Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK in danger from Russia?

614 replies

hereforalongtimenotagoodtime · 24/02/2022 21:58

Keep receiving conflicting information. I am sick to my stomach and quite simply hate the unknown. So a simple question - is it likely that the UK will be in danger from Russia? And if so what does that look like? Cyber attacks, bombs being dropped?

OP posts:
User48751490 · 25/02/2022 10:33

@fghjk

On the point of consequences, I just found this 10 min video which highlights a point I hadn't even thought about: food production.

When I thought about what a war with Russia would mean I automatically jumped to the consequences on energy prices etc and didn't even think about this point.

Apart from the America is great vibe, it was a good video highlighting the food production implications. Good point.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/02/2022 10:33

It really wasn't just a "two day annoyance".

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 10:32

There's no need to be snarky just because I'm not so knowledgeable about this as you. It doesn't make me want to read your very long post when you start off so rudely, even though I'm sure you have something interesting and informative to say.

Being uninformed does not mean you are incapable of using google to find out why so many people are worried about the threat.

Instead despite this you were arrogant and confident enough to reply that others with this fear were talking rot.

Engage your brain before typing. Its a good protection against people pointing out how ignorant your post is. Or 'being snarky' as you clearly prefer to call it.

That comment was jaw dropping. It needed picking up on and robustly challenging.

Kinsters · 25/02/2022 10:31

@RedToothBrush same to you. There is no need to be so rude. Cyber attacks are not something I have any familiarity with apart from that one that hit the NHS a few years ago which was just a two day annoyance. Are you aware that you can inform and share your thoughts without being rude? Is this how you talk to people in real life?

didshedidntshe · 25/02/2022 10:30

@Tealightsandd

Are you really trying to compare post viral symptoms with Russia invading a country and the terror that people in Ukraine are going through? That's in such poor taste it's actually stunned me

Seriously?

You express concern about people suffering terror. What, like the 160,000 people in the UK killed by Covid? And the many disabled Long Covid sufferers.

(Hope, btw that your concern for the people in Ukraine is extended to those suffering in Yemen, Ethiopia, Syria, and other conflict torn regions).

Stunning poor taste indeed to dismiss heart, lung, and brain damage, strokes, clotting, and early dementia, that is Long Covid.

Are you aware that you can care about all sorts of things at the exact same time? Lmao talk about whataboutism
roses2 · 25/02/2022 10:30

What harm would a cyber attack really do though? A day or two of systems down..it would just be an annoyance.

Shops can't sell products without till connectivity. People can't take money out of banks. People who work with computers can't work. Airlines can't fly planes.....

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 10:29

What harm would a cyber attack really do though? A day or two of systems down..it would just be an annoyance.

OMFG.

This comment is special.

I swear to god, people have no idea how the world works at all.

Lets give an example:
www.ft.com/content/acf4ac78-c738-48c6-8de1-077697e062d6
Patients fall victim to health ransomware
Cyber hackers’ access to personal data can cause havoc at medical facilities

The WannaCry ransomware attack in 2017 caused severe disruption to the NHS, costing the UK’s health service £92m and leading to the cancellation of 19,000 patient appointments.

And

In one case in Finland, the confidential treatment records of thousands of psychotherapy patients were hacked and leaked online — many patients were blackmailed to keep the data private. In September 2020, a ransomware attack took down a chain of more than 250 US hospitals and clinics.

Or shall we talk about how an attack could in theory wipe a banks records or start mass transferring money from your account. How could you prove how much money was in your account beforehand? Not everyone would be protected and it could lead to a bank collapsing.

I can promise you that security in places like this are not nearly as good as you might think and expect.

We are extremely vulnerable.

I would suggest looking into the possibilities rather than dismissing as a 24 hr only event with no consequences.

Kinsters · 25/02/2022 10:28

@AllOfUsAreDead

What harm would a cyber attack really do though? A day or two of systems down..it would just be an annoyance.

OK now that I've stopped laughing at this..

It's a really really big deal. Let's just take what happened to sepa in 2020 as an example. To actually resolve that it took months, and replacing all of their computers, servers, everything. The same thing has happened to numerous other smaller companies in 2021.

Now imagine that across the whole of the UK banking sector. That's a lot of banks. A lot of computers, a lot of servers. There actually isn't enough replacements in the UK to cover that. So you can't access your money because its all compromised and switched off.

Now moving on to water companies. If they managed to get in and get into the secure areas that control things like chlorine levels in the water, they could adjust that. Or just switch it off altogether. Waste management, same thing.

They could target the NHS, which has happened before. Machines like life support could be targeted. On a more basic level, they could just lift all of your data and use it.

Targeting all of that, plus more, would take years to resolve. Years. There are plans in place to resolve it if it happens to one, maybe two. But to actually fix all of that quickly? There aren't enough people who know what to do employed, thanks to cut backs, and there isn't enough spare infrastructure to replace the compromised machines. The ones controlling the water levels etc tend to be very very old machines that are no longer even made. So how do those get replaced to actually work with the systems? It's a complete nightmare. You couldn't trust anything if it happened.

