Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is the UK in danger from Russia?

614 replies

hereforalongtimenotagoodtime · 24/02/2022 21:58

Keep receiving conflicting information. I am sick to my stomach and quite simply hate the unknown. So a simple question - is it likely that the UK will be in danger from Russia? And if so what does that look like? Cyber attacks, bombs being dropped?

OP posts:
fghjk · 25/02/2022 11:10

@MistressoftheDarkSide you're correct. To me it's not even the direct effects (which I admit I wasn't AS clued up on as I could have been but thanks to PPs have learned they are clearly destructive enough). Even without knowing that, it was obvious the sheer chaos would be enough to damage us beyond comprehension.

How many people are waiting for their child benefit to clear on a Monday before buying milk and bread for the week?

I don't even carry cash. Made worse by the fact places stopped accepting it during covid. I'd be raiding the kids piggy banks for their birthday money, sad as that sounds.

I will however take a couple hundred out and stash it under the mattress just so I can kid myself into thinking I'm prepared. But really, it's not going to make much difference if communication is down and people are looting etc.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 11:06

@Applesonthelawn

Western countries off cyber attacks from Russia and China every day even before Ukraine. It is nothing new for countries to successfully fend off those attacks.
Our ability to fend off these attacks isn't what it should be. The public sector (that includes GCHQ) doesn't pay the going rate for the best at this.

The specialist skills are very much the preserve of the private sector and contractors in the UK.

Both are struggling to recruit enough people with good enough specialist skills at junior roles. For senior roles, its actually quite frightening.

If we had several major cyber attacks at the same time, we simply don't have enough people to deal with it quickly. We have far too many weak points in our infrastructure because of poor skills and practice.

We are not nearly enough scared by this nor anywhere near at a level where we have adequate protection.

Think about stuff like DeepFakes and how they could be employed too in a war scenario.
hacked.com/what-are-deepfakes-and-why-are-they-dangerous/

Many people have expressed fears over nukes. Why do that? Nukes have side effects that can literally blow back in your face.

If you want to cripple someones ability to resist and fight you, in the past you would do a blitz bombing hoping to take out their resources, manufacturing and infrastructure. Now you can do that remotely. Its much less messy for your domestic policy because you dont tend to have leaked images of body bags upsetting your citizens.

We should be almost as scared of military level cyber attacks as we are of nukes imo.

We are talking about the potential to have a complete breakdown of just about any service, manufacturing or distribution organisation.

You don't have to target government institutions either. Take out Tescos stock system for a day or two. How do they know what goes on what lorry, where it goes, how many they need to order etc etc?

This is stuff that certainly wont have military level defence.

CIaireFraser · 25/02/2022 11:06

What harm would a cyber attack really do though? A day or two of systems down..it would just be an annoyance

Yep, so annoying to have our water supply contaminated, planes grounded, patients life support switched off, transport infrastructure fucked, bank accounts emptied/frozen, shops unable to open, supply chains fucked, energy supplies disrupted etc for as long as those who had control fancied.

I'm not sure you understand what 'systems down can really mean.

AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 11:05

@EpicMugs

Yep, for years they have been sniffing, sniffing, sniffing.

I imagine all that sniffing has uncovered vulnerabilities they have not released or exploited yet. Whilst the Log4j vulnerability I talked about was not very actively/effectively targeted, even that still saw state-level activity from Russia (among other places). It is entirely possible (likely) that the activity was not designed to take advantage of that vulnerability at that time, but to increase knowledge and arsenal for a future cyber attack.

They have been definitely. I used to work for a company that got daily hits from Russia and China. This is not new to them at all and god knows how far they got into it.

As @Bunnyfuller said, his use of the word immediately is the worrying part. Nuclear is obvious what will happen. If its cyber then they are already in our infrastructure waiting for the go ahead. You can't pull that off immediately otherwise.

Either way we're fucked as a society. No matter what action they take. And I doubt (although I don't know for certain) that we are in their infrastructure like that.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 25/02/2022 11:04

Over 20 years ago I was in a very large B&Q when their till systems and payment machines went down. The chaos that ensued was unbelievable - there were 3 or four staff members at every till, writing down bar codes for manual input later, furiously using calculators, advising on nearest cash points etc etc. That was a tiny internal systems failure...... multiply that exponentially in the context of our far more digital society, and that's just "straightforward" commerce....

