with Russia bombing the UK (and the US probably, from the far east of Russia) and vice-versa, and that could escalate into a nuclear apocalypse, but that's probably months, if not years away.