It's a very big deal and not just a couple of days of annoyance. It's a life changer, for years. To the point that I'd say getting money out now is pointless, if that actually happens, society is already over. Same as if we are hit with nuclear weapons. Its complete devastation.

There's no need to be snarky just because I'm not so knowledgeable about this as you. It doesn't make me want to read your very long post when you start off so rudely, even though I'm sure you have something interesting and informative to say.
Applesonthelawn · 25/02/2022 10:26

Western countries off cyber attacks from Russia and China every day even before Ukraine. It is nothing new for countries to successfully fend off those attacks.

Ciaram55 · 25/02/2022 10:26

One man causing all this chaos, fear and loss of life. The man should be physically restrained/ disobeyed.

AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 10:18

What harm would a cyber attack really do though? A day or two of systems down..it would just be an annoyance.

OK now that I've stopped laughing at this..

It's a really really big deal. Let's just take what happened to sepa in 2020 as an example. To actually resolve that it took months, and replacing all of their computers, servers, everything. The same thing has happened to numerous other smaller companies in 2021.

Now imagine that across the whole of the UK banking sector. That's a lot of banks. A lot of computers, a lot of servers. There actually isn't enough replacements in the UK to cover that. So you can't access your money because its all compromised and switched off.

Now moving on to water companies. If they managed to get in and get into the secure areas that control things like chlorine levels in the water, they could adjust that. Or just switch it off altogether. Waste management, same thing.

They could target the NHS, which has happened before. Machines like life support could be targeted. On a more basic level, they could just lift all of your data and use it.

Targeting all of that, plus more, would take years to resolve. Years. There are plans in place to resolve it if it happens to one, maybe two. But to actually fix all of that quickly? There aren't enough people who know what to do employed, thanks to cut backs, and there isn't enough spare infrastructure to replace the compromised machines. The ones controlling the water levels etc tend to be very very old machines that are no longer even made. So how do those get replaced to actually work with the systems? It's a complete nightmare. You couldn't trust anything if it happened.

It's a very big deal and not just a couple of days of annoyance. It's a life changer, for years. To the point that I'd say getting money out now is pointless, if that actually happens, society is already over. Same as if we are hit with nuclear weapons. Its complete devastation.

fghjk · 25/02/2022 10:17

On the point of consequences, I just found this 10 min video which highlights a point I hadn't even thought about: food production.

When I thought about what a war with Russia would mean I automatically jumped to the consequences on energy prices etc and didn't even think about this point.

strawberryapricotpie · 25/02/2022 10:12

@Libraryghost

You have to accept the unknown to a large extent I'm afraid. The first thing that will happen is the cost of living will go up. Rising gas and oil prices inevitably means higher commodity prices. As for what actions Russia will take, who knows? No point worrying about it really. Easier said then done I know but it's a fluid situation. It all depends on if it carries on escalating and if he breaches NATO lands. It's worth remembering we have been here many times. Read up on the Cuban missile crisis, many people though a nuclear war would kick off then. We are still here.
We could easily not have been, though. I'm not old enough to remember the Cuban missile crisis personally, but I've read a fair bit about it and I do remember the last couple of decades of the Cold War, notably how close to the red button we were in the 80s on several occasions. It genuinely could have degenerated into nuclear conflict. Not trying to panic anyone (I'm neither a political commentator nor in possession of every single piece of info about what's happening atm) but I don't think it's all that surprising that some people are worried about the nuclear possibility either. I am myself.
CourtRand · 25/02/2022 10:09

@Monday55

One-on-one war against Russia and we will definitely lose, we literally like a mosquito bite compared to what they can do. The only countries that can win against Russia one-on- one are USA & China and there's absolutely no way China will ever fight on the same side as USA.

A lot of UK citizens sleep easy thinking we can defend ourselves but we are not even in the top 5 strongest armies and we barely make it in the top ten.

We have the fifth largest defence budget in the world alongside pretty solid alliances with the US, Canada, Aus and half of Europe. We would never be fighting Russia alone.
MistressoftheDarkSide · 25/02/2022 10:08

Depends on the definition of danger.

Russia and China have the world over a barrel because of their military / nuclear capabilities. Therefore they can pretty much demand anything "or we'll nuke you" / "cyberattack you into chaos and destabilise your infrastructure".

Meanwhile the people of Ukraine suffer horribly while governments do cost / benefit analysis and have to submit to fears of escalation.

It's a shit show whichever way you look at it.

I said yesterday the things that will really worry me on the physical danger front are if they test air raid sirens and if world leaders vanish to their bunkers.

PerditaNitt · 25/02/2022 10:08

Too much Russian wealth in London for it to be nuked is my view. Cyber attacks are a possibility and I understand that the BoE has been asking financial institutions on their readiness to withstand cyber attacks (although to be fair, ongoing improvements to cyber security is business as usual for London financial institutions, so I wouldn’t say there is an immediate risk and no need to worry!)