We are almost complete dependent on technology for all aspects of our lives, going back to bartering and carrier pigeons is not really an option......

KerryWeaver · 25/02/2022 11:02

Some posts on this thread really do give credence to the axiom that ignorance is bliss.

If one has little understanding of a concerning issue one cannot be troubled by it.

EpicMugs · 25/02/2022 11:00

Yep, for years they have been sniffing, sniffing, sniffing.

I imagine all that sniffing has uncovered vulnerabilities they have not released or exploited yet. Whilst the Log4j vulnerability I talked about was not very actively/effectively targeted, even that still saw state-level activity from Russia (among other places). It is entirely possible (likely) that the activity was not designed to take advantage of that vulnerability at that time, but to increase knowledge and arsenal for a future cyber attack.

Bunnyfuller · 25/02/2022 10:57

Two of parts of his threat jumped out at me - the measures of which have never been seen before…which we’re all speculating about, but the key to that, for me was his use of ‘immediately’. That for me is the worrying bit.

Cyber? Huge bombs that aren’t nuclear - they exist? Bio weapons? He’s seen how the west bumbled through Covid? I suspect Cyber, and I suspect they’re far ahead of what we can imagine. Unlike us they’ve quietly progressed their military capabilities, instead of slashing and burning to make sure rich shareholders don’t have to pay towards public services.

AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 10:55

@Ereshkigalangcleg

I feel we are wasting our time on that one. She has said she doesn't want to learn, just help those who do.

I'd question whether they are posting in good faith, personally. Dismissing the hugely disruptive Wannacry attack as a "two day annoyance" Confused

Yes but it's these kind of people that let the hackers in unfortunately. Because they won't listen. Clicking on links in emails that they don't know who it's from is such an easy way for them to get in. But try telling them not to click on every link in emails that come in.

As someone else said, it's basically just good luck that we haven't been compromised yet. The amount of shove back I've had in my job from other it professionals is bad, and they should know better.

I think really though, if Russia is going to do this to us, they are in already and sitting in the code quietly, waiting. Breaking in takes months, it's not something they can easily accomplish next week unless they are already in. They've been planning this for months, let's not assume they don't already have back doors.

fghjk · 25/02/2022 10:54

Probably @RedToothBrush but it is kinda impossible for one human to know about everything there is to know. We've jumped from the medical implications of Covid and lockdowns, to BLM and racism and critical race theory, to the social / moral implications of covid mandates and human rights, to a war with Russia that has history before many of us were born and all the potential of that in the space of two years. All while many people are trying to deal with juggling working, keeping themselves safe and sane, school closures and isolation periods etc. With economic uncertainty, energy price rises, and climate change around the corner too.

Also, even if it were possible to keep up, some people just don't want to think about it. And there can be valid mental health reasons for that too.

There's examples all over MN (and even on this thread) of people who should have probably stepped away from certain problems the country / world has because it's doing them more harm than good. Especially when Joe and Josephine Bloggs on the street just aren't going to make much of a difference even if they DID spend hours every day researching and trying to keep up with it all.

EpicMugs · 25/02/2022 10:53

These things would be annoying but it is not a catastrophe for a shop to need to accept cash only for a day or two until systems are back (which they quickly would be).

They wouldn't be back quickly. They really wouldn't. Log4j was a level 10 critical vulnerability found in December last year. That is the highest level of vulnerability seen and - fortunately - was not being very actively targetted (it was relatively unknown). We're at the end of February and there are still many technologies that have not properly 'closed the loophole' on it. Because even fixing something when you know what the weakness is, when you have all your normal reosurces to hand and what you are not under attack is STILL taking this long.

This stuff is complex and, having worked in the industry now for 20 years, I can promise that a proper attack will not be resolved in days.

DirectionToPerfection · 25/02/2022 10:52

I think the Irish health service (HSE) would argue that Russian cyber attacks are extremely damaging, and dangerous for patients. People had life saving treatments cancelled/postponed and the after effects lasted for months.

BlondeWidow · 25/02/2022 10:51

@JimmyDurham Just because you disagree with somebody's opinion, that does not give you the right to declare it as "rubbish" Hmm

Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/02/2022 10:50

I feel we are wasting our time on that one. She has said she doesn't want to learn, just help those who do.

I'd question whether they are posting in good faith, personally. Dismissing the hugely disruptive Wannacry attack as a "two day annoyance" Confused

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 10:50

I can not fathom how people have managed to avoid the subject of the risk of cyber attacks to this degree.

Its beyond my comprehension.

If you don't know something, you find out. You don't just dismiss others concerns and warnings because by your own admission you don't know.

What we are effectively saying here is its ok to be arrogantly unenlightened.

No its not ok. People should be embarrassed.

Go and find out before putting crap out. Thats disinformation and denial. It should be treated with contempt.

EpicMugs · 25/02/2022 10:48

To add to the previous posts on cyber attacks (helping protect critical UK systems from this is part of my day job)...

999 systems could be hit. Meaning calls to the emergency services go unanswered. Limited police response because it all falls back to someone, somewhere writing down each call and trying to find who is free to respond (if the phone lines themselves are not hit - which they may be).

If they hit those, they can and probably will hit crime recording and evidence databases, meaning criminals cannot be found, arrested, charged or convicted.

NHS systems: when you hit those, wards need to close. This means people with life threatening medical events/illnesses have no where to go. Or, if the wards are allowed to remain open, limited care given because machines don't work. Surgery goes back to being analogue which reduces the types of surgery you can do and the people you can save - with younger surgeons having to learn whole new ways to operate because they have always had cimputers to help and guide them in complex cases.

Banking, communication, councils, the military, the government, police, fire response, medical response, water and energy supplies, food supplies, all vulnerable.

In short, everything requiring technology can be impacted and - as others have said - it is true that:

a) this is easier to pull of than the public imagine (a healthy dose of luck and relative geopolitical stability is what has previously provided defence)

b) it will literally take weeks, months, even years to bring some of these systems back. Both hardware and people resources will be in very short supply and there will be long queues for both.

The cyber question, is a big deal here. We have succesfully fended off those attacks but, genuinely, our defences are not that good and luck has played a large role here. That and the fact that the attacks either come from non-government sources are need to appear as if they have. So they are smaller scale, mostly. They are just out sniffing for a weakness but otherwise often not especially malevolent.

Open economic warfare with government-sponsored Russia cyber organisations prepared to come out of the shadows and target all Western countries? Different ballgame. It wouldn't be a walkover but it also is a real risk.

CrabSnake · 25/02/2022 10:44

@RedToothBrush

See this is what I think of when I think of a cyber attack. These things would be annoying but it is not a catastrophe for a shop to need to accept cash only for a day or two until systems are back (which they quickly would be).

Hhaahahahhahaahahahah ok. Yes.

Hahahahhahahahahaah. Hahahhahahaha.

Did you just read whats been posted above you about the possible effects of a cyber attack.

Military level cyber attacks would be worse.

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/apr/11/israel-appears-confirm-cyberattack-iran-nuclear-facility
Israel appears to confirm it carried out cyberattack on Iran nuclear facility

If nothing else consider the implications of what could happen in just 24 hrs...

I don't understand where your rudeness and aggression is coming from but I'm not engaging any further.
AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 10:44

@RedToothBrush

I feel we are wasting our time on that one. She has said she doesn't want to learn, just help those who do.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 10:43

@fghjk

There's no need to be snarky just because I'm not so knowledgeable about this as you.

Agreed. Discussions / debates are so much better when we leave that at the door. (With the exception of genuinely batshit stuff like WHAT ABOUT LONG COVID Grin).

For example I had the same type of reaction when a pp mentioned how easily we could shoot planes out of the sky. As someone who knows a thing or two about directional infrared counter measures due to years of designing them... it made me giggle.

BUT we need to be aware that we're a bunch of accountants, IT experts, SAHMs, shopworkers, and everything in between. Better to educate each other and learn something than make people too self-conscious to post anything because they don't know all the facts there is to possibly know.