CourtRand · 25/02/2022 10:06

@Valhalla17

If Boris keeps making threats then it's highly likely we will be nuked.
It's not highly likely we will be nuked ffs. Putin won't just tank all political relations and take out half of Europe's economy because Boris threatened him with sanction.
CoffeeWithCheese · 25/02/2022 10:06

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuxnet
That's what a cyber attack is capable of doing if it gets into things like control systems for infrastructure. It's not just computers that sit on your desk - it has the potential to hit absolutely fucking everything really.

fghjk · 25/02/2022 10:05

@Iggly yeah I understand it's clearly a lot more complicated than I can comprehend. I guess my point is more about trying to see this from Putin's POV rather than dismissing / categorising him as a willy waving power hungry lunatic etc.

Kinsters · 25/02/2022 10:02

@jytdtysrht

Yes we are in danger imo. And I personally think it will be a cyber attack. No sense of right and wrong, only power.
What harm would a cyber attack really do though? A day or two of systems down..it would just be an annoyance.
Iggly · 25/02/2022 10:00

It's complicated basically, and I don't think we have any business getting involved in this war. In fact I don't think we have any business getting into any wars that don't directly affect us, as sad as that is for people around the world who cannot protect themselves

As we are not anywhere near close enough to being self sufficient, we don’t have the luxury of not getting involved. We’ve sold most of our national infrastructure and assets to overseas companies, we have not invested in home grown technology and have just encouraged foreign investment which means we have little control over a lot of our economy.

That is why our government is so easily bought by the likes of Russian donors.

So sadly we are involved whether we like it or not.

jytdtysrht · 25/02/2022 09:59

Yes we are in danger imo. And I personally think it will be a cyber attack. No sense of right and wrong, only power.

CoffeeWithCheese · 25/02/2022 09:58

@Tealightsandd

If not Russia, there's Long Covid. Despite rumours to the contrary that threat has not gone away.
It's OK sweetie - we shall get him to put face masks on all the missile noses.

Seriously what the fuckedy fucky bollocks?!

It's scary as shit but move away from the "OMG HE HAS CHERNOBYL - NUCLEAR STUFF" thoughts. He wanted that area because it basically has the potential to open a route from Belarus (his allies) through toward Kyiv - nothing really to do with the reactor, just the strategic location of it - it opens up a short and relatively direct route.

As for nukes - that bit I don't actually get worried about - the Cold War era shows how much willy waving of their nuclear warheads they all got up to back then, but it wasn't covered in saturation level detail on rolling news, on phone alerts and on social media.

Bits that worry the shit out of me - oil and gas, and cyber attacks. That could fuck us up insanely effectively and insanely quickly - looking back to the NHS cyber collapse in the past and how much more difficult that would be to resolve with so many clinicians now working out of their home on laptops that would need to be recalled back in etc. Plus Russian bots poking away at social media trying to stir up panic (and aided by ordinary people who are fucking terrified).

TheVolturi · 25/02/2022 09:57

@Monday55

One-on-one war against Russia and we will definitely lose, we literally like a mosquito bite compared to what they can do. The only countries that can win against Russia one-on- one are USA & China and there's absolutely no way China will ever fight on the same side as USA.

A lot of UK citizens sleep easy thinking we can defend ourselves but we are not even in the top 5 strongest armies and we barely make it in the top ten.

That's because we are a tiny island! Our army is amazing for the size of our country. But in the grand scheme we're insignificant. Which is why I hope Boris does not try to take the lead in pissing off Putin, because it would not take much to wipe us out entirely.
fghjk · 25/02/2022 09:57

Granted I am basing this all on my very basic understanding of what is going on and what I can remember from high school History class, but is anyone else seeing the connections in what happened back then with what is happening now?

Wasn't one of the main driving factors behind Hitler and his rise to power the aftermath of WW1 and the sanctions etc the ROW were still putting on them?

From Putin's perspective: wasn't there a general agreement between US & Russia that NATO would not expand further East after the Soviet Union. Now they have and there is talk of Ukraine joining.

You have to wonder how Biden would feel / what he would do if Russia and China formed a military alliance / club, refused to let the US join, then allowed Mexico and Cuba in on it and were in talks about letting Canada join?

Would he be making some threats? Posturing?

And if ROW responded to those threats / postures by the financial sanctions we've seen, what would Biden / Trump / Obama / Bush do then?

Add in the fact they've been under sanctions for years now, making them generally resentful of "the west" or the Anglo-American-Block who appear to wage wars wherever and whenever they want and well... don't we have the type of "straw that broke the camel's back" moment we saw in the run up to the world wars?

I feel like it's worth stepping back for a minute and seeing things from Putin's POV. I mean, what does he have to lose really? They share a big border. It's a pretty big "weakness" in his defence. To use the same US analogy, what if this was Ireland? What if the UK had many historical reasons to be wary of the EU, they're sanctioning us, they're making alliances with China, Russia, the US, and now they're in talks about getting Ireland in. We can all try to kid ourselves that a defence alliance like that doesn't put Norther Ireland and therefore the entire UK at risk, but really it does.

Would we just do nothing, or would we make the first move to "take Ireland back" so we'd have a much more secure border?

It's complicated basically, and I don't think we have any business getting involved in this war. In fact I don't think we have any business getting into any wars that don't directly affect us, as sad as that is for people around the world who cannot protect themselves.