The video I posted is a prime example of this. Who knew just how precarious the wheat situation was? According to the guy (who might be right or wrong, an expert or a charlatan) one type of fertiliser is disappearing because of what's going on in energy markets, the other because of what's going on in China, and if this war happens the 3rd type has a shortage too.

He says if we remove all 3 at the same time, the world is over. We are literally FUCKED. So nukes and cyber attacks and planes being shot out of the sky kinda pale in significance anyway Grin

Tbh i had hoped that people had generally speaking learned a little bit about supply chain disruption and the massive knock on effects due to the pandemic or the Evergiven. Or lack of ppe due to sudden changes in demand. Or just whether they can get petrol or bog roll on demand.

I think now this was clearly vastly over optimistic.

RedToothBrush · 25/02/2022 10:40

See this is what I think of when I think of a cyber attack. These things would be annoying but it is not a catastrophe for a shop to need to accept cash only for a day or two until systems are back (which they quickly would be).

Hhaahahahhahaahahahah ok. Yes.

Hahahahhahahahahaah. Hahahhahahaha.

Did you just read whats been posted above you about the possible effects of a cyber attack.

Military level cyber attacks would be worse.

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/apr/11/israel-appears-confirm-cyberattack-iran-nuclear-facility
Israel appears to confirm it carried out cyberattack on Iran nuclear facility

If nothing else consider the implications of what could happen in just 24 hrs...

fghjk · 25/02/2022 10:38

There's no need to be snarky just because I'm not so knowledgeable about this as you.

Agreed. Discussions / debates are so much better when we leave that at the door. (With the exception of genuinely batshit stuff like WHAT ABOUT LONG COVID Grin).

For example I had the same type of reaction when a pp mentioned how easily we could shoot planes out of the sky. As someone who knows a thing or two about directional infrared counter measures due to years of designing them... it made me giggle.

BUT we need to be aware that we're a bunch of accountants, IT experts, SAHMs, shopworkers, and everything in between. Better to educate each other and learn something than make people too self-conscious to post anything because they don't know all the facts there is to possibly know.

The video I posted is a prime example of this. Who knew just how precarious the wheat situation was? According to the guy (who might be right or wrong, an expert or a charlatan) one type of fertiliser is disappearing because of what's going on in energy markets, the other because of what's going on in China, and if this war happens the 3rd type has a shortage too.

He says if we remove all 3 at the same time, the world is over. We are literally FUCKED. So nukes and cyber attacks and planes being shot out of the sky kinda pale in significance anyway Grin

User48751490 · 25/02/2022 10:37

I think this is a huge learning curve for many of us. I have been listening constantly to BBC World Service since yesterday because I don't know enough about the current conflict.

No need for some posters to shoot others down with harsh responses. We are all here to learn!

Kinsters · 25/02/2022 10:35

@RedToothBrush

There's no need to be snarky just because I'm not so knowledgeable about this as you. It doesn't make me want to read your very long post when you start off so rudely, even though I'm sure you have something interesting and informative to say.

Being uninformed does not mean you are incapable of using google to find out why so many people are worried about the threat.

Instead despite this you were arrogant and confident enough to reply that others with this fear were talking rot.

Engage your brain before typing. Its a good protection against people pointing out how ignorant your post is. Or 'being snarky' as you clearly prefer to call it.

That comment was jaw dropping. It needed picking up on and robustly challenging.

Please quote where I said where anyone was talking rot!! I don't speak like that to anyone on here or in real life (unlike you).
AllOfUsAreDead · 25/02/2022 10:35

And that's why you won't learn @Kinsters. Too busy being offended to bother reading what others know about to realise you're wrong and see how it could affect us. Getting snarky at me still means you're not knowledgeable about this. And lack of even basic knowledge on this topic is how they get access I'm afraid.

But it's fine, you be offended that you were wrong. That will stop the hackers. Hmm

Kinsters · 25/02/2022 10:33

@roses2

What harm would a cyber attack really do though? A day or two of systems down..it would just be an annoyance.

Shops can't sell products without till connectivity. People can't take money out of banks. People who work with computers can't work. Airlines can't fly planes.....

See this is what I think of when I think of a cyber attack. These things would be annoying but it is not a catastrophe for a shop to need to accept cash only for a day or two until systems are back (which they quickly would be).